apoorva shantilal shah v. cit gujrat.docx

8/19/2019 Apoorva Shantilal Shah v. CIT Gujrat.docx

1/15

APOORVA SHANTILAL SHAH HUF VS. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAXGUJARAT 1 AHMEDABAD

LAWS(SC)-1983-3-2

AIR(SC)-1983-0-09

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

C!"#$ %- P.N.B'#* + A.N.S, J.D,*/,/ ! M#"& 03+ 1983C**APOORVA SHANTILAL SHAH,HUFA22,#VERSUSCOMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX,GUJARATR,2!/,

F!"# V$%&' - A22,# #!,/

A&*+'"$ - P.H.P#",4& + H#"*& N.S#, + G#5#$ P&**2 + S.C.M#/#+ A* D, S*'& + A.S56#&**

JUDGEMENT

AMARENDRA NATH SEN -

1. THE P"**2# 75,*! !" /,**! * &* #22,# 6 S2,*# L,#, *&,&," &, #&," * ,:,"*, ! &* "*'& # 2#"*# 2!, # !" !&,"*,# ,;, # 2#"*# 2#"**! 6,,, &*$, #/ &* $*!" ! !


2/15

! G5

3. AGGRIEVED 6 &, !"/," ! &, A. A. C.+ &, R,,5, , 52 * #22,#

! &, I!$,-#: A22,#, T"*65# (",,"",/ ! # T"*65# &,",*#," !"&, #4, ! 6",*) ! ,', &, A. A. C. ",!'**! ! &, #*/2#"**!. T&, T"*65# &,/ !" ",#! ",!"/,/ * &, !"/," 2#"*#2#"**! * &, *# #, ,", !5*/, &, "#$,. !"4 ! &, H*/5# #/ # 5& &, !5/ ! 6, ",!'*,/ # #*/ !" &, 25"2!, !S,*! 1?1 ! &, A. I *, ! &, $#," &, T"*65# , #*/,&, A.. A.. C. !"/," #/ ",!",/ &, !"/," ! &, I. T. O.U/," S,*! =@ (1) ! &, A+ &, T"*65# ",,"",/ &, !!*'75,*! ! &, H*'& C!5"%-(1) &,&," ! &, # #/ * &, *"5$#, ! &, #,+ &, T"*65# # "*'& * &!/*' S&"* A2!!"# S*# !5/ ! &*$,


3/15

, '*, !, ! 6, ! &* $*!" ! ! &, 2#"**! 2"!2!,/6 &*$ * &* */**/5# #2#* # #&,"(=) &,&," ! &, # #/ * &, *"5$#, ! &, #,+ &, T"*65# # "*'& * &!/*' &, 2#"*# 2#"**! ,", !5*/, &,"#$,!"4 ! H*/5 #

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

. FOR ",#! ",!"/,/ * &,


4/15

",2, ! ", ! &, *,$ ! 2"!2," !5/ 6, ,;,,/ ! *& &,!, ! # &, !2#",,". &, &,", # # /*"52*! ! &, #5! &, HUF ! !, !" $!", ! &, !2#",," !5/ ! ** !"/***! ! !$, *,$ ! &, 2"!2," *&!5 ,;,*' /***! * ",2,! # &, *,$ ! 2"!2,"*, ,:,2 6 !, ! # &, !2#",,".

@. I ",2, ! #

C!5" !" ",#! ",!"/,/ * &,


5/15

"#*,/ * &, H*'& C!5" ,"",/ * !$*' ! &, !5*! * &,# #/ *"5$#, ! &* #,+ &, 2#"*# 2#"**! ,", *#*/.

@. MR. D,#* ,#",/ !5, #22,#"*' ! 6, ! &, #22,#

#/#,/ &, !!*' #"'5$,.1. A!"/*' ! &, M*#4"# S&!! ! H*/5 L#+ &, #&," #2!," ! /**/, #,"# 2"!2," #$!' &* ! #/ &, 2#"**! $#/,6 &*$ * 6*/*' ! &* ! 2"!*/,/ &, 2!," * ,:,"*,/ 6!#/, #/ * #!"/#, *& # &*& ",'5#, #/ ","* * * &,*,", ! &* !. T&* 2!," ! &, 2#" ! &, #&," * ",!'*,/ *,: 6!!4 ! H*/5 # #/ 6,, #,2,/ * # 5$6," ! /,**!6,'**' *& &, #, ! >#/##$*. . D!"#*#$* A#"+ ILR (1880) =M#/ 31?.=. A #&," * # 5& #, ! #,"# 2"!2," &, 2!," !,2#"#, "!$ # !" "!$ ,, !$, ! &* ! ",$#**'

!&," ! !" ,#*' &,$ ! !*5, # #

,:,2 &, #&," !" '"#/#&,"+ # !$2, &, !&," ! 6,!$,,2#"#, #$!' &,$,,. A #&," $# ,2#"#, "!$ # !" "!$!$, ! &* !+ ",$#**'


6/15

B!$ 10 #/ ! &, /,**! ! &, M#/"# H*'& C!5" * &, #, !V,4#,#"# P##" . >. M#4##$$#+ AIR 193@ M#/ ??@.. S,*! 1?1 ! &, I!$,-#: A+ 191 #/ S,*! =@-A ! &, ,#"*,"A , 6,,# #!' #,2,/ # $#&*," 2"!**! #/ !"'*' ,*!. I &, ,#"*," A &!5'& &,", # ! ,:2",

",,",, ! 2#"*# 2#"**!+ &, 2",,"#6, *, ,:2",,/ * /,**!5/," A # * &,", # # 2#"*# 2#"**! ! # #, ! &,#$* !" # #, ! &, #$* # /**/,/ #/ # 2#","&*2 #!*5,/ #/ &, #$* !*5,/

. MR. M#!/# ,#",/ !5, #22,#"*' ! 6, ! &, /,2#"$, #/#,/ &, !!*' #"'5$,%1. U/," #*, H*/5 L#+ 2#"*# 2#"**! # 54!. S,,"#, !#5 /*"52,/ &, #$*. T&,

! M#, B!!4 ! H*/5 L# #/ U#', !" !,/*' #'",,$,6,,, &, 2#"*, * # *, 75# !.


7/15

3. T&, 2!," ! 2#"*# 2!,# #", !,/ $#* ! &, 2!," ! ,,"&, #5 ! &,

!5/ 6, ! #"# ! # H*/5 5/**/,/ #$* !**' ! &* *,+ S#6,+ &",, ! #/ &*$,. H, # # 2#"," * *:$##'*' #', "$ * *: $*. I 2",*!5 ,#" &, *!$, ",,*,/6 &*$ # 2#"," * &,, M##'*' A',*, # 6,*' #,,/ # &,*!$, ! &, H*/5 5/**/,/ #$*. O D,. 11+ 19@ C"#/#H#"*/# #*' !" &* &",, $*!" ! #/ &*$, #/ S#6, &**,. ,,",/ *! # !"# #'",,$, !" 2#"*# 2#"**!. B #'",,$, C"#/# H#"*/# '#, !, 2*, ", ! &* /#5'&,"

P"#*6 * &, $##'*' #', !$$**! "!$ ! ! &, *:$##'*' #',*, &,/ 6 &, #$*. T&, 6##, !',&," *& &,!&," ", * &, !&," $##'*' #',*, # /**/,/ * , ,75#", 6,,, C"#/# H#"*/#+ &* *, #/ !. T&* #'",,$,# ! !$, *! ,;, "!$ 10119 &*& # &, 6,'**' ! #",& #!5*' ,#"+ O 11& S,2.+ 19 C"#/# H#"*/# #*' !"&*$, #/ &* $*!" ! #/ S#6, ,:,5,/ # $,$!"#/5$ !2#"*# 2#"**! * &*& &, #6!, # ,", ",*,/+ &, /!5$,25"2!"*' ! 6, # ",!"/ ! / #4, 2#, !"# ,#"*,". I &,#,$, ,#" 19?-8 #/ 198-9+ C"#/# H#"*/# #*$,/

&, *!$, &!5/ ! !'," 6, ",#,/ # *!$, ! H*/5 5/**/,/#$* 65 # ,2#"#, *!$, ! &, /**/,/ $,$6,". T&, I!$,-#:


8/15

O," /,*,/ ! ",# &, *!$, # # 65 ! &, H*/5 5/**/,/#$*+ #/ #,,/ &, *!$, # 6,!",. A #22,# ! &, A22,#,A*# C!$$**!," # 55,5 #/ &, $#," # #4, ! &,I!$,-#: A22,#, T"*65#. T&, T"*65# &,/ 6 &, /!5$, *75,*!+ &, /***!+ * #+ # ! &, *!$, #/ ! ! &, #, "!$

&*& &, *!$, # /,"*,/ *#$5& # &, #'",,$, ! &,$##'*' #', *& &, $##',/ !$2#*! /*/ ! 5/,"'! #', ,," # # ",5 ! &, #,',/ 2#"**!. T&, T"*65#+&,",!",+ &,/ &, #""#',$, ! ", &, ",,*2 "!$ &*!5", ! *!$, # ! 6*/*' ! &, /,2#"$,+ * &, #,&,$,, !*5,/ ! ",$#*


9/15

,;, 52! &, #$* * ! #" # &, H*/5 L# * !,",/. J5 # &,# ! # 4#"# 6,!$*' # 2#"," /!, ! *"!/5, &, $,$6," ! &,5/**/,/ #$* *! &, 2#","&*2+ &, /***! ! &, #$* /!, !', &, 2!**! ! &, 2#"," *-#-* &, !&," 2#"," !" 2#",". T&, I!$,-#: L# 6,!", &, 2#"**! #4, !,+ #5#+ ! &,

2!**! ! &, 4#"#+ #/ #,,, ! &*$ 75# 2#"," 65 #",2",,*' &, H*/5 5/**/,/ #$*. I /!*' !+ &, I!$,-#: L#!!4 ! ! &, 2"!**! ! &, 2#","&*2 A+ 65 ! &, 2"!**! !H*/5 L#. &,+ !, &, #$* /*"52,/+ &, 2!**! 5/," &,2#","&*2 !*5, # 6,!",+ 65 &, 2!**! 5/," &, H*/5 L#',. T&,", * &, ! H*/5 5/**/,/ #$* # # 5* ! #,$,* 2!* ! #+ #/ &, *!$, &*& #"5, #! 6, #*/ ! 6, ! #H*/5 5/**/,/ #$*. T&,", * !&*' * &, I/*# I!$,-#: L# !"&, # ! 2#","&*2 &*& 2",, &, $,$6," ! # H*/5

N! /!56+ &,", ,", $# $!/, ! 2#"**! &*& $*'& , 6,,#/!2,/ 65 &, 75,*! ",$#* * &, #$* /,*",/ ! 2#"**!&,, #, ! #/ ! $!",+ !5/ &, , #,/ * !$, !&,"$#," ! #&*,, &, #$, ",5 N! #," ! &, 75,*! ##,$2,/. I *+ &,",!",+ $#*, &, #$* !!4 &, 5,$,#5", 2!*6, !" /**/*' &, #!!$# T#2,#"* P"##/ (HUF) . C!$$". ! I!$,-#:+

>#25"+ (198=) 133 ITR 90+ &* C!5" !6,",/ %U/," H*/5 L# 2#"**! $# 6, ,*&," !# !" 2#"*#. A 2#"*#2#"**! $# 6, # ",'#"/ 2,"! &! #", $,$6," ! &, #$* !" #",'#"/ 2"!2,"*, &*& 6,!' ! *. &,", &,", 6,, # 2#"**!+ ** 2",5$,/ * # # !# !, 6!& # ! &, 2#"*, #/ 2"!2," 65&, &,", * # 2#"**! 6,,, 6"!&,"+ &,", * ! 2",5$2*! &,", 6,, 2#"**! 6,,, !, ! &,$ #/ &* /,,/#. I *+&!,,"+ !2, ! # 2#" &! #,', &, 2#"**! 6,, 2#"*#,*&," # ! 2,"! !" # ! 2"!2,"+ ! ,#6*& *. T&, /,**! ! 75,*! /,2,/ ! 2"!! ! &, 2#"*, *,/,/ - &,&," &,

*,/,/ &, 2#"**! ! 6, 2#"*# ,*&," # ! 2,"! !" # ! 2"!2,"*,!" # ! 6!&. &, &,", * 2#"*# 2#"**! # ! 2"!2,"+ &, #$*


10/15

,#, ! 6, 5/**/,/ # ",'#"/ 2"!2,"*, * ",2, ! &*& 5&2#"**! #4, 2#, 65 !*5, ! 6, 5/**/,/ *& ",'#"/ ! &,",$#**' #$* 2"!2,". A," 5& 2#"*# 2#"**! &, "*'& !*&,"*#, #/ #*,#*! /*;," #!"/*' # ! 2"!2," * 75,*!6,!' ! &, $,$6," * &,*" /**/,/ !" 5/**/,/ #2#*. P#"**!

# 6, 6"!5'& #6!5+ (1) 6 # #&," /5"*' &* *,*$, 6,,, &*$,#/ &* ! 6 /**/*' ,75# #$!' &,$+ (=) 6 #'",,$,+ !" (3)6 # 5* !" #"6*"#*!. T&,, ! /,**! ! &* C!5" ,#" #, 2#"*# 2#"**! 5/,"H*/5 L# * 2,"$**6,.

?. E $# $,*! * &, #, ! M!* L# S&#$ S5/," . C!$$".! I!$,-#:+ U. P.+ (19?=) 8 ITR 18+ # D***! B,& ! &, A##/H*'& C!5" #! ",!'*,/ &, #*/* ! 2#"*# 2#"**!. R. S. P#+ J.+(# &* L!"/&*2 &, #) &! 2!4, !" &, B,& &,/ !" ",#!#,/ * &, #"# * $!/," *$, &!5'& &, $"** #//*', ,$2! !"/ *4, >55$6* (K#< IL @)+ G"&*+ G"#*+ P"#6&5(>#. @3) #/ ! >#"#. H, 2,*# 2!," ! /*2!**! (6

$!"'#',+ #, !" '*) ! #$* 2"!2," * # ,#! ! /*", (!"/,6)+ !" &, 25"2!, #/ 6,, ! &, #$* ($#*,#,+ ,/5#*!#/ $#""*#', ! $,$6," #/ !&," /,2,/,) #/ 2#"*5#" !"",*'*!5 25"2!, (S"#// #/ &, *4,). T&, #&," &, #$,2!," # M##'," #/ ,"#* !&," 2,*# 2!,"+ &*& ! !&,"!2#",," . T&, #&," # ,2#"#, &* ! "!$ &*$, #/ #!#$!' &,$,, * &, ! /,*",+ ,, * &, /! ! /,*", ! ,2#"#,.(K#


11/15

T&, #"*!5 !$$,#"*, ! H*/5 L# 6 &, #"*!5 ,#",/ #5&!"'! ! */*#, #*, H*/5 L# 2,#4 ! !$2,, ,,"#, !

$*!" !+ * &, #&," * &, *,", ! &,


12/15


13/15

(3) O &, !$2,*! ! &, ,75*"+ &, I!$,-#: O," ",!"/ #/*' # ! &,&," &,", 6,, # !# !" 2#"*# 2#"**! ! &,

I!$,-#: O," 5/," &* ,*!+ #/ &, 2#"**! !!4 2#, /5"*'&, 2",*!5 ,#".(#) &, !# *!$, ! &,

(?) F!" &, 25"2!, ! &* ,*!+ &, ,,"# *#6** ! # $,$6," !"'"!52 ! $,$6," &,",5/," 6, !$25,/ #!"/*' ! &, 2!"*!! &,


14/15

I $# 6, !,/ &, !!*' 5"&," 2"!**! # *5/,/ * &,#*/ ,*! # 56-,*! (9) 6 &, F*#, (N!. =) A+ 1980 . ,. .101980 %-(9) N!*&#/*' #&*' !#*,/ * &, !",'!*' 2"!**! ! &*,*!+ &,", # 2#"*# 2#"**! #4, 2#, #," &, 31 /# !

D,.+ 19?8 #$!' &, $,$6," ! # H*/5 5/**/,/ #$* &*&,"!#,,/ # 5/**/,/ %-(#) ! #*$ 5& 2#"*# 2#"**! #4, 2#, 6, *75*",/*! 5/," 56-,*! (=) #/ ! /*' 6, ",!"/,/ 5/," 56-,*! (3) 5& 2#"*# 2#"**! / #4, 2#, #/ # /*'",!"/,/ 5/," 56-,*! (3) ! ,;, &,&," 6,!", !" #," &,18& /# ! J5,+ 1980 6,*' &, /#, ! *"!/5*! ! &, F*#, (N!.3=) B* 1980. 6, 5 #/ !*/(6) 5& #$* !*5, ! 6, *#6, ! 6, #,,/ 5/," &* A #* ! 5& 2#"*# 2#"**! / #4, 2#,() ,#& $,$6," !" '"!52 ! $,$6," ! 5& #$* *$$,/*#, 6,!",5& 2#"*# 2#"**! #/ &, #$* 6,

&!/ &, H*'& C!5" , "!' * /,*/*' 2#"*# 2#"**! !&,


15/15

# &, *$, ! /***! ! &, ",+ &, ", / 6,, /*"*65,/,75# #4*' *! !*/,"#*! &, ", &*& / ,#"*," 6,,/*"*65,/ #$!' &, 2#"*,. I !5" !2**!+ # 2#"*# 2#"**! ! #

#$!' &, !-",". I * ,:2,,/ &, #&," &! ,,4 ! 6"*'#6!5 # 2#"*# 2#"**! !

2#"**! * $ !" **!5 !" ! # ',5*, !,+ ! ,75*"*, $#/, 6&, I!$,-#: O,"+ #/ # &, 2#"*# 2#"**! * !&,"*, #*/ 5/,"&, H*/5 L#+ &, 2#"*# 2#"**! ,,#"* ! 6, ",!'*,/ 5/,"&, 2"!**! ! S. 1?1 ! &, I!$,-#: A #/ &, #,$, $56, ,,#"* $#/, ! &, 6#* &,", * 2#"*# 2#"**! ! &, #*/",.

13. IN &, ",5+ &, #22,# 5,,/. T&,

apoorva shantilal shah v. cit gujrat.docx

Documents