صحف سابقہ کی تاریخ ، پیشگوئیوں کو توڑ موڑ کر پیش کرنے...

0*Šg~z‹~™r#ëŒÛWyÔÑ²!~VÆ)Íf!*v(¾~ƒä»o]Zk§bÌ½™@*ì: ''In his putting into the mouth of God garbled statements as to scripture history, prophecy, and

doctrine, to suit the purpose of his prophetic pretensions'',

0*Šg~™r#ZyZÖp~øg}Ñ~V6,t**0*uZ²ZxÎDW\åä’è‚—Å@*gõÆ!*g{~ÔrðÆ!*g{~Zzgo{Æ!*g{~%zhF,zh™Ò**]}.ZÆì~eZáW\ÆŠúòt]Æ‚BñZkgnpX0*Šg~™r#ÃZ¤/ŒÛWy™*ÆÒ**]6,Ãð2]¸Zzgz{ZŠ[Æ‚BZk6,ÃðÎZwc*Z‹Zn™DÂ…**gZW»Ãðh7å10*Šg~™r#äTZ0+Zi~tZ‹ZnZVc*ìZzgZv¬\ÆƒÐYZ;gÑ~V6,i!*yƒŠgZiÅìz{…ZYi]ŠêìëÌZ4Æö~ZyÅZŠZ5™,ZzgZyÃŠ3NZ‹ZnZrVäZVc*ìz{ŒÛWyˆ6,7ÉZ**ã6,zZgŠƒ@*ìXZ**ã6,ZäÇ**)ÅrÇVÔ@*gõZzgZ+ÃÂh%zh™7™C

ÎzZãƒZ**ãä6,ZäÇ**óÅrÇVZzg@*gõZzgjZÎ]ÐÚ|uHìz{‡.ÞÑxÑ^Æ**xÐf™HY@*ìXZzgZ¤/W\ÃìwƒëƒÐ»xágìÂëpŠW\Æ¸ðf!fY!*ªÆZZwÆîg6,7™,ÐX

äzß‡ÅZ**ãZzg|][mZ?x»©**)ƒÐ¬äÅZgÆ¬!*[Ã„kXäÆZgâöä¬!*[~|][»Zq-pŠ‚©**)7HìXZk©**ó»Zq-Ñtì|][ÃZ0ŠZîŠU*"$HYñª|]ŠZîŠmZ?xÅ±~ÐU*"$HYñZkÅzztì·Š~

23 Ôk,x{!*[ 1 We$ 11 Ô$iš5é GG{!*[ 11 We$ 132 !*[ t¦ggZòƒ[åWäzZÑ[ŠZîŠÅ±ÐƒÇX)·ŠÆZk¦gÅãCŠi1gÔz){6,¶(XÁqÅmU*"$™äÆnä»Zgâö6gƒZìË§bZ7ŠZîŠÅ±ÐU*"$™}XZy 5 We$

ÆzZ−Â¸„7X¥xƒ@*ìZgâöÃZyÅzZ−{ÆŠZîŠÅ±Ðƒä»Ãðo]75X)ß‡ÅZgÐŒÛÜMìz{Ñz~FÐ‰ZknŠZîŠÅ±Ð7ƒ‰(XÅ<å XEZZgâöä7Íð7g~™ä»Zq-3,ZÑeàïÑìZq-©**))ZKfZ]~Ì`ì(|]%*Æ{z0+-Š»Šc*ìZzgZk©**ó~-ŠÃ|]ŠZîŠÅ±ÐŠ3c*ìXZzgZk§b

|][ÃŠZîŠÅ±ÐŒÛZgŠ¶ÅÃÒÅìX0*Šg~z‹~™r#!W\ŒÛWy6,ÔÑ²!~V6,tZ‹Zn™Dz{ô`Å@*gõ—h@*ì@*ZKt]ÆŠ¬z~U*"$

™}XŠ¶W\ÅÂ[lkä|][ÃZ0ŠZîŠU*"$™äÆnù@*gõ»ù—hZìZkÅ@*G~-Š»©**)7HìqÑè-ŠÃ|][ÐÃðum7X:|][-ŠÆdW-ŠÆ©**óÐZyÆŠZîŠÅ±ƒä»o]ïnX-Š|][ÆÛè!*\XZ¤/tU*"$ÌƒYñ-ŠŠZîŠÅ±ÐA$Ì|][Z0ŠZîŠU*"$

7ƒDXZgâöäÃÒÌÅÔ@*gõÃ—hZÌZzgZk—hÆfg=ÁqÆŠúòmÃU*"$™**°ŠåXÍc*Z‹ZnŒÛWy6,ZzgÑ²[~V6,W\äZVc*åz{äÅZg6,zZgŠƒZXZÌ!*]»7ƒðXä»Zgâö©**)Šg`™äÆˆqì:

’‚—Å@*gõÔrÇVZzgZ+ÃÂh%zh™ÒyZ**ã? ™äzZÑÃyì?ŒÛWyˆc*

Ú`ç…μ^…pæan†pÒ1Î†]?áÚrn‚μ†]Âj†]•^lÒ1qç]hÚn6]mÔ:ãçŒÂ×ÛoæivÏnÏoÚÏ^Öä

E‰n‚Ún†ÚvÛç]uÛ‚Þ^‘†D

1

÷÷ƒ¹Z',;xÐŠZîŠJ-aŠ{¹ƒNZzgŠZîŠÐá™¤/ëgƒ™!*.ÞYäJ-aŠ{¹Zzg¤/ëgƒ™!*.ÞYäÐá™[DMS ]?mk M EÚjoe^h J-aŠ{¹ƒNX

ŒVä»ZgâöZLËfz¹ìwÅ¯6,©**óÃaŠ{aŠ{_VÅ&)oV~„™**eLìX¥x7YV?)áh+ZknŠZîŠÃ‡Zã$4èG÷Šz›óëZzgZkÆZQÆˆ[ÐZ°ZŠÅöZyaŠ{kì(X

~-gZxÆˆ&**xZc*{Ô-ZkZzgZ!{5é EG{ghŠñ6,ZäÇ 8 We$ 1 1ZkfztzØt~äÆZgâöä!*[2 ~-({ÆˆZ1³»**xghŠc*ì6,ZäÇ**óÅÂ[ 11 ~èÃgXZzgWe$ 12Ô11 We$ 3 **óÅÂ[ZXÂZgõ!*[

~èÃgìX 34 We$ 23 sv!*[Š¶0*Šg~™r#*Ç**)W\Æ4,Šq-Â[lkZzgxZÞì¾§b6,ZäÇ**)Åz{ÌW\Æ4,Šq-Â[

lkZzgxZÞìÄç-$™@*ìXZzgÜs6,ZäÇ**óJ-„özŠ7pŠäÆZgâöäaŠ{aŠ{Æ&¤/z\¯ñ**x:aŠ{X 13 ZkÆWy~¤/z\~

~t©**)äÆ© 38 We$ 23 tÂåäÆZgâö»©**)1Zq-©**)ß‡ÅZg~ÌŠg`ìXß‡!*[**óÐ®Ò0îGGSZìXt©**)Ì-Š»„ì|]%*»7)',Ryz0*Îy~‰0*Šg~tŠúò™DZq-©**)

**x 54 %*»ìZzgŠzuZ-Š»Xt!*]ŠzâV©**ñVÆzZãZÖpÆÜsì(XZk©**ó~|]ŠZîŠÐá™-ŠJ-**xX**ñVÅ®ZŠÆ´z{ŠzâV©**ñV~**ñVÅ”!*ÇZìXut 28 XäÆ©**ó~pŠäÅ2ÌÆ_.

(1ß‡ÅgzÐz{|]ŠZîŠÆ 7 We$ 1 ìäÅgzÐ|][|]ŠZîŠÆdW|]ÑyÅZzÑŠ~Ð¸)ä!*[dW**@Å±ÐXZzg0*Šg~™r#fgZ¨gÐZL0*Šg~¸ðÅt’k,7,³:

"Both genealogies reflect current rabbinical ideas about the Messiah descent. It was disputed, for

instance, wether He would be descended from David through Solomon, or wether, owing to the

curse on this live (Jer: 22 28 30 36) through an other son, Nathan

(1Ch:3-5)

Accordingly St. Matthewis genealogy traces our Lords descent through Solomon, St Luke through

Nathan.(A commentary on the Holy Bible Edited by the Rev. J.R. Dummellow

Macnillan & Co. Ltd. London .St.Matthew introduction , page 623)

·Š~tcƒZ™C¶WäzZÑ[ŠZîŠÅ±ÂƒÇ1ŠZîŠÆ¾dWÅ±ƒÇ?¼ë¸ÑyÅ±ÐÔ¼ë¸**@Å±ÐXääZLiâäÔZL´ºZzgZLâjwÅcÆ_.Zq-©**)|][»»g™Šc*T~U*"$™Šc*

|][ŠZîŠÆdWÑyÅ±Ð¸Xß‡äZLiâä~ZL´º~ÔZLâjwÅc~Zq-©**)»g™Šc*ZzgU*"$™Šc*|][ŠZîŠÆdW**@Å±Ð¸!!

0*Šg~™r#!W\äŠ¬Z²ZxW\äŒÛWyˆ6,@*gõZzgrÇVÃ—hä»Îc*åz{¾÷÷áyóóÆ‚BpŠW\ÅÂ[lk6,zZgŠƒ@*ìX/'tÂ¶ÃÒäZzgß‡ÅÁqÃZ0ŠZîŠU*"$™äÅX@*6,ZäÇ**óÅrÇVÆ_.W\ÃZ0ŠZîŠU*"$™ÆW\»[ƒ**U*"$™}X1Š¶pŠ|][Zk!*g{~HëX¥xƒ@*ì|][6,tZ‹Zn(,~”]Ðƒ@*å

S Em³³çu³³ß³³^Ún³6]³^…é÷m³³ä]Âj³†]šÚ³çq³ça³1!m³Óãn³6m³çu³ß³^e³^h z{ŠZîŠÅ±Ð7Zkn[¾§bƒMhXDPO i^ PL ]?mk

|][Æ0*kZLZ0ŠZîŠƒäÆnäZzgß‡ÆpŠ‚©**óÂ7X:|][äZkZ‹ZnÆ!*g{~¹z{fgZgÐ7,#:

~–ì÷÷ZzgZ#Û+¦ƒñÂÁqäZyÐ7Y?[Æh~HBƒ?z{¾»gCì?ZrVäZk 22 ä!*[

2

Ð¹ŠZîŠ»XZkäZyÐ¹:ŠZîŠgzbÅ@Ze$ÐYðZÐ}.Zz0+Hì}.Zz0+ä÷}}.Zz0+Ð¹X÷~Š6§sÖXZ#J-~¾}Š7VÃ¾}0*îVÆn:™ŠzV?:Z#ŠZîŠZkÃ}.Zz0+HìÂz{Zk»gCYðIZX?ZzgÃðZkÆZ[~

DPR i^ PM ]?mk NN EÚjoe^h Zq-ws:ÈeXZzg:ZkŠyÐQËäZkÐÎZw™äÅP]ÅóóXHx0*Šg~™r#!ZkjZáÃ7,#ZzgQ7,#XäZzgß‡ÆZgâöé@*y™7gZizgÎ™W:~uŠgzZZzg„Š

Zzg6,ZäÇ**óÐÌZ©**óF,Zl™|][ÅœZ‰ÜU*"$™äÆnW\ÃZ0ŠZîŠU*"$™gìZzg|][ZyÅÓxœ6,0*ã¢Dƒñ6,ZäÇ**)ÐZo™DWäzZÑ[ŠZîŠ»gC7ƒYX

Å§bß^™W\ÅÃ boomrang 7ÍÇVZzg@*gõÃ*™ä»Z²ZxW\äÑ²!~V6,Îc*åz{¾§blZzgW\ÆZøÁq6,zZgŠƒZX

Z**ãZzgÁq[ÅaZö»E+™{/'ZzgZÌÂt¹ã^g„ìX©**óÆä»ZgâöÁqÅaZö»f™™@*ìZzgZkŸ~Ì6,ZäÇ**óÅ÷÷r×VóóðV™äÅÃÒ™@*ìX–ì:

÷÷Z[Áq[ÅaZöZk§bƒðZ#ZkÅâV%*Å«-ŠÆ‚BƒÂZyÆZNƒäÐ¬z{gzbZ;kÅŠg]Ðqn0*ðˆX:ZkÆØCÙ-ŠägZ]45é GEiåZzgZÐ$+**x™**7eLåXZÐíÐghŠ¶»ZgZŠ{HXz{Zy!*ÂVÃÎa„g;å}.Zz0+ÆÛºäZÐpZ[~Š¬ðŠ}™¹Z}-ŠZ0ŠZîŠZKç~ÃZL;VáWäÐ:egYèZkÆù~ìz{gzbZ;kÅŠg]ÐìXZkÆgCƒÇZzgÂZk»**xÁqgYèz„ZLßÍVÃZyÆkHƒVÐ]Š}ÇXtƒ¼ZknƒZ}.Zz0+äÑÅcÄ¹åz{7gZƒ÷÷ŠdZq-.Zg~qnƒÏZzggCÃÏZzgZk»**xqâZsgO

ÐóóXT»F,Àì}.Zøg}‚BX:-Šä’ÐYv™z(„H6}.Zz0+ÆÛºäZÐ¬Šc*åZzgZKç~ÃZL;VDNQ i^ MT ]?m^l M EÚjoe^h áWc*XZzgZkÃ:Y**Z#J-ZkÆgC:ƒZZzgZk»**xÁqg3óóX

ÐmgBbìX 16@*14 Wc*] 7 äÆZgâöäÁqÅaZö6,ðV™äÆnrðŠg`Åìz{$iš5é GG{!*[TÆZÝZÖp»F,À¼Zk§bƒ**e’:

÷÷ŠdZq-Zyúg]qnƒÏZzggCaZƒÇZzgz{Zk»**xqâZsgÇÏZzgz{Š„Zzgß3ñÇZ#J-z{nZzg$+~ÆgŠzJwÆ‡.Þ:ƒX6,ZkÐ¸t±»nZzg$+~ÆgŠzJwƒtoTÆŠzâV!*ŠáƒVÐNÐ]ìzk,ZyƒYñÇóóX

Z[Š¶ZkgKÏ„g]~äÆZgâöäZLŠ´£œÆn¾Šg’pÐ»x1ìXZzw:Zkä$iš5é GG{ÅÂ[~0*ñYäzZáÂ÷÷{‘Ð*î MMMóó»F,À.Zg~HìZzgZk§bÁqÅœZ‰Ü6,$o]ÎäÅÃÒÅì

1){‘Ð*î MMM(Æp.Zg~Â7ƒDZyúg]ÆƒDXpZ{áŠ~”{ƒpZ{.Zg~ƒXZ¤/$iš5é GG{ä.Zg~Æh~rð™ãƒCÂz{‡ZãÂG!ZEw™@*X1ZkäZyúg]»ÂZEwHìX1ZgâöäZkÃZLÑÆn%zhF,zh™)z‹~

»F,ÀìW\äŒÛWyˆÆnZEwHå(.Zg~F,ÀHì@*rðÃ|]%*Zzg|][ garbled ™r#!tÂ6,ðV™nX

Åczs‚ÆZi+ñ˜: Peake

"The rendring "Virgin" is unjustifiable, for this bethulah would have been used; the word

employed here, almah, means young womans a young woman of marrigeable age, without any

suggestion that she is not married". (A commentary on the bible, edited by

Arthur S.Peake M.A.D.D. Thomas Nelson & Sons Ltd. London. Page442)

äÆZgâöä„CÙZq-gKÏp~$iš5é GG{ÆZÖp~'×h+ÅìX$iš5é GG{~–ìz{)aÅzZ−{(Zk»**xqâZsgÇÏ1Xä~ì÷÷z{Zk»**xqâZsgOÐóó$iš5é GG{~qâZsª÷÷}.Zøg}‚BóóÆZÖpaÆ**xÆîg6,ZzgŠ*Y„

3

ì**x~·îwæÃƒ@*ìÍc*âVZLaÆnZkpZé»ZÖg™g„ì}.Zøg}‚BƒX1ä~„CÙgKÏp~ÅˆìZk»ÑtƒYì)zZvZD(¹YñaÆ!*g}~Íc*ßv}Ðt}.Zìøg}‚BìXZ¤/Z(„ìÂZgâöä6,ZäÇ**óÆZÖp~Zq-©àŠp~™Æ÷÷Zß:[óóÆo}Å§sZq-ŠxZVc*ìX

1Zk‚g}Òy~ƒÐç**u!*]tìäÆZgâöätŠúòHì$iš5é GG{ÆZyZÖp~|][ÅaZöÅrðìXäÆZgâöä$iš5é GG{ÅZÝ„g]~ÐtgKÏ„g]%zhF,zh™7™Š~ìZzgZL‡gMÃt@*W,Šc*ìÍc*tWäzZá[Æ!*g{~rðìÁq?ðVƒCìXZ\kt!*]|Ð!*ÇZìZzgZgâöÅŠc*-$ŠZg~Ã™g„

ìXZ¤/øg}‡gM$iš5é GG{ÅÂ[Åw™Zk»‚ÂZV!*[ïBÂZgâöÅtÝg~Zy6,p[ÁYñÏX$iš5é GG{Ã7,|™ŠBZk~Ë|][ÅaZöÅ§bFœ-VˆƒäzZázZ§»Ãðf™„7XZk~ÂZq-¶Ky»f™ìZq-aÆaZƒ™nÆgŠz

Å‚ÆZi+ñ˜ Peake JwÅ/ÃîJ-¦~‡ìŠzâV·Š~qVÅn„zZµƒYñÏX ''The sign is to be fulfilled in the near future, since it is given for a pressing emergency. It has therefore no

reference to the birth of jesus more than seven hundred years later.''(A commentary

on the Bible .page442. Edited by Arthur S Peake M.A.D.D. Thomas Nelson & Sons Ltd.)

0*Šg~z‹~™r#ä–åŒÛWy~—g~V»‚—ô`ÅÃÅrÇVÃ%zhF,zh™ZLŠúòÆo]Æn7]hμ^…pæan†p‘^ugÒoÞò1Â`‚Þ^ÚäÒ1e^…cÚn6Òn^…]ñ1a1[ ™**ZnZíZYƒä»o]½™@*ìX

Yââ( 1997 BŠc 4 Yâ@*1997 BâÞ 28 ),·:ZZÚD

Eæ‰†pÎŠ¼DZ[WÐ¾ä»Zgâöqì:÷÷Z#Áq‹zŠö!*Šá{Æiâ:~·ŠtÆšM¡~aZƒZÂŠdFXÏ7g[Ð-gz~tëƒñWñ·Š-V»

!*Šá{aZƒZìz{¹Vì?Yè7g[~Zk»*g{ŠN™ëZÐ>{™äWñXtÍ™‹zŠö!*Šá{ZzgZkÆ‚B-gzÆƒßv<ÍZ‰XZzgZkä¸xÆƒuŠZg»~VZzg¢©-Að

EGGXVÃ¦™ÆZyÐ7Y[ÅaZö¹Vƒãe’?ZrVä¹·ŠtÆšM¡

~YèÑÅcÄ-V–ŠHì:÷÷Z}šM¡·ŠtÆ´ºÂ·ŠZ{Æq*V~CÙ¦/ƒÐgN*7Yè~ÐZq-uŠZg†Ç÷~Z#ÖZuZLÅŠ!*ã™}ÇóóX

Zk6,‹zŠöäX±VÃíÐš™ZyÐïÅz{*g{¾z‰ÜŠ3ðŠc*åXZzgtÈ™Z7šM¡Ã5Y™ZkaÅ!*"$ÇÇŠgc*Ä™zZzgZ#z{AÂ=Šz@*~ÌW™ZÐ>{™zVXz{!*Šá{Å!*]Í™gzZ:ƒñZzgŠd*g{ZrVä7g[

~Š¬åz{ZyÆWÐWÐ`ŒVJ-Zk(ÆZz6,IŠH˜Vz{åXz{*g}ÃŠN™.e$plƒñZzgZkÆy~V™aÃZkÅâV%*Æ0*kŠ¬ZzgZkÆWÐ¤/™>{HZzgZLe"Åw™Î**Zzg]yZzg'ç NZkÅ2+gHXZzg‹zŠöÆ0*kQ:YäÅ@Ze$pZ[~0*™Šzu~gZ{ÐZLoÃgzZ:ƒñX

Z#z{gzZ:ƒ‰ÂŠd}.Zz0+ÆÛ¸ä-ŠÃpZ[~Š3ðŠ}™¹ZJaZzgZkÅâVÃ‚Bá™Ã¸vYZzgZ#J-~Ð:¼VzgxYè‹zŠöZkaÅˆl™äÃì@*ZÐhu™}X:z{ZVZzggZ]Æz‰ÜaZzgZkÅâVÃ‚Bá™^Å§sgzZ:ƒŠHXZzg‹zŠöÆ%äJ-zg;@*}.Zz0+äÑÅcÄ¹åz{7gZƒ^~Ð~äZLdWÃšc*XZ#‹zŠöäŠ¬X±Vä÷}‚BçÅÂ.e$VƒZZzgWŠòŸ™šM¡ZzgZkÅƒuuzVÆZ0+gÆZyƒ±ÃVÃ

z‰Üz{!*]7g~ƒðk,x{ÑÅ O™zZŠc*ŠzŠz',kÆc*ZkÐgL¸XZkz‰ÜÆˆ[ÐZkäX±VÐïÅ¶Zk4

cÄ½¶:â?gZ4ZL”VÃgzg„ìZzg−Jw7™CZknz{7XZ#‹zŠö%ŠHÂŠd}.ZÆÛºä gZ)~WzZi‹ðŠ~gz**Zzg(,Z

^~-ŠÃpZ[~Š3ðŠ}™¹ZJZkaZzgZkÅâVÃá™ZuZLÆo~`YYèaÅYyÆpZ;V¸z{%‰X:z{ZVZzgaZzgZkÅâVÃ‚Bá™ZuZLÆo~WŠH1Z#‹ZgÜîkZL!*\‹zŠöÅ(·Št~!*Šá„™@*ìÂz;VYäÐegZXZzgpZ[~@Ze$0*™¯Ò5ÿGÆ´‘ÃgzZ:ƒŠHXZzg**Ü{**xZq-à~YÎ@*1VÅcÄ¹ŠHåz{7gZƒZz{**Ü~

D N EÚjoVe^h BñÇóóXZzgô`‚—ÆjZ!Y]Æ!*g{~0*Šg~ Zk!*[~äÆZgâöäô`‚—ÆegjZá7G

z‹~™r#äZ²ZxŒÛWy™*?ÎäÅÃÒÅìz{7g}izgÆ‚B6Ç**)6,zZgŠƒDXZyjZ!Y]Æ_.|][»šM¡~aZƒ**Ì¢zg~ì·ŠtÆß/~ìZzg**Ü{~g;öZzgZkÆ³~**Ü~

B**Ì¢zg~ìZzg**Ü{»àÒ5ÿGÆß/~ìXZ[Š¶z‹~™r#W\ÅÂ[lkÆŠz{ZyŠzâVrÇVÃ¾Ýg~Ð7gZ™DXä»ÒyW\äZz6,7,JX

™@*ì|][»{0+Zy·Št»gzZÑå¾qw**Ü{)Ò5ÿG(Ð7Wc*åZzg·ŠtÆàšM¡~|][ Imply ä»Zgâöt~Å¶XQt{0+Zy‹zŠöÆÕÆegÐpZ[~@Ze$0* 5 ÅaZöƒXÅ<å XEZtrð7g~ƒWäzZá[Æ0}{!*[

™^`ŠHZzg~g;XZ#‹zŠö%ŠHÂpZ[~@Ze$0*™zZ:¦ÆngzZ:ƒZX1·Št~‹zŠö»gCZgÜîkqÁåZLÕ~gåZ=t{0+Zy·ŠtzZ:YäÅOñ¯Ò5ÿG`ŠHZzgz;V**Ü{**òZq-ÇîV~W!*ŠƒŠHZzgŠd1VÅcÄrðWäzZá[Æ!*g{~¶7g~ƒz{**Ü~BñÇX

/'Z[äÆZgâöÆ‚tŠzr×VXWäzZÑ[šM¡~aZƒÇXZzgWäzZÑ[**Ü~BñÇXäÆZgâöäZLiø~zZu]ÅgzÝ~ŠzâVrÇVÃ7gZ™Š3c*ìX

Zk!*g}~HHì: ß‡»Zgâö Z[Š¶÷÷ZyŠâV~Z(ƒZ„Zz±ð YN]4ø

GNÅ§sÐt¬Yg~ƒZ‚g~Š*ÆßÍVÆ**x‘YNXt«ZÌâ+ÎgtÆqÁÃg/ÆÇ~ƒðXZzgƒßv**xZäÆnZLZLàÃ‰X:-ŠÌÒ5ÿGÆà**Ü{ÐŠZîŠÆàšM¡ŠH·Št~ìXZknz{ŠZîŠÆyZäZzgZzÑŠÐåX@*ZK|Æ‚Bqn¶**xZñXZ#z{z;VÂZ(ƒZZkÆzäÜ»z‰ÜMWàXZzg

DS i^ M ]?m^l N EÖçÎê^h Zk»UN*gCaZƒZZzgZkäZkÃÀ}~™lã~g3YèZyÆzZWuZñ~(:¶X÷÷QZ#ñ.ÅÑ<ÆñZ¬ZyÆ0*uƒäÆŠy7g}ƒ‰Âz{ZkÃk,zÑñ@*}.Zz0+ÆWÐq¢™,óóX

DNN ]?mk M EÖçÎê^h

DOU ]?mk M EÖçÎê^h ÷÷ZzgZ#z{}.Zz0+ÅÑ<Æ_.ƒ¼™`ÂÒ5ÿG~ZLà**Ü{ÃQ‰óóX/'Š¶0*Šg~™r#ŠzâVr×V¾ÌðÐ7g~ƒIXß‡»ZgâöHì-ŠZzg%*¯Ò5ÿGÆà**Ü{Æg

zZá¸z;VÐ%ŠxÑg~Æn·ŠtÆàšM¡W**7,Zz;VaÅzÑŠ]»z‰ÜWŠHZzgÁqÅzÑŠ]ƒXz;VÐk,zƒDƒñzZ:Ò5ÿGÆà**Ü{−‰XÍc***Ü~ÌBñYègzZá„**Ü{Æ¸ZzgaZöÅrðÌ7g~ƒXtÂìß‡»ÒyX

ä»ÒyW\Zz6,7,|`šM¡~aÅaZöƒð)Íc*t{0+ZyZÏ´‘»gzZÑå(z;VÐ‹zŠöÆegÐ¸v™^−‰X‹zŠöÅzÃ]ÅZ:qBÂzZ:¦Wñ1Z#‹‹zŠö»ªÝgCZgÜîk·Št~qÁìÂz;VYäÐeg}ZzgÒ5ÿG−‰XZzgz;VÆZq-à**Ü{~W!*Šƒ‰XZk§bŠzâVr×V7g~ƒIXŠ@0*Šg~™r#W\ä;BÅÌð!ŠzâVZgâÁVäŠzâVr×V¾ÌðÐ7g~™ÆŠ3Š,XW\äZ²ZxŒÛWy6,Îc*åz{6Ç**)6,(,}izgÐU*"$ƒZX

Ò**]}.ZÅ§s™[™@* Garbled /'ZzgZÌ!*]»7ƒðXW\ä¹åŒÛWyrÇVÆ´z{@*gõÆ0Ì1ëW\ÃW\Æëè<ØfYÆÒy7™Šï Garbled ìXtÂW\U*"$7™nŒÛWyÆ@*gõÆ!*g}~ÃyÐÒ**]

5

ìXŠzâVr×V Garbled TÐ¥xƒYñÇß‡»tÒy-ŠZzg%*%ŠxÑg~~**xZäÆnšM¡‰ÜqU*"$™äÆnWäzZÑ[**Ü~BñÇ1šM¡~aZƒÇt@*gõ7Åt{0+ZygzZÑ**Ü{»åXZk§bÁq**Ü~Bc*1aZöšM¡~ƒðYèZyŠâVz;VŠHƒZåX

Z[ÎZwtaZƒ@*ìZ¤/t{0+Zy**Ü{»gzZÑåÂšM¡¾nŠHƒZåXZkÆnß‡ÆZgâöät±gF,Záì-ŠŠZîŠÆyZäÐmg‚råz;VYä6,6gåX „ZzÍ]4ø

GÆ¬Ð«%ŠxÑg~ƒg„¶ZzgZk~**xZäÆn1ß‡t@*g]zZ§7™DƒñtÈwŠHÅ@*g]ïtU*"$™Š}Ït%ŠxÑg~ZkñµÐF‚wˆƒð¶Xß‡

ÆZgâöÃÂšM¡~zÑŠ]Årð7g~™äÆnšM¡YäÆnË·äÅ¢zg]¶X%ŠxÑg~ZkÆiâ:’k,Ðœ~¬»zZ§åX¾Ãc*Šì%ŠxÑg~¥îg6,Á@*g:V~ƒð;V%ŠxÑg~Zq-gzZ§åZzg(,ZZYñ§åZkÃ-ŠZzg%*ÆšM¡»!*)¯Šc*Yñ1ß‡ÆZgâö‚B„tÌÉÆZk%ŠxÑg~Æz‰ÜÃg/áx»qÁåXZzgÃg/@*gõÆ_.LÌ‹zŠöÅi0+Ï~áx»qÁ7g;Å<å XEZt‚gZÒyÌ‡uìXZÚ6,ñi!*ªÆ¬Ý!{3¨4è EE

GE|áÐèIîg6,Îîgnp˜:

"According to Luke Joseph and Mary had been residents of Nazareth i n Galilee (Cf. 1:26) Jesus

was born in the stable of an inn in Bethlehem because the exigencies of an imperial census had

brought his parents to the city of David. In contrast the birth stories in

Mathew assume that Jesus was born in Bethlehem because that was where

Joseph & Mary had their residence. The family left Bethlehem and settled in Nazareth only after an

interlude in Egypt, in response to oracles that warned against threats to the life of the Christ child. All

this raises the question: was Jesus born in Bethlehem? or did both Luke &

Msyyher matthew did scount the tradition that Jesus had come out of Nazareth and tell their

variant of his birth at Bethlehem in order that he might better fulfill Jewish

messianic expectation?" (The Interpreters Bible: vol VIII, New york Abingdon Cokesbury

press).

Å‚~–ì: Peaks

"In making his point Lk. seems to have made use of historical date with which he was

imperfectly acquainted. A census was held about A.D.6, when Quirinius was legate of Syria

and Coponius procurator of Judea (Jos, Ant. XVII, XIII,5; XVIII,i.I). This is referred to in Ac. 5:37, and

Luke was probably uncertain of its date and ignored the inconsistency involved here is associating it

with the region of Herod." (Peaks Commentary on the Bible, General Editor

and New Testament Editor Matthew Black Nelson)

Š¶!0*Šg~z‹~™r#!W\äŒÛWyˆ6,rÇVÆ´z{ZL£œÆn@*gõÃ /'—hä»Z²ZxÎc*åXW\Æ¸ðt™DZgâÁVä|][Ã·Š~Âu]Æ_.7gZZ@*gäÆnZkx»Zg‚[Hì?

//'ZÌZzgWÐ¾äÆZgâöä|][ÅzÑŠ]6,‹zŠöÆšM¡Æa%zZä»rŠgHìX@*gõ~ÂZkzZ§»Ãðf™7MXƒYìÔët™fe@*gõ~tzZ§ŠgƒäÐg{ŠHƒ)Z¤/pi$©ø GEäZkiâäÅ-@*gõè

ì(¾°ZÒwâyfe‹zŠöäšM¡ZzgZkÅuuzVÆZ0+gŠz‚wJ-Å/ÆƒaO™zZŠñXZ[ä»ZgâöZk

6

'×ú)zZ§6,Ì6,ZäÇ**óÅZq-rððV™@*ìX–ì:÷÷Z#‹zŠöäŠ¬X±Vä÷}‚BçÅÂ.e$VƒZZzgWŠòŸ™šM¡ZzgZkÅƒuuzVÆZ0+gÆZyÓx±ÃV

ÃO™zZŠc*ŠzŠz',kc*ZkÐgL¸XZkz‰ÜÆ[ÐZkäX±VÐïÅ¶Zkz‰Üz{!*]7g~ƒðk,x{ÑÅcÄ½ˆ¶:gZ)~WzZi‹ðŠ~

(18@*16 Wc*] 2 â?gZ4ZL”VÃgzg„ìZzg−Jw7™CZknz{7)ä!*[ gz**Zzg(,Z/'Z[fgZk,x{ÅÂ[Åw™Š¶T»jZ!ääŠc*ìXk,x{~|]gZ4|]©[ÅZq-ç~‰Zzgµ

ZuZLÅâVÅwgBb‰X·Š~Dbt—$¸ç EEÆúÆ³~{~¯™!*.ÞáYñ‰ZyÆgzä»f™ì)gZ)~|]gZ4ÅG¶XÍc*á²Z:Z0+Zi~u5ŠHìµZuZLÆŠkDbÆZ§¯™°zíGYä6,gZ4ZKGÐò™gzùg„(X

!*ª9ì: Interpreters œ-VˆšM¡~ƒäzZá¸„Zq-ÛèzZ§»k,x{~Ãðf™7X "Rachel, the mother of Joseph and Benjamin and hence the ancestress of the northern

tribes, in her represented as weeping over the loss of her children,i.e.over the exile of the northern

tribes. The Prophet comforts her with the promise that after their repentance they

will be returned and restored to their lands." (The Interpreters Bible: vol V page: 1031)

Š¶0*Šg~™r#ŒÛWyÑp6,ZzgÑ²!~V6,W\»tZ²ZxÎ**Íf!*vÑLŠú~t] /'Å{§‚—’ÅrÇVZzg@*gõÃ%zhF,zh™7™DpŠW\ÃHµ7,ZXk,x{Åz{„g]ÑàÆ·Š~Z§zVÆ!*g{~¶ZzgXÅZ§~6,ZyÅâVgZ4»gz**åW\ÅÂ[lkä[ÅzÑ]6,ðV™äÅ**»xÃÒÅZzgZkc”VÆO»Zq-Z(zZ§F,ZÙ7,ZZkiâ:Å-@*gõ~ñŠ7X

ÌŠNkß‡»Zgâöqì|][»{0+Zy¯Ò5ÿGÆ**Ü{Ð·ŠtÆšM¡~%ŠxÑg~ Zq-Zzg%: /'Z[nWc*Xz;V|][ÅzÑŠ]ƒðz;VÐk,zƒDƒñZzg}.ZÆy~q¢~Šïƒñ¦ñzZ:Ò5ÿGÆ**Ü{~‰Xä» Æ

ZgâöHìšM¡~aÅaZöÆˆ‹zŠöÆegÐ¸v™−‰Zzg‹zŠöÅzÃ]6,Ð|][Ã‚Bá™zZ:WñX

aZƒðXZzg6,ZäÇ**)ÐZkä /'Z[äÆZgâöÃøD¬Š]Zk¸„ÛèzZ§6,ÌÃðrððV™äÅpZé: Zq-jZ!eð&+„1TÐ[»ÐW**U*"$ƒXOçZgâöqì

DMR ]?mk M EÚjoe^h ÷÷@*}.Zz0+äÑÅcÄ¹åz{7gZƒ^Ð~äZLdWÃšc*óóX1ZkjZ!ÃŠg™DƒñZgâöä7g~ZôoÅìZkL{Ð¬ZzgˆÆLZ]}Šg:ƒYNXYèå

jZ!¼Zk§bì:÷÷Z#ZuZLZÌ^„å~äZkÐ›g¿ZzgZLdWÃÐšc*XZrVäTŠgZyÃšc*ZÏŠgz{ŠzgƒD‰XZrVä$›Í-ê EG

DN i^ M ]?mk MM Eaç‰nÄe^h ÆnŒÛ!**V¦/Zg3ZzgF,ZÙƒðñgZVÆnlg°c*óóXŠ¬0*Šg~™r#W\ä!ZkÃë;BÅÌðXƒW~Ërð»Ãðf™:åXZk~ÂƒWÑÐ¹¬ZuZL}.Z

»gCìZk»|]ñ.Æ‚BÐWä»f™ìX˜VÐ}.ZäZ7Â©Ænšc*1ZrVäÑLqŠzVÃ}.Z¯1XäÆZgâöäaZöÆ|][ÆáYäZzgQz;VÐzZ:ÑñYä»zZ§Z£F,ZáìXYètÒyß‡ÆÒyÐ”Z@*ìX

QZkÅ@*G~ƒWÅZq-rðŠg™Š~rð7ÉâèÆZq-zZ§»Òyì?

7

ÃyŠêìŒÛWyc**Ç**)? Garbled Statements /'Ûâ0*Šg~z‹~™r#rÇVZzg@*gõÆ0ÌÍkXä»Zgâö!*sy|][Ã¯Ò5ÿGÆ**Ü{~à@*ì)ß‡ÆÒyÆÜsYèz{ Zq-Wy~!*] Z[W\

Hì-ŠZzg|]%*ÂgzZá„**Ü{Æ¸(Z[ZkÆnÌrðe’1‚g}6,ZäÇ**ó~Zzg¤>Š~Â**Ü{»ÂÌ7Wc*pWy;BÅÌðÆz{âCÙXä»Zgâöqì:

÷÷Z#‹zŠö%ŠHÂŠd}.Zz0+ÆÛºä~-ŠÃpZ[~Š3ðŠ}™¹ZJZkaZzgZkÅâVÃáÃZuZLÆo~`YYèaÅYyÆpZ;V¸z{%‰X:z{ZVZzgaZzgZkÅâVÃ‚Bá™ZuZLÆo~WŠH1Z#‹ZgÜîkZL!*\‹zŠöÅ(·Št~!*Šá„™@*ìÂz;VYäÐegZZzgpZ[~@Ze$0*™¯Ò5ÿGÆ´‘~gzZ:ƒŠHZzg**Ü{**xZq-

(23@*19 Wc*] 2 à~YÎ@*1VÅcÄ¹ŠHåz{7gZƒz{**Ü~BñÇóóX)ä!*[Z[6Zz6,ÒyƒZ‚g}6,ZäÇ**ó~**Ü{»Â7ìXËÑä**Ü~BäÅrð7ÅX¤>Š~ÌtÂ7

ìXZÚ6,ñi!*ªÆ'˜:''The village of nazareth is not mentioned in any ancient records''.(Volume VII page 262)

Å‚!*ª~–ì: Peaks

"It is curious that Nazareth is not mentioned in OT, Josephus or Talmud".

(A Commentary on the Bible by Arthurs. Peaks page 702).

Qtä»Zgâö**Ü{»Â¹VÐáWc*X¸'˜$iš5é GG{Ôk,x{Zzgr¨45é EEG{~f™åWäzZÑ[ŠZîŠÅác~(ZzgácÆn‡ZãÂ÷÷¾óóZEwƒZìXäÆZgâöä|][ÃÐÑ™**Ü{~Îc*ZzgácÆÂ 702 ÐƒÇX)™

Ð©àÏp~™ÆZÐ**Ü{¯c*X!!! Garbled Statements /'Š¶0*Šg~™r#ZkÃë@*gõZzgrÇVÆ!*g{~

Yâ( 1997 BŠc 11 Yâ@*1997 BŠc 5 ),·:ZZÚD

DO EÎŠ¼ÞÛf†Z[ëZk*yÆŠzu}{ÃfeZzgŠÙŒÛWyˆäô`‚—ÅrÇVZzg@*gõÆ0HgztZ(g

Òy0*c*Y@*ì?ë%:Æîg6,¼@*g]zZu]»Y,{feŒÛWyZzg!*ªŠzâV~ Garbled HìZzgHŒÛWyˆ~ÃðñŠX

!*ªÅr×VŒÛWyˆ~èÃg$45ÿIGñÏðÆ¼gÅrð

!*ªÅr×VXÅ§sŒÛWyÑp~Zág{ìZy~ÐãCŠ~ZzgZÝZÑßwrð!*ª~ñŠ{Q~ (' 1))ÎgZðQB@*ì(ZyZÖp~ì:X

óóª~ZyÆnZy„Æ¸ÇV~Ð¾~â#Zq-Ñ',0*™zVÇX ZÞ^eo]ÎnÜÖ^âÜÚnÏh]ìnãÜÒ^Úçì^ LDMT ]?mk MT E]‰j%ß^ðe^h

W\Y…ZkrðÅ@*G~i1gÔ$iš5é GG{~r×V0*ðYCZzgZ**ãZg‹~ZyrÇVÅ§sZág{ìX

8

(ÆZÖp~ìXµ 11 We$ ³çå]Ö³ûÏ^Í óó) Zã³³â³ºÚ³àe³ß³o]]ñnØÂ×oÚ%×ä ZkrðÅ§sZág{ŒÛWy™*~LZuZL~ÐZq-xZyÍZ{äZLZq-$45ÿIGÅÞŠ]Š~¶X

]Ö³m³àmjf³Ã³çá ŠzuZZág{ZkÀòWe$~ìT~ZkrðZzgŠzu~rÇVÅ§sù¦îg6,Zág{ìXÛâ@*ìX÷÷()ZvÅgØZyßÍV 158 We$ ]Ö³³çÙ]Ö³ßf³o]Ö^Úo]ÖpmræÞäÚÓjçe÷ÂôßøâöÜÊo]Öjùç]éôæ]Ö^ÞrnØXXEçé]Ö^Â]Í

Ænì(ZkgÎwÑZ&ö OÅZnq™DT»f™z{ÂgZ>ZzgZg~0*DXóó ]ôÞ$^]ø»ø×»ßø^]ôÖøn»ÓöÜ»øöç»÷ø^âô]÷Âø×øn»ÓöÜ»ÒøÛø^]ø»ø×»ßø^]ôÖoFÊô»Âøç»áøøöç»÷³ ~ì÷÷ 158 ÅWe$ çå]ÖÛ$ ŠZZág{

ëävg~§sZÏ§bZq-gÎw5ì‰ÛúyÅ§sëäZq-gÎw)|]ñ.mZ?x(Ã5åXXZÏ§b‰Zzg£â]6,Ì‰ZágZ]X

Z[C0*Šg~z‹~™r#ŒÛWyÑpäÃrðÃ%zhF,zh™7Ûâðì?H!*ª~zZãîg6,Zq-ñ.‰ÑÆ¼gÅrðìc*7??XZ¤/ìZzgW\Ìt™DZ+rðñŠìTÆfg=WyÅ!*Šá„ZuZLÐáà

(ÂQ¾¯Y6,W\tŠúò™DŒÛWyˆä!*ª 43 We$ 21 YñÏZzgZkxÃZkÆVÑñŠ}Š~YñÏ)ä!*[ÅrðÃ%zhF,zh™7Ûâc*ìX

áh+W\t}ŒÛWyˆZyrÇVÃ|]·~V6,ðV™@*ìZzg¸Zy»%zh**F,zh**ìÂH0*Šg~™r#=th7~¼VW\ZyrÇVÃÁq6,ðV™gìZzgZk§bW\ZyÃ%zhF,zhgìXW\Ãt7gZhìŠ?Ð}tr×V·gÎwZv~V6,ðV7ƒ'Zzg=t7gZhì~Š?Ð!*]™zVtr×VÁq**Ü~6,ðV7ƒ'X~ZzgW\d$ÆŠZ],{~g{™ZyrÇVÅ´â]ÃZLZLIh+{]Zt6,ðV™äÅW»hgnp

1W\tU*"$7™MhŒÛWyˆäZyrÇV~Ãðp~ÅìÔÃðÄç-$ÅìÔÃð—h™7™äÅÃÒÅìW\»ŠúòåX

Årð~´â]ÒyÅˆz{¾6,7g~ZF,CXZ**ãÆ 18 We$ 18 WZ[WgZxÐÖ™ŠBZ]Y!*[óó Þ³êo]ÎnÜÖ^âÜÚnÏh]ìnãÜÒ^Úçì^ ~trðZk§bìÊ÷ 18 We$ 18 Áq6,c*ŒÛWyˆÆ·~V6,!ÎzZãƒZ]Y!*[

kãCŠ~rðÆˆZkÑÆ!*g}~¼´â]ZzgZkÅÙ|#Å ~Zq-ÑZyÆnZyÆ¸ÇV~Ð¾~â#9Z™zVÇXZzgZ¼¶K*VŠg`X

ZkrðÆ]ZtÅtìz{Zq-ÑƒÇX›yZkrðÃWÀ]~V6,ðV™D1W\åÃ «´#Ö Z[}.Zc*}.Z»ÇgCŒÛZg7ŠïXW\Ãƒ1VÐZaZzgƒ»uŠZgŒÛZgŠï1W\åÃÑ„â…XW\\ßvZkrðÃZ**ãÆÁq6,ðV™D1tŠúò™DÁqZKyƒDƒñÌCÙÒpÐCÙòÐÔCÙUÐ»ï}.ZåXZzgZKã@*gõ~LtzZ§:¬ƒZZzg:ˆ~ƒÇ}.Z¬\ìZK]Ì]Zzg]ÆZKã^~¼g5+k,ƒZX

Z[fgZgÅÃÐŠ¶Ht!*]ëwÃWCìZq-xZyY{z°wzZá!*Šá{c*œgZ%Mc*gzkÆu',Z{ÅWæÅtKg]ZyZÖp~Š~YñZq-e÷—´º~WäzZÑìc*Zq-¾&+gZQÆWä»f™Zk§bHYñZq-v¾&+gÅWæáµìXZ¤/ZK+MÅ@*gõ~«ŠiZzgWy~ŠiZKã]k~}.Zñ³zV»¼gƒäzZÑåÂZkÅtKg]ÜsZq-ÑÆZÖp~ŠbÂZ(„ìZq-',F,ZzgZdÅWæ»E+™{ZŠÌwÆÂÐHYñX

ZkWäzZáÅZyZÖp~ÒyÅˆìz{µZuZLÆ¸ÇV~ÐƒÇXW\0*Šg~W\äp[ Šzu~´#Ö(XµZuZLZzgµZ³ŠzâV„|]Z',Z 25 !*ª7,SìW\Y…µZuZLÆ¸ðµZ³X)aZö!*[

mZ?xÅZzÑŠXƒYìW\4+\oŠzVÅ§bt±g7™,!*ª~µZuZLÃZq-Šzu}»¸ðŒÛZgŠc*ŠHìXÅ<å XEZZkrð~Ì¸ÇVÐ%ZŠµZuZL„Ât±gW\»Šg„:ƒÇXYè˜VZ]Yz){Ã~µZuZLÃµZuZLÆ¸ðÆîg6,f™HŠHìz;V¼Z©â]Š‰ZzgµZuZLÆCÙÛŠÃæ[HŠHìz{ZL¸ÇVÐ(

Årð~Â‚g~¸xµZuZLÅ¨ù¦%ZŠàˆìµZuZLÆÃZ+{ÆnZq- 18 We$ 18 |u™}1Z]Y!*[

9

ñ.6Ñ¬_ƒÇXZyµZuZLÆ¸ÇV~ÐƒÇXªCÙìz{ÑƒµZuZLÆÃZ+{Ænì:PÆnXZzgªCÙìƒµZuZL¨ù¦ï™ZL„¸ðÂ7ƒMhXZ¤/¼µZuZL»f™ƒ@*c*¼Ðæ[ƒ@*Â¢zgz{ŠvµZuZLÆ¸ðŒÛZgŠñYMhX1Z#ŒVƒµZuZL%ZŠÂZyƒÆ¸ÇVÐ%ZŠ¢zgÃðZ+¸xƒÏµZuZL

~áï7ZzgªCÙìz{µZ³ÎaZöÅÂ[µZuZLÆ¸ðŒÛZgŠîìXZzgªCÙìZk´#ÖÆÒpÐZ**ãÆÁqZkrð»]Zt7;VŒÛWyˆÆ·~VZkÆ]ZtX

tCðˆìz{ÑñÏ»$45ÿIGƒÇXÛâ0*Šg~™r#ZzgŠw6,;BgÄ™Ûât´#Ö Š~´#Ö Zkrð~WÀ]~V6,7g~ZF,Cìc*Áq6,?

]Þ³Û³^]Þ³^eº |]ñÏðZKyZzg7g~§bZKyZzgxgÎwX|]·~V»ïZKyZzgxF,+gÎwXÛâD:üû1Áq–wW\Æ}.ZÔ}.Z»ÇgCXñ.Æ$45ÿIGÁqƒñc* m³^]mã³^]Ö³ßù³^]Þ³o³çÙ]Ö³×³³ä]ÖnÓÜqÛnÃ^ ûZzgü Ú%³×ÓÜ

WÀ]~V?/'|]ñ.Zq-i',Š„Ñ<ÑñT~µZuZLÆn@Ze$¶XWÀ]~VZq-»ïÑ<ÑñT~

ƒŠ*Æn@Ze$¶XÁqÃðÑ<7ÑñÉ–wW\Æ‚—Ñ<ÃÌ™c™Šc*XÂQñ.Æ$45ÿIGWÀ]~Vƒñc*Áq??

/'|]ñ.Zq-Y',xÅ§sÇ‰XZzgZyÅÓxF,ÃÒÆ!*zŠZyÆÑÐôpgìZzgZyÆ´‘Ðó]™‰X

WÀ]~VZq-ªÝxÅ§sÇ‰ZzgZyÅÓxÃÒÆ!*zŠZyÆÑÐôpgìZzgZyÆ´‘Ðó]™‰XÁq×Zq-6,Zð¸xZzgÓ#ÖÅ§sÇ‰1W\ÆìwÆ_.ZyÅÑZgÂVÐ$:nZzgâgŠñ‰ZzgZ¤/p

ZrVä¹Âå÷~ZzgÌƒ,Zkƒ{:Å7=ZyÆ0*kÌY**¢zgì1ñ]ÅzzÐtZgZŠ{7gZ:ƒeZzgó]:™nX$45ÿIGñ.ÃyìXWÀ]~Vc*ÁqmZ?x??

/'|]ñ.ZLZë»xÅ×Š™Æ¯]ƒñZzgZÏi}~Š®ƒñZzgšM¢šð EEg~ZyÅGµXWÀ]~VZLZë»xÅŠ™Æ¯]ƒñZzgZÏi}~Š®ƒñZzgæÜëg{~W\»'×Zg¯XÁqZL»x~

(,~uJ-–wZ**ã**»xgìZzgðh}Ð%h+¶¸z{Ì–wZ**ãzZ§ÇÆz‰Ü¸v‰Zzg}.Z¬\äW\Ã)·Š~ç0++ZzggzòÓ#ÖÐXäÆn(Wy6,ZV1XC$45ÿ

IGñ.ÃyìWÀ]~Vc*Áq??

/'|]ñ.Ñ<ÑñZkÃW\äZKx~gZòHXZq-Âx‡ìH˜Vz{½**ÇÅYñXWÀ]~V»ïÑ<ÑñZÐW\äZK¸x~gZòHXúiÔi2>Ôez){ÆZ©â]ÅF,zóÛâðXZq-Âx‡ìH˜Vz{½**ÇÅ

C0*Šg~™r#$45ÿIGñ.ÃyìX YñXÁqÃtñ§:5ZK½ÃgZò™,ÃðÂx‡ì™ÆŠ3N˜Vz{½**ÇÅYñXWÀ]~Vc*Áq?

/'|]ñ.mZ?xÅfZ]~°w¸å1)wÌåZzgÂgZ>9ìW\ƒgzñi}ÆßÍV~J¸Zzg¹ÐñZµ6,W\äZLŠ7VÃçsHX

WÀ]~V~°wZzg)wŠzâVÌ]ZL¾w6,‰Zzgô/Æfg=W\Å°ài»×ic*Š{¼gƒZ)6Z[|][ñúŠmZ?xÆfg)W\åÅ)ài»×ic*Š{¼gì(1ÁqÆfg=Ãð°àiªCÙ:ƒðZzg:W\Ãtñ§5Ó#ÖZzg¤‰Ügnpƒñ,ZzgŠg¦/gÐ»xBXqÑèWÀ]~Vä|]ñ.mZ?xÅ§b1W\Ð¹(,|™¤‰ÜZzg]gnpƒñ,ZzgŠg¦/g»x%:Š3c*X

ÎvZzgCN0*Šg~™r#$45ÿIGñ.WÀ]~Vc*Áq??

/'Z[CN0*Šg~™r#Z¤/W\$45ÿIGñ.ÅrðÁq6,ðV™DÂÁq~Zzg|]ñ.~H˜t0*ðYCì?ðh~¹˜tÂŠ*ÆZÐZZÛZŠ~ÌQì1Z#}.Z¬\Årð~tÃ´#ÖZzgÙ|#¯c*ŠHƒÂ

10

Ãð{m˜tSe’1ÁqZzg|]ñ.~ÂÃð˜tÃ7WCX/'eìW\Ìz„±g7™**e¬xîg6,U*â~ŠgzÆ\oŠZkñ§6,7H™D|]ñ.äµ

]»‚âyHÁqÌÇ6,%™]»!*)¯X ZuZLÅ10*Šg~™r#tÂZNŠ~Z%ìXªCÙUíÂZk»Ãðo]7X~(,~~Ðt!*]HƒVÁqÐ¹(,|™WÀ]

~VäÀŠ*Å]»‚âyHXtÂ÷}ZzgW\ÆZNŠÅ!*]ì1rð~T§bÅt»f™ìz{tÁqZzgñ.~7QZzg:„)p[gÐ[(ÁqäZLnLZk˜t»ZLnŠúòHìX1tt(,~áyÆ‚B|]ñ.ZzgWÀ]~V~0*ðYCì)ZzgŒÛWyÑp~tŠúòñŠì(ZzgQttW\ŠzâVx1VÅfZ]J-7g„ÉŠzâVx

‚wÆ[»¼gƒZZÏ§bZã„²áÆ 1300 1VÅZáVÆqÑ]~Ìtt0*ðYCìX‚T§bñ.ÅZ#Ö~Z#Ö·t~Zq-xZy[»¼gƒZX

Zk$45ÿIGñ.ÑÅZ]Y~tCðˆì: a¶´#ÖDMT ]?mk MT ]‰j%ßßðeh ¼~ZÐ¬Šzóz{ZyÐ¾ÇX) ÷÷ZzgZC¯xZkÆì~eZßVÇZzg

C0*Šg~™r#Z¤/W\Áq6,ZkrðÃðV™DÂz{¯x¹Vì}.Z¬\äÁqÆì~eZÑXyz0*ÎyÆÁDoŠzVÅ§b=W\Zkß.~eZ%ÅÃÒ:™,z{¯xäÔ%²Ôß‡Zzg-¦ÅZ**ãXtoŠ‚Š{ßb›âVÃZgÆÂÐZkß.~2™DÍc*tegzVZ**ãz{¯xì}.ZÅ§sÐÁqÆì~eZÑŠHX10*Šg~™r#W\ÃÂp[¥xìtegzVZ**ã|][ÆiâäÆèIZzgtZKã¯x~:}.Z»¯xX1WÀ]~V6,t#ÖÌp[ðVƒCìZzgZq-ÎaŠ{ŒÛWãÎgÂVÅ~z{¯xZ[ÌZÏ§bñŠZzgôpìZv¬\äW\Æì~eZÑX

Zz6,ÅWe$~tCðˆì÷÷Zzg¼~ZÐ¬ŠzVÇz„ZyÐ¾ÇóóXt#ÖÌTáyÐWÀ] 0*v,´#Ö‚wÆ²~p[ÅwÅw™ŒÛWyˆ»CÙCÙÂÔCÙCÙWe$ 23 ~V~7g~ƒðÁq~7g~ƒCÃ7WCXWÀ]~Vä

óóZzgZ#tÂ[7g~**iwƒ_ÂZq-ÑÄÐiZZ+Æ… Zm³]mã³^]ÖçÙe×ÈÚ^]ÞÙ]ÖnÔ ßÍVÃ‹Š~Zzg–Š~6pŠZv¬\äÛâc*LóóH~äZCx»àŠc*ZzgZ#ƒ…äàWzZi Zâ³Øe×ùÇk(âØe×ùÇk(âØe×ùÇk ~p[Åw™Šgc*ÄHZzg—WzZiÐ7YL

XªZ}Zv ]Ö³×ã³Ü]ã(]Ö×ãÜ]ã(]Ö×ãÜ]ãXX tÍZ„Š~W\ätxàŠc*ÂWyÅ§sZiZV™}.Z¬\Ã#¥™ÆÛâc*:÷÷ÂÍZ{g{xÂä=àäÆnŠc*åz{~äàŠc*ìX

Z[ŠBHt´#ÖW\ÅZ**ãÆÁq6,Ì7g~ZF,Cì?W\ÁqÃ}.Zâ…Ô}.ZÅ]»â´ŒÛZgŠï1HÁqäZKi!*y~LZk!*]»ZŒÛZgZzgZÖgH?Zß:ÂŠg)gÁqÃZL[ƒäÆZÖgÐÌZÁnåX™s–ìÊ÷÷Zkz‰ÜZkäZL

DNL ]?mk MR X!EÚjoe^h á¤/ŠzVÃ¬Šc*ËÃ:C**~[ƒVóZLÁq»øg}·~VÆZkgzbÐ£¨<Z#–»ÅßzZŠ~~ŠÔÆZe7-)áµúÅzzÐW\åŠÔÅ»g

Zzg¾zVÅ1Yh~(,~¼®)Zzg·Šg~Æ‚B:ÜsWÐ(,_−‰ÉŠÔÃX~ÐZÒe$W\åÃT…Ì:ƒftÈ™óóXZkÆ£«~W\ÅZ**ãÆÁqÃZâZôoæÃ¶ Z]Þ³³]Ö³ßfoÖ³^Òhý ZKÙ|#Ì™zZðZzgZL£x»Z´yÌÛâc*:L

ZrVäZzgZyÆ&jZg-VäNhÆZz6,Zq-BÂg{Š¬T~|]ñ.ZzgZYÃWñXZkÆ!*g{~%²ÅZg~–ì:DU ]?mk U EÚ³†Î‹eh Z¼?äŠ¬ìËÐ:Ióó ÷÷Z#z{NhÐZF,D¸ÂZkäZyÃ¬Šc*Z#J-Z0WŠx'çNŠzV~ÐY:

Zzg-¦ÅZg~ÂÁqätXp[Åw™CŠc*ì:Óx!*'Åw™CðZzg:CMhX÷÷=?ÐZzgÌ¹Ï!*'I1Z[?ZyÅ',ŠZ“7™MhpZ#z{ªCð»gzbWñÇÂ?ÃÓxCðÅgZ{Š3ñÇXZknz{ZK§sÐ:¾ÇÉ

DMO (MN ]?m^l MR Emçuß^e^h X ¼•Çz„¾ÇXZzg»WÒ{Å¸,Š}ÇóóZ¤/W\ƒÅÃÐ:ŠBÂÁqŠgZÝŒVZkrðÅ§sZág{™gìøg}W\ÆŠgxyâ/ZÕZqìZzgZk

DMT ]?mk MT ]‰j%ß^ðe^h )X rðÆZ4ZÖpÅ§sÁqŒVZág{™gì÷÷¼~ZÐ¬Šzóz„z{ZyÐ¾ÇóóZzgŒV-¦ÆjZ!~ÁqäZág{™Šc*ì~pŠZkrð»]Zt7Éz{zŠìÓxCðÅgZ{Š3äzZÑìXTÅÍZ„

11

Š¶ÆnÁq=pÑñ¸6ZrVä¨îkÆ‚tÒyŠïƒñ¹Ê÷÷~ZknaZƒZZzgZkzZWŠ*~Wc*ƒVDOS ]?mk MT Emçuß^e^h h6,ÍZ„ŠzVóóX

W0*Šg~™r#ëW\Æ‚tŠ*zm,~o]Å§bZq-Z+!*]7™DTÆË~Šz~ÐZq-!*]¾qwW\Ãâ'7,}Ïc*tâ'7,}ÇÁqZKx]ÃÖDgìZzgZLZÝuÃZrVäªCÙ7ƒäŠc*X)Z¤/t!*]9ìÂW\Z]Y!*[

ÅrðCÙ¦/Áq6,ðV7™MhYèrð~¹ŠHìZkrðÆ]ZtÃ÷÷~¼VÇz„z{ZyÐ¾ÇóóXc* 18 We$ 18zg]ŠvW\t!*]t™ä6,6gƒfÁqäz{x])eÔñg{ÔZß:[Ô[»¬KuÔñÎ~Ñ<»¬ƒ**z){(

§s™[™DƒñZLZ+ŒÛZgŠïXZzgZ¤/t CÙ¦/7Š,W`|áÁqÅ§s™[™CìXªz{Z+W\ÁqÅ!*]Šg„ìÂW\ÁqÅúÒÏ»Z(g„7gnpX

/'¾qwW\Áq6,Zkl)Å»ggzZð7,#·ŠÅ°Zª¬DÆ‚tÁq6,`c*ŠHXW\Y…Áq6,Šz°ZpV~l)`XZq-l)·ŠÅèI°Zª¬D~ZzgZq-¨îkÅ°Zª~X¨îkÅ°Zª~ÂÁqÆ#5»‚gZizgtåZ7„»!*©U*"$™,ZzgZk§bZ7MmJNX1·Š~fYäpŠZKèI°Zª~Zy6,l)`c*Zk~‚gZizgZk!*]6,åZ7Š+ñÎ~Ð',XU*"$™,XZk°ZªÅ»ggzZðegzVZ**ã~ñŠìXOçäÅZg~–ì:

÷÷ZzgÁqÆñäzZáZkÃ»$¨é JE**xuŠZg»‚Æ0*ká‰˜V¢©->î EGGXZzg),gv¦ƒ‰¸XZzgBkŠzgŠzgZkÆúuŠZg»‚

ÆŠ-Zy{:J-ŠHZzgZ0+gY™\ŠzVÆ‚B³ŠÚÖŠHZzguŠZg»‚Zzgƒœg°ZªzZáÁqÃâgeZ%ÆnZkÆÜsÑKÍZ„eð&+äÑ1:0*ðXÍ¹ÐÑLÍZ{WñpWy»gŠzÍZƒVäW™¹Zkä¹ì~}.ZÆlkÃeJYZzg&Šy~ZÐ¯YƒVXZzguŠZg»‚ä9}ƒ™ZkÐ¹ÂZ[7Šê?t¾}ÜsHÍZ„Šï?1Áq{ñlg;XuŠZg»‚äZkÐ¹~Ni0+{}.ZÅnŠêƒVZ¤/Â}.Z»gC[ìÂëÐÈŠ}XÁqäZkÐ¹ÂäpŠÈŠc*É~?ÐHƒVZkÆˆ?Z0

WŠxÃ‡ŠgÇÆŠ6§sÆZzgWyÆ!*ŠßV6,WDŠdÐXZk6,uŠZg»‚ätÈ™ZLÀ}Mh}Zkä¬•ìXZ[ëÃDRQ i^ QS ]?m^l NR EÚjoe^h ÍZ„ÅHq~#g„XŠd?äZÌ¬‹ìvg~HgZñì?ZrVäZ[~¹z{OÆÑëìóóX

%²~–ì:÷÷Qz{ÁqÃuŠZg»‚Æ0*káŠHZzgƒuŠZg»‚Zzg),gvZzg¢©->î EGGXZkÆ;V¦ƒ‰ZzgBkÃ,6,ZkÆ

úúuŠZg»‚ÆŠ-Zy{:J-ŠHZzg\ŠzVÆ‚BÖ™Wv@*LÎXZzguŠZg»‚Zzgƒœg°ZªzZáÁqÃâgeZ%ÆnZkÆÜsÍZ„eð&+äÑ1:0*ðYèzVäZk6,ÑKÍZ„VÂŠ,pZyÅÍZ„V5:‰ZzgQ‰äZJ™Zk6,tÑKÍZ„Š~ëäZÐtë‹ì~ZklkÃ;BÐ¯ìeJîVÇZzg&Šy~ŠzuZ¯îVÇ;BÐ:¯ƒXpZk6,ZkÅÍZ„

5:hXZzgQuŠZg»‚äÖ@~9}ƒ™ÁqÐ7YÂ¼Z[7Šê?t¾}ÜsHÍZ„VŠï?1z{{ñl„g;XZzg¼Z[:Šc*XuŠZg»‚äZkÐQÎZwHZzg¹HÂZk2Š{»gC[ì?Áqä¹;V~ƒVXZzg?Z0WŠxÃ‡ŠgÇÅŠ6§sÆZzgWyÆ!*ŠßVÆ‚BWDŠdÐXuŠZg»‚äZLÀ}Mh™¹Z[…ÍZƒVÅHq~#g„??ät¬‹vg~HgZñ

DRP i^ QO ]?m^l MP EÚ†Î‹e^h X ì?Zyƒä:òŠc*z{OÆÑëìóóß‡ÅZg~–ì:÷÷Z#ŠyƒZÂuŠZg»‚Zzg¢©->î EG

GXª¸xÆ),gÍVÅ>¦ƒðZzgZrVäZKœg°Zª~áY™¹Z¤/Â[ìÂëÐÈŠ}XZkäZyÐ¹Z¤/~?Ð¼VÂ¢:™zÐXZzgZ¤/7gVÂZ[:ŠzÐpZ[ÐZ0WŠx‡ŠgÇ}.ZÅŠ6§s´gìÇXZk6,Zyƒä¹:HÂ}.Z»gCì?ZkäZyÐ¹?pŠëƒYè~ƒVXZrVä¹Z[…ÍZ„ÅH

DSM i^ RR ]?m^l NN EÖçÎ^e^h q~#g„?YèëäpŠZÏÆìÐÍ1ìóóX-¦ÅZg~–ìÊ÷QuŠZg»‚äÁqÐZkÆá¤/ŠzVZzgZkÅ½Å!*"$7YXÁqäZÐZ[Šc*~äŠ*Ð´6!*'ÅX~å„Š]{âVZzg«~˜Vƒ·Š~¦ƒD½Š~Zzg7æ{¼7¹XÂíÐYV7ØìXGgzZßVÐ

DNM iMU ]?ml MT Emçußeh ì~äHH¹óóX 7b~äZyÐH¹XŠNZyÃ¥x/'0*Šg~™r#egzVZ**ãÆZyjZßVÃgÐ7,#ZzgŠ¶¾§bt|áÆñŠ{Z+ÆÜsŠ*zm,~o]

½™gìX12

Wy~jZá~–ìÁqä¹~äŠ*Ð´6!*'ÅZzgå„Š•âVZzg«~˜Vƒ·Š¦ƒD½Š~Zzg7æ{¼7¹XÂíÐYV7ØìXGgzZßVÐ7bXŠNZyÃ¥xì~äHH¹XZzg«&Z**ã~™s–ì

Áq6,¬Æo]ÆnÍZ{6,ÍZ{Ññ‰XÑKÍZ„V½ÅI1ÃðÍZ„‡ì:g{mX!*syÁqÆZq-ãL{6,uŠZg»‚äÀ}Mh}Zkä¬•ìXÎZwtìZ¤/Áq»tŠúòCåZrVäZ´6½Š~ìZzg„Š•âVZzg«~·Š-VÅñŠÏ~½Š~Zzg7æ{¼7¹ZzgZk½~Áqä|áÆñŠ{Z+Å½Š~¶ªeÅ½Š~Ô·Š~Ñ<Å™q»ŠúòHÔ]Æ0·Š~Z+ÅOññg{Å½7ÅÔZLW\Ã}.ZÆîg6,7HÔ·Š~¸xÆ£{¸xƒäÅOñZLuÃƒñVZzg”VÆn7VCc*Ô9LÆZ©xÃ™cŒÛZgŠc*Zzgƒ!*'´6}ÔÂtƒ!*'aè·Š~uŠZg»~VZzg¢©-Að

EGGXVÆ

ÃÐ¬É¬$ðEOZbZknœg°ZªÆ‚tÁqÃ»ÛU*"$™äÆn%zVDÙZgzVÅ®ZŠ~FÍZ{9}GYMh¸XH¢zg]¶Zq-ÐZq-ÑN*ÍZ{7HYñZzgQZyÅÍZ„5:†X

/'Z[Ñi˜ZkÆŠz„Ëä3c*ÂÁqäZyZ+ÅZZÑ´yÃð½7Š~XZ¤/t!*]Šg„ìÂÁq6,trððV7ƒCYèZkrð~WäzZá$45ÿIGñ.Å´#ÖtCðˆìZÐ¬Šc*YñÇz{µZuZLÐ¾ÇX

c*ŠzuZ³tÀ_ìÁqä½´6îg6,ƒ·Š-VÃŠ~z{ZyZ+6,CÙ¦/Œ7¶)eÔñg{ÔZß:[Ô¬Ñ<ñÎ~z){(W`Æ|ðÁqÅ§s™[™DX

Yâ( 1997 BŠc 18 Yâ@*1997 BŠc 12 ),·:ZZÚD

E2çiãoÎŠ¼D

Ò**]Šñ‰XZkZ‹Zn Garbled 0*Šg~™r#ÆZkZ‹Zn»ŠzuZztåŒÛWyˆ~ô`Å@*gõÆ!*g{~»Zq-Z[ÂëZz6,,ÐŠ}`tkH{øg}à~7W\„Æà~HY@*ìX

WëŠÙŒÛWyˆäÁzZu]»E+™{Hì˜VZkä‚—ô`ÆñŠ{zg×ZyÆÒ**]ÐZ%sHìZzg‚B‚BZk!*]»Y,{feHZyzZu]Æ!*g{~ŒÛWyˆ»ÒyYz$¨Õä EGSŠg„ìc*0*Šg~z‹~™r#

Æô`»X

|]WŠxð»zZ§/'ªzZ§!*ªZzgŒÛWyˆŠzâV~Òyì|]WŠxð»zZ§ìXZkzZ§ÆÒy~ŒÛWyˆZzg!*ª¹¼

Z·ZuÌgnp1¼Z%Ã]ÌgnpXWZyZ%Ã]»Y,{BX/'ªZ%sŒÛWyˆZzg!*ª~tì!*ª9ìWŠxªZKyåXZkÐ¬™{Zgn6,ÃðZKy:åX1ŒÛWy

ˆWŠxÐ¬™{Zgn6,=zZgZŠ{gppzZà‘tÃt™@*ìX( æ]Ör^áì×Ïß^åÚàÎfØÚàÞ^]ÖÛçÝ )

W`Å‚bZzg@*g]|ŒÛWyˆÅ@*G™Cìc*!*ªÅ? C0*Šg~™r#!//'WŠxÆzZ§ÆÒyÐŒÛWyÅZq-p!Z½™‚tWCìŒÛWyˆZv¬\ÃÓxÌ]õ»âŒÛZgŠê

ìXCÙÍÔ$zg~ÔkH{Zzg{òÐ0*uŒÛZgŠêìX1!*ªäzZ§WŠxÆŸ~)Íf!*v(Zv¬\ÃÑ^1%zZÑZzg-yŒÛZgŠc*ìXOç–ì:÷÷}.Zz0+äWŠxÃ¬Šc*Zzg¹Â!*rÆCÙŠg|#»V"gzuIu3Yìp(z$+ÅTyÆŠg|#»V

13

DMS(MR ]?m^l N Eμn‚]ñe^h X L:3**XYèTgziÂäZk~Ð3c*Â%ZóóQ–ì:

÷÷úg]ä‚,$Ð¹!*rÆŠg½V»VÂë3DXtŠg|#!*rÆÖ@~ìZkÆVÅ!*"$}.Zä¹ì?:ÂZÐ3**Zzg:g**zg:?%YîÐXA$‚,$äúg]Ð¹?CÙ¦/:%zÐÉ}.ZY}ìTŠy?ZÐ3îÐvg~

(Q i^ N ]?m^l O μn‚]ñe^h óX) ÆY+zZÑ0YîÐó W@ÁYNÏZzg?}.ZÅâ#(z$+Zk!*[~,Ðtf™ìZ#WŠxZzgZkÅúg]ätV3c*Âz{%}7É}.ZÅ§b(z$+ÅTyZ7qÝ

(XŠ¶!*ª» NN ]?mk O Eμn³‚]ñ³e^h ƒXOç–ì:÷÷}.Zz0+}.Zä¹ŠdZKy(z$+ÅTy~ëÐZq-Åâ#ƒŠHóóÒyì}.ZäWŠxÐZq-!*]½z{Íf!*vÑKhZzg-yÅ!*]Eh)ªWŠx%Z7(Zzg}òäZkÅ¤&ÅX

Ò**]!*ªŠîìc*ŒÛWy? Garbled Ûâ0*Šg~™r#@*gõÆ0/'0*Šg~z‹~™r#ŒÛWy™*6,Z²ZxÎDZkäô`lÅ@*gõÃ—hZìX0*Šg~™r#ÐŠgpZ„ì

z{pŠZL¸ÇVÆZkÒyÃgÐ7,³T~:Üstf™ì!*ªÅ»Ñ]ÅðÅ¹ã:Üs‚³î]Ð_“7gBbÉpŠaZöÆ¬!*[Å¹ãÔaZöÆŠzu}!*[Å¹ãÐÌZìX

~–ì: Arthur S. Peaks M.A.) )%û A Commentary on the Bible

"Those who are interested in the once burning question as to the relation between this

narrative and modern science should consult the very thorough discussion in Driver's Commentary.

Here it must suffice to say that the value of the narrative is not scientific but religious; that it imperils

faith to insist on literal accuracy in a story which can only by unjustifiable forcing be made to yield it;

that it was more in hormony with the method of inspiration to take current views and purify them so

that they might be fit

vehicles of religious truth then to anticipate the progress of research by revealing

prematurely what men could in due time discover for themselves; and finally that even if this

narrative could be harmonised with our present knowledge, we should have the task of the

harmonising the very different narrative in the second chapter both with the

present story and with modern science." (A commentary on the Bible, by Arthur S.Peake M.A.D.D.

Page 136)

Cz‹~™r#@*gõÃ—häÅf)ŠZg~!*ª6,WCìc*ŒÛWy6,?|]âb»zZ§

ÌŒÛWyˆZzg!*ª»Z·ZuÌ /'WŠxðÆˆŒÛWyˆZzg!*ªÅŠzu~Zë,|]âßPÅìXâßPÆzZ§~ìZzgZ%sÌX

!*ª»ÒyìâbÅ#¿Æ³~ZkÆ#56,0*ã»i',Š„îÃyWc*Zzgz{îÃyÐ¾t™Šñ‰XŒÛWyˆÌZkÐZ·t™@*ìX1!*ª9ìâbÆ#¥ÀŠ*ÅW!*Š~¶Zzg&4-@î EGGEGSt±Z[ÌÀŠ*6,Wc*XŠ*»CÙoZzgCÙ¸ZzgŠ*

DÙZgÅì(µW[WŠHZzgÎZñâbZzgZkÆ{0+ZyÆ™{ZgnÅ‚g~ 30 »CÙZz‘ÐZz™Nh)âî.$Z-g†Å—~ŒÛã(X 7Ô6 Æ³~ñ]»DgƒX)Š¶aZö!*[ W!*Š~ZkîÃy

ZkÆ£.Þ—g~VÛâDÀZK+MÆnªgÎw~ƒVXt÷~‚—ZmCYÆ£¨~ZqÐi~S¤]ôÞ³$]ø»ø³×»³ßø^Þöç»u÷^]ôÖøoÎøç»Úôä]øá» ìZzgŒÛWyˆÎg{âbÆÑzq~„Šz!*gzŸs#Ûâ@*ìâb»uZyÅxJ-özŠåXÛâc*Ê÷÷

óóëäâbÃZkÅxÅ§s5åZK¸xÃƒâg™zXZkÐ¬Zy6, ]øÞ»³ô»Îø³ç»ÚøÔøÚô³à»Îøf»³Øö]øá»øm³³»iônøãö³Ü»Âø³ø]hº]øÖôn»Üº

14

(ªCÙìŒÛWyˆÅgzÐ±Z[âbÆ#56,Wc*z{ZyÅ¸xJ-özŠå²!*ªZÐ¬K 2 ŠgŠ**u±Z[Wñ)Îg{âbWe$±Z[ŒÛZgŠîìX0*Šg~™r#!W\Åf!î]Zk!*g{~ŒÛWyÅ@*G™Cc*!*ªÅ?'×h+Hg:

"Sir Leonard Wooley's excavation of Ur showed evidence of a destructive flood at a very early

date, and that fact has been used to support the belief in the accurence of a Universal deluge. But

excavation on the sites of other ancient Mesopotamian cities has showen similar evidence of early

destructive floods, but not at the same period. Hence the Mesopotamian evidence only proves that

the Tigris-Euphrates valley was subject to severe river-floods, and that this local feature had been

taken up into the myth of the destruction of mankind which a

diffferent origin altogather." (Peak's commentary on the Bible. Matthew Blake ,page 184)

Íc*Š¤ZzgÛZ]ÅzZŠ~~Ò]ÐŠgc*ðc[WDXÃ¬Kn„ÅŠZ*y¯Šc*ŠHX~–ì: Arthur S.Peak %û A commentary on the Bible

" The question as to the character of the narrative still remains. The terms seem to require a

universal deluge, for all flesh on the earth was destroyed (6/17,7/4,21-23), and "all the high

mountains that were under the whole heaven were covered"(7/19f). But this would involve a depth of

water all over the world not far short of 30,000 ft., and that sufficient water was available at the time

is most improbable. The ark could not have contained more than a very small proportion of the

animal life of the globe, to say nothing of the food needed for them, nor could eight people have

attended to their wants, nor apart from a constant miracle could the very different conditions they

required in order to live at all have been supplied. Nor without such a miracle, could they have come

from lands so remote. Moreover, the present distribution of animals would on this view be

unaccountable . . . . . Nor if the human race took a new begining from three brothers and their three

wives (7/13, 9/19) could we account for the origin, within the very brief period which is all that our

knowledge of antiquity permits, of so many different races, for the development of largnages with a

long history behind them, or for the founding states and rise of advanced civilisations. And this quite

understates the difficulty, for archaeology shows a continuous development of such civilisations

from a time far earlier then the earliest to which the Flood can be assigned. A partial Deluge is not

consistent with the Biblical representation..... And an inundation which took seventy-three days to

sink from the day when the ark rested on the mountain of Ararat till the tops of the mountains

became visible (8/4f) implies a depth of water which would involve a universal deluge. The story

therefore, can not be accepted as historical,(A commentary on the Bible by Arthur S. Peak pp.143)

0*Šg~z‹~™r#fgZZkWy~L{ÃŠz!*g{7,#ZzgQZLZkZ‹Zn6,ÃeZnŒÛWyˆÍf!*vô`lÅ@*gõÃ—h@*ì!!

/'|]âbðÃ!*ªZq-§sZ((ŒÛZgŠîì9ì÷÷âb%ŠgZ]45é GEiZLiâ:ÆßÍV~"ÍåZzgâbX1‚B„t½rÌâbðÆ0Òy™Cì÷÷Zkäó8ZzgZÐ¹Wc*Zzgz{ DU ]?mk R Eμn³‚]ñ³e³^h }.ZÆ‚B‚B¸g;óó

DNM ]?mk ML Eμn‚]ñe^h ZLek,{~',ƒŠHóóZzgZ#)qŠ!îIGS(ZkÆdWqxäsy»!*\åZÐZkqª~ŠN1Ââbðäƒl~W™qxÅ±ÆÜstŠ¬

15

DNQ ]?mk ML Eμn‚]ñeh ¸ÇVÆ5iñV»ÝxƒÇóóX Å÷÷sy²yðÔz{ZLZzwÂ!*ªÐ¥xƒ@*ìqxäÃðt7ÅXtâbÅ¶)Íf!*v(TäÑZ[8ZzgZâ8æƒlƒŠHZzg

æƒÙ~^ƒŠHZzgqxäZ·CZkÃZkqª~ŠN1XpZ¤/qxäÃðtÌÅ¶ÂâbðÃthÂ7åqxÃÒ™äÅOñZkÅWÒ{ƒäzZà±ÃsyBC¶²y™Šc*X™sªCÙìaèµZuZLsyÆ´‘6,ú™ÆYgq:îg6,Zk6,ï™**eT¸Zkn@*gõÃ—h™¹ã7ÅˆìX:0*Šg~™r#@*gõÃ—häzZà!*ªì:ŒÛWy!

|]Z',Z4-ê XGPZzg|]ß¾P»zZ§/'|]âbðÆˆ|]Z',ZmZ?x@*gõô`~¹úc*V£xgnpX|]Z',ZmZ?xÆ!*g}~

ÌŒÛWyˆZzg!*ªŠzâV»Z·tÌìZzgZ%sÌXÆ_.Íf!*vZ',ZðäZq-Ûèç{Å¯Y6,:ÜsZq-Ñ^1ÑÉZk 20 Q!*[ Zzg NL i³^ ML ]?m³^l MN μn³‚]ñ³e³^h

Ñ^Æ³~Y…1wƒñZKç~ÅÓÃç{~eZwŠc*Xtz{Z',Zðì!*ªÆÒyÆ_.ƒ',ÆV»YìZzgDO ]?mk MN Eμn‚]ñe^h i}~ƒXVÆn}.ZÅ',•»zaìX

ZkÆ£.Þ~ŒÛWyˆ:ÜsZ,]VÐ0*uìÉ|]Z',ZÃ.e$s1%zZÑgZ]45é GEiÑŒÛZgŠêìXDPN E‰ç…åÚ†mÜ]?mk

¥xƒ@*ì!*ª~@*gõŠg`Åˆìz{Zkz‰ÜÅÝ]ÃæÃgÄ™"ÅˆìµZuZLÆŠzu~¸ñVÐ©]ÅâÎÅÝ]‰XZ]YÅÂ[Ð¥xƒ@*ìµZuZLÆ©]ñWçVÀEVÐ>{ƒñ¸ZknaZöÅÂ[~|]Z',ZðÆK~˜V|]ßoð»f™W@*ìz;VñWçVZzgÀEVÅŠ#~|]ßoð6,.e$n}

TÆË~ñW!Zzg DMU Eμn³³‚]ñ³³e³³^h Z²Zâ]ÎñÍc*Íf!*vZrVäÑZ[ÅæðÙ~ZKŠzâV@VÐi**»g~ÅXÀãaZƒñX

E‰³³ç…é]Ö³³^Þfn³³^ð /'ZkÆ£.Þ~ŒÛWyÑpYO|]ßoðÅ°pÛâ@*ìÔZyÃZÞÕzD»ñgŠŒÛZgŠêìXF,ZìVÅ§s!*ªägzZ ZzgZknÅ**0*uZ²Zx (TS E‰³ç…é]Ö^ÞÃ^Ý]?mk ZyÃÓx˜âV6,¤gppzZßV~ÑgÛâ@*ì (SN ]?mk

g¿Zág{Ì7Ûâ@*X/'Hx0*Šg~™r#!HW\Åù]Zk!*]Ãt™$Ëì}.Z¬\ßoðÅxÃÂZkn™ÐSŠ}z{

Ò"gZ{gz~»Zg‚[™D¸Zzg|]ßoðZzgZyÅZzÑŠÃZLÛºŸ™]Š}1pŠ|]ßoðZK¸xÅÒ"gZ{gz~Ð**0*uF,ÒkH{Æ%>ƒñƒVZzgQ}.ZÅÃ~=wÌƒV6!*ª»ÒyìX

ŒÛWyäW\Æô`Å@*gõÃ—h™77HÉW\Æô`~ZKã;ðVä :

**0*u@*gõ(,JŠ~¶ZkÃ0*u™Æ7Ûâc*ì!ÆzZu] |]ZGñPZzg|]©ØP

/'T§b!*ªä|]Z',Zð6,Šz%ûÑ^1%ZzgZq-Ûèç{Å¯Y6,ZKç~ÅÓÃç{~eZ%»Z²Zx~¬Z+HìXTÆ£.Þ~ŒÛWyÑp|]ZGtÅYO°p™@* 26 Îc*ìX¸Z²ZxZkä|]ZGtð6,ÌaZö!*[

ìX/'|]Z',ZðZzg|]ZGtÆˆ!*ªÅZq-x,|]©[X»ÄZuZLìXŒÛWyˆ|]

©[Å¹°pÛâ@*ìZzg·Šz»gòÃZyÆdWÈ™ZyÆZÎ{6,¿™äÅSÛâ@*ì1!*ªZLZkò),gvÃ~–ì: 27 ÌŠZ¼Zg™äÐ7HCXaZö!*[

÷÷Z#Z?t®ƒŠHZzgZkÅW@Z+Š®ÑIZÐŠ3ð:ŠêåÂZkäZL(,}dW‘4ið GNÃšc*Zzg¹Z}÷}

16

dW!Zkä¹~q¢ƒVXA$Zkä¹ŠN!~Â®ƒŠHƒVZzg=ZKñ]»Šy¥x7ÎZ[ÂfgZZCÏgÔZCF,¿ZzgZK¾yá™k~òYZzg÷}nDgâgÑXZzg÷~øDI¯j+3**÷}n»g™Æ÷}WÐáW@*~3îVZzgZL%äÐ¬ŠwÐNŠ¬ŠzVXZzgZ#Z?tZLdW‘4ið GNÐ!*'™g;åÂg—Íg„¶Zzg‘4ið GNkÃòŠHDgâg™ÑñX

A$g—äZLdW©[Ð¹ŠN~ä¾}!*\Ã¾}¸ð‘4ið GNÐtë‹ì÷}nDgâg™¯j+3**÷}zZW»g™@*~3îVZzgZL%äÐ¸}.Zz0+ÆWÐNŠ¬ŠzVXÎZ}÷}dWZk¬Æ_.~NŠîƒV÷~!*]ÃâyZzgY™g-h~Ð–~ÆŠzZiZia=ÑŠ}Zzg~ZyÃá™¾}!*\ÆnZkÅøDI¯j+3**»g™ŠzXZzgÂZÐ!*\ÆWÐáY**@*z{3ñZzgZL%äÐ¸NŠ¬Š}XA$©[äZKâVg—Ð¹ŠN÷}¸ð{ÆŸ6,!*wZzg÷ZŸ™sìXáh+÷Z!*\=5áÂ~ZkÅÃ~Š!*iIzVÇZzg',•7ÉÒ¾îVÇXZkÅâVäZÐ¹Z}÷}dW¾~Òí6,WñÂÜs÷~!*]âyZzgY™z{a=ÑŠ}XA$z{ŠHZzgZyÃÑ™ZKâVÃŠc*ZzgZkÅâVäZkÆ!*\ÅøDI¯j+3**»gHXZzgg—äZL(,}dW‘4ið GNÆ%]kZkÆ0*ky~¸á™ZyÃZLgLdW©[Ãzc*Zzg–~Æ”VÅ3BZkÆ;ðVZzgZkÅ¤/Šy6,˜V!*w:¸Š,XZzgz{¯j+3**ZzggzKZkä»gÅ¶ZLdW©[Æ;B~Š}Š~XA$Zkä!*\Æ0*kW™¹Z}÷}!*\!Zkä¹~q¢ƒVXÂÃyì

÷}dW?©[äZL!*\Ð¹~¾ZUVgC‘4ið GNƒVX~ä¾}ìÆ_.HìXÎfgZZJZzgÖ™÷}Dg»Í“3@*ÂŠwÐ=Š¬Š}XA$Z?täZLdWÐ¹gCNtZkŠg¢ùïŠH?Zkä¹Zkn}.Zz0+¾}}.Zä÷Z»x¯Šc*XA$Z?tä©[Ð¹Z}÷}dW!fgZ4,Šq-W~N5ßVÂ÷ZgC‘4ið GNìc*7XZzg©[ZL!*\Z?tÆ0*kŠHZzgZkäZÐ5w™¹WzZiÂ©[Åì6,;B‘4ið GNÆXZzgZkäZÐ:T**ZknZkÆ;ðV6,ZkÆ¸ð{

Æ;ðVÅ§b!*w¸XÎZkäZÐŠ¬Š~XZkäZÐ7YÂ÷ZgC‘4ið GN„ì?Zkä¹z„ƒVXA$Zkä¹3**÷}WÐáWZzg~ZLdWÆDg»Í“3îVÇ@*ŠwÐNŠ¬ŠzVXÎz{ZÐZkÆ4,Šq-áWc*ZzgZkä3c*Zzgz{ZkÆn

óÑc*XZzgZkä8XQZkÆ!*\Z?täZkÐ¹Z}÷}dW!Z[0*kW™=axXZkä0*kY™ZÐaâA$ZkäZkÆ]kÅpÒ0*ðZzgZÐŠ¬Š}™¹:Šd÷}dWÅíZkEÅíÅâ#ì&}.Zz0+ä',•Š~ƒ}.ZWyÅZzkZzgi}ÅÛÍZzg¹ÐZ**`ZzgóN

!¸~¾~}.#Ö™,Zzg\¾}‚tg!ÂZL¸ÇV»uŠZgƒZzg¾~âVÆdW¾}WÐg!6,Ò™}z{pŠvƒZzgNŠ¬Š}z{',•0*ñ!

Z#Z?t©[ÃŠ¬Š}[Zzg©[ZL!*\Z?tÆ0*kÐ„åZk»¸ð‘4ið GNZLDgÐßN*Xz{Ì¯j+3**å™ZL!*\Æ0*kÑc*ZzgZkäZL!*\Ð¹÷Z!*\ZJ™ZLdWÆDg»Í“3ñ@*ŠwÐ=Š¬Š}XZkÆ!*\Z?täZkÐ7YÂÃyì?Zkä¹~¾ZUVgC‘4ið GNƒVXA$ÂZ?t$hå EI]»&4/õ EFEÎZzgZkä¹Qz{ÃyåDgâg™

÷}0*káWc*XZzg~ä¾}WäÐ¬ƒ~ÐðhZðhZ3c*ZzgZÐŠ¬Š~?ZzgIguÌz„ƒÇXZzg‘4ið GNZL!*\Å!*'Fg(,~—WzZiZzg‹ÚuWzZiÐ`ZVZzgZL!*\Ð¹íÃÌŠ¬Š}XZ}÷}!*\íÃÌXZkä¹¾Z¸ðŠÐ

DOR i^ M ]?m^l NS Eμn‚]ñe^h Wc*Zzg¾~',•áŠHóóX/'Š¬0*Šg~™r#W\ä!tW\ÅÃlÅ@*gõTÆ_.µZuZLÆñg_ZdäÑ^ÔÛd$ÔŠÆ

ìXgzqã Â³³^Ö³Ü]ÖÇngæ]Ö`³^é fg=ZL!*\Ðgzqã',•qÝ™àX!*\**ÓC¸ZknŠð~W‰X1ÛâZv¬\Â',»]Â}.Z¬\Å§sÐWCXH}.Z¬\ÌŠÔÛd$ÔÑ^Ôh_ÃŠÙƒñZzgZy»Dgnpƒñgzqã',»]«Ûâ@*ìX

0*Šg~™r#!W\ëŒÛWyˆô`‚—Å¤&™DƒñÌZyÅ@*gõÆÒ**]Ã—h@*ìX$¨45é GGGESŒÛWyÑpZyô`Å¤&™@*ìYètZ’ZÖS}.Z¬\Å§sÐ¸XZzg$¨45é GGGESZyÆ‰Ò**]Å6,izgF,Šh+™@*ìYèW\ÅxäZyÂ1V~ZK§sÐÒ**](,JñTÅZq-VwZÌëZz6,Šg`™WñXŒÛWyÑp|]©[Æ0µ

17

ZuZLÆñg_ZdÔµZuZLÅÓxF,#…VÆ!*zŠÃð**ÍZg!*]7H6!*ªä½XÉÛâ@*ì|]~áï¸X)Îg>m(>VÆni¸] ]æÖ³o]Ö³^m³pæ]Ö³^e^ ©[mZ?xÔ|]Z',ZmZ?xZzg|]ZGtðÅ§b

E‰ç…é]Ö^Þfn^ðD Ìgnp¸Zzggzqãù]ÌZ7qÝ¶Zzgz{CÙnÆYŠÐ0*u¸X2çiãoÎŠ¼

BŠc( 25 Yâ@*1997 BŠc 19 ),·:ZZÚD

Eμ^Þ3çm6ÎŠ¼D μ^

ÆzZu] mZ?x |]ñ.0*Šg~™r#˜VW\Æô`lµZuZLÆñg_ZdÃÛRÔÑN*ZzgŠ!*iŒÛZgŠïz;VµZuZLÆƒÐ

(,}ÑZzgágqÃÌçs7™DX|]ñ.Æ0Zyô`äZ²Zâ]Îñz{Â1VÆŠÔÔ1V6,Îc*™DX~–ì: 4 1W\ÅÃlä|]ñ.ðÆŠ7V»™ŠZgZŠZHìXyz`!*[

÷÷Q}.Zz0+äZÐtÌ¹ÂZC;BZLJg6,gÄ™eJ7-áXZkäZC;BZLJg6,gÄ™eJ7-1XZzgZ#ZkäDR ]?mk P Eì†æte^h ZÐïw™Š¬ÂZk»;BÃh|Ð',sÅâ#CåóóX

tì!*ª»ÒyXòóóX æø]ÛöÜmøøÕøÖoFqøß^uôÔøiíöteøn^ðøÚàÆønôöçðõ]Fmè÷]öì ZkÆ£.Þ6,ŒÛWyˆäÛâc*Ê÷÷

"And draw thy hand close under thy arm-pit. It shall come forth white, without any disease".

Z[C0*Šg~™r#!W\“{™DŒÛWy!*ªÅ@*gõ$+mìXÂYV:$+á?}.ZÆxZyÑÔµZuZLÆu',Z{ZzgágqÆ!*g{~!*ª9ìZy»;BÃh|ÅzzÐCƒŠHXŒÛWyHìz{}.ZÆâgÐCƒZÃðFg~7¶XCÃyÇHìŒÛWyc*!*ª?ZkÆ‚B„tÌæÃgOÃhSÆ!*g{~|]ñ\ö WPÅ§sÐªÓ:½™[Åˆìz{tì:

÷÷ZzgÃhSZkš~2ƒZkÆÀ}ÁZzgZkÆuÆ!*w)}gZzgz{ZLZz6,Æƒ.$ÃeJêZzg7ÕäFO7ÕäFO™¾

**0*uÔ**0*uXZzgæŠyJ-z{Zkš~2gìz{**0*ugìÇZzgz{ìÌ**0*uX:z{Zñg;™}ZzgZk»kyHÇ{Æ!*CÙƒóóX

DPR (PQ ]?m^l MO E]uf^…e^h

Íc*z„ñ.pŠ÷÷Ãh|óóÆ%!¸)Íf!*v(Šzu}ÃhÉVÃ¬ŠïÃhSÆÀ}ÁgXZzgZkÆuÆ!*w)}gZzgz{7ÕäFO7ÕäFO™¾**0*uÔ**0*uXC0*Šg~™r#!HW\ÆÃhÉVÆhw~Zk½6,¿ƒÇ?

/'7Í/õ FGítÂ|]ñ.»fZCçnå1ªÓ:§i¿ZzgªÓ:Z©â]Ygq:úÆˆ¾d$ZZxÐœ-V~pŠ|]ñ.ÛâDX 2 ÐZLo~W!*Š‰!*ªä|]ñ.Å§s™[Hìz{uŠgzÑouìXZ]Y!*[

÷÷Zzg}.Zz0+äíÐ¹ŠN~d-BðGyZzgZkÆoÃ¾}jZá™äÃƒVÎÂZk6,ï™**Ñzq™@*z{¾~÷Z_I}XA$d-BðGyZLƒWŠñVÃá™øg}£¨~ZzgkB™äÆn(AúGXE~Wc*Zzg}.Zz0+øg}}.ZäZÐøg}jZ!™Šc*ZzgëäZÐZzgZkÆœVÃZzgZkÆƒWŠñVÃâg1ZzgëäZÏz‰ÜZkÆƒàÃá1ZzgCÙW!*ŠàÃúgÂVZzg”

DOP i^ OM ]?m^l N E]‰j%ß^ðe^h VÉ!*Ç**1Š™Šc*ZzgËÃ!*¹:ghZóóX

18

Æîg6,7™ä6,W\ŒÛWy6, 0*Šg~™r#!tìW\Å÷÷@*gõóóT~p~™ä6,Zzg|]ñ.Å,Ãg£wZKyZzgtªÓ:Z²ZxW\ÅÂ[÷÷lkóóäZq-Ši7Îc*É!*g!*gÎc*XOçZÏÂ[ÆŠ}!*[~– ZíZY»Z²ZxÎD!!!X

ì:÷÷Oç}.Zz0+øg}}.Zä$jè EEÆ!*Šá{ú`ÃÌZkÆƒWŠñVÉøg}‡1~™Šc*ZzgëäZyÃŒVJ-âgZ

Zy~ÐÃð!*¹:g;ZzgëäZÏz‰ÜZkÆƒàánZzgZq-àÌZ(:g;ëäZyÐá:1ƒX-VZg[»‚gZo$jè EE~ú`Å~áïåZzgZk~‚Jà¸øg}ï~Wc*Xtƒà¢{5Óå E

GZg¸ZzgZyÅZzœZzœŠ-Zg,ZzgMS-ZzgŠ}¸XZyÆ´z{¹ÐZ,‹Ìëäán¢{5Óå

EGZg:¸XZzg6ëä8h4ðEyÆ!*Šá{d-BðGyÆ;VHz(Zy

O E]‰j%³³ß³³^ðe³³^h ƒW!*ŠàzVÃìúgÂVZzg”VÆ!*Ç**1Š™eZÑpƒa0*-VZzgàzVÆâwÃß^™ëäZLngÄ1óóXDT i^ O ]?m^l

0*Šg~™r#…çs<Z¤/øg~Â[lkZLZzgW\ÆZmCY6,Z,ªÓ:Z‹ZŸ]7™CZzg@*gõÃ7—hCYè]Ö³³unÜ Zzg ]Ö³³uÛ³^á tÂ[:Yg¢AÅ½ŠîìÔ:Yg¢AÅZYi]ŠîìXtÂZk}.ZÅÂ[ìÑzq~„ZLW\Ã

ìXtÕZzgpéZg~W\ÅÂ[ÃIguƒTÅgzÝ~W`W\ÅÂ[Ã u³Û³èÖ×Ã^ÖÛnà ŒÛZgŠêìZzgZkgÎwå6,**iwƒðâ+zZáŠ*ÆZ”V~ZkÕzpéZg~ÅŠZ*yŠCÙZgìX

;Váh+W\tZ‹Zn™,@*gõô`»Zq-.e$á0+ZgZzgi',Š„UÌŒÛWyäghŠc*$jè EOEÃì™äÆˆZkÆ!*Šá{ú`»—ÌW\ßÍVÃâwÔ~5TÆ0W\ÅÂ[lk9ì:

(;BahZ 4 (;BMZzgeg) 9 ÷÷Zk»—ßì»¯ƒZåZzgz{µ’.ð OyÆàg!îEO~ñŠìZzgWŠòÆ;BÆ**\Æ_.â)DMM ]?mk O E]‰j%ß^ðe^h ìóóX

Š¬W\ä@*gõ»ZÚZëUZzg@*gõZKã»ZÚi',Š„zZ§ŒÛWyÑpäZágèSÌf™7HX:ú`Æ—»f™Ô:ZkÅ‚|#»ÒyÔ:ZkÅMðahZð»Z0+Zi{Ô:ZkÆg!îEOà~ñŠÏ»E+™{Ôƒ»ƒŒÛWyÐ¸T$ìXtHÂ©ÆZuZgzçgsÔœZ‰ÜZKã¡]ÅZ×VÔZÜtZKãÆ¾Ñ]Ôi0+ÏÆCÙ%~»x!ÅgZÂŒÛWyäCŠ,1ú`Æ—»

sÐÌ(,Z(»Ãðf™„7HX Matrimonia ßì»¯ƒZåâ;BMZzgeg;BahZå)Íc*W·f[Æ;V0*Šg~™r#t!*]Ìf‚~gì!*ªÈg„ìt—àg!îEO~Z[J-ñŠìX1Z[Âz{—ñŠ7Xáh+

g!îEO»**xÌ$+w[ƒX!*ªZ¤/ŠZEÂ[ìÔW\Æo{Æ_.W`Ìfg=@Ze$ìZzgWÒ{@*ª#ÖÄgZ{ìÂHZk»t7ÂHt³ïÜßƒÇZkÂ[»Šzg»ƒ[Zzg ÒyŠg„ìz{—Z[J-g!îEO~ñŠì?ZzgZ¤/tÒyW`ÆŠzg~Šg„

ìX Built in Zk»ÜsZkÅ„gÂV~„0*Šg~z‹~™r#!W\ÅÂ[ä|]ñ\öWP6,ZkuJ-„ÕgzZ7g3ÉZk»ŸZÌYg~ìX/'Z]YÆ‚Â,!*[~Ygq:.VÆˆZL´‘~œ-VÐW!*ŠñVÃ¦[™äÆˆZyÐ|u™**

ìz{|]ñ.Å§sZk§b™[Hì:÷÷Z#}.Zz0+¾Z}.ZÃZko~T6,ï™äÆnÂYg;ìàŠ}Zzg¾}WÐÐZy¹ÏñVÃªè743ðGOGV

Zzg:æELY±VZzgZñg-VZzgsEVZzgÛi$ðGOVZzg7å L-VZzg'±VÃ‚ÂV¸~Ð(,~ZzgizgWzgïwŠ}XZzgZ#}.ZzZ0+¾Z}.ZZyÃ¾}WÐ“ŠÑñZzgÂZæâg}áÂÂZyÃ!*Ç**1Š™eZÜXÂZµÃðÇ:!*0+−Zzg:Zy6,g3™**XÂZµÒ{áŠ~Ì:™**X:ZyÆœVÃZKÃÓVŠbZzg:ZLœVÆnZyÅÃÓV¢8Yèz{¾}œVÃ÷~cz~Ð',X™Š,Ð@*z{ZzgqŠzVÅ„Š]™,X-V}.Zz0+»…?6,¿ÆÇZzgz{Ã°™hu™Š}ÇXÉ?ZyÐt|u™**ZyÆèfVÃ

S E]‰j%³³ß³³^ðe³³^h eJŠbÔZyÆ2âVÃ•}•}™ŠbZzgZyÅ8ÂVÃ»^eZÜZzgZyÅF,ZÙƒðñgZVÃWv~°ŠbóóXDR i^ M ]?m^l

19

DMR ]?mk S E]‰j%ß^ðe^h X ¾}‡1~™Š}Ç**1Š™eZÜXÂZy6,F,k:3**óó ÷÷ÂZyƒñVÃXÃ}.Zz0+¾Z}.Z0*Šg~™r#!fgZ».Þ<Zk’k,»Zy’k,Z]ÐZk,ZyÆYgq:.VÆZ[~›âVÆŠÃ¦.VÆ:q]Æ

ñ§6,ç@Z]Å~èIXg%:ëŠz&’k,,Šg`™DXWfg!*yÅìÆˆtç@{’k,ƒZ:X/·÷÷Wfg!*yÆyZã´‘ZzgNh~´‘Zzguu~Zzg)gzVÆ´ºÆgzZßVZzgÓxèZ<ØzZßVÆnt’k,

ìXZyƒÃZâyìZLÓkÆnÔZLZñZwÆnÔZLèZ<ØcÔZKÑkVÆnZkÑo6,z{btZŠZ™,ZK¤‰ÜÆ_.Xtbt:a6,ì:úg]6,:EFg6,TÆ0*kâw7X:Zk¬$+Íd6,TÆ0*k¼âw7XZzgtŒVÆ!*°zVÆnÌìZzgZyÆnÌ!*CÙÐW™ZyÆ‚BW!*ŠXZyÆf)ZsòHÅZq-gZ]Šy¶yâZi~ìZzgZkÃgZ3C**ìXZ¤/ËÐÃð¯Y}.#ÖàYñÏÂZkÐbt‚ƒYñÇXŒVªx™}ZkÆntÑZ_7ZzgŒVÐ!*CÙY**eìz{Zð~ì‚ZLZðÆ£x6,`YñX

DOOP Ei^…mî›f†pqˆð$^Ö&‘Ëvä t’k,+[äèìZzgZkÆÍZ{70†ZvZzg»u0ÛóóXWgyÅrÆˆt’k,èˆ: ...../

÷÷tz{’k,ìZ÷Z>Ý/ñ0æ[ÆÍg3,uZ‘0/äà',ZiZzgWgyZzgZgðÆ!*°zVÃŠ~ìXz{Z7ZâyŠï

ZyÅYâV6,ÔZñZw6,Zzgè<Ø6,XZ7Ãðvy:àc*YñXz{úÅßg]~¯Y}.#ÖuZxŠ,ÐZzgbtZy6,7Îc*YñÇÉY}.#ÖbtÆ$+!~ƒÏX1¯Y}.#Ö:Š,Zy6,ZIWfg!*yÅ§bbtìZzggZ3C**ìZzg7g}Zq-ŠyÅö!*ãìXpZ¤/ZµY}.#ÖàYñÏÂbt:Îc*YñÇZzgZ¤/¯Y}.#Ö:àYñÏÂbtÎc*YñÇX

DOOQ Ei^…mî›f†pqˆð$^Ö&‘Ëíä ÍZ{”:†Z°×y0gÔGy0gÔ70†ZvXt’k,Ûè0Hyäèz{ÌÍZ{óóX!ígcšfg~qì:

÷÷4{0%Z#æÜÐÃ†ÆÍg3,Hg™ÆÇ‰ÂW\Æ‚Bv.f0ZyÅWfg!*y6,zÑe$»6,zZ:åXv.fñWfg!*ygzZ:ƒñZzgàZgŠâV™z;VÆgKäTÆ4ŠyZ`¦™ä»»xå¹ÏZ¯Z`›âVÆ£¨Æn¦™g¿‰XFgziJ-”h+±ZðƒCg„!*syz;VÆgKäZkÑo6,*™à:

÷÷ÃðO:HYñÇ:„Ãð¤/ëgHYñÇXÃðW$h»å GI{:¤/Zc*YñÇZzgËnÅèIgÎxc*qZgÆñ§6,ZyÆbCÙzVDONN (ONM EÊjç|]Öf×‚]á‘Ëvä Zzgg³z){~ÃðŠ4Z0+Zi~:ÅYñÏXZIWfg!*ybtZŠZ™,ÐóóX

ZIñ‡yÃt’k,Š~ˆ:÷÷tz{’k,ì70†Zvä²;k5é XGyF~ZIñ‡yÃŠ~ìXZyÃZâyìZyÅYâV6,ÔZyÆâßV6,ÔZyÆè<Ø6,Ô

ZyÅÑkV6,XZkÑo6,z{btŠ,CÙ!*Ú6,Zq-Šbgc*ZkÅ7ìXZzgípZ„™,Zzg›âVÃgZ3Š3NZzgZq-ŠygZ]ö!*ã™,XZyÆntZâyƒÏZ#J-z{ZkÇ6,‡ìgZzgøg}f)ZyÐzÃŠZg~ìXzZvZÅ.h4›é GyXpZ¤/z{ZkÇÃF,u™Š,ZzgÃðÛd$ZyÐuiŠƒÂZyÅZây!*¹:ƒÏX1tz{Šð™äzZßVÃÓ#ÖÆ4Š™Š,zg:z{ÌZyÆÑq-ŒYNÐX

DNOT Ei^…mî›f†pqˆð$^Ö&‘Ëvä ÍZ{”Ñc0ÜZgÔZ‚k0»Š[Ôú0h+XW\ëŒÛWyˆä!*ªÅ@*gõÃ$+wŠc*ìÔ!*ªÆãCŠ~Z©xÃ$+wŠc*X 0*Šg~z‹~™r#!

Z¤/ŒÛWyäZ(|uHìÂZK+M6,ZˆyHì|]ñ.‰',Š!*gZKyÅ§sªÓ:@*gõŒÛWyZkÑ~V6,**iwƒZåTä(,~ñÐZL ZzgªÓ:Z©â]!*ªä™[G¸Zy»E+™{7HX

CÙZzwŠ3Æ¾&+gÃt¬™ŠgÛâc*X–ì:Eßà]eo]¨D æÂ×o]ÖÛÏÚèì^ÖzeàæÖnÊfÃ&q¡ÊÏ^ÙÖí^ÖzÖ^iÏjØÚéæÖ^ÂßnË÷XX! ÷÷

20

—g~VÆCÙZzwŠ3Æ¾&+g{−0z6ÃWŠòŸ™¬Šc*Ëúg]ÃÔË'×ŠzgÃ)HÆ‚B‚Bƒ@*ì(O:™zXZÏ§bÛâc*:

E‰ßà]eo]¨D ]ôÞ»_ø×ôÏöç]eô»Üô]Ö×#äôæøÂø×øoÚô×$èôøöç»Ùö]Ö×#äô!øiøÏ»jö×öç]øn»í÷^Êø^Þôn÷^æøøôË»¡÷øÇôn»÷]æøøôÚ»øøé÷XX! ÷÷Zv»**xá™gzZ:ƒZzgZvÆgÎwåÆ§&6,gX:Ë(,}1hñÃO™z:ËgLaÃZzg:Ëúg]ÃX

µZuZLÆÐyz`»zZ§/'0*Šg~z‹~™r#Æô`lÅ@*gõ»Zq-ZzgŠúòTÐŒÛWyˆZ%s™@*ƒZÃW@*ìtµZuZLÆ

Ð|]ñ.Æ‚Bå3Æz‰ÜZyÅ®ZŠ»ìXyz`Ð¥xƒ@*ìZ#µZuZL^Ðò™syÅ§sgzZ:ƒñÂDOT (OS ]?m^l MN Eì†æte^h ZyÆ%ŠzVÅ®ZŠbÑÄ¶Xúg'ZzgaZkÆ´z{¸ZzgZq-B£ƒZyÆ_Z{¶X

]øÖø³³Ü»iø³³³ø]ôÖø³³³o]Ö$³ôm»³àø ŒÛWyÑpZkÆ£.Þ~Šúò™@*ìµZuZLÅ®ZŠZ#z{ZLyzVÐ†PDÙZg¶X÷÷XZ[ŠÙ!*ª»ÒyŠg„ìc*ŒÛWyˆ»XZk!*g{~pŠ!*ª DNPP E]ÖfÏ†åV ìø³øqöç»]Úôà»ômø^ôâôÜ»æøâöÜ»]öÖöç»Íºuøøø]Ö»Ûøç»lXX

ZÛZŠ¸XZqwÅÂ[~–ì: 75c*70 »ÒyìµZuZLZ#sy‰ÂDMQ (MP ]?m^l S E]ÂÛ^Ùe^h ÷÷Q-ŠäZL!*\©[Zzg‚g}æÃ

+A¢.çFFGY3‰š5Zzg©[^~ŠHóóX

÷÷ZuZLÆœVÆ**xZLZLyZäÃá™©[Æ‚B~WñtXgz0Ô’yÔÑz~Ô·ŠZ{ÔZDgÔi1ßyÔDQ i^ M ]?m^l M Eì†æte^h

&4-)4è EEGGEÔŠZyÔLàÔ].ÔWÑXZzgƒY3©[Æ'ÐaZƒN,‰Zzg-ŠÂ^~¬„ÐåóóX',kJ-gìXOçyz`~–ì: 430 !*ª…tÌCCìWäÆˆµZuZLZko~

(',kƒñ¸ZzgZyegÎM',ÎVÆ¦/gYä6,ÇZÏgzi 430 ÷÷µZuZLÃ~1Šz!*l™DƒñegÎM)DPN i^ PL ]?m^l MN Eì†æte^h }.Zz0+»‚gZHo^ÐòŠHóóX

ZÛZŠ»úgÂVZzg”VÆÎZÜs%ŠzV»bÑÄƒY**ŒÛ+ªkì!!! 75 ‚w~ 430 0*Šg~™r#HŠ¶ZÚ6,ñi!*ªÆ%Hë:

"The adult men alone numberd six hundred thousand. It is plausible that this

impossible number rets on a numerical interpretation of the Hebrew letters in the phrase "Sons of

Israel" (cf.beer,exous, page 69). That the figure has no basis in fact is clear from almost every point

of view. Such a large number could not have lived in Egypt or survived in the desert. Nor could they

have found room in Cana'n. The actual situation is intimated by 23:29-30:Judge 5.8."

(Interpreters Bible Vol. I Page 925)

ÆPeak's Commentary DÙZgÆîg6,ìX 40 ~èÃgìZk~µZuZL»f™ »jZ!èÃg{!*ÑjZá 8 We$ 5 ,>!*[: %˜

"There numbers, 600,000 (cf.Num.II:1) ,are impossible: a total population of

between two and three millions would be implied."

(Peak's Commentary on the Bible , General edition Matthew Blake, Page 220)

Zk¯Y6,ZuZLÅ·Š~Ó#ÖÆ¬zik,ZWÎÍg+Æ0tWð¶ZrVätÒyŠc*ì|]ñ.Z#^Ð%Š¸ZzgZk6,·ŠÅŠ*ZÄB5é EGwèI0*gkVä(,ZØgeZÑZzgzik,ZWÆÜsZK0*gŸ~°xZOŠ» 600 †ÂZyÆ‚BÜs

zz^7H&zik,ZWä7‚ã“Š}Š~XÃtŒÛWyÑpä^Ðå3zZáµZuZLÅ®ZŠÆ!*g{~7Hìz„W`Æ ¾qw

X ŒÛZgŠï impossible ·Š~Zzg|ðfY~=wìZzg!*ªÆÃtÃz{21

Yâ( 1998 B†g~ 2 Yâ@*1997 BŠc 26 ),·:ZZÚD

E2ã9oÎŠ¼D

ÆzZu] ð |];gzy@*gõÆ!*g{~ŒÛWyˆZzg!*ª»Zq-ZzgZ%s|];gzymZ?xÆ!*g{~ìX!*ª9ì|]ñ.Z#}.Z¬\Æ—g¼²ÆnNh6,=pá‰ZzgµZuZL~"ìaZƒðÂ|]

;gzyðäµZuZLÅŠgpZ„6,ZyÆnZq-Îä»ôZqŠÆîg6,¯c*X–ì:÷÷Z#ñ\öWPäNhÐZF,ä~Šk,ÎðÂz{;gzyÆ0*k¦ƒ™ìÑZJøg}nŠ-@*¯Š}øg}WÐWÐ−

Yèë7Y…Zk%Šñ.ÃëÃo^Ðïw™Ñc*ìHƒŠHìX;gzyäZyÐ¹vg~ç~Zzg±ÃVZzg±YVÆ»âV~ÎäÅ!*1VZyÃZ@*g™÷}0*káWîXOçƒßvZyÆ»âVÐÎäÅ!*1VZ@*gZ@*g™ZyÃ;gzyÆ0*káWñZzgZkäSyÃQyÆ;ðVÐá™Zq-eJÑƒZôZ¯c*TÅßg]ÝPÐÇÅXA$z{ìÑZ}ZuZL¸¾Zz{Š-@*ìÃo^Ðïw™Ñc*XtŠN™;gzyäZkÆWÐZq-ŒÛ!*yÇ{¯ðZzgZkäZ´y™Šc*À}.Zz0+ÆnÏƒÏZzgŠzu}ŠyðÎk,}ZJ™ZrVäŒÛ!**VmJNZzgsäÅŒÛ!**V*gZ3XQZyßÍVäÖ™3c*\ZzgZJ™öÃŠ~

DR i^ M ]?m^l ON Eì†æte^h µ‰óóXQ–ì:

÷÷Zzgñ.ä;gzyÐ¹ZyßÍVäF,}‚BHHåÂäZyÃZã(,}kH{~ªŠc*?;gzyä¹÷}â´»…:¿ÆÂZyßÍVÃY}ì$+~6,ÒgTXOçZ4äíÐ¹øg}nŠ-@*¯Š}øg}WÐWÐ−Yèë

7Y…ZkWŠòñÏÃëÃÐïw™Ñc*ÔHƒŠHXA$~äZyÐ¹TTÆ0*kÎ**ƒz{ZÐZ@*gÑñX:DNP i^ NL ]?m^l ON Eì†æte^h ZrVäZÐíÃŠc*Zzg~äZÐWv~eZÑÂtôZò7,ZóóX

tì!*ª»ÒyuZu|];gzyðÃÍf!*vôZ¯ä»êxŒÛZgŠêìX~Ûâ@*ìZv¬\ä|]ñ.ÐÛâc*X)ZyWc*]» 99@*84 ZkÆ£.Þ6,ŒÛWyˆ»Òy5±ÛâXÎg>†î WWWc*]

|xtì(:÷÷ëä¹Z}ñ.?ZK¸xÃgh™¾n¢~¢~W‰ƒXñ.äZ[~¹z{ßv÷}úWgìZzgZ}

÷}g[~Zkn¾}0*k¢~ÐWc*ƒV@*ÂplƒYñX}.Zä¹ëä¾~¸xÃ¾}ˆZq-Wiâö~eZwŠc*ìZzg‚%~äZyÃeZ{™Šc*ìXZk6,ñ.ZKxÅ§sVÐ½}ƒñZfŠ{ß^‰Zzg¹Z}÷~xHvg}g[ä?ÐZq-ZYz°{7HåXc*Zkz°{Æ7gZƒä~ÃðŠk,ƒ¶c*?teTƒ?6,vg}g[Å§sÐÃð…**iwƒÎ?ä

÷}z°}ÃgŠ™Šc*XZrVä¹ëä¾}z°}ÃZK%èÐgŠ7HÉÛúyÅxÆi-gZ]»1úë6,ÑŠŠc*ŠHåZkÃëäNŠc*ZzgZk§b‚%~äÌZyÃNŠc*QZkäZyÆnZq-ôZ»gH¡Ÿ„åXZkÐZq-"pWzZiÇ¶QZrVä¹tvgZÌZzgñ.»Ì}.ZìZÐÈwŠHìX1Hz{ŠÙ7¸z{ôZZyÅË!*]»Z[7ŠêåX:Z7ÃðœvyàYåXZzg;gzyäZkÐ¬ZyÐÈŠc*åZ}÷~x?ÃZkô}Æfg)Wiâö~eZÑŠHìZzg

vgZg[Âg×yì:÷~Znq™zXZzg÷Z¬ââX1ZrVä¹Z#J-ñ.øg~§szZ::Wñë',Z',ZkÅ„Š]~'w

22

gÐXZ#ñ.zZ:WñÂZrVä¹Z};gzy!Z#?äZKxÃeZ{ƒDŠ¬Â»¾äIHå?÷}ú−WîH?ä÷}¬Å**ÛâãÅX;gzyä¹Z}÷~âVÆdW÷~ŠZhSZzguÆ!*w:ñX~ÂZk!*]Ðeg@*å?t:¼

?äµZuZLÃ!*.$Šc*ìXZzg÷~@Ze$»ZOg7HXZk6,ñ.ä¹Z}‚%~¾ZHçnìXZkä¹~äz{¼Š¬ZyßÍVä7Š¬åZzg~ägÎwÅ!*ÂV~Ð¼ÂZ(g™BQ)Z#ñµWc*(Â~äZy)Z(gÅƒð!*ÂV(ÃÌ

NŠc*Zzg÷}Ñä¸q=Zh™ÆŠ3ðXñ.ä¹ZYYX¾~ZkŠ*~¸wZìÂZkŠ*~CÙZq-Ð¸Hgì=gƒ7XZzg¾}nZq-z‰ÜHgì&Â—7nÇXZzgÂZLqŠÅ§sŠNTÅÂ6,-™@*gLåXëZkÃ°N

E‰ç…é›FäFD X ÐZzgQZÐ«g~NŠ,ÐvgZqŠÂÜsZvìTÆÎZÃðqŠ7z{CÙZq-qÃY}ìóóZ[0*Šg~™r#tZq-zZ§ÆŠzzg×XZq-§s!*ª»ÒyÎä»ôZ¯äZzgÎäÆô}ÃqŠ¯äÆ¬

êxÍf!*v|];gzy¸XŠzu~§sŒÛWyˆ»ÒyZk»ZÝêx‚%~åZzg|];gzyäZÐñÐIHå1ÜsZkegÐµZuZLŠz

”V~#$:YNZrVä|]ñ.ðÅ@Ze$»ZOgHZzgZ(ZŠZx7HTÐx~‘aZƒYñX0*Šg~™r#!W\[ZzggzqãÃÐŠBZy~ÐÃy‚ÒyŠg„ìXHz{¿TÃ}.ZäpŠ„ÑÆîg6,O

ƒÔTÐpŠg[Z°=ä¯xHƒZzgÛúy‰Y',!*Šá{Æ£«Æn5ƒÔTÆfg=}.Z¬\äi',Š„¶K**]ªCÙGƒVHz{}.ZÃgh™Zq-ôZ¯™ZkÅ7Y™Yì!??XH}.ZZ,ßÍVÃZCúÒ{¯™ZK+MÅgZÉðÆnŸYìZkÐ¼Zg~™äzZáƒV?HÃð$zgÐ$zgqÁÌZ,¿ÃZCZ½¯™5™@*ì!!?X

ŒÛWy»ÒytÕZzgëqZLZ0+gg‚rì:;gzyäZ(…rî**xH:z{Zk6,gZèåÉZkäZkxÆÜsZK¸xÐW@{HÔZ7(,}izgÐIHZzg!*igppÅÃÒÅX

™7™@*ì? óó e,^\ ÷÷ 0*Šg~™r#!HZ[ÌW\Ã“{ìŒÛWy!*ªÅ@*gõÃ/'ZzgZÌ!*]»7ƒðpŠ!*ªÐ„!*ªÆZkÒyÆÜsZoƒYìX!*ªÐ¥xƒ@*ìôZ¯ä

zZßVZzgZkÅ„Š]™äzZßVÃ|]ñ\öWPäOÅwZŠ~Zzg&DÙZgZÛZŠñ]Æv^Z@*gŠñ‰Xyz`~–ì:÷÷Z#ñ.äŠ¬ßv"‡1ƒ‰Yè;gzyäZyÃ"Îxgh™ZyÃZyÆŠ7VÆŠgxyf?™Šc*Âñ.ä

HÇ{ÆŠgzZi}6,9}ƒ™¹}.Zz0+Å§sÐìz{÷}0*kWYñXA$ƒµÑz~ZkÆ0*k¦ƒ‰XZzgZkäZyÐ¹}.Zz0+ZuZL»}.Z-VÛâ@*ì?ZKZKgZyÐŒZg\d™MS-MS-xx™‚g}HÇ{~ZL¸ÇVZzgZLZL‚¹VZzgZLZL7,z±VÃO™DQzXZzgµÑz~äñ.ÆìÆñZ¬¿HXOçZkŠyßÍV~ÐŒÛã&DÙZg%Š

EWñXZzgñ.ä¹W`}.Zz0+ÆnZLW\Ãºm™zÉCÙ¿ZL„dWZzgZL„¸ðÆÜsƒ@*z{?ÃW`„',•Š}ZzgŠzu}Šyñ.äßÍVÐ¹?ä(,ZkH{HZzgZ[~}.Zz0+Æ0*kZz6,Y@*ƒVXáh+~vg}kH{»ñg{Š}jVXZzgñ.}.Zz0+Æ0*kß^™ŠHZzgìÎ;ñZyßÍVä(,ZkH{HZLnÎä»Š-@*¯c*XZzgZ[Z¤/ÂZy»kH{çs™Š}Âízg:÷Z**xZkÂ[~ÐÂäèìSŠ}XZzg}.Zz0+äñ.Ð¹Tä÷ZkH{Hì~ZÏÆ**xÃZKÂ[

~ÐSîVÇXZ[ÂgzZ:ƒZzgßÍVÃZk(áY~äNCðìXŠN÷ZÛ¸¾}WÐWÐ−Çp~Zk_cÆŠyZyÃZyÆkH{ÅwZŠzVÇZzg}.Zz0+äZyßÍV~'ç M~ÈYèôZ;gzyä¯c*z{Zy„»Zc*ƒZåóóX

DOQ i^ NQ ]?m^l ON Eì†æte^h

Z[Š¶0*Šg~™r#!ôZ¯äZzgZkÅ6,-™äÅŠzwZNŠ~ˆX|]ñ.Å§sÐO¬xÅZzg}.Z¬\Å§sÐ}.ZÅÂ[Ð**xS™'ç M~Æfg=ñ]ÅX1ŠzâVwZîVÐ|];gzìPXñ‰–w!*ª(,}êx¸XXÆì6,µZuZLZKúgÂVZzgVÆ»âVÐ!*1VJ-Z@*gÑñ¸ZzgMVäWv~i-geZw™ôZ¯c*åXtÐZ»sìZÝêxÂ!*ÇôpìZzg²êñVÃ|]ñ.ÌOÅwZŠ}gì)ŒÛWyÑpÆÒyÆ_.ôZ¯äÆZÝêx

23

ÃOÅ7É!*§^ÅwZŠ~ˆ(1;gzyÃÃðwZ7ŠïZzgZv¬\Ì|];gzìPÃwZ7Šê²U*â~êñVÃ'ç M~Æfg=hu™@*ìX¥xƒZ|];gzyðä6ŒÛWyHìZkx»Zg‚[H„7å°z{ŠzâVwZîVÐXñ‰ZzgQ:Üstz{wZîVÐXñ‰ZyÃ}.ZÆ—g!çEOiZzgµZuZL~Zq-—£xZq-!*³]%ûŠc*ŠHZzgÐZ½q‚Åwg‚rå»g™ÆZkÅ}.#ÖZzgã»Z³Zi;gzyZzgZyÅZzÑŠÃŠc*ŠHXOç–ì}.Z¬\äñ.Ð¹:

÷÷ZzgÂÎøŒÛ!*ãÆè%ZzgZkÆƒøzsÃC™Æè%Ãlk™**Zzgè%.e$„lkI}ÇZzgÂjnZzgZkÅ™ÏÃÌC™Ælk™**XZzg;gzyZzgZkÆœVÃÐZ½qÆŠgzZi{6,Ñ™ZyÃ0*ãÐ<ŠÑ**Zzg;gzyÃlk]kz**ZzgZÐCZzglk™**@*z{÷}n»‚Å}.#ÖÃZxŠ}XZzgZkÆœVÃÑ™ZyÃ™Dz**Zzg‰ZyÆ!*\ÃC™}z,„ZyÃÌC™**@*z{÷}n»‚Å}.#ÖÃZxŠ,XZzgZy»Cƒ**ZyÆn±Šg±Z$+~¹-$»¶KyƒÇXZzgñ.ä

DMQ i^ ML ]?m^l PL Eì†æte^h ƒ¼6}.Zz0+äZkÃ¬HåZÏÆ_.HóóXôZ¯äÆZÝêxÃÂtZ³ZiŠc* Š¶|];gzìPÃH(,ZZ³Zi5ZzgZyÆÜ@*ª#ÖZyÅZzÑŠÃÌXHt¦geì

YñZzgÁF,êñVÃOÅwZŠ~Yñc*'ç M~Æfg=huHYñXŒÛWyä!*ªÅ@*gõÃ—hZ7É :!*]z„ìŒÛWyä½¶;gzyäÑu7HÉÑuÐIHZzg

! ZkÅoÅZkK~Zq-ZzgZ%sÌ!*ªZzgŒÛWy~0*c*Y@*ìXZ#|]ñ.Å)ñŠÏ~µZuZLäôZ¯c*ÂZv¬\

ä|]ñ.ÃZkÅZ:qŠ~XZkÐIZv¬\|]ñ.ðÃpŠZL;BÐÀV6,Ñ<ÆãCŠ~Z©â]É™Š}[åX|]ñ.ZyÀVÃá™nZF,}ZzgxÃô}Æ~2Š¬ÂZrVäZv¬\Æ;BÅèƒðŠzâVæVÂheZBX–ì:

÷÷Zzgñ.ÞŠ]ÆŠzâß²;B~nƒñZtQZZzgNhÐnZF,ZZzgz{ß²SŠOÐZzgQŠOÐzzâV§sÐèƒð‰XZzgz{ß²}.Z„Å¯ðƒð‰Zzg–ƒZåz{Ì}.Z„»–ZzgZy6,+{HƒZåXZzgZ#3qäßÍVÅ—gÅWzZi”Âñ.Ð¹HÇ{~±Zð»Øgƒg;ìXñ.ä¹tWzZiÂìqzV»È{ì:¦[ÅÛc*ŠXÉ=ÂÇäzZßVÅWzZi‹ðŠîìZzgHÇ{Æ4,Šq-W™Zkäz{ôZZzgZy»**OŠ¬XA$ñ.»…¿»ZzgZkäZyßjVÃZL;ðVÐáŠc*Zzg

DNL i^ MQ ]?m^l ON Eì†æte^h ZyÃNhÆnÂheZÑóóXtì!*ª»ÒyXZzgŒÛWyÛâ@*ì:

æøÖøÛ$^øqøÄøÚöç»Fo]ôÖøoÎøç»ÚôäÆø»fø^áø]FôË÷Îø^Ùøeôò»øÛø^ìø×øË»jöÛöç»Þôo»Úôà»eøÃ»ôp]øÂørô×»jöÜ»]øÚøøeùÓöÜ»æø]øÖ»Ïøo]»øÖ»çø]|øýýæøÖøÛøøù^

DMQQ i^ MQM E‰ç…é]Ö^Â†]ÍV øÓøkøÂøàÚöç»oF]Ö»Çøøgö]øìøø]»øÖ»çø]|øæøÊôoÞö»íøjôãø^âö÷pæ$øu»ÛøèºÖô×$màøâöÜ»ÖôøeùãôÜ»mø»âøföç»áZ#ñÏZK¸xÅ§s×ZzgZ\kÐ½ZƒZßN*ÂZkä¹÷}ˆ?ä÷~úÒÏÅz{¹',~¶XH?äZL

g[Æ¬Æçn~¢~ÅZkz‰Üñ.äz{æVgÄŠ,'QZ#ñ.»×QZƒZÂZkäz{æVX6,Z©xZÞ‘ƒñ¸QZVBÂZyÆnZLg[Ðps™DZyÀVÅ’k,~gØZzg@Ze$ñŠ¶X

Š¶0*Šg~™r#!!*ªZzgŒÛWyÆÒy~Ûtì¾§b=Zzg¡]ŒÛWãÒyÅ¤&™CìXñ.}.ZÆÑ¸X}.ZÃZyÐZzgZyÃ}.ZÐ"u\gåXtùeì|]ñ.ZL\g}Æ;BÅµƒðZkÆ;BÅF,ZÙƒðZzgZkÆ;BÅèƒðZßZbÆ•}•}™eZsXHŠ*Æ¬ÔÌZL8[»jewew™7gnp?H|]ñ.Ã}.ZäpŠZLxÆn7OåZzgZyÆnxZy¶KyZzg‡**u7}7Š3ñ¸XŒÛWy»Òy÷CìZ#|]ñ.nZF,}Â¸x~2¶ZzgZk£xÐÌn¤/_¶T~|]ñ.ZyÃgh™‰¸XÅ<å XEZ|]ñ.ä*6,z¤/Zxzzîg6,gÄghZZzg¬»ZKŠ¬Zzg°wÆfg=£HXQZ#z{»ƒŠHZzg'×h+°à|uÅ¢zg]:g„ÂZrVäz{ZßZb

24

zZ:ZV™ZyÅ½Æ_.gØz@Ze$»»xÑzqHX!*ª|]ñ.6,(z{ |]ñ\öWP!*ªÆ‹zZzgW\0*Šg~ŒÛWyÃµZuZL»ŠÔBX1Ð!*]ì

X ŠZrÎCìZzgŒÛWyZkŠZrÃŠð@*ì

|]ÈLÆzZu]|]ñ\öWPZzg;gzyðÆ²ˆ!*ªZzgŒÛWyˆäZq-ÑÆfg=T»**x!*ªÈLCCìµZuZLÆxDb6,

Zq-!*Šá{Æfg=Zq-%œ/~Ó#ÖÆªx»f™Hì@*ÛzãúWzgzV»)}ƒñµZuZLÆ!*g{Db6,úWzg¸£¨HYñXOçÈLÅÂ[~–ì:

÷÷A$ƒZuZ¢),gv¦ƒ™gZ)~ÈLÆ0*kWñZzgZkÐìÑŠNÂ®ìZzg¾}dW¾~gZ{6,7ºXÈLäZ#ZkŠgpZ„ !DR i^ P ]?m^l T !‰ÛçñnØe^h ME X Z[ÂËÃøgZ!*Šá{Hg™Š}ZzgñVÅ§bøg~°Zª™}

6,¼ZÁn»ZÖgHÂZrVä¹:÷÷ëÂ!*Šá{eTøg}Zz6,ƒ@*ëÌZzgƒñVÅâ#ƒVZzgøgZ!*Šá{øg~°Zª™}Zzgøg}WÐWÐ−Zzgøg~§sÐ±Zð™}ZzgÈLäßÍVÅƒ!*'[ZzgZyÃ}.Zz0+Æ»âVJ-àc*XZzg

DNN i^ MU ]?m^l T !‰ÛçñnØe^h ME }.Zz0+äÈLÃÛâc*ÂZyÅ!*]âyZzgZyÆnZq-!*Šá{Hg™X~–ì: 10 QZkÂ[Æ!*[

÷÷ÈLä%ÅKàZzgZk)‚îw(Æu6,Z&+~ZzgZÐaâZzg¹H¸!*]7}.Zz0+äNCH@*ÂZkÅDN i^ M ]?mk ML !‰ÛçñnØe^h ME ÷Z_»§ZƒóóX

QÈLä‚îwÐ¹:÷÷}.Zz0+Ågzb6,izgÐ**iwƒÏZzgÂZyÆ‚Bt]™äÑÇXZzg$+w™Zzg„WŠòƒYñDR ]?mk ML !‰ÛçñnØe^h ME ÇóóX

QÈLä!*‡°{‚îwÆ}.Z¬\ÆZN[Æ_.!*Šá{ƒäÅ½d$ÂÅXOç–ì:÷÷Z#z{ßÍVÆŠgxy9ZƒZÂZ(ŠWzgåßvZkÆ+ñJ-WD¸ZzgÈLäZyßÍVÐ¹?ZÐŠÙƒ&}.Zz0+ä`1ZkÅâ#ƒ

DNP ( NO ]?m^l ML E]!‰ÛçñnØe^h ßÍV~ÐZq-Ì7?J-ƒßv—g™1wZ`!*Šá{ƒgìóóX1!*ª9ìZÌic*Š{²7¦/gZåÔZÌÈLi0+{å‚îwuŠgz™ŠHX–ì:÷÷A$}.Zz0+»¯xÈLÃà=Z\kì~ä‚îwÃ!*Šá{ƒäÆnHgHYèz{÷~cz~ÐQŠHìZzg

DMM ]?mk MQ !‰ÛçñnØe^h ME Zkä÷}¬7âäóóXQ–ìÊ÷÷}.Zz0+Ågzb‚îwÐ].ZƒZzg}.Zz0+Å§sÐZq-',~gzbZÐ*äÐóóX

DMP ]?mk MR !‰ÛçñnØe^h ME

t¾wì!*ªÅ@*gõŠZã»µZuZLÆ!*g{DwÈLÐŠgpZ„™DaèW\®ƒ`Zknë6,!*Šá{Hg™Š,XÈLäpŠ!*Šá{Hg7HÉ}.Z¬\Æ—g²nHZzg}.Z¬\äpŠ‚îwÃ!*Šá{HgHX1ZÌÈLi0+{„

¸‚îw™ŠHZzgZkä}.Z¬\Å**ÛâãZ(gÅZzg',~gzbZkÃ*äÐZzgÍf!*v}.Z¬\Dc*ZzgZkä¹=‚îwÃ!*Šá{¯ä6,Z\kìX

}.ZÆ0Íc*ZkäpŠ„Zq-ßWŠò» Â³³^Ö³Ü]Ö³Çn³gh]ÖÃ³^ÖÛnà t¦gì0*Šg~z‹~™r#!W\ÅÃl»½gHZzgQZk6,Z\k»ZÖgHXÍc*}.Z¬\ÃWÒ{»D„7åXZzgZkäÍf!*vZKÑdÅ¯Y6,ßWŠò»ZN[HXtì0*Šg~™r#W\ÅÂ[lk»ÒyTÅo6,W\ŒÛWyÑpÃñgŠZ²ZxIZDX

XZyWc*]™»|xtì: 257@*247 Z[HgŒÛWyHHìX5±ƒVÎg{ZÂ{ÅWc*]÷÷H»µZuZLÆZyu™Š{ßÍV»qw¥x7ñ\öWPÆ¦/g}Z#ZrVäZLZq-ÑÐ¹øg}nÃð

25

¿!*Šá{Æîg6,Hg<@*ëZnâƒ™ZvÅgZ{~kB™,XZkä¹}Z(Â7ƒÇZ¤/?6,kBÛnÅYñÂ?kB:™zXZrVä¹Z(7ƒÇX…HƒŠHìëZvÅgZ{~kB:™,ÐqÑè…ZLyzVÐïÑŠHìZzgZL”VÐ].ZHŠHìX1Z#Zy6,kBÛnÅˆÂZy~ÐZq-gKÏ)®)ÆÎZ!*¹ƒQ‰ZzgZvª>VÃp[Y}ìXZzgZyÆÑäZyÐ¹Zvävg}n¤ß]Ã!*Šá{¯™Zk»xÆn9ZHìXZrVä¹ZÐë6,Ó#Ö¾§bï$Ëì²ëZkÅÚÓ#ÖÆic*Š{hŠZgZzgZÐâàÛZqÌÃðZ+ic*Š{«7ƒðXZkä¹ZväZÐ?6,$¨45é GGGES¤Š~ìZzgZÐdZzgKãÒpÐÛZq«ÛâðìZzgZv&I™@*ìZÐZCo«™@*ìZzgZv¤öŠ¶zZÑZzg¹Y+zZÑìXZzgZyÆÑðäZyÐ¹ZkÅÓ#ÖÅŠ?tÌì»Zq-Z(@*1]AÇT~vg}g[Å§sÐúƒÏZzgZkq»†ƒÇñ\öWPÆ•Zzg;gzyðÆ•äúghZXÛºZÐZVñƒñƒfXZ¤/?ñðƒÂZk!*]~vg}n$¨45é GGGESZq-(,Z¶KyìXQ¤ß]ZK¯VÃá™ÂZkä¹ZvZq-0+~Æfg=ÐvgZZJyhezZÑì:TäZk0+~Ð

ù½™0*ã81z{íÐzZh7gìÇÎZñZkÆTäZL;BÐZq-g½81XQƒZtZy~Ððh}ÐßÍVÆÎZƒäZk~Ð0*ã81QZ#z{pŠZzg2z{ßvZkÆ‚BZZyÑñ¸Zk0+~Ð0*gZF,‰ÂßÍVä¹W`ë~Yß]ZzgZkÆHzVÆ£¨Å!*Ç¤‰Ü71ßv¢gnp¸z{Zq-ŠyZvÐYzZáZrVä¹Z}øg}g[¹ÏgK)ÈZvÆ¬Ð(,~)oV6,¸W_ZzgZvñ™äzZßVÆ‚Bƒ@*ìXZzgZ#z{Yß]ZzgZkÅ¯VÆ£¨Æn†ÂZrVä¹Z}øg}g[…ñZzgZ4w«ÛâZzgøg}Šx)ñgÄZzgZy»ÛzVÆ

Üsøg~æŠ™ZzgZrVäZvÆ¬ÐŠ7VÃ“Š~ZzgYß]»{ØŠZîŠðäHZzgZväZÐÓ#ÖZzgÕŒZzg¼ZvÃàgåZk»DZväŠZîŠÃ«HXZzgZ¤/Zv‰ZKâVÃÑZg]ÐŠzu}ZKâVÆfg=:gzÂÂi}µz!*ÑƒYC

pZvÓx˜âV6,(,Za™äzZÑìXtZvÅWc*]Îë»7,|™‹DZkqª~?h6,‡ìƒZzg?$¨45é GGGESgÎßV~ÐƒóóX

tìÒyŒÛWyˆ»XZ[0*Šg~™r#!ZkZ·ZuZzgZ%sÃâ^<ŒÛWyZzg!*ª~ìXŒÛWyZzg!*ªŠzâVZk!*]6,5|]ñ\öWPÆˆµZuZL6,Zq-Z(ŠzgWc*¢o%œ/~gZÉñŠ:ƒäÅzzÐÛzãçizgñ‰Zzg¢zg]

CkƒðZq-¢o,ÅZyÆ£¨~ªŠ]ÆÛZøuZxŠ}XŒÛWyZzg!*ªŠzâVZk!*]6,5}.Z¬\äZkÑÅcÄZq-!*Šá{HgHZkÆŒÛWyHìZkgZÉä.e$ÂqÑ]~W@Z:Z0+ZiZ(g™DƒñŠE~ˆYÐìñh™¸g~®ZŠ~ŠÔ6,„0*1ZzgZÐ“Š~X1!*ª9ì!*Šá{Z¤/p}.Z¬\äHgHåZzgZk»Ñic*Š{F,tåÈLÑÆˆªŠ]~ÜY:aZƒ1z{&}.Z¬\äHgHå™ŠHZzg$+gzbZkÃ*äÐZzgZkä}.Z¬\Å**ÛâãÅZzg}.Z¬\äZ\kHZkäZ(!*Šá{HgÛâc*X

C0*Šg~™r#!=Zzggzq+MÆÒpÐ}.Z¬\ÅlkÌ]ÃæÃgnpƒñŒÛWy»XHW\Z[Ìt}ÐŒÛWyä!*ªÆ@*g]Ò**]Åo™ÆÍf!*vZLZíZYƒäÅÍZ„ Òyic*Š{9ìc*!*ª»

½Åì!!

Yâ( 1998 B†g~ 8 Yâ@*1998 B†g~ 2 ),·:ZZÚD

E‰^içm6ÎŠ¼D

26

mZ?xÆzZu] |]ŠZîŠmZ?xÆ!*g}~ÌŒÛWyZzg!*ªÆÒ**]Z·ZuZzgZ%sgnpXZq-§s!*ª|]ŠZîáPÃ}.Z»H[Zz |]ŠZîŠ

g}.ZÅ§sÐHg™Š{Zzg‚îwÆ£¨~ÈLÑÅcÄ}.Z»&.iðb9ìZzgŠzu~§s.e$n}Zzg**0*uZ²Zx|]ŠZîŠð6,¬Z+™CìXOç|]ŠZîŠðÆ}.ZÆ&.iðbGYäÆ!*g}~–ì:

÷÷ÈLä$gö GOÐ7Y¾}ƒ±Æ¸?Zkä¹ƒÐgN*ZÌg{ŠHìz{ƒ–c*VlZ@*ìXÈLä$gö GOÐ¹ZÐšŸYèZ#J-z{ŒV:WYñë7$ÐXÎz{ZÐZ™Z0+gÑc*Xz{ucg8-Zzgpzg]Zzg@åZzg}.Zz0+äÛâc*ZJZzgZÐC™Yèz{¸ìXA$ÈLä%»−1ZzgZÐZkÆ¸ÇVÆŠgxyCHZzg}.Zz0+ÅgzbZkŠyÐWÐÃŠZîŠ6,izgÐ**iwƒC

DMO i^ MM ]?m^l MR !‰ÛçñnØe^h ME g„óóXZzgZkÂ[~,ÐZkxZyzZ§»f™ìT~|]ŠZîŠðäZÌgLÐ±Æ¸Š7VÆi',Š„UZy

qÃTÆ‚tÐƒZuZ¢%Š¸MZzgegD¸¡ZK‡ÆßÆfg=huHXQ–ì:÷÷ŠZîŠZKƒgZƒV~ŠZ**ðÆ‚B¸åZzg}.Zz0+ZkÆ‚BåóóX

DMP ]?mk MT E]!‰ÛçñnØe^h

Zzg|]ŠZîŠ»ZLg[Æ—gt\gZÏÌ!*ªäŠgHìX÷÷}.Zz0+÷~"yZzg÷Z°Zzg÷ZrZäzZÑìX}.Z÷~"yìX~ZÏ6,½zgÅVÇXz„÷~4Zzg÷~]»−ìX

÷ZZz™',`Zzg÷~C{ìX÷}]Š¶zZáÂ„=ÕÐX@*ì~}.Zz0+Ã*öÆÑëìågzVÇ-V~ZLŠ7VÐXc*YîVÇYèñ]ÅñVä==ÍZX"Š´Æc1Vä=egZc*X0*@*wÅg(V÷}a¤/Š‰Xñ]Æ¡}í6,W7,}¸XZK

¤~Ô$4è MGä}.Zz0+ÃågZX~ZL}.ZÆ—g7ÕäFOc*XZkäZK«~÷~WzZi”Zzg÷~Ûc*ŠZkÆ»y~âXA$i}IˆZzg»,$Z_ZzgWyÅãCŠzVäR3ðZzgIIXZknz{õuƒZ'}.Zz0+WyÐ¤/YZzgh¬\äZKWzZi‹ð'ZkäZz6,Ð;B

(,J™=åx1XZzg=¹0*ãÐé™!*CÙïÑXZkä÷}izgWzgŠÔZzg÷}°Zz]gppzZßVÐ=rZ1Yèz{÷}n.e$i',Š„¸Xz{÷~¤ÆŠyí6,W7,}6,}.Zz0+÷Z–gZåXz{íÃ¤Š{(~ïwÌÑc*XZkä=rZc*Zknz{íÐplåX}.Zz0+ä÷~gZ4ÆñZ¬=bZŠ~Zzg÷};ðVÅ0*ÀÏÆ_.=$+!Šc*XYè~}.Zz0+ÅgZƒV6,¸g;ZzgÑZg]ÐZL}.ZÐZµ:ƒZXYèZkÆ‚g}Ÿ÷}‚t¸XZzg~ZkÆWMÐ',X:ƒZX~ZkÆ—g»ïÌg;ZzgZK$+»g~Ð!*ig;XZÏn}.Zz0+ä=÷~gZ4ÆñZ¬É÷~Zk0*ÀÏÆ_.ZkÅÃÆ‚t¶$+!Šc*Xg3ŠwÆ‚BÂg°ƒÇZzg»ïWŠòÆ‚B»ïX™»gÆ‚B(ƒÇZzgRzÆ‚BdJX¤iŠ{ßÍVÃÂXñÇX6,¾~W@fzg~6,Ð@*ÂZ7—™}XYèZ}}.Zz0+!Â÷ZlZrìZzg}.Zz0+÷}Z0+ƒ}ÃZYÑ™}ÇYè¾~$+zª~¯`6,ŠJzZ™@*ƒVZzgZL}.ZÅ$+zªŠ-ZgM0+Y@*ƒVXp}.ZÅgZ{»ïìX}.Zz0+»¯x@*c*ƒZìXz{ZyƒÅ4ìZk6,½zgnpXYè}.Zz0+ÆÎZZzgÃy}.Zì?Zzgøg}}.ZÃgh™ZzgÃy"yì?}.Z÷Z¢o°ìXz{ZKgZ{~»ï¿ÅgÉð™@*ìXz{ZkÆ0*îVCÙEVÆÐ¯ŠêìXz{=÷~Zzœ»V~‡ì™@*ìXz{÷};ðVÃkB™**2@*ìXŒVJ-÷}!*iz|èÅ¾yÃqŠïÂäíÃZK]Å4ÌŒZzg¾~3,òä=),gv¯c*ìXÂä÷}n÷}Šx¤Š{™ŠñZzg÷}0*îV7èX~äZLŠ7V»ù™ÆZyÃhuHZzgZ#J-z{+:ƒ‰~zZ:7Wc*'Âä=÷~xÆ×zVÐÌrZc*XÂä=¸ñV»uŠZgƒäÆngÄghZìXTxÐ~zZÌ7z{÷~.ƒÏ'ZknZ}}.Zz0+!~ñVÆŠgxy¾~]¦/Zg~Zzg¾}**xÅæbuZð™zVÇXz{ZL!*Šá{Ã(,~]ÁW$™@*ìZzgZL&.iðbŠZîŠZzgZkÅ±6,å.™@*ìóóX

DQM i^ N ]?m^l NN !‰ÛçñnØe^h NE

~–ì: 23 XÈL!*[ 2 Zzg|]ŠZîŠÆZxÆ0÷÷ŠZîŠÅWy~!*'tXŠZîŠ0$gö GOHìªtZk¿»¯xìuÛZiHŠHXZzg©[Æ}.Z»&.iðbZzgZuZL»è,Ï‚i

27

ìX}.Zz0+Ågzbä÷~cÄ¯xHZzgZk»K÷~i!*y6,åXZuZLÆ}.ZäÛâc*ZuZLÅ"yäíÐ¹XZq-ìœZ‰ÜÐßÍV6,Ó#Ö™@*ìX}.ZÆpsÆ‚BÓ#Ö™@*ìXz{ðÅgzÝÅâ#ƒÇZ#ÎgÀ_ìXZ+ðT~!*Šw:ƒVXZ#3,x3,xvki}~Ð!*glÆË™s®Æ!*)ÇìX÷ZyÂsã}.ZÆ‚tZ(ìÌ7XÂÌZkä÷}‚BZq-ŠZEÇTÅƒ!*'¥Zzg0*GZg!*0+JìXYè¸÷~‚g~]Zzg‚g~%ZŠìÍz{ZkÃ(,J@*7X

DQ i^ M ]?m^l NO !‰ÛçñnØe^h NE

tì|]ŠZîŠðÆŒzZˆy»ÏZq-§s!*ªÇCìZzgZy!*ÂVÃZkÅWy~!*'ŒÛZgŠîìX/'Z[Š¶!*ª¾§bWyÐi}6,¤/CìZzgÍf!*v|]ŠZîŠÃÌ¤/ZäÅÃÒ™CìX–ì:÷÷ZzgáxÆz‰ÜŠZîŠZL—6,ÐZJ™!*Šá„ûÅ¿6,Ô=ÎZzg¿6,ÐZkäZq-úg]ÃŠ¬.g„¶Zzgz{úg].e$

pzg]¶XA$ŠZîŠäßvŸ™Zkúg]»qwŠgc*ÄHZzgË:¹Hz{Z°xÅe"$#78-öGOZzgc*{Åç~ì?ZzgŠZîŠäßvŸ™

ZÐš1Xz{ZkÆ0*kWðZzgZkäZkÆ‚BÄÅ)Yèz{ZK**0*ÅÐ0*uƒ_¶(Qz{ZLyÃ¬ˆZzgz{úg]qnƒXÎZkäŠZîŠÆ0*kÈ~qnƒVZzgŠZîŠä-W[ÃB58-ö L

GOZzgc*{Ã÷}0*kŸŠ}XÎ-W[äZzgc*{ÃŠZîŠÆ0*kŸŠc*ZzgZ#Zzgc*{Wc*ÂŠZîŠä7Y-W[÷ìXZzgßÍV»HqwìZzgkBtƒg„ì?QŠZîŠäZzgc*{Ð¹ZLyYZzgZL0*îVŠðZzgZzgc*{!*Šá{ÆûÐZzg!*Šá{Å§sÐZkÆúúZq-pZy5ŠHXQZzgc*{!*Šá{ÆyÆW*:6,ZLâ´ÆZzgƒ{ŠñVÆ‚BÎc*ZzgZLy:ŠHXZzgZ#ZrVäŠZîŠÃtCc*Zzgc*{ZLy7ŠHÂŠZîŠäZzgc*{Ð¹HÂ^Ð7Wc*?:ÂZLyYV:ŠH?Zzgc*{äŠZîŠÐ¹1ztZzgZuZLZzg·ŠZ{Ñ;-V~gTZzg÷Zâ´-W[Zzg÷}â´Æ{ŠxAyZy~ek,}eZáƒñÂH

~ZLyYîVZzg3îVkVZzgZKç~Æ‚BÎîV?¾~q~#Zzg¾~YyÅníÐt!*]:ƒÏXQŠZîŠäZzgc*{Ð¹W`ÌÂDg{YÀ~NgzZ:™zVÇXÎZzgc*{ZkŠyÌZzgŠzu}ŠyÌk,z~g;ZzgZ#ŠZîŠäZÐšc*ÂZkäZkÆ—g3c*\ZzgZkä

ZÐö™áZÑHZzgáxÃz{!*CÙY™ZLâ´Æ{ŠñVÆ‚BZL_6,Îg;6,ZLyÃ:ŠHXðÃŠZîŠä-W[ÆnZq-â–ZzgZÐZzgc*{Æ;B5XZzgZkäâ~t–Zzgc*{Ã]y~ƒÐWÐgZzg?ZkÆ0*kÐ?ØY**@*z{âgZYñZzgYyeƒXZzg-VƒZZ#-W[äZkà»5±™1ÂZkäZzgc*{ÃZ+(g3˜Vz{Y}å·Šg%ŠXZzgZkàÆßv†Zzg-W[Ð±}Zzgz;VŠZîŠÆ{ŠñV~Ððh}Ðßv»xWñZzg8-ö LGOZzgc*{Ì%ŠHXA$-W[äWŠòŸ™kB»ƒqwŠZîŠÃCc*ZzgZkä‡œÃ@*N™Š~Z#Â!*Šá{ÐkB»ƒqw²n™`A$Z¤/Z(ƒ!*Šá{Ã×WYñZzgz{ÐìÑ?±äÃàÆZ,4,Šq-YV−

‰?H?7Y…¸z{Š-Zg6,Ð¾âg,ÐX%æGN$iï EOGÆdWZ#-)Óë ELGÃ¾äâgZ?HZq-úg]ä_»0*^Š-Zg6,ÐZkÆZz6,Z(7²z{&43ú

GGEE~%ŠH?Î?àÅŠ-ZgÆ4,Šq-YV‰?ÂQÂI¾Z{Šx‚Zzgc*{Ì%ŠHìXÎz{‡œ`ZzgW™T»xÆn-W[äZÐ5åz{ƒŠZîŠÃCc*XZzgZk‡œäŠZîŠÐ¹z{ßvë6,¸ƒñZzgò™yZy~øg}0*kW‰XQëZyÃgDƒñMS-Ææ4J-−‰XA$¾Z0+ZizVäŠ-Zg6,Ð¾}{ŠñV6,¾gh}XÎ!*Šá{Æðh}Ð{ŠxÌ%}Zzg¾Z{ŠxZzgc*{Ì%ŠHXA$ŠZîŠä‡œÐ¹Â$ðGNW[Ð-VINZk!*]Ð**pÙ:ƒZknŒZg6Zq-ÃZhZCìz(„Šzu}ÃXÎÂ

àÐZzgJkB™ÆZÐeJŠ}ZzgÂZÐŠxŠÑ‚ŠbXZ#Zzgc*{Åç~ä‹Zk»ØCÙZzgc*{%ŠHÂz{ZLØCÙÆnâ?™äÐZzgZ#ÎvÆŠy¦/g‰ÂŠZîŠäZÐZ™ZÐ

û~gÄ1Zzgz{ZkÅç~0ZzgZkÐZkÆZq-±»ƒZ6,Zk»xÐ&ŠZîŠäHå}.Zz0+**gZnƒZXZzg}.Zz0+ä**@ÃŠZîŠÆ0*k5XZkäZkÆ0*kW™ZkÐ¹Ëà~Šz¿¸XZq-Z÷ŠzuZ¾d$XZkZ÷Æ0*k

¹Ðg-hZzgŒ¸X6,Zk¾d$Æ0*kƒÅZq-à¬ÆÎZ¼:å&Zkäyh+™0*ÑåXZzgz{ZkÆZzgZkÆ!*w”VÆ‚B(,S¶X''ZzgZkZ÷Æ;VÃð)ÛWc*XÎZkäZk)ÛÆnZkÆ;VWc*ååäÃZLg-hZzgŠ~Ð¼:1ÉZk¾d$ÅƒáàZzgZk¿ÆnZkÆ;VWc*ååðXA$ŠZîŠ»…Zk¿6,$hå EI]¿»ZzgZkä**@Ð¹}.Zz0+Å§]Ånz{¿Tät»xHzZZ#ZÅ©5ÿ

GGìXÎZk¿ÃZkƒ»akH½**7,}ÇYèZkäZ(»xHìZzgZÐF,k:Wc*XA$**@äŠZîŠÐ¹z{¿Â„ìX}.Zz0+ZuZL»}.Z-VÛâ@*ì~äNC™ÆZuZL»!*Šá{¯c*Zzg~äN

28

‚îwÆ;BÐrZc*XZzg~ä¾}W‡»yNŠc*Zzg¾}W‡Åçc*V¾~ÍŠ~™Š,ZzgZuZLZzg·ŠZ{»yZ:ÃŠc*ZzgZ¤/tƒ¼ðhZåÂ~ÃZzgq,ÌŠêXÎÂäYV}.Zz0+Å!*]Å$™ÆZkÆ—g$+~Å?Âä8-ö

GOZzgc*{ÃŒZgÐâgZZzgZkÅç~áà@*z{¾~ç~¶ZzgZkÃµ’.ð OyÅŒZgÐO™zZc*XÎZ[¾}yÐŒZgLZµ:ƒÏYèÂä=HY**Zzg8-öGOZzg&éGO{Åç~áà@*z{¾~ç~ƒXÎ}.Zz0+-VÛâ@*ìŠN~ÑÃ¾}„yÐ¾}ÜsZVîVÇZzg~¾~ç-VÃá™¾~W\VÆ‚t¾}äñÃŠzóZzgz{ŠyŠ;h}¾~ç-VÐÄ™}ÇYèÂäÂ¾™tH6,~‚g}ZuZLÆgz',zŠyŠ;h}t™zóXA$ŠZîŠä**@Ð¹~ä

}.Zz0+»kH{HX**@äŠZîŠÐ¹}.Zz0+äÌ¾ZkH{õXÂ%}Ç7XÂÌaèÂäZk»xÐ}.Zz0+ÆŠ7VÃ¬Ì»(,ZñµŠc*ìDMQ ]?mk MN i^e^h N ]?mk MM !‰ÛçñnØe^h NE Zknz{±»ÌÐaZƒÇ%YñÇóóX

÷÷ZzgŠZîŠäÀ Š¶0*Šg~™r#tz„ŠZîŠìTÆ°wzZ»sÆ!*g{~ZÏÂ[~–ì:ZkŠZîŠ6,W\Å DMQ ]?m³k M !‰³Û³çñn³Øe³^h NEX ZuZL6,ÅZzgŠZîŠZKƒgÎÆ‚B°wzZ»s™@*åóó

Â[i**»g~Zzgi**»g~ÆnZL.e$(ŠwZzg‡.ÞBÃ%zZä»Z²ZxÎCìXZzgZ#ŒÛWyZy!*ÂV™ÆZLZíZY»ÔÍf!*vÔo] Garble ÅF,Šh+™@*ìÂW\ëŒÛWyäô`lÅ@*gõÃ

X Šc*ì:!*[ 22 !*[~èÃgìZzgZkÂ[Æ 12Ô11 XÈLÆ 2 W\tŠúòÌ7™MhŠZîŠ¬4åQˆ~™ŠHYèt**0*uzZ§

~i0+ÏÆWyJ-ŠZîŠÅ0*ÀÏ»f™ì6z{Hì÷÷~ZkÆWMÐ',X:ƒZ~ZkÆ—g»ïÌg;ZzgZK$+»g~Ð!*ig;óóXDNP (NO ]?m^l NN !‰ÛçñnØe^h NE

!*[~–ìŠZîŠÅWy~!*'t:÷÷ŠZîŠ0$gö GOHìªtZk¿»¯xìuÛZiHŠHZz©[Æ}.Z»&.iðbZzg 23 ZzgDN(M ]?m^l NO !‰ÛçñnØe^h NEX ZuL»è,Ï‚iìX}.Zz0+Ågzbä÷~cÄ¯xHZzgZk»K÷~i!*y6,åóó

:pŠ!*ªZq-§sWyz‰ÜJ-ŠZîŠÃ»ïZzg$+~Ð0*uZzg}.Z»&.iðbZzgZuZL»è,Ï‚iZzg}.ZÅgzbÐ¯x™äzZÑŒÛZgŠîXsvóó~ÌñŠìXŠZîŠ 1 ìZzgŠzu~§sZk6,**0*uZì»Z²ZxÎCìX|]ŠZîŠÆWy~z‰ÜJ-gZ4ZzgœZ‰Ü6,‡ìg»ZŒÛZg÷÷

Æ0–ìÊ÷÷z{¾}—ggZ4ZzgœZ‰ÜZzg¾}‚B¦ñŠwÐ¸g;ZzgÂäZkÆzZWt(,ZZˆygÄghZåÂäZÐDR ]?mk O !‰¡›nàe^h ME X Zq-gCÁe$HZkÆª6,Æóó

Xsv~X 1 /'|]ŠZîŠÆWy~/J-}.ZÆ—g0*ugzlƒäÆ!*g{~|]ÑyÆtZÖpÌæÃg÷÷ÎZ[Z}}.Zz0+ZuZLÆ}.Zz0+ZLÈ{÷}!*\ŠZîŠÆ‚BZkwÃÌ7gZ™ÂäZkÐHå¾}WŠñVÐ÷}

óX ¾~ZzÑŠ‰Â÷}—g¸g;z,„÷}—g½ÆnZKgZ{ÅZôogÇó —gZuZLÆª6,ázZáÅ¶:ƒÏÆºDNQ ]?mk T !‰¡›nàe^h ME

Xsv~–ì: 1 /'ZzgŠZîŠÆWyz‰ÜJ-}.ZÆ—g»ïg»o]ZkÐÌMìÆŠwÃ)qŠzVÅ§sâb™ZŠc*ZzgZk»Šw}.Zz0+ZL}.ZÆ‚B»ï:g;6ZkÆ!*\ ÷÷Z#Ñy%+JƒŠHÂZkÅç-VäZk

DP ]?mk MM !‰¡›nàe^h ME ŠZîŠ»ŠwåóóXtåŠZîŠÆ!*g}~!*ª»ÒyÚE+&+[Zzg§Š»DgìXZq-§sŠZîŠÃ}.Zz0+»&.iðbZzg»ïŒÛZgŠîìXŠzu~§s¬xZKã

£gÐ¤/}ƒñZìÌZkÅ§s™[™CìX/'Z[HgŒÛWy»ÒyŠZîŠð»Hpzg]umìT~ÃðZ%s7ÔÃð§Š7ÔÃðE+&+[7XZyWc*]™»|xtì:

X /'ŠZîŠäYß]‰i',Š„úWzgŠÔÃ»HZzgZväŠZîŠÃÓ#ÖZzgÕŒZzg¼Zväe;Zk»ŠZîŠÃDŠc*DNQN E‰ç…å]ÖfÏ†åV

29

/'ëä?6,ÌZÏ§bzk**iwÛâðT§bâbZzgZkÆÓxZmCY6,zkÅ¶XZzgëäZ“5ÿGPZzgZ',Z4-ê XGPZzgZGñPZzg©[ðDMRP E]ÖßŠ^ðV ZzgZkÅZzÑŠZzg‘4gö GWPZzgZ-ØPZzg-$ø

EPZzg;gzyðZzgÑyð6,zk**iwÛâðXZzgŠZîŠÃëäi1gÜÂ[«ÛâðX

/'ZzgzŠÌWyZzgi}~…zZáZ7vgZg[ƒÐic*Š{Y}ìXZzgëä$¨45é GGGES‰ZmCYÃŠzuzV6,¤Š~DQR Eeßo]‰†]ñnØV ¤ÂŠd(ŠZîŠÃëäi1g«ÅX ìXZzg)ŠZîŠÅ

/'ZzgëäŠZîŠÆ‚BNh~´‘Æ!*°zVÃÌZzggzqãWyÆ6,0+zVÃÌ»x6,ÎŠc*åXz{ƒ}.ZÅÄ™DZzgëtƒ¼DTM(TL E]ÖÞfnðV ™ä6,‡ŠgXZzgëäŠZîŠÃZq-]k»¯**2c*åz{±ZðÐvg~YyXñX:H?]¦/ZgÐ

/'Zzgëäi1g~ÃÆˆtz°{Ì–åi}ÆzZg_÷}(È}ƒfZk)*y(~Zq-„Š]*Zg¸xÆDMLS (MLR E]Ö^Þfn^ðV nZq-{mxìX

/'ZzgëäŠZîáPZzgÑyðÃD«Ûâc*ZzgZyŠzâVä¹£»â´Zv¬\„ìTä…ZL¹ÐÈzV6,¤«DMR E]ÖßÛØV ÛâðìX

/'ZzgÑyŠZîŠ»zZg_ƒZZzgZkä¹ßÍ!…gzqãc~ZhäzZßVÅi!*y«ÅìZzgCÙ¢zg~½…Š~ˆìZzgtîDMS E]ÖßÛØV X îaì

/'ZzgëäŠZîŠÃZK§sÐa«Ûâc*åXZzg¹åZ}NhÆgzZß!ZzgZ}gzqãc~ZhäzZß!?ŠZîŠÆ‚BëâZƒ™}.ZÅÄ™zZzgëäZkÆnßìÃ3,x™Šc*åZzg¹å7g}‚,Åig¯îXZzgZyÆôgL¯**ZzgZ}ŠZîŠZzgZkÆ‚¹!

DMN (MM E‰f^ðV ZLZZyÆ_.¿™zX~vg}ZqwŠNg;ƒVX/'Zzg¼z{ëZk6,ñÐ»xß)ZrVäŠZîŠÆ0H¼7¹(Zzgøg}È}ŠZîŠðÃc*Š™z(,~¤‰Ü»â´å)Zâ

¤‰ÜÆ!*zŠ(!*g!*g}.ZÆ—gCåXëäNh~´‘Æ!*°zVÃÌZkÆ@*,™Šc*åXz{áxZzgðÄ~ÑgT¸XZzg—6,zZiZKâVÃÌ¦™ÆZkÆ‚BÎŠc*åXz{ƒÆƒ}.ZÆ—gszZá¸XZzgëäZkÅÓ#ÖÃ¢oHåXZzgZkÃÕZzg‡éŠ?Œ¶ZzgH»ZyŠ7VÅ¥xìZ#z{Š-ZgM0+™Z0+gW‰¸XZ#z{ŠZîŠÆ0*kãÂZkäç{CkHXZrVä¹eg7ëŠz×äzZáÛ&Xë~ÐZq-Šzu}6,ic*ŠC™g;ìX:?øg}ŠgxyZ»sÐê™ŠzZzgic*ŠC:™**Zzg…¦ñgZ5ÅgÉð™zXt÷Z¸ðìZkÅ'â}ŠmCVZzg÷~ÜsZq-ŠÑìXQÌz{HìZKŠÑ=Š}Š}XZzgc~=Š!*@*

ìXZk6,ŠZîŠä¹¾~ŠÑÔ™ä~ZkäÕÐ»x1ìXZzg¹ÐÑ»YZ,ƒDZq-Šzu}6,Õ™DÎZñZyñëVÆZZyÆ_.¿™DZzgz{ßvðh}XZzgŠZîŠÃ¢ƒŠHëäZÐWiâö~eZÑìŠ7VÆuZVäÅzzÐX:ZkäZLg[ÐZlg™**ÑzqHZzgZLg[ÅZ¤®)~i}6,¤/ŠHXZzg}.ZÅ§sázƒŠHX:ëäZkÅn]Zzg6,Š{7ÙÛâðYèwz{øgZH[åXZzgZÐøg}0*kZY1:AÇXZ}ŠZîŠëäNi}~Ñ¯c*ìX:?ßÍVÐZ»sÆ‚BÓ#Ö™zZzgZKpZéÅcz~:™**Xz{»ZvÅgZ{Ðê?Š}ÏXz{ßvZvÆgZ3ÐxYDZyÃJ±Z[MìYèz{[

DNS i^ MT E”V ÆŠyÃ>ÆXDOM E”V /'ZzgëäŠZîŠÃÑy«HXz{H„ZYÈ{åX$¨45é GGGESz{}.ZÅ§s¹szZÑåX

tìŒÛWyÑp».e$"ÔzZãÔ)P&+[ZzgCÙnÆZ%sZzg§ŠÐ0*uÒy|]ŠZîŠðÆ0Zq-$ò~.ÐìX1|]ŠZîŠðÃWy~i0+ÏJ-°wzZ»sZzg}.ZÅ›Ð©gŒÛZgŠîìZzgŠzu~§s**0*u ZkÆ!*W.Þ!*ªÆÒ**]§ŠÐ6,XZq-§s

Zäâ]ÎCìX!*ªÆZk§ŠÅzz¥x™**ÌÂ7X|]ŠZîŠðäZq-xZyÓ#ÖÅŠZrâeZàZzgW\ÆxdW|]ÑyðÆ

Zy»**ÑëgCg83›é ExªdƒZZzg‚]‚wÆZ0+gÓ#Ö~Y^7,ˆZzgŠkDbäZÛZFÆk,…xÆâÑw~ZKÓ#Ö‡ì™àXZzgk,z~|]ŠZîŠðÅZzÑŠZzg{0+ZyÅÓ#Ö‡ìg„ŠzDb6,Œ¶XZ[Zk§b|]ŠZîáPÆ{0+ZyÅÓ#ÖÌ‡ìƒZzg{0+ZyÆÜsÓ#ÖÌ‡ìƒXZzgtŠzâVÓ‘Zq-Šzu}Åg«gXÍLL*ÆŠzgÌWñX:Z#6,ZäÇ**óÅÃÈLÔsvÔÂZgõ%A$ƒNÂŠzâVÓáVÆŠzâV´VÆfYÅ’k,Z]ZzgìÑ]ZyÂ1V~gZ{0*‰ZzgZk§b@*gõ»ù—hŠc*ŠHX

30

X Ò**]6,ZäÇ**)Æ:ŒÛWyÑpÆ Garbled 0*Šg~™r#!@*gõÆ0 :

Y( 1998 B†g~ 15 Yâ@*1998 B†g~ 9 ),·:ZZÚD

E:ãçm6æì†pÎŠ¼D

ÆzZu] mZ?x |]Ñy|]ŠZîŠðÆˆ¸|u!*ªä|]ÑyðÆ‚BHXZq-§sZyÃÕzŠZø»‹¹ÂŠzu~§sæuZzgÈl¯c*X

|]ŠZîŠðÅè#ÖÌÅ1|]ÑyðÆ£¨~ZyÅæbÌÅìX|]ÑyðÅ°p~!*ª9ì}.Z¬\ä|]ŠZîáPÃ#¥ƒ™Ûâc*:

÷÷}.Zz0+ÃC@*ì}.Zz0+¾}yÃ¯ñgÇÇZzgZ#¾}Šy7g}ƒYNÐZzgÂZL!*\ŠZŠZÆ‚BÎYñÇÂ~¾}ˆ¾~±Ã¾}'ÐƒÏ9Z™ÆZkÅÃ‡ì™zVÇXz„÷}**x»Zq-y¯ñÇZzg~ZkÅ»ªåÆn‡ì™zVÇXZzg~Zk»!*\ƒVÇZzgz{÷ZgCƒÇXZ¤/z{æ™}Â~ZÐWŠñVÅÑ_ZzgµWŠxÆ@*ic*âVÐÒ™zVÇX6,÷~gØZkÐ].Z:ƒÏX‰~äZÐ‚îwÐ].ZH&~ä¾}WÐÐŠ«HXZzg¾ZyZzg¾~‡ZµgìÏX¾ZªåÆn‡ìHYñÇóóX

DMS i^ MM ]?m^l S !‰ÛçñnØe^h NE

/'|]ŠZîáPäÑyðZzgZK±Æ!*g{~ZktKg]Ã0*™}.Z¬\Æ—goY]Åz{Zk§b:÷÷Z}}.Zz0+}.ZZk!*]ÃÂäZLÈ{ZzgZkÆyZäÆh~Ûâðì‡ZÆn‡ì™Š}XZzg6ÂäÛâc*ìz(„

™Zzg‡ZtÈÈ™¾}**xÅ(,ZðÅYñg„ZÑZ`ZuZL»}.ZìZzg¾}È{ŠZîŠ»yZ:¾}—g‡ìHYñÇYèÂäZ}g„ZÑZ`ZuZLÆ}.ZZLÈ{6,ªCÙHXZzgÛâc*~¾ZyZ:¯ñgÅVÇXZkn¾}È{ÆŠw~tWc*¾}WÐt

oY]™}ZzgZ}â´}.Zz0+Â}.ZìZzg¾~!*'EZzgÂäZLÈ{ÐZkn»z°{HìXÎZ[ZLÈ{ÆyZäÃ',•óX Šbàg™@*z{‡Z¾}gz',z0*GZggìÂ„äZ}â´}.ZzZ0+t¹ìZzg¾~„',•Ð¾}È{»yZ:‡ZIgugìó

DNU i^ NQ ]?m^l S !‰ÛçñnØe^h NE

ZkÂ[~|]ÑyðZzg|]ŠZîáPÅ†±ÆnttKg]ÌQì}.Z¬ÅöW÷÷ZL&.iðbŠZîŠZzgZkÅ±6,å.DQM ]?mk NN !‰ÛçñnØe^h NE ™@*ìóóX

/'!*ªÑyðÃ|]ŠZîŠ»ÇYdŒÛZgŠîìZzgCCì!*Šá>ØÆÑLŠúh+ZgzVÆ£.Þ~!*Šá{ŠZîŠäpŠZzg}.ZÆÑ**@Å7g~@*GZÐqÝ¶‰–ì: ÑyÃYdHgH

÷÷ŠZîŠ!*Šá{äÛâc*œzt»‚Zzg**@ÑZzg·h+qÆdW¯c*{Ã÷}0*kšîXÎz{!*Šá{Æ—gWñX!*Šá{äZyÃÛâc*?ZLâ´Æ5iñVÃZL‚BßZzg÷}dWÑyÃ÷}„ß6,ÎZg™ZîXZzgZÐtyÃáYîXZzgz;Vœzt»‚Zzg**@Ñ

ZÐC™,z{ZuZL»!*Šá{ƒZzg?3,êY„ZzgIÑy!*Šá{ƒgìXQ?ZkÆúú−W**Zzgz{W™÷}ª6,ÆYèz„÷~(!*Šá{ƒÇZzg~äZÐHgHìz{ZuZLZzg·ŠZ{»qÁƒXA$·h+qÆdW¯c*{ä!*Šá{ÆZ[~¹W}X}.Zz0+÷}â´!*Šá{»}.ZÌZ(„¾X‰}.Zz0+÷}â´!*Šá{Æ‚Bg;z,„z{ÑyÆ‚BgìZzgZkÆªÃ÷}

DOS i^ ON ]?m^l M !‰¡›nàe^h MEX â´ŠZîŠ!*Šá{ÆªÐ(,Z¯ñóó}.Zz0+Å§]ÅnT gnp¸ZyÃ}.Z¬\ä!*Šá{¯c*ìXOç–ìÊ÷÷ /'ZkÂ[~tÌ–ìÑyÌt¢

31

äíÃªxõZzgíÃ÷}!*\ŠZîŠÆª6,èc*Zzg÷}nZLz°{Æ_.Zq-y¯c*$¨45é GGGESZŠz*{W`„OHYñDNP ]?mk N !‰¡›nàe^h MEX Çóó

/'QÑyÆ0–ì:DO ]?mk O !‰¡›nàe^h MEX ÷÷Ñy}.Zz0+Ð›g‚rZzgZL!*\ŠZîŠÆWM6,¸åóó

/'Ñy»}.Z¬\Ð\g»m!*ª~Zk§bªCÙHŠHì:÷÷83šð EEy~}.Zz0+gZ]Æz‰ÜÑyÃpZ[~Š3ðŠc*Zzg}.Zä¹â8-~NHŠzVXÑyä¹ÂäZL{Šx÷}!*\ŠZîŠ6,(,ZZˆyHZknz{¾}—ggZ4ZzgœZ‰ÜZzg¾}‚B¦ñŠwÐ¸g;ZzgÂäZkÆzZWt(,ZZˆygÄghZÂäZÐZq-gCÁe$HZkÆª6,Æ6W`ÆŠyìXZzgZ[Z}}.Zz0+÷}}.ZÂäZL{ŠxÃ÷}!*\ŠZîŠÅ(!*Šá{¯c*Zzg~gN*±»„ƒVZzg=!*CÙYäZzgàWä»Åg7XZzg¾Z{Šx¾~¸xÆÖ@~ì&Âä`1ìXz{Z+¸xìÒ]

Æ!*):tY$Ëì:Ñgƒ$ËìXZzgÂZL{ŠxÃZK¸x»Z»s™äÆnKzZÑŠwÁe$™@*~',}Zzg@~ZqÐi™jVXYè¾~Zk(,~x»Z»sÃy™Yì?Zzgt!*]}.Zz0+ÃIWðÑyätqâZzg}.ZäZkÐ¹aèÂätqâZzgZLn/ÅŠgZi~ÅŠgpZ„:ÅZzg:ZLnŠzª»ÎZwHZzg:ZLŠ7VÅYyâÉZ»sI~ÆnÂäZLzZW

W~ÅŠgpZ„ÅìÂŠN~ä¾~ŠgpZ„Æ_.HX~äZq-¬ZzgKzZÑŠwÃõXZ(¾~â#:ÂÃðÐ¬aZƒZZzg:Ãð¾}ˆ‚',0*ƒÇZzg~äÃ¼ZzgÌŠc*Âä7âóªŠzªZzg³]XZ(!*ŠáƒV~/½Ãð¾~â#:ƒÇXZzgZ¤/Â÷~gZƒV6,−Zzg÷}WMZzgZ©xÃâä‰¾Z!*\ŠZîŠ¸g;Â~¾~/ŠgZi™zVÇóóX

DMQ i^ Q ]?m^l O !‰¡›nàe^h ME

/'QÑyÅ°p~–ìZväZÐZLk?#\ÐâZiZ:÷÷Zzg}.Zz0+»¯xÑy6,**iwƒZtyÂ¯@*ìÎZ¤/Â÷}WM6,−Zzg÷}VÃ7gZ™}Zzg÷}ÛââVÃây™

Zy6,¿™}Â~ZCz{w~ä¾}!*\ŠZîŠÐH¾}‚B‡ìgÅVÇXZzg~µZuZLÆŠgxygƒóZzgZKxZuZLÃDMO i^ MM ]?m^l R !‰¡›nàe^h ME F,u:™zVÇóóX

/'ÑyÅ°p~tÌ–ìÊ÷÷}.ZäÑyÃÕZzg™¹„ic*Š{ZzgŠwÅzÝÌÁe$ÅÜ«gÆ)g}DOM i^ NU ]?m^l P !‰¡›nàe^h ME Åge$ƒCìXZzgÑyÅÕƒZIætÅÕZzgÅ‚g~Õ6,¯EgBb¶óóX

/'!*ª9ìtXŠ]ÌÑyÆz~WðZkä}.ZÆnZq-y¯c*Zzgtx',•ZÐqÝƒðX–ì:÷÷A$Ñyä¹}.Zz0+äÛâc*åz{~@*gO~gìÇX~ä°Z"Zq-y¾}gÆnÉ¾~ŠZEj-$

ÆzZWZq-(¯ðìXZzg!*Šá{äZCì¢ZZzgZuZLÅ‚g~)®)Ã',•Š~ZzgZuZLÅ‚g~)®)9~g„ZzgZkä¹}.Zz0+ZuZL»}.ZIguƒTäZLìÐ÷}!*\ŠZîŠÐ¯xHZzgZÐZL;BÐtÈ™7gZHTŠyÐ~ZK¸xZuZLÃÐïwÑc*~äZuZLÆƒXV~ÐÌËàÃ7OZq-y¯c*Yñ@*÷Z**xz;V6,ƒ6,~äŠZîŠÃ1

z{÷~¸xZuZL6,qÁƒXZzg÷}!*\ŠZîŠÆŠw~å}.Zz0+ZuZLÆ}.ZÆ**xcZq-y¯ñXp}.Zz0+ä÷}!*\ŠZîŠÐ¹aè÷}**xÆnZq-y¯ä»ìw¾}Šw~åÎÂäZYHZLŠw~Z(V**XÂÌ$ðGNZkyÃ:¯**É

¾ZgC¾}'Ð†Çz{÷}**xÆny¯ñÇZzg}.Zz0+äZK!*]Zkä½¶‡ìÅìYè~ZL!*\ŠZîŠÅ(ZVƒVZzg6}.Zz0+äz°{Hå~ZuZLÆª6,´ƒVZzg~ä}.Zz0+ZuZLÆ}.ZÆ**xÆnZkyÃ¯c*ìXZzg~ä

Hg™Š~ìT~}.Zz0+»z{ÇìZkäøg}!*\ŠZŠZÐZ#z{ZyÃÐïwÑc*Ô!*0+JåX z;VZq-(Zk1ztKnZzgÑyäZuZLÅ‚g~)®)Ægz',z}.Zz0+Æè%ÆWÐ9}ƒ™ZL;BWyÅ§s;ñZzg¹Z}}.Zz0+

ZuZLÆ}.Z¾~â#:ÂZz6,Wy~:ni}6,Ãð}.ZìXÂZLZyÈzVÆn¾}—gZL‚g}ŠwÐºÇZzggØÃó{g‚rìXÂäZLÈ{÷}!*\ŠZîŠÆh~z{!*]‡ìg¿T»ÂäZkÐz°{HåXÂäZLìÐÛâc*ZzgZL

32

;BÐZÐ7gZH6W`ÆŠyìXÎZ[Z}}.Zz0+ZuZLÆ}.ZÂZLÈ{6,÷}!*\ŠZîŠÆ‚BZkwÃÌ7gZ™ÂäZkÐHå¾}WŠñVÐ÷}—gZuZLÆª6,ázZáÅ¶:ƒÏXÆª¾~ZzÑŠ‰Â÷}—g¸g;z,„÷}

DNR i^ MN ]?mk T !‰¡›nàe^h MEX —g½ÆnZKgZ{ÅZôogÇóó/'òÅi!*yÐ!*ªä!*Šá{ÑyÅZk§b°pÒyÅì:÷÷pl‚¾}ßvZzgplë¾}t5ix',Z',¾}—g9}gTZzg¾~ÕFgX}.Zz0+¾Z}.ZIgu

ƒÐZ(pÛŠƒZNZuZLÆª6,èc*ìaè}.Zz0+äZuZLÐ‡Z›g¿ìZknZkäN°wZzgZ»sDML i^ T ]?m^l ML !‰¡›nàe^h M E ™äÃ!*Šá{¯c*óóX

/'Q!*ªÑyÆh~-VæbuZìÊ÷÷Ñy!*Šá{ŠzªZzgÕ~i}Æƒ!*ŠáƒV6,'áŠHZzg‚gZ˜yDNP (NO ]?m^l ML !‰¡›nàe^h ME ÑyÆŠh+Zg»¤å@*ZkÅÕÃ}.ZäZkÆŠw~eZà¶•óóX

|]ÑyðÃZk—£x6,à™Q!*ª$+|Å|]ÑyðÐ™Cìz{ZkÐÌ$+F,ZzgZkÐÌic*Š{‡.Þ¢ì$+|Åz{|]ŠZîáPÐ™_ìX!*ª9ìz{¿ÕZzgŠZøq~~Š*~ƒÐ(,|ŠHåÔTä}.Z»ŠZEy¯c*ÔTÐ}.Zë¯xƒ@*åÔTäi0+Ï½}.Z¬\Å@*Gz¾]Š@¶z{}.Z¬\ÐQŠHZzgÑL¡¦Š-@*îVÅ„Š]™äÎX

X ]Þ^Ö×äæ]Þ^]Önä]qÃçá]gÑy»7Zy™zZßV»ìMVä·ŠÅÓ#ÖÆŠz”V~qWÆˆ|]ŠZîŠðZzg|]ÑyðÆ{0+ZyÅ

Ó#ÖÆ£.Þ~9}ƒ™pŠ|]ÑyZzgŠZîŠÃ„$+**x™ä»ÚZZV1Zzg]g0*Šg~™r#»ì!*ª~ŠZ4ZyZKã’k,zVÃlkô™™QŒÛWyˆ6,ZyÅF,Šh+ZzgZyÅoYzÐ**gZnƒDXŠ¶!*ªäùªÓ:Zzg…rîäZ²ZxpŠZL‹z6,ÎñX–ì:

÷÷ZzgÑy!*Šá{ÛúyÅeÆ´z{¹ÏZbúgÂVÐª!ð NW!Ô’.ð OãÔZzzòÔÂZãZzg8-ö LGOúgÂVÐ›™äÎXtZyñVÅ‰XÅ!*"$}.Zz0+äZuZLÐ¹å?ZyÆÖ@:Y**Zzg:z{vg}Ö@WNYèz{¢zgvg}ŠßVÃZLŠ-@*îVÅ§sâb™BÏXÑyZy„ÆG»Šx½äÎXZzgZkÆ0*k‚]ÎPZŠc*VZkÅçc*VZzg&w~‰XZzgZkÅç-VäZkÆŠwÃ¢Šc*XYèZ#Ñy%+JƒŠHÂZkÅç-VäZkÆŠwÃ)qŠzVÅ§sâb™1ZzgZk»Šw}.Zz0+ZL}.ZÆ‚B»ï:g;X6ZkÆ!*\ŠZîŠ»ŠwåóóX)!*ªâöÈw‰z{|]ŠZîŠ6,ÌZ²ZxÎ`X**(X÷÷YèÑyÂZEVÅŠ-~“k5éGgZ]ZzgÀEVÆÐC”xÅcz~™äÎXZzgÑyä}.Zz0+ÆWÐ$+~ÅZzgZkä}.Zz0+Å7g~cz~:ÅÜZkÆ!*\

XÈL~ŠZîŠ6,}.Z¬\Ðgz¤/ŠZãÔZzgZzgc*{Åç~Ði**»g~ZzgZkx6,6,Š{eZ%ÆnZzg&éGO{ÃO™zZä» 2 ŠZîŠäÅ¶óóX)f™Zz6,¦/g[ì(Õ÷÷QÑyäñWçVÆÐC*kÆnZkNh6,k,zÆ‚tìZzgµÀyÆÐCñ´Æn—£x¯Šc*XZzgZkäZ(„ZKƒZbç-VÅ{§HZLŠ-@*îVÆ—glg°CZzgŒÛ!*ã¦/gZ„‰Zzg}.Zz0+ÑyÐ**gZnƒZYèZk»Šw}.Zz0+ZuZLÆ}.ZÐQŠHåTäZÐŠz!*g{Š3ðŠ}™ZkÃZk!*]»¬Håz{)qŠzVÅcz~:™}6,Zkäz{

DML i^ M ]?m^l MM !‰¡›nàe^h ME !*]:âãT»¬}.Zz0+äŠc*åóóXŠ¶0*Šg~™r#t|u!*ª»ZL),gÍVÔZL·ŠgzVÐX6,}.Z»¯x**iwƒ@*åÔXÃ}.Zä!*Šá{¯c*åÔZLŒÛ[Ð

âZiZåÔZKÕZ7«Å¶ÔZq-§sÂ!*ªZyÃWy6,èCìŠzu~§si}Å0*@*w~¤/ZCìXZ[7,#ŒÛWyÑp»ÒyXÛâ@*ìX)ZyWc*]™»|xtì(:

/·÷÷t)gÎwZv~VÆ#5(Zk§&¿Åcz~™gìTÆúÑìPÅÓ#ÖÆiâä~ZkÅÓ#ÖÆÑZg]™äzZáÔhÐŠzg!*©7,}gT¸ZzgÑy»Û:åóó)!*ªäY½ÆÑy6,¬»Z²ZxÎc*ì(÷÷É!*©»Û¸Xz{

DMLO E‰ç…é]ÖfÏ†åV ßÍVÃŠðŠ¶zZà!*'2DóóX/'ëäZ}·)~V(?6,ZÏ§bzk**iwÛâðT§bëäâbZzgZkÆÓxZmCY6,zk**iwÛâð¶Zzgëä

Z',ZZzgZ³ZzgZGtZzg©[ZzgZkÅZzÑŠZzg}ZzgZ-[Zzg-÷Zzg;gzyZzgÑy6,Ìzk**iwÅ¶ZzgëäZ',ZÃZGtZzg

33

©[Šñ¸XZzgëäZyƒÃ@Ze$Š~¶ZzgZkÐ¬ëäâbÃ@Ze$Š~¶XZzgZ',ZÅZzÑŠ~ÐŠZîŠZzgÑyZzgZ-[Zzg-ŠZzgñ.Zzg;gzyÃÌZzgZÏ§bëZh§b»x™äzZßVÃ$+!Šc*™DXZzgŠZîŠZzgÑyÃc*Š™z²z{ŠzâVZq-k

Æ×}~ê™gì¸Zkz‰Ü²Zq-¸xÆ¬òßvZkÃ3‰Zzgn{™‰ZzgëZyÆêÆÍZ{¸XZzgëäZÝçnE‰ç…é]Ö^Þfn^ðD ÑyÃŒŠc*ZzgƒÃ„ëä¬ZzgD«Ûâc*åóóX

ŒVŒÛWyˆ!*ªÆZyÒ**]Åo™@*ìTÆ³~f!®+äZkìw»ZÖgHì|]ŠZîŠÅ‰0*åV9‰1|]Ñyäß0*åVZ(gXX

ªZ²Zx!*ªätÎc*ìÍf!*v|]ÑyäßZzgÜsÂ©Z+Z(gGZkÅF,Šh+ŒÛWyÑpäÑzq~„™Š~ÔÑyä¬7HåÉZkÆ£.Þ6,uÉ™äzZá»Û¸X Ú^ÒË×nÛ^á Ô

» Z(gÅZzg(,~¯`ÅOñgKZzgÃu¯` Strategy ŠzuZZ‹Zn!*ªätZVc*ì|]ÑyäŠÔÆÜsßZEwHXOç!*ªä¬Zk!*]ÃÑ<»z¯c*ì!*Šá{h}:gÇZzg^Ðh}ÂCÙ¦/:jZñX–ìÂZL¸ÇV

~Ð„ËÃZC!*Šá{¯**Zzg6,Š+Ã¾Z¸ð7ZLZz6,qÁ:™¢8XZÚ¢zgìz{ZLn¹h}:¯ñZzg:ßÍVÃD MR (MQ ]?m^l MS E]‰j%ß^ðe^h ~Ç@*ZkÆ0*k¹Ðh}ƒYNX

Zk¬ÃÑ<»z¯äÆˆQ|]Ñy6,„¬Å**Ûâã»Z²ZxÎc*ŠHìX–ì:÷÷h}ÑyÆ0*k¸z{Ð|ñ‰¸Zzg!*Šá{ÆÎŠZ¤/Zq-Zq-}Å7Î™ZyÆ}Æ}1™D

DNT ]?mk ML !‰¡›nàe^h ME óóX!*ª»tZ²Zx!*Ç"pìX|]ÑìPä¹(,~aw¯`ÅOñZkÐ×gKic*Š{ÃuZzgg~îg6,w•~Wä

zZà{ÎZg`»gÅZzg(,~¯`˜VW`ÆiâäÆŠ~Š*Æ´ÆŠ"CDÔ±z‚bÃJik,!*g™ŠîìZzgmÃZ(g™nƒVÂZk6, Motorised Divisions ÐÌ|]Ñy6,Z‹ZnZ(„ì¹YñËoäZ$©2.ç EEEH~ÆOñ

Z‹ZnHYñX|]Ñyðä)·Š~ZZxÐ©]Z2ZgGqÑèt|]ÑìPÅ{gz ŠZZ‹Zn|]ÑìP6,tHY@*ì

0*ŒÅ»x!¶:‡.ÞZ‹Zn!*]X1!*ªäZk!*]Ã—h™Zkg8-~7HìX–ì:÷÷Ñy!*Šá{ÛúyÅeÆ´z{¹ÏZbúgÂVÐªñW!ÔÀãÔZŠzòÔÂZãZzg8-ö LGOúgÂVÐ›™äÎXtZyñV

DN(M ]?mk MM !‰¡›nàe^h ME Å‰XÅ!*"$}.Zz0+äµZuZLÐ¹å?ZyÆÖ@:Y**Zzg:z{vg}Ö@WNóóX!*ªä|]ÑyÅ.e$i',Š„{gz0*ŒÃ(z{g8-~7HìXZrVäÛúyÐ)ZkŠzgÅ40*zgÐ(ZzgZgŠ¤/Š

ÅZZxÐ.e${©]‡ìGXZzgZ#t©]|]ÑyÆ»ƒñÂ¸svÅÂ[ÍZ{ì¾§bZ7ÓáVZzg¤!VäµZuZLÅŠzâVÑàZzg†!ÓáVÃ!*g!*g¦[HZzg!*syät¸ÂVÆ;ðVtŠzâVÓ‘PˆŠv}n{ƒNX

aåZ‹Zn!*ªÆÒ**]ÅgzÝ~f!®|]ÑyÅß0*ÎVÆ!*g}~ÎDqÑè!*ªpŠZŒÛZg™CìX1 |]Ñyä:ÜsZ0+gzãîg6,¢zgc*]i0+ÏÃ7gZ™ä~æŠŠ~ÉÛzã¸ñVÃÌZLŠ]Ð%ƒy5™1Oç

~t!*'ÒyX 9 XÂZgõ!*[ 2 svÆŠk!*[~ZzgQŒÛWy™*Ûâ@*ì:/·÷÷ZzgÑyÆnëä!ƒZÃÌ’™ghZåX)Šzi',Š„Ú}ZrVä»gG¸(ZkÆ¬Æ_.¹¶X

Zki}Å§sT~ëä',•g¿¶Zzgëƒ¼Y…Zzg¼u¿DbÌ¸uÉgh™ÑyÆÆ»ñVÆnE‰ç…é]Ö^Þfn^ðD «gzV~ðÎD¸ZzgZkÆÎZZzg»xÌ™D¸XZzgëZyÆ»xÆôZyóóX

÷÷ZzgëäŠZîŠZzgÑyÃD«HZzgŠzâVä¹Zv„ƒ°p»â´ìXTäëÃZL¹ÐñðÈzV6,¤Š~ìXZzgÑyŠZîŠ»zZg_¯ZzgZkä¹Z}ßÍ…—6,zZigzqãßÍVÅi!*y2ðˆìZzgCÙ¢zg~âŠ~qZzggzqã½…

34

«ƒðìZzgtîîaìXZzgÑyÆ‚t83ð EEOVZzgZKâVZzg6,0+zV~ÐZkÆHF,KMzZgZNG‰QZ7Ãa»¬5ŒVJ-z{Z#zZŠ~$~ãÂ’x~ÐZq-¿ä¹Z}’xZLZLyzV~−YîZ(:ƒÑyZzgZkÆHÑdZzg"~~»EŠ,X:ÑyZkÅt!*]Í™—Zc*)ŠÔÃÌZˆkìøg~Z¯Z`Ñd~Ë9xÃ1àŠ,ÂàŠ,ZgZŠèSZ(7™$Ë(ZzgZkä¹Z}g[=Â=Š}~¾~Ú»Âäí6,Zzg÷}zZ−6,Åì]ZŠZ™jVZzgZ(oƒ¿™zV&ÂIÛâñZzgZ}}.ZZLaÐ=ZL),gvÈzV~ŠZ4™áXZzgZkäƒ6,0+zVÅq¢~àZzg¹

=HƒZì~@@Ã7Š8c*z{Yy1ú™)q¢ìX~ZkÃ$¨45é GGGESJwZŠzVÇc*ZÐO™ŠzVÇc*z{÷}‚tZK)q¢~»Ãð¢oZi7™}X:z{¼Šk,IZZã~@@q¢ƒZZzgZkä¹X~äZq-Z+q»DqÝHìW\ÃqÝ

7XZzg~òÅxÆ´‘ÐW\Æ0*kZq-DZ:qá™Wc*ƒVtì~äz;VZq-úg]ÃŠ¬ìZyÅ‚g~x6,Ó#Ö™g„ìZzgCÙ§bÅÚZÐqÝìXZzgZk»Zq-(,ZªìZzg~äZkÃZzgZkÅxÃZvÃgh™Îg`ÆWÐ>{™D

Š¬Zzg-yäZyÆ¿ZyÃpzg]™ÆŠ3ñXZzgZyÃFgZ5ÐgzuŠc*ìTÅzzÐz{@Ze$70*DZvÃ>{™,WâVZzgi}ÅCÙ7æ{¼k,ÃªCÙ™@*ìZzg¼?ÖDƒZzg¼ªCÙ™DƒZyD+ÛzVÃÌz{Y}ìXz{ZvìT

ÆÎZÃðqŠ7Xz{Zq-(,}ª»â´ìXZk6,Ñyä¹ëŠBÐÂäs1Ñìc*ÂÑIV~ÐìXÂ÷ZtâáYZzgZÐòÅxJ-àŠ}QZyÐìñhßŠdz{HZ[ŠïXZ#ZkäZ(HÂz{1àZ}uŠZgz!=Zq-diâŠc*ŠH

ìÑyÅ§sÐìZvÆ**xÆ‚B"Z•g3™äzZÑ!*g!*gg3™äzZÑì?í6,ic*ŠC:™zZzg÷}—gÛâÎŠZg~Z(g™Dƒñq¢ƒXä¹Z}uŠZgz÷}Zk»x~ZK¢gZñŠzYè~¬ê7™zVÏZ#J-?ñŠ:ƒX

uŠZgzVä¹ë(,~¤‰ÜzZáZzg(,}§ZzgçnW\Æ;B~ìXW\g™BW\H¬ŠbeSXZkä¹!*Šá{Z#Ëo~ŠZ4ƒDÂZÐn{™ŠïZzgZkÆdi!*°zVÃf?™Šc*™DZzgz{ZÏ§b™D−Wñ

X~äêHì~ZyÅ§sjÙVÏZ½HZ[ÑDXQZ#z{jÑyÆ0*kWc*ÂZkä¹H?âwÆfg=÷~æŠ™**eTƒZ¤/t!*]ìÂc*ŠgÅZvä¼=Šc*ìz{ZkŠE~âwÐZkä?Ã«Hì¹4ìÉ?ZL6,¹**iZVƒXZ}@@?ZyÆ0*kzZ:YîZzgZyÐÈŠzë(,}HzVÆ‚BZyÆ0*kWNÐX»£¨™äÅZ7¤‰Ü7ZzgZyÃòÐf?ƒäÅqª~ïwŠ,ÐZzgz{nƒ`ƒfXQZkäZLuŠZgzVÐ¹?~ÐÃyZkªÃ÷}0*kÑñÇIZkÆz{ÛâÎŠZgƒ™÷}0*kWNXNh~ñV~ÐZq-u¿uŠZgä¹W\ÆZk£xÐYäÐ¬~z{ªáWîVÇZzg~Zk!*]6,Šg]gppzZÑZâ-$ŠZgƒVXZk6,Zk¿ä¹TÃZÞÂ[»DqÝå~W\Æ0*kZkÃWç=£Ð¬áWîVÇX:Z#ÑyäZkÃZL0*kg3ƒZŠ¬Â¹t÷}g[ÆaÅzzÐƒZì@*z{=Wiâñ~]™@*ƒVc***]~™@*ƒVZzg]™}z{ZKYyÆÃZ+{ÆnZ(™@*ìZzg**]~™}Â$¨45é GGGES÷Zg["*iZzg(,~Iz]™äzZÑìXQÑyäZgáŠHZkÆnZk»ªH™ÆŠ3îXëŠBHz{@Ze$0*Cìc*ZyßÍV~Ðkì@Ze$70*DX:Z#z{WˆÂ¹ŠHH¾ZªZ(„ìXZk6,Zkä¹-V¥xƒ@*ìtz„ìXZzgÑyäÃZvÆÎZ6,-™äÐgz»z{$¨45é GGGES»Ûx~Ð¶XZzgZÐ¹ŠHû~ŠZ4ƒYîX:Z#ZkäZkÃŠ¬ÂZÐZ0*ãŒZzg<ÍZˆA$Ñyä¹tÂûìT~jÆ•}Îñ‰A$z{1àZ}÷}g[~äZKYy6,ÕHZzg~ÑyÆ‚B

DPQ i^ MR E‰ç…é]ÖßÛØV]?m^l g[Z°=6,ZZyÑCƒVX÷÷ZzgÑyÆnZ+ƒZ»x6,ÎðT»ð»»Zq-¹Æ',Z',ƒ@*åZzgáx»»ÌZq-·Æ',Z',ƒ@*åXZzgëäZkÆ

n@*Æ»*»c*Zzgëä(,}(,}u¿ßÍVÅZq-)®)Ì«Å¶ZkÆg[Æ¬ÐZkÆ@*,Ûây¿™C¶ZzgëätÌÈŠc*åZy~ÐÃðøg}¬ÐRz~Z(g™}ÇëZkÃ¿ÂƒZ±Z[àNÐXz{¼eLåz{u¿ñVÆuŠZgZkÆn¯D¸Xª)].Zzge|ƒñ

&Bg+õ EZzg(,}(,}ÎjçVÆ',Z',ƒD¸Zzg¸g~¸g~ŠCCÙz‰ÜaÛV6,ŠO~gS‰Zzgëä¹Z}ŠZîŠÆ{0+ZyÆßÍ]¦/Zg~Æ‚B¿™zZzg÷}ÈzV~Ð¹Á]¦/ZgƒDX

DMP iMN E‰ç…é‰fð]?ml

35

»[0*Šg~™r#!tìŒÛWy™*»ÒyT~!*ªÆÒyÆ£.Þ:ÂÃð§Šì:ÃðE+&+[ìX:}.ZÅ§sÐZëZzgxZyf)ŠZg-V6,Ã,GYäzZßV6,ÑuZzg¬ZzgZÜ¹ZìÆZg‚[»ÃðZ²ZxìÔ:„}.ZÅ0*uzkZzgZkÆk?#\»

@*gõëX Garbled ñgŠ“WzZßV6,ÃðŠZrÎc*ŠHìXZ[tìŒÛWyÑpÅ0*u@*gõ!*ªÆ£¨~&W\

Yâ( 1998 B†g~ 22 Yâ@*1998 B†g~ 16 ),·:ZZÚD

36

صحف سابقہ کی تاریخ ، پیشگوئیوں کو توڑ موڑ کر پیش کرنے...

Spiritual