naxouosa H.B., PMxTep K.K. UJOPMMPOBAHME 3KOHOMMKM MHHOBAUMOHHMX M3MEHEHMfi 6 poCCMM: OTBETM HA COBPEMEHHME Bb130Bbl CKB03b nPM3MY MEXAYHAPOAHOrO OnblTA (pocCMfl, CAHKT-nETEP6YPt rEPMAHMR ~ ~ q e p T.B. COUMAnbHOE nAPTHEPCTB0 rOCYAAPCTBA. 6M3HECA M HEKOMMEWECKLIX o ~ ~ A H M ~ A U M ~ - OCHOBA MHHOBAUMOHHOTO PA3BMTMR POCCMM (POCCMR, TOMCK n.ntuuna O.A. MHHOBAUMOHHOE PA3BMTME CTPAHbl KAK OCHOBA3KOHOMM'4ECK

8 10H-

HblX 2 ). CM- 5

roir 9 4, M i r , 2

robon H.B. rOCYnAPCTBEHhAR ~ O A ~ ~ E P X ~ A M PErYJlAPOBAhAE B CTAMYJlAPOBAhAA ........ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~ 0 . M H ~ o B A J M O ~ ~ O L ~ AdTMBHOCTA B 3KOdOMMKE POCCMM (POCCAR. KAJlYrAl 3 5

:o- BOnPOCU 3KOHOMH'4ECKOA TEOPHH. MAKPO3KOHOMHKA R ~ . II! - ro Bonosvlr B.H. COBEPLUEHCTBOBAHME oTHOLUEHLI~~ C06CTBEHHOCTM KAKYCJlOBME MOAEPHM3AUMM M- ~0CCkl f iCKOf i 3KOHOMMKM (POCCMR. CAHKT-nETEP6YPr) 4. Kosaneea T.IO. OUEHKA 30 S o PA3BMTMR (POCCMR, A6AKAH 2 ," 3-

Ufenynqosa M.A. PMCK-MEhEnXMEhT B OSLLECTBEhhOM CEdTOPE 3KOhOMAdA (POCCMR, nEPMd 46 Ufnnosa c.n.. nenvxnna T.n. I I E M O ~ P A U J A ~ E C ~ A ~ ~ nPOLECC ~ A K O S ~ E ~ T YnPABnEnnfl H A @ E ~ ~ E P A ~ ~ H O M M P E ~ M O H A ~ ~ H O M YPOBHRX (POCCMR

?- 6ernosa E.W. POJlb ~ A P A ~ O T H O ~ nJlATbl B CTPATErMM C F Puurliyc 5.8. H O B ~ I ~ KPMTEPMm KAqECTBA XM3HM B CTPATErMM PA3BMTMR POCCMM (POCCMR, MOCKBA) .............. 57 3- ......... pLanranur C.A. HEPABEHCTBO AOXOAOB HACEJlEHMR: BMnbl M nOCJlEACTBMR (POCCMR. CAHKT-nETEP6YPr) 59 1.

-

Co~oruna W.3.. 3a~vSwna A.M. POJlb KOOnEPATMBOB B rJlO6AnbHOfi 3KOHOMMKE (POCCMR. BOJlOrLlA) 64 ~w~onaewro A.B. ~ ~ ~ T E J ~ D ~ o c T ~ POCCAfiCKOjl UJEnEPALMM n0 YKPEflnEdAlO P ~ r ~ O h A J l o h O j l 6E30nAChOCTA B A3MATCdO TMXOOdEAhCKOM PErAOHE ,POCCMR CAhKT nETEP6YPrI 67

~~~ - - ~ - ~ - , ~~~

Ony@pnesa O.A. MHBECTM$IOHHAR CTOPOHA MEXAYHAPOAHblX rA30BblX ~POEKTOB (POCCMR. CAHKT-nETEP6YPr) 0 rmaynnnwa A.P. COTPYAHMqECTBO KAK OAKTOP nOBblLUEHMR KOHKYPEHTOCnOCO6HOCM 3KOHOMMKM B YCJlOBLIRX rJlO6AnLI3AUMM (POCCMR, KA3AHb) 2

ronnuosa I0.A. nMhAMMKA nPOJECCOB KOPnOPATMBHOLi MHTErPA/LIA B POCCMA. CACTEMA d00PnLIHAT XX-XXI BB (POCCAR. CAhKTTIETEP6YPr). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 76 Hosocenbcram C.A. 0 nOCTPOEnAM CMCTEMol ~ O K A ~ A T E ~ E ~ ~ 3UJOEKTABhOCTA C T P Y ~ T Y P ~ D I X

. . . . . . . . . . . . . n O n P A 3 n E f l E ~ ~ f i OAO .PXn: IPOCCMR CAhKT-nETEP6YPrI . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 81 . . .7~

Muxaltnos C.H., ~ a ~ n u r ~ a ' ~ . ~ . OUEHKA YPOBHR MHBECTMUMOHHOGI KOHKYPEHTOCnOCO6HOCTM nPEAnPMRTMfi C T P O M T E J ~ ~ H O ~ ~ OTPACJlM (POCCLIR. H M X H M ~ ~ HOBrO 85 raticenor B.B. Y'4ET3ATPAT M nPMMEHEHLIE 6KJAXETMPOBAHMR H nPEAnPMRTMRX no Y60PKE TEPPMTOPMM (POCCMR. CAHKT-nETEP6YP 89 Ceuenosa A.B. BJlMRHME H n C HA OOPMLIPOBAHME OMHAHCOBblX P nPEflnPLIfl~LIjl (HA nPAMEPE PECrIYSJlMdA CAXA (RdYTLIRJ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 93 bysupen B.B., Maprunos 8.e. BOCnPOA3BOnCTBEnhAR CTPATErMg KOhdYPEhTOCnOCOSHOrO PA3BATAH nPEfll IPMRTMR JlErKOfi ~ P O M D LLlJlEhhOCTA (POCCMR, CAhdT-llETEP6YPrI.. . . . . . . . . . 96 Sa~cvroma T.B. AnrOPMTM nOCTPOEhAR CACTEMbl PLICK.MEhEnXMEhTA B P O C C L I L ~ C ~ O ~ ~ KOMnAhALI . - . .

... (POCCMR, CAHKT-nETEP6YPr) ......................................................................................................................................... 100 nocrn~rosa fl.B. OTPAXEHLIE BHELUHE3KOHOMM'4ECKMX O ~ E P A U M ~ ~ €3 YqETHOM nOJlMTMKE O P ~ A H M ~ A U M ~ ~ (POCCMR, MOCKBA) ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 104

M.A. Ulenyuqoma. npenowsarenb r r a t p ~ a r @uvaucoeorn MeHenmMeHra HawoHanbHoro

nccnenoearenbcnom ywsepcurera .Bblcuran uKMa 3KOHOMHKHr B f l e p ~ n sheluncovama@hse.perm ru

B crnambepacc.wampueoemcn sapy6exwbll o n b i m p e ~ ~ a ~ u u p u c ~ ~ i u e ~ e d ~ ~ e ~ m a 8 o6yecm8e~nau cexmope 3~onnrruxu, a moxwcepoccuiccxaa npowmuwa nyenxu ~&&e~musnocrnu upucxos u ~ s e c m u y u o ~ ~ u x p e w e ~ u t i e d o n ~ o l i c&e. I l pu~e~umenbno K 06u+ecrn .~e~~a~y cexmopy ~KOHOMYKU onpedeneno noHmue npucw., 8bldene~u pucxu. xomopbie dmxt i td atianuupoeambcn npu oyeHxe npoeamoe, a maKxeporcMompenbr OCHOBHble 3rnanbt n p o s e d e ~ w p u c x - ~ e ~ e d x m e ~ r n a .

Knmversre o r o s u : p u c x - ~ e ~ e d w ~ e ~ m , uiieecmuyuu, 06qecrnse~nt~ l i cexrnop, oyenKo pucxos

YAK 336.132 BSK 65 ' i

B nacronuee soeMn B csnw cen~oacrarweA wnbo rocvnaoc- o n c ~ - ~ e n e n x ~ e n r a . (Risk-manaaernent Assessment Framework). ,.. . . . rsao ~xonoun~enoaen~erca .eobxonarrocib no*c*a nncrpyue.- a raxnenoxyue-l= Oceurp~oroGan~al71 Q r<c<oropur crpamnx. hay ros soropae no3sonaor de Tonodo olmneara ~@gexrnsmocrb danpnuap s Oenr~obp*ramnr. iposenewe prcxuemecuuemra ~noecmqu i e rocynapcrseuHoM (06uensen~o~)ceKrope ~ K O H O - nsnnercn 06nsarenbnol cocraennmqel npoqeAypu oqenKn UH-

MUKU. HO H ynpasnnrb BO3HHK?.D~UMH npn ?TOM PUCKaMU. secmL(U0HHtAX npoexros, peanu3yeMux B obqecrse~nou ceno- Bonpoc ynpasnennn pucKaMn, csn3anntAMn c peannsaqnel pe ~KOHOMUKU.

~ B C T H Y X WHBBCTWULIOYH~X ~ D O ~ K T O B . ~ c c n e n o ~ a ~ ~ O C T ~ T O ~ H O B 3a~v6eXHuX nayrnblx CTaTbRx, nocsfluennux nDoseneHnm

nonpo6no ne paccuarpusanca. flpunquna ~ U C K - M ~ H ~ ~ ~ X M ~ H T ~

E 06qecree~HoM U VaCTHOM CeKTOpaX pa3nMraoTCn. nOCKOnbKy nnsennpoaanne snepsoMn3 HUX Hanpasneno naco3nmuesu- roA ne nnn nonnperHoR @UPMY, a nna 06qecrsa e qenoM Cne- AoaarenbHo,ananu3 pncKoe,csn3anntix craKnMn nnnqnarusaMn, nonxes BKnD9aTb nccne~osanne pnnanononnnTenbtibIX acnexros no cpasneHuo c nayrenuew racrnbtx u~sccnrqu l .

PaccMa~pllBa~ npaKTHKy np0PEneHUn pUCK.MeHe&XMeHTa B

O ~ U ~ C T B ~ H H O M CeKTOpe 3KOHOMHKU PocCYU, CTOUT OTMeTUTb, 910

naHHblR ennpoc ocraercn, KaK npaenno, sa paMKaMU BnnMauua nccnenosarenek, a raKxe ~op~arne~o-npaeoeux anroe. Ha ce- rOAHRUJHUfi neHb 8 0 MHOrHX o6nacrnx POCCUU npUHRTtd HOpMa- rnsnue,qonyMenrti, pernaMemnpyoque OUeHKy i@@e~ruewocru nDOrDaMM U nPOeKTOB, OWUeCTBnneMblX 8 O ~ U ~ C T B ~ H H O M CeK-

cncreub prc* vehenxvenra Y~a3a~nbe sonpocbpaccuarpnsanr nor n 6antpniBa cry D 19381 6 A p ~ r y a H Curra 0 IAi lua B el a cel 2010) n MdordenDvrre q-enae He*oropbe asroD* nanpdueD . . ~ e H ' ( ~ h e n L el 'i.;2006). nccnenoeanu'noeue Oopru cnvrxe~vra pucxos npn npenocrasnennu 0 6 q e c r s e ~ ~ t J x ycnyr Hanpn~ep, K TaKWM cnoc06a~ MHOCHTCR tl00Ull)eHHe SaCTHtiX &MOM K MOO. . . nepaqun c r o c y ~ a p n s e ~ l i u ~ u opranaNiu s sune @op~uposanun rocynapnsenwo-rannoro naprsepcrea.

Hec~orpn Ha 10, r ro cvqecrever aocTarorno 60nbuoe rncno & 4

rope B svcne rawx perno~oe u o n ~ o daman nenn.irpa,uc*yo nnrcnonpenenedreno+arrn p rcnascan~nco~cm60r rmsenr4n. Ka T,nbcltya.Hnxercponcnyo Cauapc6yo Xa6dpoacnyo o6nac~r o~.~ulxpoue*riso6narr~co7~anraot&ecrse~~~x6nar arame 9

n e o 6 x o ~ u ~ o c ~ n nposenenun or len~n pncKoe: ne scerAaonpe4en~- eTCR llOHRTUe qPHCKI llPWMeHUTenbH0 K 06qecTBenHo~y CeKTOpy 3KOHOMWKU. Momno YTBePXnaTb. 110 B c Y ~ ~ c T B Y K I u ~ ~ npaKTUKe aHanU3a ~@@~KTHBHOCTU PerUOHanbHblX UHBeCTH4HOHHblX nPOeK- TOB He UCnOnb3yWTCn CUCTeMaTU3aUUR pUCKOB U KonU'leCTEeHHtAe MerontA ux O ~ ~ H K U .

P~CCMOTPUM M€TOnUKy, KOTOpaR pa3pa60~aHa B ~ ~ ~ ~ M C K O M

Kpae Ann onpeaenesun s @ @ e ~ ~ u e ~ o n u nnsenuqnonnux npo- eKTOE, PeanU3YeMblX 8 O ~ U ~ G T ~ ~ H H O M CeKTOpe. C O ~ ~ ~ C H O 3TUM

M ~ T O ~ Y ~ ~ C K U M Y K ~ ~ ~ H U R M ~ P H O U ~ H K ~ U H B ~ C T U ~ U ~ ~ L ( U T ~ ~ B ~ W T C R

HeTOnbKO HX ~ ~ & K T U B H O C T ~ . HO U DWCKW, nacn0~1a UHBeCTUunOH-

ARTIIU p x n a 8 nonrencTe nccncnosamnu 06~.ec~~ennoro cellopa .~xomou~xw sbaonev.,a p r c ~ o s nopnexau~x a*anmr a ranne 9 cranni 6orop.e s cebn snnmaer pncn-uenopnue~r s 3ro l 06. 4 nacrr n ~ ~ s e p ~ a e r c a r c n y , e ~ n p a ~ r r r o ~ o , ? n x r p c r o ~ a n ~ b x 3 npoe*~oe s y133ankoi. ccpep@ ~i

la . . npOeKTOB B o ~ u ~ C T B ~ H H O M CeKTOPe 3KOHOMUKU. T p a ~ n q u o ~ ~ o

Herarmsno noenuRer Ha seponmonbnocnneHuR qenn,noc~aenen HOR B npoeKTe (Civ~l contingency act. 2004; Aritua B el. al., 2010). qro6u ~a~oe-nu60 ~06blrue Morn0 DaccMaTDnsaTbcn B KaqecTeo

I nDaBUTenbClBaKDaR 6 HUXneDeSUCnRDTCR OCHOBHueDUCKU KOTO- TeDH nDeLlCTaBnReT ~060R 04WHlIY E O ~ A ~ ~ C T B H R DUcna na moen $ pae M O ~ ~ T ona3a-0nebnaronpum~oe s o ~ ~ e A c r e ~ e .a pelfnbrarb Hyxrno orMer.iTb -To n e n o ~ o ~ b e nccnenosarcnu (Baloy D 1998

,'

r~secmpoeam~a Buecre c reu prcr-uenenxup*r cna6o n*rer. p 36' a ~ a n n l n p ~ a r rnl*cnnb;r 4nrn C O ~ ~ T A P . moropce a b c i y m . i G

pnposan B npoqecc peanusaqun TaKux U H H O B ~ ~ U R B YaCTHOCTU, er UCTO~HUKOM pucna. nnn roro r ~ 0 6 t i onpenenurb. na KaKoM era 3 . . - - - - - -

cro *ot>rpana*re TO-rr onkaro a*anr? pwrdnn orpa.n-nsaercn Onpenenan no.in-ne Prcna eolhnnaouen npu ~ ~ a e c m p o s a - I . . .

M O X ~ T OKa3aTb ne6naronpnnr~oe sos,qelcrsue Ha Aocrnxenue BHUMaHne Ha erO OTnUqnH 01 TePMUHa rHempenenennocrbr. B HaMeqeHnblx o nporpaum qenel. Cucreuar~sauun B O ~ M O X H ~ X oTnurne OT nocnen~efi. PUCK csn3an c raxuM cobrueu , sepo- pnc~oe n ux ~ o n n r e c ~ e e ~ ~ u i ? a~anue orcyrcrsymr. mnonb nacrynnenn~ Koroporo MOXHO onpeaenurn, no3ToMy

3apy6ex~uR ontir nposenennn p u c ~ - ~ e ~ e & x ~ e r r a B 06. nsnnelcn oqeHueaeMtiM obbe~rou, nonpamqu~ca aHanH3y n UeCTBeHHoM CeKTOpc 3KOHOMUKu UJnoxeH B p a ~ ~ a a 6 p a s ~ u X y I lpa~ne~~D[81 .

pyKOEOACT0 CTOHT OTMeTUTb pa3pa6o~aHntie B Benu~o6pnTaHnn flaloT AocTaTo'lHo uupOKyD TPaKTOBKY HenPe~BUAeHHoMy cny .Opanxesylo KHHrYr ( T ~ C Orange BOO^. 2004) M .Pauxn OUeHKU ram (emergency). nsnnmrqeMycn nnOqHUKOM p ~ c ~ a , onpenennn

4 6

6ocronHun abqecrea nnw anpyxaloqeu cpenu. cenrope Ha ueneeble rpynnbl Hacenenun, a TaKxe na npyrne renoserecKMx xuanei, yoenureHue gabonepa- cnan, KOTOpble norenquanano MOryT 6 ~ ~ b 3aTpOHyTbl ~ P O ~ K T O M .

un, paapywenue crpy~ryptd 3~paaoaxpaHenun. CornacHo peKoMeHnaunnM BceuUpnoro 6anKa. ecnn cyuecreym nloneR. nanecenueope~aracr~oi co6craennocru. sblco~an oepon~noc~b n3ue~enun o c ~ c e n ~ x u e n e ~ npaeKra us-aa

o ~ o ~ o n b c r e e n ~ o i , sneprernrecKoR,sKonorurocnoi s o e ~ e u c r s ~ ~ PUCKOB. TO OH uonxen bbirb nepecuorpen u M3MeHeH

PaCCMOTpnM OCHOOHble 3Tallbl PUCK-MeHeaXMeHTa B 06qe-

r r o npU OLieHKe nHDeCTUqn0HHblx pewenuk, nepebix. n3 eblnBneHn8, Ol4eHKM n MOHUTOpnHra Cy~eCTeeHHblx ~ C T ~ ~ H H O M C ~ K T ~ ~ ~ ~ K O H O M U K U , ~ O ~ X ~ H ~ H ~ ~ pncnoe, KOTOpble uoryr nouewarb uocrnxennlo nocraaneHnblx u u c n e ~ i p puc~os,ceneann~x c napywenueu qenei, n, eo-eropbix, wa oroernblxneicreui (Aritua B., et. a[., 2010).

-~""..-. lvdpacrpydr)pm Xpoucroro pJnn;,a nprndua-b~neasndua~ne -a? ennamnc ina-~uolx pncroo nonabno ,npaonemrc pncdsun

censah~.~ec npnonc-cmneu ~ d c n c r r c ~ n ramc/n~n"Toe n oo3nnmo-nMAnrn /moecrnpoeanad e *ornorarnemor cadrop p*Ke nooe*roe n 06-ccroem-oi ctpcpu, nocronhr, 0.4 r a w ? p*c*.uenen.rue-r o sb,ccrecnmou ccd~opr 3do-oun~n mn,e,~c~

. ,,,,,. . . , , .,ea::z. ,, - . , *mr , U B B + ~ ~ O oKameamr enannue Ha pesynbrart. peanusaqnu npo-

en L., el. al., 2006). oruerwrb, TO B neKoropbrx acrornunax K pnc- OryT npUeeCTU K OTKnOHeHUK, pe3ynbTaTOB PC-

Doenra or Hauerenntdx, npuqucnnercn ranxe Tame

, KOTO asa npenocraenenun ycnyr n ocyqecrenennn

." ". . . i p u ~ e p x pucnoa, noropb~e uoryr nonennrbc~ na pasnb~x i ~ u x e ~ennoro uunna (hiiaylor at ai., 2006).

. ~ ~ - ~ n~3a3acnynunaur rncdn rnacc~wnra,nn ~~~~~~x nrcnnoncno

.,, +cno ' ' cneuuanncmuh B c e ~ n p ~ o r o 6an&a !81 B coorocrcrora c ncll.

! o atiue- Pdcnn Bc@epe n p ~ ~ ~ ~ o o n e n n n 06-ecioennox bnar n o n i m pac. - x claTb86 cuarpnsarbcn, e ncroya a.rreno c nold,.w oh,~croe o ,pnou ,P npdoo- 30 npeflnonaraer /,cr n radnx ne6naronrnnrnrrr eo3nc~cred.i ~sec~rdn ' an. hanpvuep. n o e ~ o d ~ o c r ~ co3nan.w nnfio ,rn,finc.na CO-A

.r a ranme anbnwx *od@nn,nnaroe Ann o 6 ~ c c r o e ~ ~ o r o ncpaoemcroe o rc3,n.-

ABaETCR B rare npuhnrnp ~ ~ o c c r n : ~ o n ~ ~ x pc-pndi o PaCCMaTPAlJCMOM

+OM I ce*. CeKIOpe 3KONOMdKU

ClBCHnbl 6av o r ~ e ~ ~ c i c ~ o non/uenrax Bce~nc-o ro tianra co-n-

nendano. ... a"ehhe ppvtcru cen3anm,c c oc,,enonP.neu noboro npocdra , cenropa 1 MOrYT6wrbpmnenchdna nnra :ppn Ye6oroppr a3 - A x 2rpan;a-

. 3 Tanme OT Bnn~nue ocyqccsne;nn nnjec~d,ni "a ofi_.ec~eo e ,cnou

. ~ 2 . i 06. wyrue -no3p?ucm~e S ~ P ~ ~ E ~ cpcnb nacau ~ P J C I ( T Y~CMOTPR 3-anbnY1 *a 10,sro aHannruK re6 npanmo "P MO.+PT ( n p a h n ~ ~ b pncdaun.

ora3bsao~uuw eJ3ncicrove ma C ~ M nhoec~n,nOnmb;I npOehT. 'sne.ueU Peanu3yeuau o 0 6 , c c ~ o ~ ~ ~ o u cenlope onn o6a3arcn~~ononn;- (nunohno n~~bl-OhflR.~chb n o*na-em, :I anandl Tyrnerlhn Oxaparrepn3yeu na-a rp,-n p ~ c r o o OQ~"RCMDX BCPMAP.

,ciaenen. 3blM 6a"~ou

3. 20101 K Pncnau coneammsu c nnaccrdpoaanneu o 06-ccreen-OM 6asecrse J CCKTOP@ ~*OHOMA%U non.+-o b o ~ ~ 07n~ccno c ~ p a - o e ~ e p ~ c d n .e cede* OrPaxaaunc nondr*qccr,o -ecrafinnanocra onacnocr- 003-

13MeDn0- ddK*osednn ro?Q.-ndro3 n r n Cpenn n o n * r ~ n o - 3 d o n o u n s e c ~

a npoe*'. P ~ K O ~ - ~ O ~ X O A W U O paccuaTpneaTa oo~uon;noc d3MPnPnnC npo- , D, ,998 : eflaenm~en~.~un 3a~~repccoe3n~aun:p~nnaMn -Dun-repech

sacr,na. . 'Orv 6*1byaevnc.ro o pe3,n.rarc oc,Lecrexncrdoro npoc6Ta anOM cro a rrCne 'Pynn pncroo npnclrcrwer rarn;c yrpala ncbnaronpn.

Rrhoro ~ ~ ~ S ~ U C T C A R npowTa ma 06-ecroo o a c o h e ~ ~ o c r n -a ~cmposa. c'4nacb*o rlela,nilem~.c nnn la3onuae cnod maccncmnw A m - ?mrnp,Or " n r Y q * O ~ ~ ~ ~ e p n c ~ ~ n~no.nmr e ceha ncnocrarosmoc pe3on-

7..

,ocrw B "eu,C:ary-oo:b,~c~o~ n X X O C 3 ~ M L n d C T p ~ p O 3 ~ n A C ; I F O e K T O e

'M o c p "'" ~ P G M O 70.0. ,uo.>r~, amnn~npooara;n 3n3Crl~hn~C pnc-4.

a,ou, Od SBR3a*we c ~ 3 u e ~ c ~ w e t ~ uadp03%0m0~n-e~ro> cnr,a,*n c ' A u ~ a r ~ ~ e c n ~ ~ ~ 3QpPnTaMn A 7 2 Yrn6x>nnuo orucr4ro -ro

9anu31 4 ':

oa3dax npocnroe p33.2n,rrlc rplnns pncnoo u c r p nuern heonada~neoe 3rasCmrP

i p ~ a n A A CM, cnv. ennenemwn A amann3a nccx p ~ c * o e or-ocn-nxcn A

~ge~enl l l l repcqrcnc;ld.~~ rplnnau o n a n n ~ n ~ noT,-agi nonnla naprun,

. .- 7

He Ha ycrpanenne pucna eoobqe, a Ha ero cnnxeHne no ypoenn, KOTOPblh n0380nHT nOCTUL(b nOCTaeneHHblX qenefi. He UOnyCTnib nepepacxoua blonxernblx cpencre, npeuureparmb earpnsnenne onpyxaioqei cpenbl u np.

Oxapamepnsye~ 3ranbl peanusauun pucn-uene~xuenm 60- nee noupobno, 3ran eblnsnenun pucKoenennercn ucnnloqurenbHo B ~ X H ~ I M u o ~ a ~ b ~ ~ a e ~ s ~ a r u ~ e n b ~ ~ e o n u ~ ~ n e ~a pewenun, nennlo- uuecn ~esvnb~arou nponenennn DUCK-uenenme~ra(Mavlorena

(Antua 0. el al . 2010). Hecuoron Ha sro, na ceran~nwnni neHb cyqecreyer uano s ~ n u p u r e c ~ u x nccneaoeanul, nocenuennux BblReneHUlo PUCKOB npH OueHKe Y H B ~ C T U U U ~ B O ~ ~ ~ C T E ~ H H O M

CeKTOpe. B ~ O ~ ~ U ~ U H C T B ~ pabor B obnacru pnCK-MeHeflXMeHTa paccuarpueaiorcn ronbKo crannn a~annsa pncKoe u paapabor~n orsernblx neicreni.

OUeHKa PnCKOe. CeU3aHHblX C HHBCCTWUUOHHblMH PeUeHHRMU

eaeuol np06ne~a~UKe B uenou, oueHna pncna sa~nloqaercn B

onpeAeneHun seponrHocruroro, r ro ~ O K ~ ~ ~ T ~ ~ U ~ + + B K ~ M ~ H O C T W

npOeKTa4OCTMrHyTKOHKpeTHblX 3Haqenni. Kannpaeirno, PeKOMeH- nyercn eblnonneHue cnenyloqnx waras npu npoeenenau oueHnn PHCKOB, COnpRXeHHblX C UHBeCTU4nOHHHMU peWeHnRMn B c+epe cosnannn 06uec~eennt .~ bnar [31

11 Ananna rvecrenrenbnacru, n o n x e ~ nDoeonnrbca nnn rex

npaslmy, rannuu nepeMeHHblMU nennlorcn r e napauerptd, sapua- unn ~oropux e npeuenax 1% npusonur K raKouy x e npoqeHrHo- MY usuenenn~) ~HCTOI npuoene~noi CTO~MOCTU 8blron npoenra. npyrnun cnoeaun, ecnu ryecreurenbtiocrb ruc ro i npusene~noii crouuocrn eblron npoeKra K usuenennlo +a~ropa honbwe nu60 paeHa I , ra Ha Hero nyxno 06paqarb ocofioe BHUMaHUe. Konnper- Hb l i CnUCOK TaKUX nOKa3a~enel MOXeT MeHSTbCR B 3aeUCHMOCTU or cneqn+uKn npoeKTa.

8 paMKaX aHanU3a YyBCTeUlenbHOCTn BblRenfllol TaKXe aHa- nne cuenapuea, noropbli( II0380nReTYW3CTb COBOKYnHOe snunHue onpe,qenennoro nafiopa saxneiwnx nepeuenrb~x na no~asarenn e++enrnenocru npoeKra. npu JTOM nsyrenne PUCKOB ne Ronxno ncrepnblearbcn a~anusou ryecreurenbHocrn u cuenapues.

2) Bblnenenue pacnpenenenun eeponrnocrei u a ~ e ~ e n u n nOpeMeHHblX npOeKTa. B OTnUYUe OT aHaJU3a ryOCTenlenbHOCTn u cuenapnee, na RaHHOM 3rane usyraercn eeponrnan nanpae- nenHocrb n 3 u e ~ e n u ~ saxneRillux nepeuennbix. Pacnpenenenne e e p o ~ ~ ~ o c l e ~ MoXeT 6blTb OnpeneneHO nYTeM JKCnepnMeHTaJIb- noro cfiopa nanHbtx, npu nouoqu ~ncneproe, a ran~xs gpyrnuu BO3MOXHblMU cnocobauu.

3) Ananus pucna npu nouoqn MeTona Monre-Kapno, 4)Ouen~anpneune~oroypoen~ pucna. npu3rou.KaKnpaeuno.

peKOMeHfly(yeTCn COXpaHXTb nO3UqUlo HeuTpanbHOCi4 K p8CKy 131. E ~ ~ O , ~ H U M C ~ O C O ~ O M yrecrb npu a~anusenpoe~ra, peanusy-

eMor0 e o f iuec~eenno~ CeKrope, npucyqwe euy pucnu nennercn pacrer axunaeuoro (7, e. c yqerou BepORTNOCTU soa~nnnooenun) nOTOKa BblrOR, 003HHKaDqUX n w peann3aUUU npOeKTa, C nOCne- ~ ~ ~ ~ U I h e r O ~ H C K O H T U p O B a H U e U no h e s p ~ c ~ o s o i Cl2sKS.,&PY5"U" cnoeauu, pncnyqurbleaercn c nOMOUbK) KoppeKTUpOEKU HeCTaoKn I(UCKOHTMpOeaHUR, a CaMOrO nOTOKa BhirOA-

47

TOnKHyTbCR Ha pa4 ~ e o h x o n ~ ~ o c r b OU

Hanpuuep, aHsec uuerb qenbw CHU noarouy xaay pecypcoe. K O T O ~ U A o6opa'lwsaerca ~ e x s a r ~ a l cp

cnacennble ~ lenoswec~ue XU~HU. U ~ C T B ~ H H O M cenrope JKOHOMHKU.

flocnonbry ranue Hnsecruuuowble peluenuu nauenenbl Ha co- s ~ a p y 6 e ~ ~ o R nay~noRnureparypeo60~naramcarepMunoM. rnanue sblron Hennu o m e n b ~ o l cbwou~. a MR scero 06ulec~aa snonsetc risk>. O ~ s e ~ n b l e n e l c r s u ~ Morn8 ce6uaKnloLlaTb raK

r o ~ r + p o e a ~ r a npd o ~ e k * e ~ ~ s e c r ~ ~ u u 8 caepe npenocrasnendn emra *a*. npesuno Haqano nanaelca ero nauboree prcrrosakdol o b ~ e c r r * * n x u .acmax 6nar r a ~ n e pa~nd4e. @am* C re-enmu s2euehd pdcn cranoadrca .une nocnonany

ramn>ae*no Mnxe - e u - a c r ~ b e ram MI( npennpdalue B crnnqdc y-erou a o r o @ ~ r a c n e n ~ e r a b 6 u ~ a & u e p ~ n o c ~ n x e h r o p ~ c ~ , or o6~ecrsa. uoner obanrporn&cR Bo sropol~ eornh.e or *ac o -adme no npenornpzye#uo pucxosox crrrya4su xu31

r w x npoen.08 n k e e c r ~ ~ n n s o b ~ e c r e e ~ k o u c e ~ r o p c ~Ko-oMn*r B 3a<nu*c*ile Crou~ O I M ~ T I I I O -10 B ~ 8 ~ 3 4 co cna60J dn~er. r n P t l

~ e a n ~ ~ v ~ o r c u e rex ccbe~ax me ~adn~na lo rca neasan. DblHna B ~ a u u e l D U C K - M ~ H ~ K ~ X M ~ H T ~ 8 ~ P O U ~ C C OUeHKH n ~ c b e n r ~ ~ n o c ~ u 4

ublx 8 06qec~senHo~ CeKTOpe.&38HO H aKrueHo paccMarpusaercu C B R ~ ~ H H U X c OcyqeciBneHueu r a w HHBECTW~WOHHYX peWeH 8 sapy6ex~blx pyKOEORCTBaX no npoBeneHUlo ananuaa UwZ+W3K Harome~nb l l onblr ananuaa pucros e mpnopamsnou ceKiop H sLiro& B 06qecmennou cenrope. a raxxe a nnocrpaHHLix u ore- a~owo~wxu. a ranxe ~apy6exHblir onblrnpoaeaennn pucn-uen YeCT8eHHblX nayqwblx crarbax. M ~ H T ~ s o 6 q e c r s e ~ ~ o u cenrope nossonulor sbwenurb ocnosn

Crour oruemrb, qro wosuomlru sarpyqtienueu npu oqenne aranbl u uncrpyuenrbl p u c ~ - ~ e n e ~ x ~ e n r a nnn npHMeHeHH pucna, csaaau~oro c peanu3auHeR npoeara, nsnaerca pasnenenue POCCUU.

nneparypa

1. Aritua 8.. Smith N.J., Bower D. What risks are common to or amplified in programs: Evidence from UK public sector inbastructur schemes. 2010.

2. Baldry 0. The evaluation of risk managemenl in public sector capital projects. Internafional Journal of Project Management V No. 1. 1998. - pp. 35-41.

3. Guide to Cost-Benefit Analysisof Investment Projech. European Commission, Directorate General Regional Policy. 2008. 4. Maylor. H., Brady, T. Cooke-Davies. T. Hodgson. D. From projectification to programmification. International Journal of Pr

Management 24,2006. - pp. 663-674. 5. Maytorena.E.,Winch. G.M..Freeman,J..Kiely,TTheinRuenceofexpenenceandinformation search styleson projcct riskidentific

performance. Engineering Management, IEEE Transactions on 54.2007, pp. 315-325. 6. ShenLY.Platten A,. Deng X.P. Roleofpublic private partnerships lomanage risks in publicsector projects inHong.Kong.lnternati

Journal of Project Management 24, 2006. - pp. 587-594. 7. Civ~t contingency act. Local Arrangements for CivilProtecl~on. 2004. Pexuupocryna: http:l~wwlegislation.govuWukpga120041

section/l 8. Risk management. 2004. PexuM nomyna: http:/~ww.alarm-uk.org/pdiiALMfl7~awards~2208~0830.pdf 9. Social Analysis Sourcebook. Social development department. The World Bank. 2003. Pemr* Rocryna: http://web.worl

org/W8SITEiEXTERNAL/TOPICS/EXTSOClALDEV/O,,~ntentMOK:2l~77387-menuPK:329l442-pagePK:64l68445-p1PK:64l -theSitePK:3177395,00.hIml

4 8