ipl sept 30 pdf

of 65 /65
SECOND DIVISION G.R. No. 170891 November 24, 2009 MANUEL C. ESPIRITU, JR., AUDIE LLONA, FREIDA F. ESPIRITU, CARLO F. ESPIRITU, RAFAEL F. ESPIRITU, ROLANDO M. MIRABUNA, HERMILYN A. MIRABUNA, KIM ROLAND A. MIRABUNA, KAYE ANN A. MIRABUNA, KEN RYAN A. MIRABUNA, JUANITO P. DE CASTRO, GERONIMA A. ALMONITE and MANUEL C. DEE, who are the officers and directors of BICOL GAS REFILLING PLANT CORPORATION, Petitioners, vs. PETRON CORPORATION and CARMEN J. DOLOIRAS, doing business under the name "KRISTINA PATRICIA ENTERPRISES," Respondents. DECISION ABAD, J.: This case is about the offense or offenses that arise from the reloading of the liquefied petroleum gas cylinder container of one brand with the liquefied petroleum gas of another brand. The Facts and the Case Respondent Petron Corporation (Petron) sold and distributed liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) in cylinder tanks that carried its trademark "Gasul." 1 Respondent Carmen J. Doloiras owned and operated Kristina Patricia Enterprises (KPE), the exclusive distributor of Gasul LPGs in the whole of Sorsogon. 2 Jose Nelson Doloiras (Jose) served as KPE’s manager. Bicol Gas Refilling Plant Corporation (Bicol Gas) was also in the business of selling and distributing LPGs in Sorsogon but theirs carried the trademark "Bicol Savers Gas." Petitioner Audie Llona managed Bicol Gas. In the course of trade and competition, any given distributor of LPGs at times acquired possession of LPG cylinder tanks belonging to other distributors operating in the same area. They called these "captured cylinders." Acc ording to Jose, KPE’s manager, in April 2001 Bicol Gas agreed with KPE for the swapping of "captured cylinders" since one distributor could not refill captured cylinders with its own brand of LPG. At one time, in the course of implementing this arrangement, KPE’s Jose visited the Bicol Gas refilling plant. While there, he noticed several Gasul tanks in Bicol Gas’ possession. He requested a swap but Audie Llona of Bicol Gas replied that he first needed to ask the permission of the Bicol Gas owners. That permission was given and they had a swap involving around 30 Gasul tanks held by Bicol Gas in exchange for assorted tanks held by KPE. KPE’s Jose noticed, however, that Bicol Gas still had a number of Gasul tanks in its yard. He offered to make a swap for these but Llona declined, saying the Bicol Gas owners wanted to send those tanks to Batangas. Later Bicol Gas told Jose that it had no more Gasul tanks left in its possession. Jose observed on almost a daily basis, however, that Bicol Gas’ trucks which plied the streets of the province carried a load of Gasul tanks. He noted that KPE’s volume of sales dropped significantly from June to July 2001. On August 4, 2001 KPE’s Jose saw a particular Bicol Gas truck on the Maharlika Highway. While the truck carried mostly Bic ol Savers LPG tanks, it had on it one unsealed 50-kg Gasul tank and one 50-kg Shellane tank. Jose followed the truck and when it stopped at a store, he asked the driver, Jun Leorena, and the Bicol Gas sales representative, Jerome Misal, about the Gasul tank in their truck. They said it was empty but, when Jose turned open its valve, he noted that it was not. Misal and

Upload: saline-escobar

Post on 02-Jun-2018

222 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 1/65

Page 2: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 2/65

Page 3: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 3/65

Page 4: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 4/65

Page 5: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 5/65

Page 6: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 6/65

Page 7: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 7/65

Page 8: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 8/65

Page 9: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 9/65

Page 10: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 10/65

Page 11: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 11/65

Page 12: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 12/65

Page 13: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 13/65

Page 14: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 14/65

Page 15: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 15/65

Page 16: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 16/65

Page 17: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 17/65

Page 18: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 18/65

Page 19: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 19/65

Page 20: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 20/65

Page 21: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 21/65

Page 22: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 22/65

Page 23: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 23/65

Page 24: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 24/65

Page 25: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 25/65

Page 26: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 26/65

Page 27: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 27/65

Page 28: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 28/65

Page 29: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 29/65

Page 30: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 30/65

Page 31: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 31/65

Page 32: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 32/65

Page 33: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 33/65

Page 34: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 34/65

Page 35: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 35/65

Page 36: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 36/65

Page 37: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 37/65

Page 38: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 38/65

Page 39: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 39/65

Page 40: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 40/65

Page 41: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 41/65

Page 42: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 42/65

Page 43: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 43/65

Page 44: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 44/65

Page 45: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 45/65

Page 46: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 46/65

Page 47: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 47/65

Page 48: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 48/65

Page 49: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 49/65

Page 50: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 50/65

Page 51: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 51/65

Page 52: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 52/65

Page 53: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 53/65

Page 54: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 54/65

Page 55: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 55/65

Page 56: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 56/65

Page 57: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 57/65

Page 58: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 58/65

Page 59: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 59/65

Page 60: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 60/65

Page 61: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 61/65

Page 62: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 62/65

Page 63: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 63/65

Page 64: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 64/65

Page 65: IPL SEPT 30 PDF

8/11/2019 IPL SEPT 30 PDF

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ipl-sept-30-pdf 65/65