rajendrasinh babubhai makwana, a088 143 880 (bia nov. 26, 2014)

8/10/2019 Rajendrasinh Babubhai Makwana, A088 143 880 (BIA Nov. 26, 2014)

1/5

Gri homas M EsqSuri Griffin, P C.325 Chesnu Sree, Sue 1305Phladelphia, PA 19106

Executive Oce r Immigration Review

Board of Immigrton ApelsQce of he Clerk

1 l I 'mw

HS .or Co. PrisoOR3400 Concord RoadYor, PA 17402

ame MAKWAA RAJEDRASIH B ... A 088-143-880

Dae of his oce 11262014

cosed is a copy of the Board's decsio ad order i te above-reereced case.

closre

P MbCole, Patrica AMaphus Gay D.Lebowtz Een C

Sincerey,

D cDoa Carrhief Cerk

Doket

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished

Cite as: Rajendrasinh Babubhai Makwana, A088 143 880 (BIA Nov. 26, 2014)


2/5

Exeuive Oce r Immigraio Revew

Board of Igron ApeOce of the Cer

5 /07 Leesburg Pike, Sute Fas Chc Vgni 253

MAKWANA, RAJEDRASINH BABUBHAI52886-037/088-143-880

HS LIork Co PisonOR3400 Concord Road

YORK COUTY PRSON Yok PA 174023400 CONCORD ROADYORK, PA 17402

ame: MAKWANA RAJENDRASNH 8 A 088-143-880

Date of this notice 11/26/2014

osed s a op o he oard's deisio i he aovereereed case Ths op is eigprovided o ou as a oues Your aore or represeaive has ee seved wih hisdeision pursua o CFR 1292(a) I he aached decisio orders ha ou eremoved om he Unied Saes or arms a mmigraio Judges decsio orderig ha oue removed, an peiio r review o he aached decisio mus e ed wih ad receved he appropriae cour o appea wihi das o he dae o he decisio

osure

P bCoe Patrca A

Mahrus, Garr Deo Een C

Siere

Dc CaDoa CarrChie Cerk

:



3/5

U Dparmnt o JuscExecuive Oce r Immgaton Reew

Decson of he Bod of mon Apels

Fls Cc, Vgn 0530

Fle 088 143 880 - Yo PA

n e RAENRASINH BABBHAI MAKWAA

RMOVAL PROCEEINGS

APPEAL AD MOTIO

ae

ON BEHALF OF RSPODENT: Thomas M. Gn Esque

O BEHAF OF HS:

CARGE

a L eSeno Aoe

V 28014

ice: Sec 37(a((B & Ac [8 U. 17(a)((B] -

In Uned Staes in oaon of a

Sec 37(a((C(} & Ac [8 U.SC 7(a()(C( Nonmmgan - olaed condions of sats

Sec 37(a)(A( & Ac [8 .SC 7(a)()(A()] Ciced of cme invoing moal uude

APCATO Remand

Ths mae as as bee he Boad on Augus 9 01 hen e hed he esonde o beemovable as chaged The Uned Saes Co o Aeals he Thid Cicui acaed heoon of ou decson holdng ha he esoden is emoale nde secio37a)A) ohe mmgaio and aional Ac 8 S 7a)(A)) d emanded he ecod o

he Boad o eassess hehe e esonde is so emoale We ll susan he aea ihesec o emoabili unde secion 37a))A)(i) o he Ac and i den he moion oemand

The esonden is a naive d cizen o ndia On Decembe 17 010 he as conviced ofone con of compue nuson esuling n oss of $5000 o moe in olaion of 18 USC. 1030(a)((A)(i, B) (2008. He was sentenced o a ter o mson o 41 mons.he Thid cu has ased he Boa o eeme hethe he esondens concionis caegoical a cme inong moa uude.

One commis he cme of comue inuson unde 18 USC 030(a)(5A)id (B(f one noingy causes he asmission of a ogam naion code o cod and asa esu of such conduc neniona causes damage ho auoizaon o a oecedcomue th a esung loss of a eas 000 We examne hs sauo anguage o



4/5

88 143 88

detemne whether the oense is one hat nvoves mora tptde For the statte tocateorcaly describe a ce nvoving moral te the east clpable codct phe

nder te tatte st be mora trdnos Park v. S. Atty Gen. 417 F3d 8,41 (3 r 205

"To nvove mora tpte a cime requires wo esent eements a cpbe mental ated repreesie conduct Matter of Orteg-Lopez, 26 l&N Dec 99 (I 2013) condctcrnazed by 18 U.S.C 130(a)(5)()(i) s ot ntentona and mlcious. Te tatuterequires know conuct and a pecic tent to cause daae thus satsig the reqremento a cupabe metal tate.

In or pror ecsion we epoye the modie ctegorcal approac o etermne tat erespondent was convcted o ndg on sch a copter Te Third rct owever, neror i or use o the modie cteorical aproach in ti maer n ligh o e hirCrcuits remand order, we cocde that under a strict ctegoric analysis te least culpabeconuct sabe der 8 US 103a)5))(i) s ot morally uino We,

terere wi sstan te apea wth respec to removal under section 23a)2))i) ote ct

Pruat to o st 9, 212, ecison, te repoen remas removable ner sectios237(a)()( ad ()() o the ct. He move to remand the record to aow hm to psueadjset o sat The respodet beeves he is te benecay o a vai, approveempoymetbased visa pettio e y hs mer epoyer However, e vsa etton upon

whc hs caim r adstment is baed was revoked o Feba 5, 209, ecaue hs empoyerwithrew aer arres (Ex 2 a Tab , )

The resondet arues tat he oul be abe o pot tat vsa pettion to s sseqent

empoyer ner secto 204 o the ct 8 U S. 1154) See eerally Mater of Neo25 l&N Dec 169 ( 2 However, he has not show at he wa red by the sbeqetepoyer por to te revocaton of the visa petition e asset e was red y te eitoningepoyer n Janary 209 aer hs rest r copter nrson (Motio to Rema at 3 Hewa ndcted o Jary 27, 209 (xh 4 The visa petiton o wc he wa e enecarywas revoke on Februy 5, 2009. He does not seci when he was red by te next employeravig no seed and own tat he a re wthn he ow tme ame between i

teintion y he etitionin emloyer and the revocatio o te visa pettion e as not shownha he wod e ble to o te visa peito eve if it ere oterwise oe under section24) o te ct Ths, he ha not show e has a va immeately avaiale an s no eligier adjtment o tatu. We will terere deny te moton to remad

OER Te appea is sustaie wih repect to the ce o removabil nder ecton27a2 o e rato and atonat c ad te graton ude' ri I ,212 odn that the repondent s removabe under ecton 237(a)(2()() o the ct isvacated.

FUHER ORDER Te ape is smised in all oer resect.

2



5/5

. '

088 4 88

FURTHER ORDER: e espoes moo to re s dee

FOR T BO

3


rajendrasinh babubhai makwana, a088 143 880 (bia nov. 26, 2014)

Documents