nber - uw8 i3q...qqi ban cj bidduh i3ncibia ban abb (qq1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1...

44
L5I3 5IaqAq DvrIxIow 5IEIHM -DMOJ 31-IT :DMIVA UMA MOITADUU3 JOOHD HOIH IO TD3T 13 M513T 3TAUMAM MUJIJDII5IUD JAIDMAI4FI mirirriH 2E1uoU .H fl3n1D .M 1inEU bliM .M nU 8Oô 1qE nbLioW HD5IA335I 3IMOMO3 IO UA31U8 JAMOITAM unvA flur13EaM OOI 8 I O AM ,bhdmtD VQQI bjI. IBnoiriM dr or OQO4Q51fl idmun rcwx) noiIjbnu&1 ni 1&ioiiM4 rIr or huIsig 3Th 3W uom"nons ns bns .3nI .oD 2 r13nJ IIhl3M (IE1I-MH bn d31s35I 3irnOflO3TIO uw8 3di nho2noq2 io .3nI .oD cI3nJ IIin3M or bns hoqqu Ii3ian&Ifl iol noirBbrIuo1 3ravhq £IU1BM bsi8 13r3 1n&fr or AiI bluow 3W .bnd ai 'bui irIi rI3irIw no tBb 3di 1o noiia3IIoo irfiE3H rn3mmO3 IillqI3rI iol 13IIflDI fIBtDEffOt. b mit I3q ndot 13u1D3M-iiBi n!m33nO3 r1o!r1313vnO3 31dJ3UIEv ioI niD nbH bn 33r1Bi2aB c1aisi tn31133x3 iol niv3M bnB 2lorIizrn 3cIfIo eorIr iqq idr ni b331qx3 aw3iv 3dT .rnom3vom noirEaub3 13UflO3 3fIt 1o u1331u8 1&IoirBM 3dr nibu!3ni noirsinBio '(fIS b 2notri2oq 3dr r33f131 'IrIsa333n on ob 3ilduq bnB nigA ni moiq d31B331 '5138M lo ili3q 2! .I3qEq 2111T .f13If$32351 3ifflOfIO3H .23!mono33 rIofI .b3vr3231 rrfii hA .b1fM .M nU bn fl3imD .M 13inU jni3rIm3H aI3IuoU .8 d VQQI © b3bivolq noi22irrn3q r13!!qx3 ruorlriw b3roup 3d Bffl Iqiwq owr b33x3 Ot ron ix3r1o 2flo!i332 .33UJ02 3rIr or nvi 2! 33itofI © gnibul3ni tib3w Ihib rBfI

Upload: others

Post on 09-Dec-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

L5I3 5IaqAq DvrIxIow 5IEIHM

-DMOJ 31-IT :DMIVA UMA MOITADUU3 JOOHD HOIH IO TD3T 13 M513T

3TAUMAM MUJIJDII5IUD JAIDMAI4FI

mirirriH 2E1uoU .H fl3n1D .M 1inEU bliM .M nU

8Oô 1qE nbLioW

HD5IA335I 3IMOMO3 IO UA31U8 JAMOITAM unvA flur13EaM OOI

8 I O AM ,bhdmtD VQQI bjI.

IBnoiriM dr or OQO4Q51fl idmun rcwx) noiIjbnu&1 ni 1&ioiiM4 rIr or huIsig 3Th 3W

uom"nons ns bns .3nI .oD 2 r13nJ IIhl3M (IE1I-MH bn d31s35I 3irnOflO3TIO uw8 3di nho2noq2 io .3nI .oD cI3nJ IIin3M or bns hoqqu Ii3ian&Ifl iol noirBbrIuo1 3ravhq

£IU1BM bsi8 13r3 1n&fr or AiI bluow 3W .bnd ai 'bui irIi rI3irIw no tBb 3di 1o noiia3IIoo irfiE3H rn3mmO3 IillqI3rI iol 13IIflDI fIBtDEffOt. b mit I3q ndot 13u1D3M-iiBi

n!m33nO3 r1o!r1313vnO3 31dJ3UIEv ioI niD nbH bn 33r1Bi2aB c1aisi tn31133x3 iol niv3M bnB 2lorIizrn 3cIfIo eorIr iqq idr ni b331qx3 aw3iv 3dT .rnom3vom noirEaub3 13UflO3 3fIt

1o u1331u8 1&IoirBM 3dr nibu!3ni noirsinBio '(fIS b 2notri2oq 3dr r33f131 'IrIsa333n on ob 3ilduq bnB nigA ni moiq d31B331 '5138M lo ili3q 2! .I3qEq 2111T .f13If$32351 3ifflOfIO3H

.23!mono33

rIofI .b3vr3231 rrfii hA .b1fM .M nU bn fl3imD .M 13inU jni3rIm3H aI3IuoU .8 d VQQI © b3bivolq noi22irrn3q r13!!qx3 ruorlriw b3roup 3d Bffl Iqiwq owr b33x3 Ot ron ix3r1o 2flo!i332

.33UJ02 3rIr or nvi 2! 33itofI © gnibul3ni tib3w Ihib rBfI

Page 2: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

2ta31T3 rrn3T-noJ 3cff :niv bn8 floitB3Ub3 23bnfiM muIu3rrluD I6i3fIEfIiT 100(132 diH 1o nD .M I3mBU mi3r1rn3H s1uoU .8

blBM .M n,U bn8 8O .o14 13qs gnbhoW 5138M

VQQI 1u1 fEll I3 1G .2oM J31.

231ffl0fl033 3ilduq bn niA TDA$1T*IA

e231311oq noiE3ub3 irnuno bfqobf3 3v&1 lo 'thoLsm h Jio1 a1 3rh 13v0

no flOi13Ln2ni 3vi3a31 n3b1Jia IoorIo2 (1ir1 tsd bbnEm 11E3fli33q2 3vEfL thonim 31dsi2 £ bn6

bnB gnivf in3m3gn8m ib313 nitbud) niAsm-noi2i33b Isi3n&1fi b!o(1uod o b3i8151 23iqo

rnoiI gnithi i3kr3knuo r1i iibdw 3thrrni3b o iqm3iiB w iqiq thu nI .(i1ho1 o bns tn3mivni

3U(1U £ fIi2U .gnive nib1f31 2noiai33b tlub6 no 3,fi3 3IdEmo32ib 'ff6 b&L 3vsrl 23iBbn8m 323rL

o 3mii ivo bni 22O13 ifod n3m31iup31 ni (10i6flEV f1 iio1qx w viu blorb2uod

thod beisi 11ifl63 ini2 3vsd bnsm rsdi 23f831brn 33n3biv3 31T .roini b 2r33f13 3(11 'uitn3bi

b3d31 n3but boqx3 33(10 fl0iE1UfflhJ336 t3as tn3updu2 bn8 £IIJ3rrIU3 Isi3nJ3nil ot 3W2OX3

noi33fI31 Iddoiq s -- ib3mmi nsrli iñiin 1ubs ncJ 3v&1 o mqq 33f1T .boodi1ub

noiEtn3m31qmi bo

ff31180 .M I3inf3U mi3lfrn3H ei(1guoU .8 (131832351 3not2l3nloD 231m0no33 lo ffI3mhsq3U

1f35I on!mBD 130001 ii213vinU bioniJ2 ?S0IQ AD Am oIn3M OEIQ AD bio1ni2

SIJHMbns ub3.b1obnt2.bn8131@mi3t1m3d

b1M .MS3U 1 qo2 hEM

bmofi 3W132351 1E13b31

WM e2r331t2 D bni r1t0 I DU nonidaiW

Page 3: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

noh3uboltnl .1

"imuno lo rnioI mno niithnEm noiisIais1 bsqob Q 8Q1 bns VQ1 nwiH

3iqoi 1o aivo3 b3Iiup5I Ils3fti38q iuam ad1 N nI .IOod3 1abnO3 ni noLa3ub3

ni3naIacJ bna JnmsJiam iib niibud molt ,nbLam-noiaib Iai3nanht b1otfeuoñ 01 inavIei

muIu3Fnu3 edt lo 8vi3jdo edT '.eIqi3nhq tnefniaevni ierho bns 1eieini biwoqmo3 01 aLood,±

ilubs iierit ni Mew evoiq bluow Iad 11bie nbam-noiai3eb 1aoii3aq diw aIn3bu1 quipe ol aaw aeiabnarn

3Vi!

ni v r3efle ed ol e1sbnsm muhJ3hliJz Isi3nanft\iemuanoo 1ooib dgId 1eqxe eno b1uod

i eiedt biisci eno edt nO .mairnieq baa mthniiqo ifiod o1 anoasei eia 5ledT Vevitejdo aidt nxvetd3a

01 5wIiaI £ molt 5leb emoz 01 tae1 Ia t1uaei 1lneupei1 anoiai3eb Isbnanft ooq taut enebive &no

d meldoiq aidt eisivells bluo3 noila3ub3 .(QI 4QQ1 mie&ne8) eijiIidaen1uv 3iflOfl03 etai3elqqa

vam noii&ube Isiansaft 1,a3 .allbi g m-noithsb 3ftbeq o\bns ebe1wo1D( rnenirieq niiudiiinoz

iadt xemsd 1aio1od3q nivomei deierfi zeflarn Iai3nanII dtiw 1hailirnth bns flolmo3 eEa5T3ni oaLs

ol iaeqqs aie1i1 1uqmo3 10 nornwp3a Fiae edt o1ana lo aw fl .gnbLsrn-noii3eb ieqoiq ebeqmi

bnad iedto edt nO .1etuqmo3 dtiw rlolrno3 lo level I iene 'Isubivibni as no taefte miet-gnol a evsii

bacnfl £.atxetnoo iedto ni I3eieb 01 Ilu3ffttb need evad eviiaiiini lanoiisaube betg,at lo ztfte nin-noI

lsi3nanft 1B311fl3 lo 1f1eff1i6II fnooI22Sb Ine1flO3 muhJ3imJ3 no eeneuflni lsei elitif evad am aetabnsm

eedt 10 116 ewo 10 .1auoiiea laiietam edi eAai ot 11th sm alnebui2 o\bns 10€iU3 ed 'tam 3iqol

mietinol edt tuoda nwod zi niiiton 1fauriiV .ev1laI1J3eq ea eviiaeii baa evi3ioq ihod &iok1s1ebiano3

3i3fl0 iom A .8abnam aIflo noiiqiiab beliabb a ioI (OQQL) flo2 bna (Q8t) dlimedgiH (QVQ1) i,bnaxslA ,e2' .qaq aidflo noibe ni b3tneq i iammu

na d o bGIwom bna IIbIa di ,vasI bluoda ni3i3 d3a3" :e3at eigtoO1o ,laIE dt ni noitaIaiI 1qmax &I .(si i,bnax,IA) nnam Iai3fln,d bna n,ifft na ni eoiuoa,i IdaLiava eu 03 isbio ni muenoo b,rmdIni

.(QQI) amodT bna muD ni noiwiib di . e ;Iqmax boog a i maio1q flai2 baSH 5ñT

Page 4: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

.aIoo±a ,sbno3a ni nobsoub5 IsiDnSflft lo 1I Isioivsñd

Isinsnft !ootka ziiñ moi1 niaris £hJ3rnu3 3d1 irt3riw 3ninrI33b 01 iqmns w iqsq aiih nI

aiifr 1azjoivctO .nbLsm-noiai33b 1si3nsnt ilubs no !dsn3aib ns bsd 5vsr! a1sbnszu noiis3ub5

bns 1ib3i 1o in3msnsm ishqoqqs 3di nivsa lo supbs 9111 gnibuloni anoiansmth nsrn asuf suaai

9111 no 1no isd au3cft sw ,anoiansmib zii1 lo us ni bsiasisini sis sw sluiW .noiis3oIIs oiloIhoq tn3birlq

Jon Inistis r1uof1J) bssqzsbiw S11J d risq ni bslsviiom ai waol aiiff .(Bnivsa 10 (3wpsbs s11i) taift

ills$1 .(sQQI 1!QQI 4misdnis8 ..s ssa) 1flh1 ool asvsa nsthsmA Isiq1 sdi IsdI irisno (Isaisvinu

rtic1 £ 01 5W2OX3 is(1Isdw Las 1qmia sw nivsa lo supsbs sili swassm 01 Isbom Ismiol £ qofsvsb nsd

.llubs ns as nivsa isñiñ 01 abssl mijhjainu3 Isi3nsni1 Iood3a

QQ1 1o 11s1 di iii bsbblI sriua blodsauod Isnoi3sa-aaola supinu s no bsasd ai aia1sns iuO

as 1!sw as 1oosba diñ bsbnslts insbnoqasi 5111 113111w ni sIsia 3(11 bstbiloe anicLt istho noms d3iI1w

mu!u31mJ3 b a13&fts sill 13313b ol niiqmsfls ii! .noiisaub IsbnsnlI 01 siuaoqxs nisrisonoo anoii3sllo3sl

aistho sift lsrft bns arnsioiq sasth bsqobs ISVSR aslsle smoe sdi Js1 sdl d bsbis ss sw esisbasm

-- srrni isvo bns assta aaois tfiod enothsqmo3 no bsasd ci aia1sns wO .asmii 1nsisThb is msilJ bslqobs

ssbnsm s lo Insmilcildsias isfhsdw sisi1asvni sw MsrnrI3nscJ £ as asista niiqobs-non 9th niau

.ariodo3 bsifts 5(11 noms tisrnrbnsd aiili moft 5whsqsb £ iliiw bsbi3nio3

15111 noiis3ibni on ci sisdT .noiis3ubs 1si3nsn1 ol swcoqxs nibu1e c1 noi1sircsvni iuo nisd sW

.2321u03 bsiasFio (llsi3nsnft s(si io sthpsi is11o oi nobsnibni niiaixs-siq 1131w bsisIsllo3 sm asJbnsrn

nssd svsrf 01 sisbnsm srh 01 onq IsAi1 som on sisw slsbn&n £ b5335113 38111 S3slC Is3iqi sill ni ainsbui

.s1sbnm £ bstsns isvsn Jsrb sista 1s3iqi ssl3 ni alnsbuta 513W (18(11 nOitZ3ubS liiansnit 01 bsaoqxs

3€8513fl1 bns bsuboiini sis aslsbnsm isiIs issqqs ob aslsi siucoqxs bsrioq5l ni a&nsisThb isvswoH

-horI ,dj rio beu3oI vad ,di ,noiiaoub9 3imonoo\1muLnoo b srii bioIqx vd eibu1E woiv3lq tns1x h oT bn iqo 2Q1) non3I ., .ioivdod nadi sdIai L,butifla 10 L8bIwonflo ewaam b,nimax, 1Iauw 3vad bna jrni

odw (Q8Q1) dan1 bria ,diudaoV iaaI ei noiiqox nO .(QV1) t1tnaJ bn* ,(QVQL) qqi( bna nsdo)1 (1821) adnnifl .rfoie 1ULflO3 no noi3s3ub munoobo p.b,11, 31(1 b3tana

Page 5: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

3

(JYq uq cpo (jq)OLLCCIJ4 OUP!2 I!4LtUT1 BCWPC!W (JQPY HPP"1 vuq CUJUCL (jQ) bO4CLP ACUV Jq M!

CUCL9J JCACj o GI1CV11OUVj ggnJuscug vuq 12 OL fJCL LVC O 29iw (qocnwcugcq pA RCWPCIW Vuq 2CPO!'

) J OL CCIULVI cOfflJCIJ OL 2"'!" bL0W0POU I ô8 I ) r CIA 2€' COU.CJV4IOU2 pcg/Accu VU wqLMqflVj,2

bLowogTou cswbi? gpcz.c tc 04CL cowbcgiu czbJVullgIou2 OL gpc awc bcuowcuoU (2cc uijJcni?

29AflJ pA bucac pon2cJJoq2 wVA pvc pccu g jcg bm.gwIJA vggupngpjc go VU cxgcu2iAc cqrtcpou uq

ccqog 9U\OL RJcOUCJfI21AC E01 cZVwbIC' Vjgponp 1CLC 12 20WC 1U1CVf1OU IpVi 41€ b024-MVL WCLCU2C in

UJOLC C102C1A LCJ94C grgcLVgnLc 4194 iUAC2t24C2 111€ LCWOU pcgMccU 2VAW VUq cqric9giou jncp O 11112 12

J14LVUHG 011 4 !UCU41AC2' !#4J1CP LGVCC2 20UJ€MV4 VWP!f1Ofl2 COUCIfl2!oU2 JJJCLC 12 9120 V 2W9JJCL' piii

bcucug 24LVU 12 couccuicq M!4P 41€ GA9Jfl9OU o bOflC€2 40 !UCLGV2C 2VA!U?A JJJGLC 2 VU Grj€U2!A€

cqncgou on VqII 1JUVUC!V1 qcc2ou2' ig 12 CcLWIuJX LCJVgcq go 2GACLVJ 24L9U2 o gpc JI4GLVUIL€ OUC

yjgponp J12 12' 40 0111. JaioNqcqc' gpc UL2L 2wqA go €XVUJIUG 41€ €4JGC42 o 2ccouqVLA ecpooj

Vf1J4 J)CIJVA!OL pA 211UJn1V4IIJ .LGV4€L 2VAIU

IUqICVPOIJ2 494 UJVU94€2 DOf OUX IUCLGV2Gq CXbO2IlLG go IJUVUC!Sl cqncsqou' (1i 2120 2A24GWSPCVJ1A VJL€LG

ILLc2bGCi!/ O 4194 !22flC' 2bGC1JC9qOU2 4194 cougoi OL 2A24cUJ!qC 1IGLGUCC2 9CL022 249LG2 bLoAgc 2POU

uog 2A2WUm4ICVJJA LGJ24€ go bLc-cxi2g1u bLccLcucc2 -- J94 1412 bLopspJA PC24 L€VLG 22 CXOGUOfl2

jmic pccu cxbo2cq) juq cou2qci.pjc 2nbboLg in ipc q9W OACLVJJ' 41€ GAqCUCG 2f1C2R 4)394 VqobPOIJ M22

PCUCJJUJVLJC 2W0U 4102€ 400 oq go JJVA€ pCGU cxbo2cq' 21U1UC9U4 1)CLCUC€ 0L 4102€ Aonu cuonp go

)OL 41€ VCCflUJflJV0U 0) U€4 MGVJ4)J pOMCACV 41€ p92!c bLcqcgou2 (no 2A24GUJVPC 11GLGUCG )LOW 411€

2I1JUJC9U4 9J€L Vqobqou' 111 411€ (flLGc41OIF 20W€M)194 qigccug bSU€LU 12 bLcqcgcq

(€!ipcL In 1CAC12 OL 9€-4LGUq2) 2CL022 2W4G2 41€ Vqobqou O4 V wVUqVgc' P114 4JGL€ 12 V 24€VqA Vuq

DW OU 2c-LcbOLj€q L9j€2 0 29A1U UJILLOL 41112 bVUcuj cxpcwcA cJo2cJ): 4IGLC VL€ Do T)JCLGUC€2

J92 V220C1V4€q MJJ cnucrqnw qcAcjobwcug' Vqobqou' VUq cowbj)Vucc

2gc9q)A !IJ4)1 411€ bV22Vgc O 4)WG jJ112 211€2g2 41394 411€ O) S WVUqVIG )2 LsqnVg' bci.pVbe LcuccpU

Page 6: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

aisi an d3ua a1oj3n1 b3inbi l3dio ol 3ldniudniin 3d sm (QQ1 abb ban i3ncIbIa bidduH cJ ban QQI

Isloivnd9d 8d1 no t1nzftb3qa bau3o1 and 31uin1ii1 aidi lo tbntnd niairnoiq 3Iom A .33fl33131q 3m1 lo

ban mi3drn 1sn8 QQ! fl5rInD ban mi3dn18) nIqIiow 3rfi ni noilS3ub3 ifI3m31il5 10 a3fl3

moa o i3jdu2 .(QQ1 b1aodo1nY ban QQ1 13cf3iIf32 ban AmID ôQQ1 mi3drn38 ôQQ1 Ioth 33n5biv3 lo bod gniworg 3dT .nivna no ai3fls 1ns3fiinia b3ftiln3bi 3vnd a3ibula 3a3fiJ anoiin3ftilsup

modsJ lo ln3mflnq3U di b31 bnm and nbLnm-noiab3b Ini3nnaft no noin3ub8 lo ai33113 3(11 nn133no3

di 01 al3thOW nn3rI5mA lo nodn3iln 3113 8IIIWMb in b3ffIIn mamoiq noi33ub3 nOiaII3q Innoilna & d3nunl 03

( .q, 2Q! gz88) lhua ia3m311131 mi3di mol lilidianoq231 lnnoal3q nbIni lo nnnoqrni

aiilr lo d3uM .noijs3ub8 ol afnui3m 3(13 no muinmti1 In13n3 mom 3(11 03 oath b31n131 ai qnq dT

ni uaai Inmin A .gnulOo(13a mo ninini 3r1ji3 ban anw nvlt3d noiJsI3m 3113 no bau3o1 and wtnm1i1

nih3bnu moa ot b1nI81 ,s a3ldthnv a8r11 lo diod inrli booifiILiI 8(11 2fl183fl03 5winm3HI aiiIi

.(QI bmnD mo 8Q1 8bno1&J 18VQ1 mi11n3daA .g. sea) 1i1ids as d3ua 3flarI3j3smnd3 8!dnvm3edOnIJ

moil b3vn,b 9mn 8d1 aa8Inu nibs3Iaim 11niineioq 8In noiinQub8 lo a138u18 3dI iuodn a83n5131n1 InaunD

3(11 fl aims a3lIaai In3iin8bi 11nmu1nM .auonox 1diaunIq mn mdi noiin3ub8 ni noilniinv lo aiwoa

iahnA lo mill om thiqa ni mslirnie ai d3somqqn muo a133qe81 ninfl33 a! .nobniJa8vni inmw3 8111 lo 1x31no3

3151a ni noinimnv moil noits3ub5 mnbnoa lo a1)8113 3(11 m8lai 01 lqmfln odw ,

(Q1 ,

I QI) mui)( ban

a3nbnnm mulu3inu3 !si3nsnft s3nia Idn1o .2u0n3Ox8 an inm1 vdi ,awsl gniloosbe moinbnsm

noilqmi.iaas mnlunia a Lm oi au 3miup8m Ion a8ob noi1sila3vni muo , smii mvo baa a3lnla anomn illod mnv

ittiw a33nbm1o a3labnsm lo noiiiaoqmi 3(11 mri1dw Ini3a8vni w ba3anI .Ii8n8ox8 flfl133fl03

3Iqmnx3 mol ;atxelno3 m3dlo lo vl3hnv n ni b3au need and 3si3a InfI8 aunT .moivnd8d ni a8nnd3

dm nibuia d &nnmmohq lsaoiln3ub3 no noiinxinoinu 'am3lbs3l lo 3T13 3(11 a3ltiln3bi (QQI) dxoH

.awsl 3383a in3n 318q ni noiisimnv

Ini3nnniI 8153a lo ln3ino3 ban motaid 3111 aimsmmua noii .awollol as b3th1nio ai qnq 3dT

I noii .aiaInnn muo ni b3au sinb vwa blod8wod dm a8dn3asb noi333 .a3lnbnnm noiis3ub5

Page 7: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

cc 4VI1OU 1U211U74C OL COU2nWCL EqI!cW (j)ot u cxvwb,c o CSCp!IJ niqc LOL bctaou JUUJCC lfl1!0U

COUflWCL cqncvpow

ccBtIJU!a4C vuq oinwv (jg)oL w cowb1cc czucpououpc Auoncouccb tc iucjnqcq iii ipc jcq o

JJflLa. CACIJ 2IUIte JJVAC bopCic2 IJrnI cuconL8c 01. LcdmLc W2ILflCUOU W COU2IIUJCL cqncwou 01. 1JAC

013 COU211IJJCL btoiccpou uq 111 WOU2 VJO1J Mup LGLC2 WCJJUI2UJ2 iøqpjc L0 COU2flIJJCL

qTAcL2rCpOu113 booro cp01cc• hw1!? 1}JC LC9 0 COU2fIWCL UJJ12 uq LCb01J1pII11!C 0CL2W2fLIICIIOU

jwuc1J rup.nwcu qic Lc1vpou2pIb CWtGGu ujc uq Lcwu? uq rpc LOjC 0 uTJ11ou 1XC2 uq

IT2C 0 cLcq1 JJ3C 2SAW 913q WAC2IIIJg bOLIIOU 0 2flCJJ CO11I2C W OCL q 2CI11OU OU A9LJO112 rThC2 o.

rpuq vicu bcI2ouJ tumicc wø? COACL poncpojq pnqcpu wouc? wucwci2 iuuq wAciw' 9uq

iu 1113 ccouowic Aicw qic buucib1ce o2nbb1? 11uq qcwuq 1113q qic L0C obucca ju W114C 2CW JJJC

iiqi couccbr flCJJ 92 JC VII0CP0U o 9LCG LC2Of1LCC2 fIlC L0JC2 O CO1J2flWCI2 bLOqI1CCL2 9uq O1GUJWCUf

9ACL1U WC229C2 11uq bLOqflCf 19PC12 ECOU0W!C2 qic ccouq 111.C9 O COU2IIWCL cqnC9POua IThIC9HA qc912

M9Iigu11c2 uq ObCL9IIOU 111Jq LCb11ft C022 COU2IIIJJCL qGci2rou-w9qIJ 11J20 W9A COACL qic 111J9A212 o

qrn onjq pc cou2iqcLcq lu cpooru 11UJ0U A9uo112 ooq uq 2C1JICC2 ncp n bucc bLoqnc LCØWLC2'

112 L111U1IJ lu JC qccI2Iou-w9Jau 2JUJJ2 n2cq 10 wccr qic 011J2 1111q uccqv JJ112 ØLC9 OCU OCIT2C2 OU C10L

C0IIWICL qcC121ou-UJVJC11J wcjnqce W2I1flC1OU lu 922C2U 1C C0U211WCL2 09J2 11uq UGq2 92 1!GJ

COIJ211WCL UJJ12 9uq Lc2bou2rpIIipc2

LCCL 10 jOflL anp-cJq2 0C0U2flWCL cqnc9liou: COUWWCL q20U-1B9Iq11 COU0W1C2 bcLzOuuJ ii" q

cqncpou wvuqce COU211UJCL cqncupou COACi. v ,iqc L9UC o lob!c2Q vjcx9uqcL (j oo)uq coii (j oo)

Jpc nrnucij cqncspou wuqc vuq?scq ru qna b11bcL c 211P2C1 oupc 111LCL C1 0C0U2flU3CL

IJC EiUUCflJI CflLL!CHIflW uquG

WU11G2 0U L9j2 0 29A11J !uq M9I1IJ 9CCflUJflJ900U cqou Q couqnqc2

cIcct o u1913q91c2 OU CCb02f1LG 10 UlmliC!91 CfC9f0W 2CP01J 2wqc2 qic CUC12 O;

Page 8: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

oo Aonu2 o pc wcnqcq !U jpc vu1bIcvo wvA pc cpuRcq vucc J(y psij ancp CVUC2 onq uoj gpc LCflhi2 !U 4P!2 bgbcL pccvnac ccjcq poncpojq onq pciponi 4PC C0UC4qvnqcpou OLM!c0U2IU pn4 OnL tC2flfll VLC U04 bVL4ICnVqA 2CLJI4IAC 40 4C L0CIV22ZUCV4OU 04 5)JI 4VIC bOIIC!C2

c!4jq a4v4c boicc cou.ccqA qnuu2 4,c pwc bcuoq pv ia 04LCtC4 LCM1JCC 40 W! snq LLP ! 0Wctcwwww2 wp2ntjA1104 C ICCOUCIJCq '9qcxvuqcL (j)nncq pc qcjiJipc 20171CC 011 flJC 8Lonuqa flJWf WOLC LCCCU4 2OflLCC2 1.C icciA jo pc40 bo1icA CpWU2C* WIJCL jg jicis b0ftJpIc 4V4C cpooj vqww!wz40L3 MCLC dncpoucq tpotti qbWIJ flqi2cLcbucic2 conqpCj1k'GCU TJCXIUqCL (j)vuq ii iv°q bIIc P 4° q4jU !u W4CthLCW4!oua oLanuc)t dncapou2 OL

(jg) uq 4JIC 14WP0Ut1 COIPOU 4OL COU*nWCL EqfICVPOU (jØ) jpctc ttc owc qtcl.cbucJc2 pcjjccu aonwc bLlcnJq?woc nqpUutpOu ou bopcic* oi. ccp v4C acc qjcxwuqc 0Wr C°"'i 011 ECOUOWTC EqnctrJOu

pCp9AiOL 12 1L WVU9C2W PC i214C2 MJJO2C Lc21qcu42 jrnq V pTJJ bLccLcucc pL 2VIIJ MCLC

MG9JJ ccnwnJVpou IiL UI pic y bocupq bLopjcw !J1p V22C22tU qic ccc4 ojwVuqVrc2 Ou IUJJ

JJ112 bbci. vcwb o wcnnc 4C o urnuqtcq COU2UWCL cqncvpou bopcic2 ou 2VIU uq

bL2OIrnj UJI91I'

COUWWCL GqUCWOU UI 44C UI J 2UC 1qCU4 2bCC!jC1jA c LCdmLcq 40 LCCCIAC wn.ncizou iii

iii uq wot opc bojicic ThCLG iwbjcwcurcq m roo 21JqCUf c LcdmLcq 4o LGCCIAC

C0U11UJCL cqflCUrioI? oi. 2bcciUcV!!A UI bcou uøuc cqnc1ioir Jyc CUL C24 bojic? is wsiwrcq p?

cqcq p? rpc bopc? uq MpCqICL qic bojic wuqic qrn bnpjic 2COOJ wiqcu LcCCIAC n12p.flCUOU W

JuG W)JG wq1Cu4c2 /ApCqiCL V 24V4G p Vqobrcq COU2fIWGL cqncpou bojic) qic jL2C qnpu cj o PC

pcpVJuoL JVpjC J 2flIJJIJJVUC2 COUVIWGL cqncVriou bopcic 'U rpc 21V1C2 uq qJC D121LICI O COIf1IJJP

COUflUICL cqncpou 9CVI12C rpC) VLC iThCL2V 1}JC2C 4ThG2 0j UJ9U94C2 2GCW 4pC W024 jqccjA ro GC4

JJJC VUVj?212 III qJI2 bVbcL MIJJ 0Cfl2 011 4}JC WVUV4C 4JJV4 LGdmLG VII 240qC1142 40 LCCC!AC 1U2p.flC4IOU iu

cqflCVpOU nJf:0 CX124I1J COflL2C2

C0UL2C 2OWC 04qIC2C 24V4C2 LCdflfl.C V 2CbVLV4G CO4U2C' MJITJC OflJCL2 VUOM 2CJJ00J2 40 W4CLS4C COU2IIUJGL

VI20 V UflUJCL 0 21S4C2 2bcCqCVflA UJVIJS4G 4J3V4 GVC 2WC1I4 LGCGIAC IUP.flCPOU 114 V CO1JI1UJCL C(tCVPOU

uiboaru Lcdnucwcu2 94 qic iocj cic p? Lcdnmu CVCJJ 121UC4 40 OCL 2OWC 0LUJ 04 COU2flUJCL Cq(ICV4IOU

2494C cqncpou 9CUC1G2 40 qCACJOb uq T21LIfl4C Urn4CLIVJ2 014 COU2UWCL CqflC94101140 t°VI 2PJC42 40

2494C2 JISIC W9UV4C2 C0ACUU COUWUICL cqrlCVpOzf VIIVOflIJ V1C UJ91Iq4C2 JVLA 'U 2CObC 4OW LGdfl1LiU

jvq 21ICJI bOJfCIC2 w pc bør owc boJIcic2 WGLCIA CUC0flL9G COUflWCL cqnCVtiOU 4° PC W"P1 OIIJCL

Page 9: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

.2noaai Ia13v iol 1AiIiw amoa ii3n3obn3 lo qJ zufT .33abnam b33ar13 3zd3 iai maa ccIi

bna I di lo in3moom imuano3 ibaoid d3 lo diwoiiuo na 3d 03 m 23labnam noila3ub3 l3mu2noD

no !niam b32u3o1 awcf noiia1ib3 l3muano3 w1 .13b8M dqIa5I diiw b3iai3o2aa '132oI3 i2om ei larli 20I .ovoda b3noiin3m 2sa d31o iuol ha in b3i11b 313w awal zft v,1nommo3 ioM .nanft Ianoal3q

di bns aquoi aniddo1 d 83aiia 1aiiai bzwoalo onaiioqmi 3113 iol auia (QSQI) 13'aM vo31oM

iom noiniqo 3ilduq nadi 1311381 awa1 13fflU2fl03 10 aaaaq rIi iol aA aa 1oia1ai31 '1 1o 233n313131q

.b3ntI3b Ibaoid

(131w b3ini3oaaa 'dIaiJw al ii no1ia1aiI l3muano3lo 383013368303 inafloquü ai noiniqo 311(111(40311W

aqiio niddo1 lo nanoqmi 3dT °'.aw 3(80201 21301112803 bamab iatli 383v3 lalu3inaq a 13V0 3gnhiuo

iioa) aioiaiieithinbs lood3a 33832 I3ilb lo 'rwa a ni iuo 3nlod aaw oa!a noiniqo 3ilduq baoid 03 b3aoqqo as

lo in3313q 1 4 "a,iiaiiini 801363111)3 l3muano3 aauaaib 03 '(bAil ieom a' quoi ((3111W" bAan niPN .(OQQI

113113 boa aioisiiainimba Ioorba a1ba3i an (13112 218801 2231o1q noiia3ub3 b3ia3thni aioiatainirnba lood 32 3(13

23831)113210 21n3Iaq 36(13 bia31bf11 383313q 01 '(too boa ;'(iinummo3 aathaud 3111 b03831b111 383313(4 QE ;almsie

rli iadi 3v3ibd 01 802651313311 21 313(11' .23Vii8iiifli flOiifi3Ub3 13(8112803 221132(1) 03 '(13)111 iaom 3(13 313W

lo 3viiain3a3lqsI '1la13n sin a13b831 ee3niwd 10 aInnoiae3lolq 801363111)3 3vi338 '(llnaiiiloq lo a33n3l3Istq

a33aia miii abml odw (VQI) bl&1 '(db3bivolq 21 33n3b1v3 l3sthu1 .33632 fl3VI a m 233n313131q blocbauocl

nl a33aia idio moi insi3Ttib '(1Jna3I1mia '(IIa3iiaiiaia ion iw noiinIa13l noiia3ub3 imuanoa b3aasq mdi

'(1Ailnuama 31 wdT .looiba d&d moft b3iaiibal3 odw aJn3biasIIo nothoqolq 3(1310 a31sa Iiaisi 3mo3n

3iabnam-sIq ,sii 1131w b3ialsrIo3 asw 3a1a 16k131338q a 01 iIoq noiia3ubo i.muano3 a 1o aaaaq lath

101 alolino3 iqnq aIthi ni aie'(Isna la3niqm3 t1i aa3bdi13v3M .ablotbauod e'33aie di lo loivad3d Iai3flaflhI

diIo yio1üd a io (Q8QI) iaM bna ,EU dl ni noiiaub, i,muno1o io3zizI a ioL (bQQI) iJainna8 332 .1nmvom mu*no ibamd

noiia3ub imuenoo eli lo insmian 03 e ladl b03aoibni cionilil ni thqx no Ia3ub imueno tftiw enoitaet,vnoD°'

.eio1aIei,I ,flo I Ibie Ia3ililoq ,ttl aa II,w ea eea buai boi3iIduq 'dflaid siw noiiaiei1

,tl,i2naJ e emaioiq bna eiiiIoq noiia3ub imueno31o 3nmqoI,vb bna aeuq d1 no bnuoibad Ianoiiibba i&I .(8Q1) naffm,Hio (VVQ1) noeeM bna

Page 10: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

8

2tTL1C) OJIJCOUJC vuq LO8LUJ i.pctbvi1ou uuq lvc mJc 1nqA ojucowc juuwic jpnto vqqc rpc

tpc wqw tpr wmJqvic uijcct pCpAiOL 2WflJ bLopJcw2 VU2C OL OtCL qut 2flLCC ncp tpc

acpooj aitc onjq Aicjq booLcL wcwn.c o cxbonLc O wuqtc uq onjq qicLcp? pm OfIL

i!JIppcjq pow qic bnppc to cunLc couijqcuppr) EnLrpcLwoLC pc ncocmicur attc mu bjgcc opip

ucuqcq pzp cpoo jjiqc ac ocnaczu Lc2rqcucc z ccoqcq w ipc 2rn.Ac?mu bLvcticc ipa zuiouzwrrou ia

poflt CxbOanLc o mumiciøj cqncpoz? vuq rpc adnic qiq uoc aojicmi tpc attc mu!Aplcp tpc Lcabouqcug

CL '' s1!JvP!C piff gpc qSIV pq UO ?ct pccu LCCsacq 2CE. LcabouqcuIa 'ci.c uot cq quccrjA

9L cxwbjc c nuc? oouanwcz. jwucca (2cE) pcu qna bLolcet iz couqrmctcq' q ow w

flu1LoI.ttnrntcJ? tpcLc ia cnu.cuq? uo bnppcj? vijpjc qøs act tpr atraijca j3cac cutcuw

we nrmvj uA occouowic suq qcwobpic q (c cunua suq ao

iao qcau.pjc jjntq we anuc wnat cojjcct ruoLwwou ou jjirnuc!j cpoLcca (aimu uq McIp)

bLoxA DH.CCf wcwaca ocxboanLc o wucij cqnctiou (pcq ou bbLobuutc)A toLqcq dncapoua) c

jnp acpoor i woprirt? CLOaa atstca 12 anTJjc1cufl? ioi tpcu cnu.cut o caiqcucc unapt pe v LC2OIJJC

922e22 cxbovac to UUVIJC1V cqncwoi? pc aflLICk apocrjq aOrcit we arste mu ipicp cVcp wquiqnVj rtcuqcq

cxboacq to jjuVuciVJ cqncpou mu pe c o j onjq uor pic Lcvcpcq c nutij j ccouq to

rnqctcq mu tpc j WVUA attca cpq uot vqobt wuq9tca nurq tpc wiq-ja yu wq1AiqnV /tpo !n

LcjVpACA rjc avui (Vuq LcjvnAcJ? J!ti! qmctcucc o avmu VCL022 &onba) buoL to we wrq-3o2 va

atcebeat bom.poua orpca cVunue iIccjouca qnuu tpcmi. )2 Vuq CVLIA 3()2 OUG cucLvI!? opacuca

2IILACA qVtV 2C1 MItJJ 2CACLV C}JVLVCtCLI2PC2 }JL2t 1]JC qVIV WI121 PC LCCCIJI II1CC WO2 MO4CCL2 VLC OU we

10 CXVUMUC C CIJGCI2 0jjJTI 2CJ100J UUVUCIVI Cm.UCnJIIUJ W9UqVIC2 OUC LCdI1ILC2 U 0f1CJJ0J

T fILAG? D4"

CIJeCIC MJJCflJL tJ12 WlThtIOU 12 OUJC Oflt 2tUt!2tCVJJ?

qacLCUcc2 mu bc-wuqvgc 2UA1J PCSAIOL PCIMCCU 2tVIC2 !AJJCLC V WVUUtC !A92 flJJbOaCq Vuq OfJJCL 2t9102 tO

Page 11: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

.sisb wn i11o3 oJ vjisaan asw ii , I noii3 in b3iuiin3bi 23u221 1o auxn

oi .3nI d3wJ fLm3M d bioanoqa bo1q riiono its biith asd iqsq 2irliIo iodius iaiiI 311T

di ioI .(sÔQQ I jnickri8 oa) rum blorl3auod 1sunn dguoidi nivsa Isnoal3q lo '9sup3bs mcIi loimom

Isi3nsmI 100(132 djiI nibu13m 23kqOi wn 1s1Dva iovo3 oi bbnsqx3 asw inmiriiani 3V1U2 3ñi Q1 lo IlsI

3viisine31q51 11I3noiisn n moiI QQI (1dmvoI'flo rfinom di tirwb bbllo3 iw ssU noiis3ub

3n3rw3 3di iol isriqo1qqs ai w3oI 3i1i3oq2-3s eiñT .Q4 bits OE lo as di now3Dd 2inthnoqa1 lo 31qm52

'nsm in aisbnsm mu1u3rnu3 lSi3nsnhl oi noijiansli ñi bnnqx mdi equoi s di is 323(12 nia buia

3tr1qsiom3b bits unono bisbnsia b313Lf1s 'rwe 3dT ttb3l3Iqmo3 w aviua OOO1o IioX A .233832

bIod3wod Isiol auoqa bnn mn3bnoqa3llo agnims3 ''23iiilidsil bits thaas blod3auod ntbu13rn noilsmio1th

quoi 31nrb3 gs aiflsia Isiham ibn au3sia mn3mo1qm3 's13vO3 noian3qlo a1qas wonsv mo3n

noiisrrriolni as 113w as nwse lo 23181 b3floq3l-1132 b31i311o2 oals ii .noinaoqmo3 blod32uod bits fl01253Ub3

lfii3nsnfl 31u3111 ol 33n8v3b1 Inimn33oq lo 233n3uflrn boodbIid as 113u2 a3iqol bisbnsia aa1 lo J3i1svs no

mdi 22813 100(132 did amn3bnoqe31 di lo nOil35fi 3(13 bits nivsa biswol 23b1J1iiJ5 1smnisq .) anoiai33b

.(33311o3 bthn3ims

ni 31522 3(13 '1imn3bi 01 amn3bnoqaol b3Aas 11s3fli33qa 'rwa d3nJ I1rn3M 3(13 bnthoqmi laoM

81.n01153Ub3 Isi3nsmI 01 UJ20qX3 nimno3 noiismiolni b3ii3iloe ii bits ttJ00(132 did b3bn3fln 'dl (13111W

slnuJ di d ibn'J IFmM io1 b3bba bnA qaq eidflo iodlua miii di sliiw noital3qoo3 iii bnib e&w ,viu .inEqmo3 rb€$L

.Iqmae itfi ni bobubni Ion ii viu ,dflo noiIqmo3 io1sd Ew,i'mlni iith bot&nimi,I odw

bn ami,ini niaud hqoiq fai idIo uod ,tha8 Iainnfl 1o uIv ,tft uodi biaieqe boiaa ,t,w Inbnoq5I1

io IthIq noibuboi iaI b nI,b.xsi vInuIov ti1rid boriilb) noiansqIo qi dI uiIn,bi 01 b,Aea isw aIrtbnoqe$I' .enilq noiiudidno3 bonflb ioI e3eaa IaIoi bivoiq ot bne (noiIudiitnoo boni1b dio

3nibul3ni Ion)1Iadd nwo all no b,vaa Ii ladi aq mod-Llo noliai1 di iimlta ol bIaa aiw btofbauod tb3 .(e1nuo1 lnmvth 01 noitudi11no3 ioIqm, iomo3ni Ialiqa bIavnii

.t28noI ,dj b,vil ,dj ,lzigiw ni taia idi imn 01 baa iw zft jootha d8id gnnub 1aie no riadi om ni b,vil di1I'

.8woqa gnimonoo noitamioIni *Iimie 113i13 Ion bib vviua 5dT81

Q

Page 12: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

I0

boJ)usOW!vJ !U VC ACtIa OcqflcvpoU cuqcL CpU!C!O qnwwica wuj awjn uq cwbjoAwci avn2JOL zpc LCUJtW!U j bcLccuj oupc miibic MC iwbntcq ctwiu pvcq ou v LCLC2iOU oLcfwiuWz ou w piLq qthcc

qq!t!I#wuvpca (c qcwoizbpicz) pvq jtujc bLcq!cp.dc bOII¼CL vuq qJCLCOLC MCI.C UO !WbL0AC !Wbfl4!OU2wCqiwu oqJC AtuvpJc OL pc znpcj owqwqn Mpohouqcq unwcuct mJacL2 ivugpw ipc 2VWC pLCJCc4 mIww pLVCCq2

is Lcboucq qit 4pc rnjnc o ivu!pJc Cfl Hp!u ucu pi.ccc' c wbn1cq pc wjnc p tjciu tpc

!AJncI pnjrcq aisiIwc2 OL Act ojq pcq ou pc jg 2m.ACA oou2nwcL Lw9ucc

qr onccw joi. pcucpuqc qc LCCL T LCj,CLLCq 10 wiqA p 1P C0ULC2!0UI nqcr OW (roo3Y

uucL1icM2 i obcu 10 dncwou ir i nqpj10 cowbic IpC2C UflUJpCL2 10 (02C qLMu LOW OIJJCL LCCOW3?C

vuq 3 coujiu iiim.A a1p21!c2 pncq ou JJC 2m.ACA q1w wcc rpc LcJivpJpr ocjcbpouc

UflWCUC W1OUJJP0IJ ou VUIJITJ c9Lu1uR2 9uq 9IJOIJJCL I bcLccuf bLoAiqcq PLVCJCCIGq IU1,OUJJ91I0U0

wijcw iwbnpouw Jc2bou2c L1C2 MCLC LcJ9riAcJ? pip OL cxniibjc bci.ccu oLcabouqcu12 bLoIJqcq

12 20J!CIICq QOW JJ02C NJJO NCLC niiupjc OL LCJTC 10 IJG WIWCUCJ UMCL2 uq bLo#iqcq pi2 OL

pCOLC 1}JC WOI bLoplcurnpc ouc (buujujA qJoc qceiucq co crcii 9C1 pojqw8) i.cJcccq imourniou

2nuc? uq rpc wo wuocnon2 o pcc (oL cxwb1c q.ic poncpoqa C21IW91 tc oj 29!!u) MCLC bjccq

pcw lu ipc 2nucA bLocc2a uiuc dncitou COUCGUflU 922C12 suq C8UJ11J2 MCLC qçccq fWPJ IICL Ri IJJC

wi2iAcuC22 jjna bcunrucq RUCWCMCL2 co cpIi2p cLcqipip o bcc Lcbouqcu1 r cc uq 10

IccI o cowbjimicc uq 10 flLC ccmsc) Onc1iou2 MCLC 2cdncuccq CC0Lq1U 10 qicn. qcLcc o

cqcq n JC22 LCJIVpJC 1JJU mcc-o-jcc ru1cLA!Ma rpc mAc?i qcvucq 10 cp1c/c pip

Ouc bocuuvj bLopjcw i rp c 2m.Ack it UJIIII21CLG p? cjcbpouc //p!I c1cbpouc u1cwc1

!ACLC bcuwcur

Lcdmtcq pX p12 OL CL 2CpOOj I22 COUCCUI11J IpC 9CCm9C? 0 1}JC2C LccOJJcCtIOU2 LC couvqccq pcjo

Lc2bouqcuI ipo UVAGLC e?Co 112 ccouq dnc2fiou i#2 pcu jccq MCCCL u? o 1C2C C0II1.2C2 ThCLC

IWØ1JCC2 rtcp 2 (pG nc opnqcj CLC 29AW2 CC0flU(2 CpcCJCUJ CC0flIJ(2 uq 20 0L(p ECP

MGLC (JJCU 927CG MJJG(CL uA o 1?C2C coraac2 2bccqjcJ? C0ACLC fobIc2 wipq (0 qo #irp poncpojq

comc qcvjru M11 poncpojq LIUUCG2 COU2fIWGL cqnctiou OL GCOUOUIIC2 JJJO2G /1410 II2/ACLG

JJJJ2 1U0LW(i0u M92 g(pGLGq RI (LGG 21Gb2 ErL2( Lc2bouqcu(2 MCLC u w pip acpoo qcA (ooJc m?

Page 13: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

I!

CpU!C!A1IIJ vqqJpou o jpc btcwa qiabAcq W JC pjc WCW2flLC CW!U O AVt) ill IPC cxbccjcq WUIJCI. MJqJ cqncpou

oqc copoi. cxbo2cq o w uq9Jc CACU rpC wvuqtc iivz flJPuI9C UCCC2f11 RI CUU W9IJCtVJ

uounuj uq rncaccp1c ig?, p, qrn cc' ouc unp uoj cxbcci io OCUC cpiiC RI CVJOL 1JJOU 1J1C

pwqm i qjccr w uo pc ninucqic acpoota w jcc uwc ro cowb1X OL w nnqujA cowbj? rn 20wC

cnuicn unpr awib1? cpooc uo o cowbj? JqJ rpc wuq9rc icu q pc wsuqrc i iinj? IIJCLCIJJCUWJ uq

wuqrc w qq jirqc WOLC gpsu !#Juqo/A qLce2w vIrCwr!ACJ acpooj2 i#uponr cou2nwcL-oucurcq

OL jpc wou.A o aiiqci jcc crcq CORL2C2 CfCfLAC2 rpcu rpc Iwbo2wOu O1

W!2 op°i q 2CJJOOj I2WC12 OL rnqTnqrwj 2COOJ2 LCcJIIftC C0UflWCL CqIIC9IIOU O pCU

wcLcsc cxbo2nIc ro wuciøJ couccbr iu ipe CI2LoOw ACr rpCLC i wr W9U9lC2 MiJJ

r psi.q o iwuiuc rjrn cnu.icrqnw w uqørc conjq mIJncucc npacdncu jjuucivj cpotcce nujce2

i 1p iwbc O( C11L4C11111W Jç6dflLGWGU4 OU qncøouJ EXb0nL6

bLoI!qc2 cou2JqcLpJc cowoi.r couccunu8 rpc A9pqirA o rpc cuiji r?ucp qr

LCUfCL2 JJJC 2WJ1JUa pCt!IcCU rJJCC 2nUJIU91.? UITIC2 izq 2Pli!1 21f!rIC2 pcq OU L UTCq 2fflAC?\2

bi.ricnjiA uorpjc rp rpc q q12bv? pc icj-qocnwcurcq C2W pc!iccU ipc iicrp OpOWCOMJJCL2 uq

irnj jcjqi suq cm.unia vjeo i& iii qc gbbLobu1c W9UUCL cLo22 bobnjvpou 2npLonb2 irI2

wcowc uq MCJj opc upr wvmrnqc2 jpc !ACØJrp qT2rupnr!ou v12o cxp1p112 rpc nvwjqncjc nbbci.

011CC OIJC CCOffUf2 OL IVC2C bUUCUJ OOAcL2wbpu Ruq nuqcL29wbjw r; pccowc rpr wcqiu

bLoppJ? LCJiACJ? CV?l O LCVC pA cjcbpouc vu.cuu ywcucue c o nuqcacbLcacurcq iu rpc 2m.ACk

pip (pA bcLpb2 UAC 0L 2!X bCLCCUI11C bow piii ipia 12 nuqcL29uqpJc IACU JJT 2ffC Of12CJ3O2 LC

pcucpwuqc2 jjic acpou oLc2bouqcur2 M0 C urnwcq uq jpc ciou !AO tc pOWCO!IJCL2 VLC g pir

A4CLLfff rAucp 21n.ACA 10 WC2C pcJcpiJjc) QC1JCLJjA 1}JC qV C0UOLIJJ LC92OIJØPIA MCII ro 1pC2c

uq rpc jo cnacur bobnj9llou 2nucA (2cc o cuJpcrw uq ucr M0 cowbc rpc joa

Page 14: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

15

wucL.•cxboacq o wwuqvtcj j uuopia c coi.A jpc bLoplcw ouncI22iQuua pip acpoo qtob-on ! AcU !wbOl4*J4 v bicjtcvj

pA WWUqV4C EOL 'P! VUjA2I2 MC fl11WC flIV4 pcA MCLC JcCj9 y' ouA j opcLMj!Ou2 (Ic2 ptu Q hci.cciijopocLOL wqiMqnt q!q "°i UU!P P!P CPOOI ! !2 !WhO!PIC 0 pIOM MpCflJCL JJCA LcWtwcq !U 2CO0 0U cuonp ro pC pCcu

pJ1CU 110 OjpCI. !U0ltou ia tAvIjpJc MC wwc pj qzc wvuqtc vbbpcq to wc ul. c,t &zqnpu8 jct qobpou

ucuqcq jnp acpoo awc Jboi!Ou oj wuqic jcqa o mi zwwcqivrc Vuq anpat9upVj wcI.C92C w

'.cabouqcur 'a ?onu cuoap to pic pccuccrcq p tpc urnuqrc(iVuA) 15'. tJJC 2tVtC RIMJJ!CP PC 0'. apc

W9U9tC Vuq pc accouq ia Acm.a arncc urnuqrc xboacq to urnuq9tc ia act cdnj to nuit) rjjc

JJJCLC VLC jcc?.. cxbjutoi.A iaupjca lu rpcac '.c'.caaioua jjjc U2t iPC!c1 cxboacq to

bCLCCUt o bc'.ccut) aViq fVt qicA MCLC '.cdnacq to wc coni.aca coicuu nrnuciøj robica

CJJVLVctcUcq JC COflI2C 92 9 LcdmLcwcur jpna mat OACL JJ bc'.ccut o'.cabouqciua (bcLccut o o

cqncVrioif bc'.ccut o ipoac aiq qrnt wuci tobica MCLC coAcLcq' vuq bc'.cciu o tpa anpaci

y pip cpou o'.cabouqcuta (bc'.ccut) ruqicrcq tpt rpc) tOOJC V JIp 2CpOO con'.ac w COU2I1UJCL

cxratcucc uq riunu o CLGCI2 ou cqncvpouøj cxboan'.c CACU tponp !t w) UJI2WC92nI.C wuuiinqc

aatcwVpcVJj?i coacjtcq iiurp tpc bLcacucc O V t9tC wuqcc on'. C2tRJJVtC2 aponjq apit '.cpvpj? wcsanLc rpc

con'.ac CACU MJJCU t}JcA VAC UOt• HOMCACL 92 JOUR 92 1}JC dnø1iA o tpc '.cabouqcuia wcwoi.? ra uo

iuqTizqnja w pvAc oLouCu ipr rpc? pic rVyCU ancp con'.ac 0'. qmij tpcA LCWCWPCL wjqu ancp V

t0tO32 VPOITt cXbOaflLC tO AVUOfl2 OWJ2 O CqI1C9IOU LVIpCL IJJVU VCPIVI cxboan'.c cc'. iij? aowc

ia nubol.t9ut to cwbpsaic IPVI 019. qCbClJqCUI A9uVpjCa '.c aqj-'.cbo'.tcq pcucc tpcA WCWfLC

toojc pnt h'92 uotLcdruLcq to rjcc v jn8p acpooj com.ac COACUU ponacpoq IumJc!g! tobica

to t9J(C V 18 acpooj coni.ac coicuu poricpojq LwVlJczVj tob,ca uq MJJCtCL tpc LCabOUqCUI

MPCIPCL 'PC LCabOUqWt tooj p8p acpooj coraac coAcI.!u ponacpojq UuVucrvj tobica IPCqiCL tpc '.cabouqcut

pip acpooi conLac iii COU2nWCL cqncpou (nicjnqru Vu? coni.aca coAcuu LwVuciVI 01. ccouowic tobica)

ojnp acpooj COUWUJCL cqncVpou JJJCLC '.c toni. qialiuci qcbcuqcut AVuVpJca: tA}ICtpCL qic '.cabouqcut tooy

i' ipc 'c catnirnrc V2c4c2 o b'.opit woqeja to ajnq? pc bLopVpiJit) o cxboan'.c to iuorta

cpoicca wou ?OnucL coJJOLt2

Page 15: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

13

OACL yc i.guRc ju btwcpcc I!"" LflUCOU vqcdnøcjA anwwwucq jpc bvgCw2 tu ipc qtvWO5 Oi)JC ZI! 2Wb1C ,#cl.c cqncicq Mipw jiC OL a!X ?cu o wuqjc c tc,wpou w,A pc vbbtoxiwcjA JWCL

JjJC WO*4 UtP1L 'I'!°' Cifr lflL!0UVICXbO2nLC iiq ).2 !IJCC MOfl C U0U-t!U HORCACL aiucc

tp wvxiwj wcwan&cq cJ.cc w apou.j OLCL (itpw v conbjc oActLz)bbct jo PC OWCMP 9wqnj CACU !UPC CLLC !2 !D U1VUC0112 HOMCACL fliC WWU94C onq iij vCpICAC oWCtpiU qoac to

L° flJC CXjCU4 MC aowcpwca UCOUcCq? w' ca Jcccq (acc btcAuona oo uotcy tpc wctancq Bu.cci wwA

MCLC cxbocq o CUCL9J COU(1WCLcqncpou W U91C2 uq jO bciccui !tCLC cxbo2cq o LIUVUCWJ

ou pcn. pa ?cm.2 uq pxp acpooj 29C ic wq qJs LOnpJA j bciccui OOflL Lcebouqcul2

qncsiiou) oL ijuuucisj cqnciiou MC nc thccic jjuucij cqncøriou urnuqc2

A9LJ9pJC2 E°1. COU2fluJCL cqncwou JAG fl2C cucuc COUZflWCL cqncpou wvuqurc (iucjnqm iu9ucij

oqi cxbo2cq o wuqc uq )cwa tucc wuqjc tc qcjucq qicLcuqA tOL qicciu qcbcuqciu

bLow2 (1opuoIf 1 fln bLocce2 ncer2 pr w bL9cf1cc iwbjcwciutiou w pc bLop.ctcq

crpcuuou j ii rpcu 2Gf onr o cjcc bijol 2CJJOO1' MIIIJ IpC Opicc O qcAcJobru 9uq ncvu woqcj

iiuo qq IJOt CO11flWCL GC1nC9!OU fqCJmCa "U!J WOLC 9 ?G9L 9JCL 9qobrlou (ccu1 uq

CSCiIC1Z JJJC 29IC O jH1OI 1.911 1G9CGL Moqcpob IOL CACL9I AC9L2 9IICL !C1aJ9IOL2 bncq ri w9uqvic

}J9AC cucq wbjcwcusiou j pvc pccu cowwou 9uq pvic ojcu LcwJicq .ow rpc j9c oidnjicq

W9U9IC ro pG iqrtj L9flJCL 9U nmJJcq19Jc ELOW couAcL29fou MJflJ COUVUJJCL cqnc9iiou 9C1 MG

011 f}1C p9212 O OIJJCL 9UCCO19J 91Jq 1U2PW1OIJ9J I11OUL19p01f JAG 1AOITJ CXbCCI Ipc CjCC2 o

A9U9JG 2ponjq pc bo2!1IAc4

011 cqnc9riorrnI cxboeiac i iqnj (c ecpooja qcAcJob crn.ucnJ9 ro cowb jAy rpcu pc cocrncicuI ot 1112

IJJIJqrC 01. w 2w1c2 /AIqtOn W9uq91c2 )cvL2 2iCC 12 2C cdnj o co j rpc cijccr o a wauqarc

pcw rpc Acai. nuqci. rpc wauqaic) Lot wqiAiqnaj2 arcuqn jn8p cpooj buoL o qic iwboeiiiou O 9

!AO acuqcq IJJJJ 2Cj300j 111 qiar 29IC nLucq j Q W j Jcu AC9L2 2IUCC WaUqaIc 12 2Ct cdnaj o (j

ro qic Lc2bouqcur E°1. cxawbjc r9c aqobcq a WaUqaIG 1.01. IQ Act oqa !U 10 auq '1 Lc2bouqcul

WC92flLC2 qic uwc cjvb2cq pcwccu rpc niibo2rIjou o qic wauqac auq qic Aci iiiMJJ!CJJ qic wauquc abbpcq

COIJ2WJCL cqflCauOIf qicu qic cocwcfcuI ot ipie AuUPLC porqq pc boaipAc AC9I2 2IJCC waiqac

Page 16: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

'4

JJC JCC OpLCA!4)Lt' I.cziqcucc (!u to P!JJ ?CPOOI jc) P I!IZLC CJGCL OU W ''It

—NC OW!t jJC OCWcq C24IWWC OL

cflU.C*J4 4V4C ! tPC VUJC V'81J CPOO L0flPIA O LCUi OCthOUqC112 JJJC oqnwwA

ojq o pc ucc1cq) ns jtct rpuu rpc cpmJc w cxboarac 0L qiq uoi qob1 wmJq1C2

(wc&wicq p? cowbuu xuqTAiqfw !Apo MCLC Aorni CU0fl ro pc MIqi xuqiqri i#po /ACLC 100

iqcunQ pc cjcc ournuqc p? au MC3CL rpc cjrnuc w cxboanLc 0L ecZ rjrn qob1cq wuuqrc

jjccjA :0 pc qobccq RI 21C2MJJCLC L1IJSIJCi cqncpou M92 WOLC COWUJOU 10 p33 M11J3 Iii CUC1 MC

UJU1C2 suq GqnC1!0uj CXbOW1C f1CJJ C0LLCI1I0IJ UI1JU 91J2C qwuqC? MCLC WOLC (oL Jc2)

bi.ucnj LCthOuqcui Mø GCIGq pA 11) p1 O1 2bCCIUC ou orn. opiccl z ro LCWOJC bmJon2 co1.Lcj:1ou

MC rucjnqc qnuiwA IU9PIC wqcrw !#C1CL ipc rc wibocq wiiq:c (Lcmqc22 o ipcrpcL Ipc

cuqcq jJ1p acpoo L1J3CL rpøu pc cnucur arsc o caiqcucc3 /j3cu 21111c-2bCcTijc C0U21U LC ounucq

WCJII2IOU C1IO1J C0112 HCLC 21EC LCCL2 0 J1C 211C 113 MJI1C flIC Lc2boUqcUI

ccp o orn. tom. qcbcuqcur iU9JC MC C2t1UfC ro woqcj picp vi.c qJ2:wnzpcq pA rpc

MJIIjC 0j I02C CXbOGq 10 CI3CLVJ C0Uf1UJCL cqnC1iou WUq1C2 j bCLCCUI 2q 1J191 IJICA 100JC WcJJ C01L2C2

CXbO2C(J 10 gCJJCLgJ COU2ITUJCL cqnc1ou WUq:Ca 41 bCLCCIU q fl191 IJJCA lOOfC COU2I1UJCL CqI1C0U C0fftC?

C0ACU1J JU9UC1J 1obrc2 siiq j bCLCCIU UTq rJrnI 1}JCA MCLC LcdmLcq 10 qo 0 fIJCMI2C' 0 q102C IJOf

Lcdrm.cq 10 qo 20 0j Lp0C CXbO2q 10 UUCTj cqflcurTOu W11U11fC 43 bCLCCUI iq IIWI 1)JCA 100JC C01112C2

wguqv:c2a bCLCCIJI 21q 1JJ1 I1JCA 1O0C COfIL2C2 C0JCLHJ rirnucwj 10b!C iq Jo bCLCCUI evIq rpcA MCLC

COLLCjVPOU PCIMCCU WC2C 4JAO AUSJC2 I2 JJ0MCACL wibcqccr 01. 1OC1301 Cxboacq 10 W91JCW CqI1C1!0U

LcdmLcq jo jc conuca coicuu 1uguciUj tobica uq MCLC cbocq fO uirnucwj Cqnc1iou uJ91Jq9C2 JJJC

1401pJA 211113 j11L JC1I0U2 °1. 1.cebouqcur2 (J, bcccur uq j bCLCCUI LC2bCCPACIA) A WCA MCLC

1!PLC2 0L Cxbo2rILc 10 WUCIJ wuq:c c 2UflUL (bcLcCu1 5Q bCLCCU1 uq 3i bCLCC131 LC2bcCPACjX)

MUPIIJ IJJC UCXI IJJLcC AC9L2 uq L0flJA bCLCCIU MCLC Cxbo2cq WOLC IpIJ 21X ACLa VJCL flJC w913qs1c IPC

cxbo2cq !c1qmJ jpc 1L21 qacc Ac12 SJfCL rpc Iwbo2iliou oJ pc wiiqsic L0npA j bCLCCIJI MCLC cxbo2cq

cqflC1!ou wq1c 01.W0 CXbO2Cq 10 CUCLJ COU2IIUICL Cqnc9fiou wuq9ce' LonpA 44 bctecur MCLC

Page 17: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

fpcA ooc v conic 911 CJGCfiAC CAGU qonp ii LcdrnLcq ccouq awqcur c ycu i.ic o.

tOt JC 92CUCC O 2!IfliC91Jf UC9fIAC COG JCGUI2 }!12I 2OWC Lc2bouqcIu2 ws? LCCOIICCf wcoiiccriAwiIflJ1ACI39JJ? CCPAC' If onjq LGqI1CC iJfl2jL9CIIOU fO SCLO JJJGLC VLC G92t iio bOIpJC cxbIuu9rIou2

fJJ9f qJC fOOC pIlf MCLG UOf LcdmLcq fO JCGa COfltG2 COACUU w9uci fobic2 OPA1OI' I13C W91J9fC

ycinvjjA i 12 aowCI!p 2nLbu2w cpr W9U9LC2 qo uoi rpc pcf1ou o ruqmiqn92 po A

prcp cxbjiu /ACfCL fpc Lc2bouqcur roo pn uo tcdrntcq fO fØCG 2flCJJ V COfll2C

LG2O1J9pJ? LcpVpJc F' fIG Cou.c2bouquJ COCJCICUf2 VLC C22CUIIVflA CLO Hi cdnVpou2 (,)uq (g)

coicuu ju9uciVj fob!c2 jJ112 bLoJiqc2 172 MJfJI 201336 LCV22flL9UCC IJJVI LCC0JICCF1OU2 V)Oflf LCdI11LCWCut2 utc

bLCci2iou iACU ipc qcbcuqcuf A9UVjC iuq1c91c 1P M92 fO f9JG V corn 26

CO2C2 COACUU poncpoq juVuciVJ fobica jpc cocwcrciu ot )cm2 mcc wuqic tc C2UW9fC MUJJ fiG

HJCLC92G fIG .VCP0U O rnq!AiqnuJa f9CJ1J CUCUC COIJ2IIWCL cqncupou COflt2C2e 92 MC!! 92 fC 9Cfl0U 19JCUJ

2iuIuc9ut ACLA pip J6A6j2 o couijqcucc jpn OACL frwC W91JVfC2 7lbbGVL fO JJVAC 2iuIUCSIUJA

HOMCACL in cdnioue (j) ptonp (fiG COGCIGUf2 o )cm wcc wuqic 916 bo2ifiAc Vuq CIJCLV1I?

2wp2rrc9!I? 1u2iIIruC91Jr jjna wqIC 9f62 fIG V2CUCC iUJWcqIVIc mibVcf ou CqncUirouVj cxbowtc

Iwwcqiuw p1 b cnJ91? fiG cxbo2cq :o wuuqurc coCWcicuf2 916 mntowii wvj n2nVjJA ucfric Vuq

A91PIC 0111 L62f1J12 WqlC9fC 191 fiG CCCr2 OUi9U91G2 9AC pCCU 2IU1UC91J1 pniL9qr7VJ LVflCL 1pJ

tot qrniiw?. AVUVJC i#c icboi. fIG qI2CLcrG cpuc in btopøpijii 9220C1916q It4fJJ V q2CLCfC CJI9IJC Hi

aVwbJc WCVIJ2 p1 bVtpcnj91? tOL COUfIUflO172 A91J9JC2 MC LCbOLf rpc qcuAVriAc o rpc btoppiir) oj, cxboentc

WC92fILC fIG CIJCC12 0j fIG CXbJVUVfoLA 191J9P1C2 013 fIG btOppijiA O CffCVfiOIJVJ CXbO2fltG GAVJflVfC 9

jO tVCqifVfC fIG iucthtciou Ot OflL LG2(7J12 MC icbo bLopir cOGWCIGUI2 191 LG 11V1J2OLUJCq fO

2fVfC COU2ISIU2 UCCC22iffC2 Ic cxc jnvou O fiG coLLc2bouqru Op2CLA 9110132

qcbcuqcuf UVJC flCLG 916 9 tCM 2W16 C0112f911f2 fJ9I btcqicf Lc2bou2ca bcti,ccqA pucc fpc rncjrrvou O1

occrn. tot wo LCU2OU2 Eft21 LC2bOu2G LVfG2 qIjGL ucp otorn. qcbcuqcuf A9LI9JC 2oq tOL GVCJJ

14016 fV1 fIG UflUICL O Op2cLAVfiOu2 AVUG2 QOW 2bCC1QCVI IOU fO 2bGciUCVfioU iii fVpJG t• IP!2

Page 18: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

bnpjic vuiprqce onq wot jqcqA 2OM rib n.ai ru q cr-Ic/cJ W9U9iC2 uq AoJnuf9tA cu1ouwcu1 9uq

IUCLC92IUgJA gIJLOJJwg rn bcLpucuI cjcciic contc buoL o pc 9qobrou o wmsqvic WCC cp9uC iii

wqicwou pv cpooj qi2juci MCLC wcLcnij? Lcdmuu rpcc Juuq2 otcontc 01. pg anqcug MCLC

n2n9JJA ewjj uq nuitoimiA !32!1!UC91U 9 COIJACUUOIJ9J 1'I OI 219P2PC9J couqCucc JJJI12 JJCLC 12 UO

(wc qcnniiou oiAjncp i a)wwcpic to J9t o)c912 9jJCL w9uq91cJ jpc C0CJjC1CIU2 0tJJ12 A9U9JC MCLC

pThoqJc212 m4pcL MC LCC2IIIJJ9Icq OfiL 2bcciUc9itou2 'ip ouc qqTpouj A9u9pjc: )c913 0LC w9uq91c,

flJCjWVtiOU2 O JJC CIJCL9 bobnjucc (Lcc911 tpc qT2cn22Iou oj cxocucitA w ccitou ) jo rnAc2ptc tjfl2

COUCCUJ2 O JC J910L2 LCL pow boiitrci 0U2CU2T2 tjrnr LcJccr ipc bLccx12pu iøtC2

9U2C pLOW boJitiC9J 9CtIAI2IJJ ou pc o uuom WtCLC2I onba 01. jOW ipc 1q1o22wcL9pc IUtCLC2i2 9Uq

MCLC COU2nWCL\T!U9UC19! GqnCøiOU M92 9pc9qA COWUJOLJ JJJI2 12 COU2I2tCUt MUJJ tJJC AICM WU9tC2

jyc bLcccqw wqiu 2r18c2f2 t91 wuqica MCLG uo WOLC (oL jc) !1CCI to pc 9qobtcq w rtc

IJJC tMO 2t9tC2 qiq uot qucic mipj VJCL ouc o ipcw qobrcq W9U91C --uq rpcu r qq °

COU2IqCLsp? WOLC ji1ccjA 10 pvc I91CCU bcwcut cora2c2 rrnu Lc2bouqcut A jjffl2 CflC9POUUJ cxbo2nLc ru

COU2IIWCL CtfC9P0U M92 9POflt fpC 29UJC 92 IU 2t9tC 9 HOMCACL MC JJ9AC 9J20 onuq W9t LC2bOUqCIJt MM92

cdnjj? jiccjX to 9AC tqecu bci.iwcut COflL2C2 i pçOLC qobpou oqjc W9U9tC iii zrc y cxbo2nic to

MIJ!IC 2 4 U C22CUCC MC 9AC ormq qiv uq (UCIIJJCL O H4JOUJ MCLC cctcq pk w9uq9tC2) MCLC

tPCLCOLC uor cxboacq) c2bouqcu A 9U poip tcuqcq JIIp2CIJOOI TU B A a Ac9L2 ojq W

?C9L2 ojq tu (uq !A92 JCLC0LC cxbo2cq o tpc uJ9uq9tc) MJfl!C Lc2bouqcut x t� (uq M92

rwbo2cq w9uqc jçc2bouqCIu2 PA iq x potp vncuqcq jnp 2Cp001 lu 2191C v H0MCACL LC2bOUqCut IA!iJn2tL9tcq i1JLOflJ 911 cxub1c pu9Juc tp9t ttc ' IuJbo2cq UJ9U9C w MP1C wrc UCACL

Lc2bouqcut2 JJIJJ 2C00J 2t91C CACL iwboacq wUqtc JJJC 2IU1JC9UCC orpI2 UUq11J 12 bGLp9b2 pC2I-

qnwunc2) t}JCLC i C22CUt1VJJ? uo cacct 9220cicq MIflJ tUG qnwuA A9U9}C2 11'1 WC92fTLC MIJCWCL rUG

j 12 bm.pcrrjiA rIJ1CLC211U 10 U0tC 1JJ9f IL! 1}IC oqq-umispcLcq cdnulrou2 (lpo2c 0wi14IJ 2191C

CpOJCC2 0L 1!1U11U V CIIUJCPJflW LCdIIILGWCU rjic) wA LGVL qJCU. bi.pcnj cporcc mi CJcC1uC

Page 19: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

r1i i&Ii nawaai 3Idnl3biano3 23bivolq thbmI 211(1 noi1s1akI 3biw-isJa m (nIb £ I1) 13181 'dno

.noiiB3ub Isi3ninfl ni Jei31m e3i1duq L813n di 03 bq231 tftiw 2UO3303 al 3lthnam sb noiiiaoqmi

3vi1 01 bliI 3iom icb 313w ans3rl3rnA ns3rüA bnfi n3moW .3a131th bo o218 s anthm1 i3diO

2321U03 bo 33n3b13rn 311i33q2-13bn3 31(1 ifli 'sm an-l3nsq 3231(1 bo Jaul 3dT .noijS3ub3 lst3nsniI\l3muano3

aIIbla 1s3ia1q no aiasdqm3 13in1 n33d i&f sm 313(11 is(1i aiaua bnoa 3(11311(1w a31mono3 3mod m

ansii3mA nS3rftA moft 3biaA .a3iiuwmmo3 rls3rI3mA nS3dIA ,o\bna 3(flO3fl 13w01 3thv-Ie 21001(32 in

.aiihonim 13db baa a31idw n33wi3d n01363ub3 1813n&Ifl 01 3WEX3 iii 33ni11th 3113i1 3d 03 aiaqqs 313(11

nm nodn3ub3 Ini3flanfl\l3muanO3 IBIII itiiif iII83i1UItafl1 11n13n3a d8uodi 335 io1 21n3131fl303 3viing3n 3dT

l3bIo '43viism3iIA .(Q) ban (E) anoiiaup3 'IIthqa3 332) aisbnnm1o in3bn3q3bni 1a13n3 33di no 3(1

abn3bnoqa31 di 11aniI .aawo3 z3d1 nAi 3v6d rfi iarfi iiob 01 '11i1 iom 3d Iqmia vam ain3bnoqa3l

nibu13m 31uaoqx3 1nnoiia1ib3 01 b316131rw ai 'ii1ngtrñ bo 3313b ain3isq 13(110 ai1( bo inmaaan

a3vii33I3 (Inianqwa idwmoa)

ioivsd,3 tiubA io atn9m9liup3$1 mulu'iiiiuD 1thninil to biqmI 9dT 2

b aujanm baa a3lnbncm n01163ub3 1613n6nfl 3iaia n33w33d anoiiabi di 'bifla 3w n0ii332 auli a!

dtiow J3n b3is1umua baa (31d61-lsv wofl a) nivna bo a1ni b3hoq31-bI32 gmbul3ru 1oivai13d ISi3nsnft 3hbn

a131 agnibn11 3iuiq2 3nieau3aib 31ob38 . ban 231d63 m benisino3 318 a3k2351 .(3Idarinv boia a)

.23U22i 1613fl3 301113 aaoibbn 01 innfloqmi

3(11 nwom1-1Iow ai aA .oupinrboj noiismiiaobo 33L0d3 3111 211103(103 011221 I810f13 321113(11'

3fl0 miii 16313 ha in Ion al ii 33rn2 .bowoAa 1i13i11 318 nivaa 1023161 bthoqoi-bIoa baa ñilsow lo anoiludniaib

(e1in3 ioqqu odi d noviib 3d 03 bnoi d3idw) anoiiudiiiaib oaodbbo 21150(113(13 3f1Fb1J12 111 boiaoioitii 3d blisocla

io 2id lath bhoqi tnbnoqi dt1i 1inu 01 Iaup b ei bna Idaiiav rnmub £21 e1n2q *guit" anoi2ETg1 edi ,,vie ivi mva gaiva avod2 aa atnlaq iisifi gnisIiab Iqm thflo anoit3ai ihT .!,va2 ,8*i,va-,vode w a1niq id 01 b,nibb 23rtbnoqx1o noiiaiI IIme a) lnnaq E bna tn,oTq E .1noiq O bv11oqei eiva ii,va woIv bna iftod b,1aInoo Idith i Ii ,IdatIo enoieeii ,dt ni Io, 1n23fl1n812 on esIq (1iIa8uiI atnaaq duod1IA .(noiiEaup 3di wna

.(1nuoa inicJ alo qirh2inwo U due) U3niiqx5 boodblido $n5nIhq dlo dtiw bn8 fl .82 3f15flIJ3 tftw

VI

Page 20: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

3'1116ffl3116 owl 32113W iqnq aili nI .5Wb33o1q 3v13361i36 I161u3ti16q s ion 21 noi31i J0 &lsbnsi2

no ansib3m nibu1e 8 .(1o113 bl6bn6i2 b3qqsli2iood diiw) noiaii n8ib3m 21 ieiiI 3dT .a3uplndot

3113 io1 .lisi iqqu di ni ncdi iñini noiiudiiiaib noiifiluqoq di 1o 1in 3(11 i lOivfid3d 1613(16(111 23dn323b

noii6Iuqoq 1in31,wp3) 23113n3313q noii6hjqoq 03 b31-I3vnoa m a3ldsrisv in3bn3qob up1ndi bno2

ol iqi ñiiw iaudoi 316 anoiicup3 n1ihJe51 3111(11 2Jn3131fl303 3tfT .anoiaa1 2J0 n1iifl io13d (thmi

in3bn3q3bth 3111 (U 233fl6d3IO aiTI3 di 3dn323b '311i :2noii6i3lql3irn Iswisn 'tnd 't1i bn6 13i1iuo

iuo b is 31311T .3IdLr16v in3bn3q3b 3d3 b noiiljdrii2ib 3111 iii noiiiaoq 2in3bnoq23i 3111 no k1ahnv

.nivsa bo 23361 bnc 233226 b3i6111ffW336 iol aflOtiUdrli2lb 3(13 lo 22311W3k 3111 illiw 3ffl163b lob 23up1111I333 13(130

3W102d6 no basd 2noii6'fl3adO ifIai3W 36113 e3uplnd 333 f10i225I31 "i2iJdO? 3Vi16133i 3211 03 21 3ViiEfll3iI6 3(10

I6Luni2 23111231 ab13r lI613n3g 3111b3301q wIT .flOi223151 2fl0iifll3Ji W0W3Iq 3111 mofi b3ni6ido anoiisiv3b

.iX3i 3113(11 b33fl3231q 32011103

fUi6ffui23 (1311W f183flI33q2 e3Idnrlnv ln3bn3q3brn lo 3310(13 3111 2(1133(103311221 1613(133 bno A

231d63 iii noiifi3ub3 1613(16(11101 311J20X3 3116ff1ffW2 0332113W bluode 231C16r16v- (f3UlW an0i38up3 Ialoiv6(bd

33612 bo 3111111133113 bflS t1tud 10 183' 3JB32 100(132113111(10 b32611 316 iiidi afd6nnv iol iqo 3W ) bn8

noiiscmdlni b3310q51-1132 3W (1) :23v1i6m3316 131130 owl 32631 36 316 31311T .(231d6ri6v 3iabnam) 2336bn6m

3111 diiw 3ruln3mLrUanl 31U20X3 16(10138311113 no noii6rmolni b3tIoq3l-b132 3211 () 31u2oqx3 16no1363ub3 no

aauo nim iii iud anoitsaa Inaupaidue ni batnaaaiq aaodi ol ,alimia bviiitiI1up n,flo au aalamiiaa 2.10 a)d3a1q nI .aanaua1th aldaibu ttoqqua 03 a1133iqmi 003 '1qmie ,ua

aeIuo31o bIuo anO .aldanav tnabnaqab adilo noiiarrnolanail inoJonom uaanilnon iiaqa a nb1i3 ot alnuoma aidT adi aAai bIuo3 ano a1qmaxa na eA .noiiudruiaib adilo liii adi aanabrlO3 'hslimia tatft anoiiannoInai3 oinolonom aaniInon tIio aAal

uol ,aaalnu) iadidua ladwamoa ,tiaaaoonlo ai noi3nu1 uaniI.non ialu3ituaq alo noibabe adT .aldanav tnabnaqab adilo 201 aauioad 1uaq ni aAnai aIiinanaq ialaiq aW .(larmon 2° ei final 1OTl adi larD noilamiolni iaiftolo iud di no ,won1 ano aIqmaxa

ant b aaulav ,moe tadi noi1añIqmoa Ianoilibba arft aid ano egol io1 noilalaiqialni Iaiulan a avad 833am tia tnaiaifl,oo nitIuaau dt ,o oia au aaldanav lnabnaqab

ol bbom tidol a atamitaa brua (Iia3 iaqqu adi "miit .a.i) aldanav tnabnaqab adi aigonuut ot ad bluow tbaouqqa uadionA di bnooo2 .uauiitha 21 tnioq noiiaonint aiD 3ruiI .rbeouqqa aidi dliw ama!doiq Imavaa uavawot1 aua ,udT .2nnoanao ioI 33,uioo hit ioqqu aiD bna noiludideib adilo ialnao dt Mdi bnim iii aid ano ,Idamuamq :hum Iaad Ia ei noiiaoiIiieuj haoilaiiala 2nrhabnu niam adi ni batastaini yjlaoianidni ai mo i1w uaab ion ii Ii ,biidT .Iaurnobni ai ninoaam aliD lud eauaooIq inmaftib d balaiana2 au

ii irnoq noiimnuu3 adi al,a ano lath babivoiq .mwbaoouq aidflo aeu mdi bmuolqxm aimI,dh,varu mvad aW noiluditlaib britaon,nt anti b

naflo au adi baabni) anoilame lnaupaadua ni bainaamiq ,aodi 01 talimia ailuami enialdo mo jiaibom adilo alqillum a3ambom amoa (ia2noula Mdwamoa

81

Page 21: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

Jo

PJ WaLI1WCU4t Avuvpc LC2flJ42 VLC rucoUcJfl!Ac !U 4Vj qic rc C0CWC!C1U2 4CIJq O ptAC JVLC IWUqLq c&LOLa

Lc U0 LCbOLcq qnc 40 flJC COUCCUJa wcupoucq !U qJC 4CX

gc2nJ2 pcq ou acJ1LcboI4cq cqnctiout cxbo2nLc WLC!u wo c 40voc q!"q lu ccpoua Q wuq pn

WPJIIJJCU1J AUD[C2 CWWVIOL2 UJVA PC 2np1CC O P!2,

WOLC JiJCCJ? JO 0LCJ C0111.2G2 JpCA J0OC 1U [2C[? LCWCWCL COflI2C2 J}JC?'. qqui jcc pi ancp cc CACU

cxbo2nLc c boppj npcc JO uou-c1u221cv1 wcvncwcu CLLOL EOL cxwbjc iuq1Axqn c bwppA

o bLcqlcc GUL0[JWGIJJ IIJCU bocupjjA IWbOLWIJI IUJpLWUJ IOU 12 [021 ccouq 2C[-LCbOL1cq wcøvmc o

riwc io JCU iUjC2 ncp v )cm. iucc urnuqic w bioxX J0L dnuprk i ncq oujA

IwbLoAc cnwcnj anp2cdncuJ o c Iwbo2tpou o uiuqrc rpcu qic drrnjtA o COflL2C2 wA iwbLoAc OACL

2cIci. bopjcw /ItU qfl2 9bbLoucp LU2f COIIL22 c uor powocucoii p cpooj Lqnjj? qcicob uq

JJWCPOU o 2Cfl-LCboI4cq cxbo2rac 9uq\oL Lcdrrn.cwcu12 iuii.nwcupu wup JC urnuqjc iupc JJJCLC c

b[n2ipJA cxocuonw jjnan?ci Ipul ouc wip ucwbr to c211uJ91c cdnroue cxhjvnnu CIJOL

qucu pA cpmic w qic 1tC2 oi WJCLG2J2 oi rpc 8cucLuj bobnjcc --ot am. bm.boc JC2Cwsuqvccy ic pvc q cncq jpc Iwbo2ipou o attc uucij cm.ucrrlnwwuqrc qoc uor bbcøi to PC

wqlAtqrwJ2 !#J1}J LC1CL IUJCLC2J 111 Jj1JIJCIJ tobica LC WOLG Jq(C[A 10 LCUJCUIpCL LIUmJC! vj 1A oLicucq CO4II2C2

y 2bnuon2 COLLCJ9POU PCWU 2C1J-LcbOLtcq LGdflftCUJCUI2 uq PCPVi0L corqq gLI2C 1J' J0L cxwbjc

ruqictiou iiJ qic quts IPSI LC2b0uqCuJ2 WCUJOUC2 0jJ1}J 2CJJOO[ C011L2C2 SLC 2CJCCPAC OL oJpcutJ2c iuibcqccr

IUCJWUIJOU2 OJ 1J102C MpO [iiC UI [JIG [OCSJ C0UJWflUTJA iucJnqTu [PC 2JflqGUJ2 bmcuJB' JJJGLC 12 9J20 2OWC

2IUflJSL bLop[cun wA guac Kcdrm.cwcui2 t [PC 2CJJOOJ OL 12J1JC1 JCACJ UJSA LCUGCJ [PC bLccLcucc2 suq

bci.wcu cm.ucnv wA pc 2bnuOnw EAGUiouc fl2C2 2cft-LcboLtcq fIfl0LUJI0U Ou COfli2C

nuqcL[A1u 152JC2 U\0L IIJJCLC2J2 C0U2CdflCU11A C0LLCtI0U2 CJMGCU JJ13UCIJ pC}JVi0L suq cxbonLc JO

WsUqIC2 [PC CCI2I0U 10 CULOJ[ W 9 JJUSUC19J CqnCuJiOu COffl2C 12 cuqocuon uq boicupsjA LCJSJCq to

OUqCL 112J (12C OJ 2Cj-LCb0L[Gq IU10WJ91!0U 011 CqnC9JIOU9[ CXb0211LG JU [JIG 92CUCC o

wuqstc A9USpJC2 B°P 0 IJIG2C 9J1CUJ911Ac2 2PJC f12 bLop[curnfIc

Page 22: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

50

b9T.ricnjm.A LCIPJC io dnc21Iou upon ncc jJJ12bLop9pt? LC2flJ2 ow coujpiuggiou OJC1OL2

orpjA Lc2bou2c L9IC to dnc2pou2 uponi L91C2 o auAw c cxpcwcj? 1np (LonpJA bcLccu

IJOITOU 0u0M 2VUJ jOLW02f LcabouqcIu2

wctac (uq bcqJ9b uo cicu ipc pct wcvmc) o avw OMCiCL iic n2bcc1 qrnr i i rpc wo 1U1f1!1C

bjn iojnutm.? qçcuj (c cwbjo?cccoutupnuouo otO) rpi i uot c ou1A COuCCIASpJC

umnwic bopcw pA auni rpc nucX dncpou rn 0 iioA poj qcuc vwg s nuthcul tojcc-powc boA

coupjpnpou bcu,ou occonu oi c,cu eowc boi.pou o LCWAC2cq cobrj nicowc jc poic oucwlucq to

IJJOI JJC LCJ.9I1R LOW thCUqTI3 M1IC OUOWCL UJOA COITUI CL cwb)oAcL COUIUPflIIOU 10 CL qcucq

buucibjc LOL cxOwbjca ouc wqmqnoj uioA piuj o vm o 1C boi.pou oj pi boAcpcctc (tsjc-powc boA)

L9fC OLC ribcci pcCWiC jpcA qo 1301 ucccaouiA LGUCCI 1C co1m1icu1 obbJicolrou o vbbLobuvtc ccouounc

JJJC fl2C oc!LcboL1cq o,wg LgC L912C iwbo1.n1 inc oj IIJICLbLCIOI!OU o owc CX1CU1 WC2C

JçG o(1IAiu

1301 rqjjcicu1jA ucp to qiiiump PCtMCCU fIG o qqjcLcut uuq o bopcic ot 9 WCL JCAC[

cqncouou urnuqoic (owiucq) oLc 2iurcouqA MC9CL tpou tpoc bLccurcq pcLc fluJoLn1rntcJA fIG qoio OLc

cxbccrcq 10 OUCCI pC}JoMOL 113 fIC2C 9LC92 J401 V1thLI2WA LC211II2 02COU 9 pLOOqCL CJ9 0ICOUVTU3CL

cqncopoiJ conuc oi.c uo qacciA cjocq o avw ouq rnicwcu cpoicc mq qtCLC0LC poiq 1301 PC

bopcica wouqopu tpot nqcu octnojjA occ com.ac coicuu juoucToJ tobtc2 OIPCL ICUJq2 0C0UflUJCL

C111.UCIIJI1UJ wsuqvrca jJ0nq MC cou2iqcL JJJLOfTpOf11 fJl2 GC1I0U MC WIqA fIG pcpoArOLoJ CjCC1 0

JJJC rpJLq CIJCL9J !2flG COUCCUJ2 bopcA ocnv ju boi.iiccqoi. MCU atnqAniR pCJ3OAIOL' MCJJ JcnJq 01:.

pcpoAiOL OJfJO2C MJJ0 MCLC anplGCI to tpc wouqorc2

0 2C9LC 0L q1LGC cAiqcUCC 11J1 2191C JU01JC19J CfIIJJCIIjIIUJ W9Uq9tG2 UGCICq (oL qiq uor ouccI) c oqnjt

A9L19JC2 MC V0iq fIG /9L12 bLopJcwe fI91 b1onc 1JJCC OIICLu9IIAC 9bbLo9cJ3C ju GCUCC' 0113. 21L91CA i

BAC2tiw91iu cdnoIIou2 Ipol cxboni nsoucioj pCpO/ioL qitccrjA o o tpuctiou o tpc wouqoic

Page 23: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

wuqrc icjj v OL v pou ocu1!c9I eocio-ccouounc cpLcrCupc2 ptjp iwo cxccbpou pcc

UUIIJ jOW ALIVPOU JU O4CL bnpjic bopc!c MC COIJP.OJ OL MIJCWCL 113C LC2bouqcu aic CiCL bocq

pcuiccu rpc cacnuiucc oj wqIAiqnvJ ow iiup uq !ipon wuqurca (nicnqm qTCLCUCC2

LCLc2iOU LC qG2IIJcq o wcm.c qic cacc o )cøLa rncc wuuqc jo LCWAC 2Acwic qtcLcucc2

C2Iqr2 OI. vAWg LG (iu bcLccuc2) c cournicq in pjc EOL rpc wo bi.r ipcc

poncpojq thcuqw 2cft-LcboI4cq LSC o 2VIU tc pc orq? JPJC wcnric ot uO'I vitu

MCjqi (acc cuipciw uq uc j)' nrnjj? pcur CIrPCL p.nc bucj qsi OL qctøijcq jo o.

cqnpi qJc cxbccccq coucJiou2 MrrJJ JupJc2 2nc11 o i (r) vuq cqnciot? c,cu couLoflw 9L

LcboLIcq LVC2 °L AW 9uq UCI M0I1 (MJJCLC .tijpjc) !2 pijij? 21 121 tCj?t 2iJ1QcVUr uq IJJCaC L1C2

umnwnw qic q qo bbca 10 couiu wcuruijij oLqiuj nqpuiipou jpc COLLC1UOU pcwCcu 2Cft-

JCLOLC PC IUCJIUCq 10 LC91 qiC aocrncq c91qiu IUT9UJJ1iOU M11JJ g LUIU O 291 4CiCI4JJCtC22

1-CWJCC uq cpos ouc onq icuq o cuiq 112 qi2rupnnou P'I ou rpc vJ 2iqC uq OUC UJ1JJ1

LCboLlcq LIC oi 2viu In IJJC uuibjc i , bcccui 2cq ou 922C1 ccnwnjiou bLoUIc2 (c 9CuJjJCIu?

30 bcLccuI o cunu uq wuc Lcthouqcui2 LcboLI I.C2 O 2VTU LC1CL rpu ?0 bcLccuc pc pipce

flhJ2bcUf cc-powc b bLn2 Aofnu1uL? CCLL[2 1çoripjA bcccui o pc wb1c LCbOLI2 iIIJ IJJOLC qiIJ

11UJC1IOU O pC 02CLA qI2pipflflOu U CLO !2 COU2I2ICUI Mup IjJC UOIIOU IVUI 11J12 A9UjC WC2nLC2

UCflAC L1C (qnJ) jJJOnp2OUJC poncpojq nnqonçuspj? J22VC In IJJC pLoøq ccouowlc 2cu2c IJJC

10 J bCLCCUI JçOnJJJA J bCLCCUI O LC2b0UqCU12 2A Ipt qC? 2AC U0qiUJ' uq U0 LC2bOUqcUl LCb0142

JJJC wcqiu 2C-LCb0L1cq LC o AiU 12 Ø bcLccuf uq qic UCLdr1m4!IC L9UC UflJ2 0W 3 bGLCCIJI

2mJJbJC IJJ9U Ofll. UCI MOL1 LCLC221OU2

OUC bi.cucj COU2C&ICUCC 12 JU1 OflL 2UIW LUfC LCLC221OU2 (12C U WflCJ JU1.cL LUC1iOU OqiC U1V

wqIMqnUJ2 UJICUqA qmz ponr 2SA1U U2 U U.UCI1OU Oj WCOWC LUIJJCL qiUu U2 U qojji. gujoniu (8CUJJJCIUr

UWOnUI2 P1 UqqIlIOI? fl1.ACA C/JqCUCC 2flC212 qrnl -- OI. qiCIL OMIJ qGC12IOU-W9)Cm bntho2c2 -- W021

bLC2f1IIJUpJA wo iuqTAiqnUja Lc91.q dric2IiOU2 9Ofl 2UAIU LUIC2 JC22 rnAViAc qrnu dnc2liou2 UOfl1 qojj

Page 24: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

3Lp!a wnwcq C4iqCI3cA 12 C0U2124C1U M!flJ fliC C2IIWViC2 LCboLcq JU P! 2vcpou

LCLG221OU jow cdnujiou (j)) ouc IUCL2 (2cJj-LcboI4cq) 29AW L91C2 /ACLC LOflJJJ? J bCLCCU1C boiut2

2WCC W 12 bO2JIiAC uq 2tStI2pC9fJ? 2!1!UC9It 113po IpC wcqiøu LCLC221OU 9uq IJJC bCLCCUIIJC L9IJ1C

JJ UL1 IMO COIIIWIJ2 Ot9pJc 2flUJUJ9IJC OITL pV2iC j!uq1u2 J401C IIJSI qic COCC1CUt OL?C9L2

9LC COU2I2tCIJI MUp jpI2 bLcqlcflou

w9uq9rc pcc !2 uo LC92OU o cxbcci 2cb9uijc cacer ow cxbo2cq to wsuqtc '2 Mc Mill acc wqr(2cc we cnuc jpcjcq tIsuv1iou bvrp w we 8iac) 10 tpc cxrcur me couiioj bLobcLJ? 0i. C912 2HJCC

L0W fiG JOMCL pcuCpuJ91.Jc 9U 9 LVfløJ C0UAGLCUCG 10 IPC IJ1l3CL pcucpirnijc MUp AcsI2 wcc urnuquic

efTp2cdncut to fiG rwboirtou o wuqrc COu2GdnCutP ouc mortjq cxbcct to opci.ic wootp qcbwnc

rwboaitiou o uimiqtc accouq qiacricq poic cm.ucnjnw dng1,i? w jrnic wibLoAcq ivqn9j?

we jcqiooq o cxbo2nLc o juucij cqncstiou rncLc92cq 9qn9jJA LuficI. 1p9u q12coutrunon2A 9CL qic

o 29Aw to lnwb TuJuJcq19tcA 10 fIG JJ1JCL pCUCJJUJ9LJe OL IIAO Lc92ou2: JL21 92 MC 91C 2CCU LU 2GCIIOU

cxbo2cq 10 fiG W9U(VtC 9ACL9C L91C2 OI 2øAIIJ MIfl pc JJ1pCL H0/ACACL OUC monjq UOt cxbcct 9icL9c L91C2

urnuqtc3 qic bLoUIc mqj corucrqc miqi rpc IOMCL pcucpuijc EOL tO2C mpo 9LC Aonu cuonp to pvc pccu

29AII3 L9C bLoQJc MOITIq one cxbcct to 02CLAC LOL 102C /1430 9LC 100 ojq to J39JC PCCIJ CXbO2Cq to ipe

2flbbOeC tJlVt UO 2flqCUt LcCCJ1Gq jU9Uc19J cqncpou buoL to c wsuquc Mjii jcwq o CLo22-2cCpou

140M 2flbbO2C f'91 211C nuboacq vu cqncvriouvj wvuqvtc vt v bvtrcrqvi. gwic LOL 2IU3b1iCi1)

LJCCt11J tpe cwbuicvj tcuqCiJc? OL LVIG2 0j, 29MU tO IUCLC92C 210M1A mup vc

bLoRic OL rnq1/iqnvJ2 /1430 MCLG exboacq 2 MC JJ9AC qL9MIJ IJJC P0113 131JG2 21obC 21Igp1JA qoiumviq

bLoUje OL IuqUJq119J2 11410 MCLC UOt CXbO2Cq to uIrnucii cqncvlioI? vuq fIG CL022-aecpoUvJ 29/Ju2 L9IC

OI 29/IU 99UJ2t L1j1 Act JJG fl1C flJCJflC2 IMO pGUCpw9i.jç c92c2: Ipe cLo22-2ccliouvj 2viu2 LSIG

eccuc vuq pv cqncviou WCLCS2C2 29MU Ju qic mc biot pAhoqicpcvj cL022-2cCpOuvj qur on LUIG2

iiicci? caect o v LwvucivJ cm.ucnlnui urnuqvic ou LØtC2 o 2VJU lye jrac 922nuJC2 11191 WSUq9IC2 9LC

LdLC221OU2 qo uoi COUfIOJ OL cxbo2cq to wvuqvfc, flLC jMc WOf1A9C fJl2 bLvCticC p? lJJfl2tL9tiU fIG

Page 25: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

ioI nadi ithnm s lo noili2oqmi c1i iII vfl 3b13 Iootb du1 bi11 di 3n1133n3 odi ioI i3d&ñ

1ubivthth b aWi Bniva 3di isñi 211n1 Dno ) noiirnip3 moi1 .oiibnam £03 boqx3 ion iw odw 320(13

i1i nsdi noiiudriiaib noii8luqoq 3113 ni i3dii1 aJnioq 3gs303313q V4 1dauo1 3d o1 bni quo 32111 3(13 moil

•quo1 bno 3di ni ubi',ibth1o is1 niv iTb ni i (Ovod8) anibnll 1811833 3113 isdi a3llqmi 316bn8m b3aoqnii 1313 33aia b noiautani 3dT

a33n313Thb-ni-233n313Tuib nDIBi 03 81)18 21 3381i2 iiiO .23f18f13 181o1v8113d ni n313Thb no b3a&f

33flL2 baq613 3m13bo inuom8 3113 noqu bn3q3b ol n313T1ib bnoa aiilflo 3bu3inm di woI18 3w Jzdi 3q33x3

izbnm baoqmi iv 3iaia lo 2in3ilT13o3 3113 13v3wod Idnio4 .33bnsm di b noiiqob6

1023361 111V82 3113 fl33W33C1 233(131311th 3ti8m33a'e if163ihf18iE 011 318 313(13 InCh 2311q1111 aIIIT .ifI83fl1fli2t11

lo 23381 niva 3(13 bn6 a338ba8m b3aoqmi 13V38 icrhi 233832 111 Iood3e d8id b3bn3ii8 odw al8ubivthth

odw lud a3iBbnsm b3eoqrni 'Ilnuinov3 inChi 231812 ni Iood3a dii1 b3b83138 011w 238 31882 3(13 lo aI6ubi,ibth

iqqa ion ob 23832 22138 23361 nivna tu 233n313Thb 3ii6m3i2'2 abiow 131130 nI .1)3116 3d ol blo 003 313W

£ nibubni 0218 d 2318(111123323(131)3(11131 3V8f1 3W (1013332 m aA .baoqmi 318 a33abn6m 13116 hilnu

'Iin3iaiano3 21 38313111303 all bns (31dai 3113 ni b3bul3ni ion) 3inbrmm 31d13d 2183'( 3f1r1U2.63(fI 31d6r18',

b3i6bTIo3 ion 21 318bn8m s lo noiiieoqmi 311J icili 33fl1111122831 I6noiiibbs 3blvolq anibnfl 32311T .iniuinieni

323(13111 thn3li nhiaix3-31q diiw 10 3J8ia 8 niihiiw 3V62 03 anoii6nhl3nk n1118v31q 'l1813n33 1131w 1311313

011 21315(11 253fl31311th-W-Z33n313Thb nb1ni 03 thA6 V 2kesj6n8 iuo duodi 4YEow 131130 nI .2110136(111 3f11

318 (asp 18111812 b al8ubivthni b3aoqxsnu bn8 b3aoqx3 tisswlsd) 233n51311th slqrrua 38111 noiiaaibth

.nib63121rn

sari 3lV82 lo 23381 bthoqsl-11s2 .nithqiuenu s () bnn (1) anmulos in anibnh1 131130

2336113(1811118 3V82 231qu03 bsrriam 38(13 sansbws 3ni02 21 sisilT .a8thtrwS bn8 noii8subo 1131w hini11n8ia

•aa dliw 13i813b0m 3211 R1V82 lo 2336138113 bnn 2I81JbiV1bf11 313(112813113

i,cho ,dl bnE ,iobd no la3e 5mEe sift ni Ioobe d8id nibnfla elBubivibni owl n,,wbd th 8niv ni on1Iib sdT s beoqmi iv,n 3am iftonk ni 2lkubrvibni owl n,,wl,d fai 8niv ni ,on,iflib df of bqmoo i fsbnm df i3fta

.,fabngm

Page 26: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

wcupoucq bI.cAiona bctccu oLcbauqcuz bwccq rpc!t bwLcup iii iiz

cwbiucj Lcuoup1b ctnøjiA pø wc 2p9bc qcbicrcq iu jjnic j. y cxbcccqpc ciiwvicq cocjcicuipL

2bcCtIjCpOIr EOL cdnv!ou () vuq(MC qq qic ivupjc cxbo2cq ro wuqrc ro ci MC1CL qic

JJJC QUJ OflL COJflWU O iupc flJAC21IiC 111C LOpflWC2 O 0tH. LC2flJ12 MUJJ LC2bcCt 0 C}JHUC2 HI

HjCLCq (PCIL CVJOL w Lc2bou2c o cnwcninuJwuqrce

cdniou2 (j) qaonp () OLco,cI? qlcLc i uo rnqiciou jrn ipc cpijqtcu o .nujbvi.ciu wrci.wjjA

Lcbouqc1u2 poac btcur MGLC uo parutjj JCL qrnu rpc 9ACLC cJ,cc wczncq flu

nbboI4 c bLcqlcpou ontjwcq w pc bLcCCqTIJ bi.ibjr jjuc wcwacq cc o cnwcnhIruu uJHuqHrc2 ou

Lc2bouqcu bmcu MCLC ACL9C OL PCIOM 9ACLC 2ACL2 (bmcu uor jjuc LC2ffJI2 2LOUjA

Lcebouqcu bsi.cu vcq WOLC quuu vcc (jpi bcui)' uq UU01CL wqicnu MCCL quc

2flWflftU cicpou pcccu CU12 arucc wuqrc iuq rio qnizJi iuuipjca ouc tuqicnu i#pcquc rpc

MC HIAc2IHJC rPa b02!P!11A HI CdflH1OU2 ()uq(MCLC MC 0WI AcHL2 2113CC wuqic

LflI 40 pC cqnuqmu 0L qJC OUIJCL qimJ OL 4JJC JUGL

pCJJgAIOL O MJJO2C bcu MCLC U04 1Lfl 2IUCC 4}JC OUJJHf cqncwouvj CflUJCflfIW Thfl UIOLC

cxbcc4 40 wq s wncju 2UJIICL cacci ou quc CVtOL o rnqiJiqn9J2 po wq bcuj qu9u OU tpc

1!u9uci9 cqnc9rIou WHA 19L? 21&JIIJCHU4JA 9uq aA21CW94IC9A 9CL022 ipc bobrqvpou ju bswcnjm? ouc unju

UIOLC pcC9112C ipcA JC9LU qJc pv2ic C!CWCIU2 oI poncpojq 29A1U 94 JJOuJca pcu 4pc rwbHc4 oi, pip 2C}J0O

ow wcn. bcuw j vjo L9!2C2 quc toJJo!Mu rn4unmg boaerpqiA: IqJC C}flfLCU oj .nvjbmcu icCOUV24CU4 frJqJ quc JiCM quvi w9u? iuq1iiqn cdnac 20wC ojquca vwrnqc2 1OM9L2 2VIU 92 C}JJLCU

Om CCU4L9J niqiiu 142 COCWCICU42 9LC ccouowicjjA I9LC Huq pipjA 2imuc9ur prcjA jjfl2 bscw je

01. JJCL bmcu42 929A1IJ 2HACq WOLC 491J 9ACL9C'u4 MJIIC Ipe 11J11210U O 1J112 A9UØJC OC2 1104 944CL 91A 04

bøicu qnwuu) AsuHpJc 12Cfl22C 113 2CCIIOU MJJICJJ 12 2C1 cdflHj 40 mJ14) fl flJC Lc2boIJqcIi4 cJJ9L9c4C1JCq J112

Edn9tTou2 () uq () oj9pc uic rqcurTcHJ o (j) uuq (y cxccb4 qu94 qi 9J20 1ucnqc qic JJ.fl9

Page 27: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

JOL IPC wcqwu Lc8Lcaiou E(tX 181 = I I5 U qJC bctccutrjc LffU LC8LC22JOIJ E(t1 gj) = jipc wwuqtc}JAC i.vcq qic Ai2!P!I!f) o uuwucw unnc2) o jo 0lCL bnpic OL buAtc 2CCIOL ØCPAWC2 pw wwA pc coiuciqcq i#uqi pc qobpou o

jpi uqiu8 aII88Cp 4)3 JJC O2CLAC CpVIJ8C !U PCP!0L LC UO uupnvpc iO P!8P-bL0UIC joppAxu caoI.j (Mpucp wX

2flUjC!CUIJA wOwJsiAc 10 LCAC9J wncp c 2J39bc orpc p.mz2ipou bvir fl312 12 U01 2mbU2i1J w

MJJCU MC PJTUCVIC Cffl2 2UJCC wuqic 91 ICU ?C9L2 NOLC CUCL9JJ? OMCACL pc q m.c iwb1? uol

bLoU,c LVWCL IJJVU IIUCVL IACLCUCC ow wc pc!wc bLoU ic pqccq oni. LC2ffJI2 pccowc owci#jrnr 21LOUCL

2IUCC w9uqc ncq ou j' ouc onq cxbcci 10 opacuc wbopc COUACLCUCC 10 9 UCM

MC 9J20 9gCwblcq 10 CX9UJC 113 LG91CL qClUJJ 1JJC fnJC1iOUU1 LCI91!0U PCIMCCU 29AIIJg LSIC2 suq

A9L19JC2 2fICJJ 92 CUCL 9uq IUC0WC pill qiq U01 qclccl 9UA LOfl2i bucui2

O JJ1}JCL 0LCL ICUIJ2 W 9C MC I00lI OL boaaipjc JUICLUCIJOU2 PCIMcCU umici cqncpou 9uq OlCL

cou.cJ9lcq MJIJJ MC C bm icnjj? LC922flLC pA l}JC LOfl21UC22 O OflL LC2fTII2 MIIP LC2bcCl 10 1C wCJfl2iOu

A9U9PIG2 jpL 29C oi cnu.cug Lc2rqcucc ( obbocq o pip 2CJ1001 2191c) 2wcc XC9L2 2111CC

cuqcL o2wc wquiqn92' cwbIo)mcul 2C9Ul2 cic) JJ1pCL 0LCL ICUIJ2 113 9C 9uq C9UJ1132'01. qnUJUJA

CC1UL9 jnJq11J2 9LC U01 icctcq pA rpC WCIfl2iOU O9 M1CL L9UC O20Ci0-CC0U0UJlC COUILOJ2 (c cpucriA

MC JJ9AC bCl4pLWCq 9 A9UCIA 0O1J3CL L0fl2PJC22 CPCC2 39l 9LC 1301 LCbOLICq w Ip2 191)1c• OflL

lonujA n iIJ1UC9IJl I0L po cdnvg1ou2

LC&C22i0U 9uq 91 pc bctcciU jCACj rn qic bCLCcupJc L9IJJ LC&C22101T 40l9pA IJJC 2191C COU2I9UI2 9LC

bLcci2iou 12 29CUCCq 2tfl rpc 9220C!UlCq COCrnc!Gu1 12 2!U1UCU uf rpc 3 bciccui jciq in wewcql9u

jccA coccicu (oLAcm.2 2111CC w913q9(c * b9Lcu 1301 ul9) i.c uor icijA cpucq l0il 011CC 91ilU

Lc2bouqcul vucuqcq jnp 2CJJOOf JJfl2 o COffl3C Lcdnac2 ne o LCWOAC 2l91C CACL rwboeCq w9uqgc JJJC

LOL cckwuoue (o) suq U MC qq CollcCliou O qr!UJUJA J9U9pjC2 WqIC91fli IPC 2191C 111 MIIICF IJIC

CISII2PC9JJA 21IJ1UC9U1 91 CouACuliOuVJ 1cAc12

uJuqic * bciue uof cpuc LCI9IIACIA j1c uq qcebirc COWC 1022 o bLcci2iou IPCA LCW9W

lJJ!2 A9U9PIC 9LC 29l1211C9[JA flJ2rIJIUC9IJ1 lye CoCjciCuf2 oq,c jccA cxb191391o1.A A9u9pfc (Acne ciuce

Page 28: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

IUCC UC4 N0tflJ i C!4)JCL 0 UC4IAC U0U-ILIA!VI LC4!0U o jpc atuibcou bbvtcuqA unt cwtjuc onjq C 40 ;pc 4)JC4 HoL4p flUOL4flIJ4CA 4P!2 wica fIL4pCL qi4JjcIqfIcc

v A9uvpjc 4pv4 ia bIwnipjA 40 4C !UCI!Ut4!0U 40 LCbOL4 mctqi pni flW.C,t4C 40 4JJC IUCIIIJVIIOU 40 vccnwnjc mctitpMC ptAC wvqc uo vUcwb(40coucc4 ot borcugij wb1c CIcC4l0U P! P3 I'' '4 4P! 'J4 iuøpiJ!4A 4° !qcup4A

WUJC LCLC22IOU q 4C C0LI1J4 .4 i !"° WJCTV4 !a "!U°"4 !U IVC U1!U3JJJC C0CJCICIJ4 WUq4c, VLC a!9u!Uc,Iu !U 04)I qic Wcqivu 1.C!0U vuq 4pc bCLCCU4IC

9bbLoxwi1ou jj1C qicnjrA MU17 11712 qcbcuqcui A9L19JC !2 1J394 11 ! U04 qcjucq 0L 170fl2C170j2 MU}J CL0

9J171024 cci.jsiujI i& !#JIJJ qic ponacpojqa LC201UCG2 bLobot.pou9j,r) 40 cumsa ia wrcuqcq a

L9IJJCL qiSU IJJC JCACJ 0 Mc9Jqr JJJC 1° 0 11712 CJJOICC 12 4J191 IPC C!JCC12 O CJ39UC2 W CXbj91J940L1 A9L19JC2

ccouq qIc cxb1guJ4oLA A9U9JC 111 C9C17 0 qIC LcboLlcq LCLC22T0U2 12 417C L9410 0 MCV4I}J 40 CSU12

amisbjc 2cjcci0U p192c28

qic awc jcic oi bLcczaiou Miqi LV4C2 o aviu rom Lcabouac L94C2 ujao L912C couccusa 90fl4 boaaip1c

0j UC4 !AOLflJ LOL p112 LCS2OU 910U OUC UJ1JJL U01 xbcc o rqcu1iJ f}JC CJCCI2 0 CIIUJCJTIflUJ UJ9Uq9IC2 ?AIljI

ipc awbjc 9iC ancicuqA cowbjC4c 9172M0L2 40 IJIC Ijin 9U9? o dnceioua OU 922C42 40 bCUJJT4 COIJ24L71C11OU

ETL24 LC2bOU2C L91C2 9LC 211J1UC9U11A IOMCL tOL UC4 /AOLI}J 417911 0L L91C2 0 29A!1J ()11J? bCLCCUI O

LC2fq12 2CACL94 CUCLØJ COWWCU42 9LC 111 oLqcL

.L9PIC Q COUISW2 LC211J12 0L 249P211C91 abccujcurroua cxbjuiuiu UCI MOL1JT RCtOLC qi2Cna211s abGCTUC

B J,464 JjOI4p

9LC 400 J9LC 40 L9!A 11712 WCLCUCC MIIJJ UJfICIJ couIjqcuCC

mq1Aiqnv c qic vbbc9L9ucc 0øU 9bbL0X1UJ1Cj? JWCVL LcjWou2pzb Pill 117C 24911q91q CLLOL2

ACSL2 ousuqurc cxboacq !#upru 10 Acma ojw9uq9rc uq cxboacq WOLC 117917 ?C9L2 VIJCL wøuqic) rpc

cmim.c 2wnJøtJ? q ouc bi.pioua qic aC oj cxboacq Lcabouqcura 11110 IJJLCC ionba (cxboacq Miqmi 3

CIJCLVJ? LCUCL2 417C wqTAiqn9J C0CC1CU42 21941241C911A JIJ211JiUC9IU 2041791 OUC C9UIJO4 jC9LU UJIIC17 ØPO11I

0L oisjA 9Ofl4 ouC-dn9L4CL oupia gi.orib jpc UJCJ112IOU OJJIJJCL OLCL cuua us )c9La 2!11CC W9U91C

oujA JQ bCLCCU4 0 Lcabouqcul2 /ACLC CXbOaCq 10 W9UØ1C2 Uuq 11141794 )cui.2 2111CC wuqc cxcccq2 Q AC9L2

Page 29: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

rpc rThicj wqmiqfwj MO ii cxbo2cq ro wuqic hLOW cdnsriou (ouc rujcL2 rp rpc uc-Moip-o-

LC&C2210U LLOW cdnnou (j)' ouc 1UCL2 qi UCr MOLfli 12 p1J1CL pA LOfTJA OUC-AC9L2 MOL$}J O CU31132 OL

10 urnuqrc 12 boawtc mq 2!2ic1JA 2TuqC11ut iu pop pc wcq1u LCLC22iOU uq webcLccIuijc LIJJC

JJJC 1JL21 MO CO!tlWLJ2 OWPJC U91.1 ° P!C U!' J401C 1P W COCUJC!CUt OCXbO2Cq

JOL LC2OU2 pacncq pqoii MC rsjcc qic 911CL 9bbLocp

1)102C MpO MCLC AOmJ cuonp 10 C ijcqcq pA ipc wuqtc (rc pA couiiojpu OL cxboecq o wuquicJ

UC1PIC IJIUCIIOIN) jpuii 0L 1)1C CCC12 O ACL2 2113CC wuqrc OL 2CUIC 0L U3C2nU13 1)JC vctWc CjCC ou

wuqv1c jyc LCJVCIOU 12 ucCc229uJA WOLC couibjcx ju jipi o rpi bLcq1criou ouc wni C1IJJCL 2bcciJA

MC qo 1OL CXbCCI C 1ACLCUCC pcMCcu 1)JC2C jIIJC2 10 rnCLC2C W0U010U1CJJA !A11)J )cu 2111CC

rpc nuiriou bp MUJJ IJIC IOMCL PCUCUJ91jC BCC9fl2C rpC PCUCU1JC2 C0UACLC 1OMVL2 1)1C U)U 2iqc 0j 1}JC

/J31 qoC2 1)112 iwbjA 0L oia C211W11OU 2prcA ucc ru out c2frurnIoL swonu o cowbuuu

cuq o couictc 1OML2 1)1C uu puq rqc o cpc q19&w

1OML2 cLO 0L Lc2bouqcuf2 M11}J LcJ1iAcIA LGCCUf PTLIJJ AcgL2 jjn rwb11c2 1)11 rpc IMO pcucpurnLJc CflC2

ouc cxbccr ro jjuq cLo22-acc1iouI bLoUlca qrnr tc L9IJJCL 2IccbIA qotuMi.q ejobcq uq rpr COUAGLC

C22cIUWJ)A rpc 29UJC iii IpC cc o 2VAW rce Milp ouc nuboi.ji cxccbpou EOL ccnwncq icjrp

p14JJ ACL 2 111 QflLC j) MC wcriqc IMO pCUCJJUJULç C2C2 2 MCII ItmI2iriou jyc UIJ9jA2I2 12

WOIIAgfC2 1)112 C)1O1CC p1 IJJC JgIILC MC b1or pThOrpcriCj CLO22-2CC1i0UJ qVlS 011 ccnwnrcq MC9IIJJ 91321

) iu 1)191 MC IAbICSJJA C0U1OJ OL CXb02Cq 10 W9U91C L9IJJCL 1)3911 e,AC9L2 2111CC w9uqrc jinLc 5

JjJ!Lcr Out 2bCCIUC9POU2 0L UCI MOLI}J (I9pIc ) qijc ow out 2bCcijjc9pOu2 OL ?9AW L91C2 (tpjc

2bCC11C A9JflC O JIC rpLC2po[q

2191J9L CLLOL2 2flp21m3119flA )J0MCACL 0111. LC2flJI2 9LC U01 buTcn)9LJA 2CU2111AC 10 2UJØJJCL A9U9110112 113 IJJC

zsoooo (o bCLccul o wcqiu poncpoq c9uJ1u2) huilfite ro iwboac 9uA C9U11U2 qn.cpojq flflJ91C2 out

CJ391JC2 111 C9UJ1U2 /AG )19UJC pcac bLopJeum pA qtobbiu Op2CI.A9P0U2 OL MJJICJJ C9U3U12 I! P10"

C91JJW2 .AOLC0/C1? )OM AøflC2 OIC9UJflJ2 CUCL91C CXILCWC Oflfl1CL2 92 MCII 92 CXILCWC 2C1J2W11f) 10 2W9JJ

Page 30: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

cxccbl qrni iic C2WVt (pG cocwcrdu o (C cxbo2cq o wuqc nUCL9COU2 irp eowcitpc 1C22

pcucpwqc bLoUJc2 wrlU COUAGLG 92 )C9I.2 2IUCC WU9(C U2C O OIJJCL iucpu c jm.cjA ncccqI

2pUjA UC9UAC 9uq 2W1121!C911X 13211QCmU JJ' ! U0( 2flLbU2W 2WCC 92 2OMU RI IftIILC 5 (JIG (MO

wouuiou 9Ofl1 (JIG 2p9bc o c u.vu2rIiou b9(p lJJrTarL9(cq rn jflLC flJC COCWCIGU(2 oi 1PIC 9LC

p1 cdnspoim (,) suq( tAG vqq (pG I9U9JG )C9L2 2111CC urnuqc 10 2CC 1MC CJ JC9U pL11CL

cqniiqsiu MJJCU bcu cOu.lujmJIcø(C (JIG p2ic c[cwcui2 ojioncpoq 29.Mut

A1CM (J191 LIIJ9UCI9J CqflC9POU 9( 2CJ1001 12 V CJO2C 2flP2P1RIC 0L W911CiVJ cqncuriou 91 JJOUJC 9U 12 J9LCJX

o qn bvpcLu 9CL022 LCLC22J0U2 OL LV(C2 O i1Afli Vuq OL 11Cr ML( bLo1iqc2 cou2iqcLVpJc 2nbbou lo (pG

2VAC WOLC (JI9U 9ACLVC uiu MG mq IJJV( (JIG cjpq 12 couccuircq iii (pe ccouq gx.onb jpc couicucA

2cbvLg(GJA J0L wquqn MJIO2C bmcu 29AC WOLC rpu CLG uq JL wqi!iqn9J2 MJIO2G bcur qiq uO1

bcLCcb(10u2 0(JJGft b91GU12 pCpVAioL EdflH0U2 ()VUq (Q) WC92RLC (JIG CU.CC12 OCflLUCflJflW W9U9(G2

flU9GC1G MC 99U1 uq ciuqcucc IJIVI Lc2bouqGur2 2VAiU2 CJJ9AI0L 12 2fLOUJA COU.CJVIGq !AI(p rpca

p1 cdnpou() 9Uq(MC qq OfIL COUILOI 0L yi bcur' pc (pG rc) COCWCJCUI2c iciVCC1Jf1J9U0U bLocc22 F!ICC LVIC2 0 29AI1J (JIG L9(i0 0 MC9J(J3-10-GVUJ1U2 9bbGVL2 10 U2C M11JI C9UJ11J2

2JJVLbJI M11}J 9C 1)1911 q0C2 (JIG L9(C o 2VAm fl1 1)312 qi2cLcb9uCA 12 VU WGAIIVpJG coU2GdnCUcC o (pG

VCCflUJflJ91C MCVJIJI 92C 011 CqflCVIiOIJ WVA 2JI0M fib 0L ojqct MOLJCCL2 MCVJ1P 9J20 IUCLC92C2 WRCJJ UJOLC

1.9C( (p91 CO)JCC CflC91C niqIAiqfl 912 JIVAG 29AG 91 J3IJJGL L9(G2 I0L IGMGL ?CVL2 -- 2!&JIIJCVIJI qJIJGLGUCC2 w

G9U1111g2 qoce 1101 vbbcm (0 U2G 2p9LbJ) MIqI cqnCVpow JJfl2 qI2cLcb9uc? w9? )1OMGACL pc V1IUPRIVPIC O

owct juqm iii colnuJu2 (j) uuq () 9LC 1101 2nLbu21u flUJ(G evrng L9(C2' (JIG L9(i0 0 MC9(p-(0-

2(9(C2 (p91 qiq uor

WVUq V(C2' (JJCLG VLG CUCL9JJ? 110 2?2(CU19(iC qqJCLCUCC f)CIJACCIJ 2(9(G2 (p91 CACUIIIVJJA IuJbo2Cq W9Uq91C2 911q

(JIG COCUJC1G1J(2 OJ 2(9(C CAGL RhIbO2Gq UiVIJqVIG,, 9i.C flJ21&1UjCVU1 wq1C9rw 1)391' buoL (0 (JIG tuiboeiiiou o

bobnjpou 12(Ufl(I0U 1)1911 (JIG UG(-MoLjp-(o-C9uflu2 L9(!02 0( (JJO2C MJJ0 MGLC 1101 CXbO2Gq V2 111 19jC '

G9L1JflJ2 L9(102 O()1O2G MJIO MC1C GXbO2cq o wnqca L0f1JJ1A bCLCCU(9G bowj JI1)JCL lu (JIG

Page 31: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

cvi, ouA PC g bCLCCUj couqcu pvj pc cocwcicu ! qicLCu tow CLO

jo wq wvuqgc 2!InUCmuIA wcLCUC cxbovac o juuctvj cqncriou ft 1iw9Icj? CCi9iC rpc L91C2

nucoiicjrcq iup bLc Iw iucjtuvpou o oi? LcdrnLc uq jc conuc rp COJCL Lw9uc191 tobrc2 M

1ngp acpooi Lw9uci cnuicnjnw urnuq9c2 o juqiu c COUJ2CU MBjJ pc MCM flJU W9U91C ØLC

ju pi apiqA' MC 9iC bLoAiqcq qc LH21 2A2ICWWC cAIqcucC 09 IVC 10I-1CUi1 PCPVdOL9I CjCC10

Q' C00C1fl!0U

JqCuiJIJ WICLØCPOU2 CMCU CqnCtiOu 9uq OIJJGL Cp9uCCIJ21iC2 MCLC qciccrcq

OLCL ICLW RI 9C uq C9UJUJ' OL qfl1J3W? AUIJ9jjC 0L 2j9jC 0j CflUCU Lctqcucc J40 L0fl2 bsj4cI.u2

O'" "PI wqnJ2 ØLC U0 VGCICq pA IJJC1UCflIOU O 9 ThICL L9UC 0 aOCio-ccoUOUitc C0UL0! JIIpCL

in cciiou ?V' MC bcqouiicq iuciA o orpci. Lopr1wc cycqc rpøI m.c uo LcboLrcq in rpc I9PIC

A9U9JC2 o flUCLC21 rpcn. ouniou wtü IwbLoc bLcc!!ou M11JJ0fl flULOqflCnI 9 A21CUJSPC pX9

w IjJC coiucx o UCI MOLIp jo c cxciu qic COU2j9U bLoxA 0L ip1 9LC oLqJoo1rnj lo ITJC

uo cowc 2nLbu2c ucu rp qic 2191C couut coumnc qccc o ccqow rp c bgwcrijt1A 29LCC

ovuu qic rrc couur vi.clowijA 2iuiuc9u1 Eu porp LCLC22i0u2 jjJc MC9(CIJW OOflL LC2flJ2 qoc2

IJJC COCWC!CUI LC1JJ9IIJ2 2!IJTIjC9Ur 91 lpC 9 bcLccul JCACJ o couljqcucc J couii 10 OflL jjuqm 0L L91C2

C0UACU1I0U9 1p0ft}J !12 GCOUOUJIC ws&nrnqc 12 211J1 2flP2ISUP9f LOL 1C bcLcculqc L9IJJ LCLC22TOU'

cxboacq 10 W9UU1C p.nvj bcu12J EOL IJJCWCqIU LCLC22I0U 1I2 COCC1CIU 1290 1OUgCL 2iUIjjC9IJt 91

qiobbnj rpc A9U9JC CACL rwboecq uJuq9fc JJJI2 LcqncC2 qic 21C O CJJC J(CA COCWCICIU2 (o

u cdnpou ()uq (j y MC qq qriwuX 9U9jC2 0L 1C Lc2bouqczu,2 p1p cpoo c' 99W

qic bopjcw 12 CAIJ UJOLC 2ClGLC 2WCC IpC (12 9JC 919 211Wb1C 12 OUJA p9ft 2 J91.c

oiw (s in ccpou y) o qic LCJSIIACIA 2UJ911 J9C1tOU °L LC2b011qc1J12 MJJO MCLC CXb02f JIJ 11J12 11121911CC

bLcci2tou jni4pci. vpcwb19 o iqcurqA rpc 2pøbc O1JJC IL9U2II1OU bøqi MCLC jmciA fw2nCCc2cflr bLop9pJA

Page 32: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

30

LOHJIJ poq? o ciqcucc jpcqncøiou urnA pc boMcqnJ foot tOL 2IUJflJUU bcLeouJ 2VAW

itpicp wqIAiqnvJe 29AC uq vcCnuinjc cji qrn.w rpcn. qttjr J1Ac2 jpc2c LCflj coupJprTrc o qc

Page 33: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

3'

qJG pjoqcbjsc: AqcucG GLOW S 2mic? oonpoq uiwco wuoLq fl1J!AL21A Nst.cp i'BUV!W B' DO1S Slid DSU!GE QSUU JJ DfLuh,ImU 511(1 COIJ IIGIJCG2 O EIUSIJC!5I qflCSflOU 111

jpupcowiu'COUInOU IG1i!OU BC2CSLCJJ C0tT11C!t ipc /JJ35LiOU CJJOOJ flIJIAGL2!LA O bGUU2A1ASU!S 1ÔÔQC

BCLUPC!W B' DOfl1S2 J!LJ5UC!5! I1!!LSC qflCSUOU 511(1 K LCWCIif 25A!U 1" VMU%

\e° 5wp4q) v: jj L;22 jp'BLlJPG!W B DOff1 JGq7IUpU 2SAIU IuCu!I !U VJSU VflL5G (cq') v)'. uou'flU!AL2!A js'9CUJJJCIJf B DORJS' ,JJJC NCU.J1I AUCIJ spA BOOW KawcuI Iuqc: flbqsLG unwGo uot.q

CO(IIJCII OL C!W1 }OU1JSpOU bb' 1-30ycqou bcLccb1!ou2 511(1 ,npc J)offcX oc) 'Ecououst onts DC: ywcucsuB1JPC!W B DOfltS2 DO HOII2PO1q2 VbbLGcfSC JP!L IPmUC!5I AtUL5P!I!(12. VIJ Vmt! O

1ouJJSl:!ou 1ôt 3-8'bOI1C? 111 3TL O)%. £tOUOUI%C Q.OH1l1 \1 \?Jt3Z MS21J11JOU DC VWCUCU CUC!1 OL CSb!W1BUJPC!W B DOfl1S J,GL2O1JS 2SAIU' IUOLWSPOU suq ECOUOW!C rLsc: 4GM D!LCC(10U2 OL J,flppC

bLG22 Tô!'CUJIJGJWe B DORI 3y ii 2t °' tcf 4GM AoL: bL!04O

BCL O1 IYJr O fSfWCp suq bCUTOU qncsiou Cb!J xfot mJ 5

PA0LIthISCG: iqqGucG LoW s 2fuJGA oEWbIo?L W!WG0 2WUloLc1 flrnAGt.rI micBSL3 J,5LiCJ i B D°'1 BCUJJJCIW uq OIJlJ KJ 2PO1 jpc EGCi2 O LWSUCISJ E(1rcPOu !U

JCIUJ h11PI12P!11 co: CWC!IJUSP OP!0a logs.BVUU1CL' KOGJjS vuq cic J,AOU2W9 'tO3 O\COtt% m tcitou onqi-

COU2mIL EqncsIfou: Ab!1U! VI!P!U IOOQB5IJ11!1CL' jçOCjjV V tUOl tU %tct '4 \3O.ltW tUJ J49POU WPU'

jutz (j)cpuiui?V2PCIJ1G1L OL1 C EPW9C!U IIJC EU2 O jL511JTIJ hLOL5W 011 E 11g O\ 0UO1% 13t

2C1J00fIIJg O1fl11\ 3t. VOUO3C U.'12 I3(5) ybUi i oo oo- rooV1JIJ21' 102J1fl0 D suq vlsi' e' U1CCL 2b1II-29IJJbiC IJJILflWCUISJ ASL!SP1C E21WV12 OUIJC KCIfIW 10

E5LUW2 OI3V.\ O\toUol\t2 JØQ(9) I4OACWPCL Ioor OO-lOJ4yiu 1°i'n D suq vjsu w Iuic8ci. ioc2 CowbnI20L 2CP001 VIICUqVUCC vacci CJJOOJ!U 511(1

DCIMCL COIOLqO 15UtTSlyJCXSuqcL y ti t,0\t EqC1!OU C°"!'°i' 0j qJC 151C

KGI.GLGUCGZ

Page 34: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

35

ro(tY iu JoHPP' ic Oi'' iq 1OUVflJSU IVG EU.CC!ACUC2 0 JAIUIUCCIJPAC2 0.W1\ 0\

OOi% JjJ(3) VflI12t ioe11OXpA C0pI rnrcL H0M jC9CJJCL2) flW0U VU1 qtCP0U L0qnCOU .\o3c\ o\

qncupou: j4C!i jgHPW!W JcopcLr 4 vjouoit owr COITUCII ou couounc

ccctcq H!P cpoo1 jcx is-ie ows i(sY MTIUCL jg)HCW9U J0pCI4 oii'HI0UCØ1 DCACJObWCIU opc COUU O C011WCL qncspou: v" EumJP0u

VWCIJ \OT1W O\COU% 13(1Y 2IWJUJCL jOI11E JJJ0U32' JJJC COU IJJCL q0Cf IOU UOMGC O bLO2bCCPAC jccjJcLa: y J4UPOU9J

jjQ)) 2flUJWCL j,-j85.OLq) 3UI 2W( CP CU2PC2 VCPU 1PC bg O qflCUi0U FC JPOU. \O\ o\

COLJIIJCL 2CCP O\COU 53(j)) 2JIJJCL jg Q-O•E1 ,ucr JçrcpsLq E /O2pflLJf uq MIIP9UJ W LLJP LPC ELC O C0UJJCL EqPu ou

iu ouci o\vtouot u,c'i j o(Y EII I ÔÔ 113-13EUCU EUC M!I1'' 0 OI uq 101311 K9L! 2CJJOJ JJ1C IWT0 EUt 0AW UfUG 011

1fWC 34j-Q4C'4 111 uq DflUCU 11JOW D° cq AU(C D!U.CLCUCC ut touont itn g(

c0ucn!01mJ B'qL '4U £L%)i 2btLh 2Gb(GWPCL 1ôô3

flU1AL2IA 0I bGU1J!A1i! IÔQ Lopouuioi(,c) bI!u !U V'M'3 4W C0Ut9WI bQ0U JG2LCIJ CO1WCII 4pC I1JJL40U 2CIJOor

CILF K0PCI4 U1 21At 2CV!CP.' JC0L2 C1jIJ b4!C!b!0U *C2 uq C0UPJPfli!011 fA2 U

obii jgjC'U'.1 COflIJC!j 0L 2AIU bL0W0p0U Mi1 cTuc JU W0UOU 1$O U3fl U *31 jojc)o: ujc

Dq) cyoojw uq ypijirl -CAi2icq.)) s 'i'cio. vtouot p bb 3-

GCLP0U 0jVUJCUC fGCCUJpGL jggBLopcc1c rcbpcu uq qA C0P4' tOIc11 cou titow. \ %t11% \bO4 Co1mMcL

£tOUO) iàôCUJpGUJ B D0fl12 Uq 101W K! 2CPO1! UbL!AS 2A!U uq WIPIIC b0llCA 1x ov) cuc ti

oj COUVIWCL EJU1JCC)) uwco ujoLq flu cLvfA jBcuJpcw? B DOflJø JçopcI4 UJj uq 1°1W KULI 2CPO1 9AflJ 113 fjIC Jogo: 0W G

Page 35: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

33

IC2GLCV C0fl1JC!I 1JC JJJLjOU2CIJOOI flLIIAGL2IA O bCUU21AU! JQ' OUJJCOW1IJ

AoPO2rr flj jCUVOU qnc9pou: JJJVr ftO4C2 TU C°t4S'U° b1120U

A1CUJOK1 O\tOWUC vittou j5(3) 1TWWGL jgj) jj'20bCL IOJJU yuq nqiq 2WICA BLCUIJCICC JJJG jC2I OLECOUOWTC F11GLCA m EA!R!OU OJJC DEEb

y-\' 49t1OUVJ C09!!P0U OL COUIWCL qflCøt0U jUC : qiou iao2l11 CP101 H 1Oflt o\o. ctcauou n'i cioo

on io(tY L911 TÔQ ôJ-115OLpge Y1 21' E ACU1! uq D'q V M! HOM JCITLCWCU 9AJUR bLOLU32 JCLC92C

o\vtOiont tiUOU 53(!Y IWiLbCCI2OU J40UJ2y JJJC H1P 2C11001 ECOUOWTC2 COIT. uq it luibUct ou couounc uoi cqc

J,A4IC71J j4J4U1IOUJ P!UrC OL EqcO '4'v ocjo W'u4 N rnca

£no OW 0j 'q'u O hflPPC JU2P.nCrIOU OCIOPCL I I -18

ccgi yij?u uq jqpw pcqicuiiou jwbjcwcurpou o cuc B'l! oi c\A4AcL jçopct co2 o\t iuc bflPJI2PCL2: 9OOII

t18 tOUO$t J' .Q(tY 2CbCWPCL JÔ8Q QOIOvjouqc jçopct.r j EAjswwJ8 cpc Ecouowcn.Ic EA9!fl9flOu o jLflflU ,LoLw2 "up ExII4uDc I

couww qncpou o\Courn j j( MwjcL joQ3-ôruc, Eq'.'riK yuq Iou LPC DCACI0bWCuI miq 1wb1cwcou i. wCOoO31 O\CO N1% J3(J) 21TUJUJCL tIR3r'suLcp1? LLGqCUC M CO1JIWGL qncitou: DOC2 i CP" 2wqu Col ucic 'q V1!Wq

3 84WC0Wb1C!1 rpc buucibJc2-o-NTcLoccouounc2 com2c o\ ouott ttnou j( 2buut IXÔKopcir yuqLc/A i iq i,i 1ibbe EVCOL DCCLWTUUJ WCU OECOUOUJ1C KUOMUC 91JCL

tOU OW o nbc utcuqcuuObflPI!C I1J2WC!013 OCOPCL J io-ropuioi? MiJpmz? jçcboI4 oUpc bll°1 cPoot bLo1 113 COUImJCL Eqncg1!oU %\It&Ot2 \O3\ o\

'\O1\o\'owtciVto3oW J03(3Y ybu1 Jô? 3O3ôHnppuLcr W 01cm? ioupU quucL uq 2tcbpcu b cqc jccniioui.X iw8 uq oci IfTLucc,

Page 36: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

i aa2'.lIJe u

uibocq

1SLG2 O( A!UnLC j: Thotpc2icq4LU (OL

!ÔIQ JÔQI 9I4ilL

MJftJ0fl cqncou

4

jIJot!iiohJ bap

ji;qncginu

Page 37: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

• aaU

yecmun,i

iu'boecqrvuqgic

ccnwnq JvpJflLG 3: AbojpG2iGq b4cLIJ LOL

baip

ML' qncou

Page 38: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

14GM T0 AG2

14GM 1GL2GA JQ AG2 140

14GM HWb2V!LG JÔ2 AG2 140

14G11!

14GPL21C 140 bol!cA

OUWU 140

!20f14 140 bopcA

2!bb! AG2 140

A4JIJUG2O4 140 bopcA

1!CI1!U 1Ô80 140 140

22CflCU2 140 bojicA

140

A1UG 140 bopcA

fOrn2I1m AG2 140

AC2 140

KU2 140 140

I0M 140

140 140

IIJ!U0!2 AG2 AG2

IcIP0 AG AG2

H"!! AG2

CGOL1

joL!q 1ó AG2 AG2

D!2ruc O C0IWP! 140 borcA

DG1MLG J.XQ AG2

COI!CIT 140 bo1!c?

ojoqo 140 boc?

CI!PU1!S AG (j) 140

VL1IJ2 J.X AG (ro&) 140

yLJOIm AG 140

VJ2C JôQ 140 14°

VIP9UJ AG2 140

C122 JCSGq,, WUqS1GL!L C0IWGL GqnCou bGL2O1I JUUCG

jpi j: coiiuj qnct!OJ ojq p

Page 39: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

COU2flWL qttcspou (iao).2ontcG: ,qGX9UqGL (jy Opu cocr ou ECOUOW!C qflCiou (g Uq M94!01J21 CO1!LOU OL

flUJG22 uocq qJG jL24 Cj222 ctcq pA umuqs 12 q UL4 CI9 2GCI pA bo!cAI8à 21J(I Nt!CO1J2!U MILIIC1LCM 142 W9IJq!4G !U

** KGUUICA M1jLGM 142 COU2IIWGL qnc9p0u bopcA Hi J9 MC24 ATL1rn2 !AULGM !42 WSUq24G uqi CJ!22 LsqnVLU 1J 1)IC Acsi 2JL spc bol!cA M22 9bbLoAGq

* IT "° !110U1m1!0U OU !WbJGWGU4210U q24G M2 2A!!I2pJG qiG JL21 C1922 2CC4C M2 922fIWGq 40 G

WIUJPCL Miqi bojcA: 19

MAO WU wo bopcA

M!2C0U2!U** AC2

MG24 AJL1U12** 1Ô AG2 (ig)

M92PTUiOU MO bOI!CA

MO b01!CA

ALUJOU4 M° bo1rcA

flW AC2

AC2 (ro) A2 (1o)IGUIJ2 1ô? AC2 MO

2OfljP D2O42 MO bojicA

2OflLJJ COJ1U 1Ô83 AG2

KP° I2!91 A2 (1ô8) MO

bIJU2JA9U!9 MO MO

OLGOU A2O1CI9IJOUJ9 18 AG2 A2OP!0 M° MO

M014P DJ°42 MO b01!CA

MOI4P C9LOI!U2 J8 A2 AC2

MGM A0LJC AG2 (1o82) MO

CJ222 2C4* UJ21J24G WVU9LG

2W4 h!L24 k2qn2zi1J c0u1jj qncsrou b01mt IJ9UC

Page 40: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

bcLcclu LcdIuLcq iO JCC COU2flUICL cq COIII2C IAIrp U9UCiJ jobic j jobCLCCU iOOJC COUVUJJCL Gq COflLC 1AU nrnUCI O1MC2

JCLCCIU OOtC COIJVTWCL cq COIIL2C 430o\0V1C C -bOnc 't03VACL9C C - Lc2bouqculbCLCCU COHCC qccc 353\ObCLCCIJI JII CIJOOI qCLGc' UO COCC Q J

bCLCCUI OqJCL UOU-M}J1(C J5\0bCLCCU yuicmJ vwcuc9ubCLCCU JJOWcOMIJCI. FbCLU CWC Lcabouqcu OOo\0J,cLccIu IJJuicq

CPCICL1PC

vpic: cucL, C1JLVCcLnPC o gp wbIG

Page 41: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

J4ou-powcoMUCL 5000 300 3000H0Wc011IICL tQ000 800 I300m.ucq conbjc oooo 0 N8000fluwuJcq wq1Aiqnve too -ooo ioooVII JOfl2CJJOJq2 5000 -00 I0000

140Ui10f1!13 MCj

J4OU-pOWcO!xJcL 000 -300 3000HOWGOEUCL I3ô000 t8a000 55'800#{LUcq conbjc IoQoo oo nooouwwcq wqiiiqn 0 ii'oooVII On2COJ2 000 8?00 000

jog1 ucr !AoI4p

J4ou-powcoNUCL 35000 I8000 0?00HOWGO!IJCL ?500 38000 80000ucq conbfc2 800 't300 80300mJrnLUcq iuqAzqn 5000 !000 t0000VII JOflCOJ2 0000 30000 ,XI400

HocpoJq cm.uw

AVLIPIC iq 2npe9IzJbIc ETL nUTJC JJJL f1L1ijC

LPI : 2nwwvI.1 Wf!2I!C tOL E'Lu!u uq iw

Page 42: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

cocwc1cur LCbLCU1 bLoppJp1A cps118c2 (quA1iAc courrunon ii.nJpjc2 cpu8c oL qi2cLcIc ApJc) uqq CUOI2mc rn bmcurpcc

x 440 13fl 90,X 13.\ 433 833 IF? 83?

OPCLA01J2 JJ j44 U31 IQÔÔ I?3 1ô IQH

cojjc8c (ooto.) (oos) (oo4s) (oo'too) (ooaig) (oo341) (oo3o1) (oo4oQ)bUfCPfl 1U1!U 00I? 0'0?8è 001ô8 00I8 0O0,Q 00390 -00338 -000Q?

(ooso) (oos) (oos't3) (oost8) (oo!i) (ooix) (o'osos) (ooso?)EW891bSLCIJ 00!?8 00139 0.0313 00338 000Q 00Q 0013ô 0'OI?X

(oo3o) (oo384) (oo391) (oo) (oos3e) (0os??) (ooso) (oo3)ØqJCLIJOU-M71 -00J33 -00095 00313 0.010 -00040 0.00? 000? -01)080

(oo4s) (00?!) (oot?Q) (00ctô) (01)34) (o1)3) (003Q) (003o?)VUjCg1jVWUCgIj 0J4 019 008?,X 0103 0140 0133 0O?44 0033ô

(oo33) (0034?) (o'o334) (00338) (ooI?9) (ooiQi) (oois) (oois)ECUJ1C 0088ô 0O4ô 01)810 008\ 00384 0095) 0040? 01)450

(ooost) (ooosQ) (ooosi) (ooos3) (0001?) (ooow) (ooot) (oooio)V8C -00058 0OOlô -O1103 -0003, 00014 00011 -00034 0001ô

(ooos) (ooio) (00085) (ooIo4) (ooo48) (oooo) (ooo?) (ooo8)A'2 2wccwmiqsrc oo31 ooio ooit oos4o oo1't 00330 oooo ooos4

(oo?Q3) (ooso) (ooQ3) (ooQ??) (oo388) (oo3o) (oo?3o) (oo?Q1)EXbO1 i° ''"qr 00?Q -0OQO? -0033 003.1 -0033Q 00?0Q 01)0ô0 00

(oose3) (oo313) (00314) (oosQs)JWbOCqW9U9!C -00 15X 01)403 0013 01)338

COUIJf2 J40 140

cqncuou qncøriou CqnCVUOU cqncpou LcdmLcq Lcdnacq ccpAcCOU2flWCL C0IJI1WCL UIJSUCIVI LW cq• wa cq Qfl cqbocq 1 EXbO1 4° EXbOC1 40 EXbO21 4° EXl)O1 1° EXbOI 1° Exbo2ccl 10 EXbO1 40

uqcbcuqcu1nJpJc (1) (s) () @) (?) () () (g)

wpc : EZb0flL6 40 C0U2flWL uq E!U*Ut!J Eqci!ou1 LLOP!4

Page 43: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

ruqq COL2 ic iu bn.u1pcc2 EOL wcqiu Lc8Lcaiou ruqq CUOI2 c poorribbcq pcq ou j LcbI,cflou2

OPCLA1!OU2 180 180 !8O J80 180 18X0 JIXO 18X0 18X0

(J•3X) (0•?Q) (1•90)8.3

(1.40)30Q

(0 ReX)00X3

JOjCUJ1IJ82\Jc(oo?)400

(1o4)?Q?

(oe3)3?5

(lot)??

(oex)33Q

(1ot)?4

(103)393

(1o9)?43

(0 oX)3R3

(loX)?1

V'\10(o4)09ô8

(ou)0iXX (o)O30X

(oii)01Q (o)039?

(oliX)01ô8

(ote)033

(olso)01X0

(o4?o)055

(o1)0305

oc8ccqnc9rcq () (j) (o?4)lXô

(138)80

(oI)188

(ufl)8?X

(os)183

LL! ()093?(190)31?

(os)0?81

(190)30ô

(o3)0?18

(140)308 (o)0?X?

i.n8Jbcui(oRs)J•

(13e)4•4Ø Jo ()flj

(o)jg

* bmcutAL 2113CC WIJqslC

(0304)0)13

(o?o?)0100 (o)00?4

* bcuf2uoi u"iAC9L2 2UCC UUqSC

(0.11 X)03X4

(044)130

(0.1 )0398

A2!UCCWt1l (y)0303(o3s)081?

(0104)03ô

(oi)0X

EXb0 10 w9uqsrc(14o)03?

(ec)-903

wmiqrcJ1ccActJwbo2oq (y)0?50

(I?o)-135

(o?4e)-0330

(1?8)-1?!

(oQol)-03??

(i?8)-FQ3

(oeie)-0319

(i.'t)0•84

C011Iu(18X)353

(98)400

(18?)3QQ

(48)383

(r8Q)3??

(u)381

(5oo)3Q3

(4e)33

couug211

couuUC

(193)

(r44) (0?!)I 30

(1 4?)?18

(o?8X)0438

(0•351)010?

(o?8e)-0•110

(o?Q)I Q8

(o leo)03?3

(0??)I •09

Lc8Lc2!ou LSUJC 0T2 LC&C22!0u LUUJC or '°' or LCLC22!OU LWJC or LC8LC2210U gUJ) orA4cc1IIJ bLC1W1 J,GqJ9U bCLCCUIIIC v4cq!u bCLCCUDIC bCLCCUITIC y4GqI9IJ bCLCCUIIIC

uqcbcuqcIuu1pJc (j) () (j) (st) (?) () (.) (8) (e) (to)

jpj : JGLccIJ1uG jG2 O( 211U

Page 44: NBER - uw8 I3q...QQI ban cJ bidduH i3ncIbIa ban abb (QQ1 sm 3d 3ldniudniin ol l3dio b3inbi a1oj3n1 d3ua an aisi lo 3m1 .33fl33131q A 3Iom niairnoiq tbntnd lo aidi 31uin1ii1 and bau3o1

ruqq cu.o12 tc w bmcufpcc2 EOL wcql9u Lcce,otm ruuqqCLLOL2 ui.c pooLbbcq pcq ouj LcbJicVflouw

OPCLAVt!OU2 Oil 011 oil eu eu eu out oil 011

(o4s) (u) (oNs) (uc) (o1'ts) (i) (041?) (u'QQ) (0414) (uo)L0f1C9UJ!1J\J0? 0H ?30 0811 O33 40? 08? 90 0t4

(0180) (ux) (1Q) (i,x) (ous) (ufl) (ouo) (ta) (owi) (185)V8C\10 0834 O3 0.814 O0 0841 083 03o 0X3 0 XX? OW

(0518) (sos) (o5t3) (sot) (osw) (so't) (0513) (3o4) (o534) (no)ojjcccqnccq 0038 -otoo s13 -ots 3o -o1 34? 00J?

(o383) (511) (o3) (suo) (o39) (510) (os??) (suo) (o3?) (u)srncq -0t?o -too -oses -us -013? -185 -OIQS -rO -o3o1

(os) (so) (0580) (sb) (oso) (313) (os) (ss)OQOS X5 0\81 8Q3 0XQ 8Q0 0?W XO

(0103) (o)IUCC UJUUfC 003Q

* u.ni bscu42 (o8Q1) (?e3) (o04Q) () (os) (?8)XbO2cqOWsUqsrc 035 F?! 03Q? V00 013?

* (0??) (4.X) (08X) (Q5) (0?J.X) (flQ)E00Wg1JcIS4 F3 138 141 10 0?00

(o4?) (ro?) (o?o) ('vo3)xbo4owmJqw 105 000 11? 000

wmJqvc (o341) (3) (03w) (33) (oo) (ss) (o3o) (ss)GAGE wbo2cq 050? •j•30 030X 1X0 03W 183 03QQ FSQ

(oi) (ass) (oQ8) (3?) (oQo) (is?) (o3) (3?) coum, couzjmjg2

C°'J'U -300 -i0X Q58 -300 ?X(? -FOO (?08

Lc&c2iou ulu Øf Lc3Lcniou L9UJC or Lc&!ou LUJC or Lc3Lc2210u L9U1C or LCRLC22IOU gflJ) oryGqJIJ bcLCCUf!JG V1P' bCLCCIit!1C GqIIJ bCLCCUIIIC bGLUUC ycqiu &CLCCU4JC

UqcbGIJqCU4LflJpJC 0) (s) 0) () (?) () () () (o) (Jo)

L'PI' Q: g4!o 0(G4 0L4 40 E8LUIU