section 1 : results & key findings - jan ki baat · son fought and lost; ... mewani is standing...
TRANSCRIPT
-
a. CM Candidate preference
b. Local leader preference
c. Party preference
d. Pulse of the people for 2019
e. Pulse of the people on economy (GST, Demonetization, Jobs and others)
f. Key Suggestions and solutions
1. () ?
2. , ?
3. ?
4. ?
5. ?
6. " " " ?"-
7. ?
8. 2019 ?
Geo-strategically selected units through purposive sampling
Structured, face to face interviews (on and off camera)
a. Data collected and sourced, and videos recorded by verified citizens reporter network apart
from team reporters and researchers
-
b. Opinion and Exit Poll released through Jan Ki Baat PMOO Model (Probability Map of
Outcomes) analysis backed by Issue-Location Matrix [Election Prediction model under Jan Ki
Baat propriety]
Metro stations, railway stations, bus stops, airports, hospitals, schools,
university spaces/colleges, malls, local/weekly markets, streets, bastis, camps, vending zones
: based on - age, gender, income levels, religion, caste, physical ability
and occupations; (i.e. among women, youth, economically weaker sections, religious minorities,
farmers, Dalits, differently-abled, middle-class, small-businesses, senior citizens)
Phase-wise, region-wise and key constituency-wise (popular state and
national leaders like Narendra Modi, Amit Shah, Rahul Gandhi, Ahmed Patel)
SECTION 1 : RESULTS & KEY FINDINGS
SECTION 1.1 Total Seat Breakdowns (Out of 182)
SECTION 1.2 Region-Wise Results
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
BJP Congress Others Total
Seats
BJP
Congress
Others
Total
-
SECTION 1.3 KEY FINDINGS AND OUTLIERS
1. Anti BJP votes should be attributed to the rise of Hardik Patel led patidar
agitation; naturally adding to the number of votes of the congress in Patidar
dominated areas.
2. On a macro level this election is Kadva Patidar agitation against BJP with certain
division in Leuva Patidar votes against the BJP. Against that, BJP can rely on the OBC
consolidation of votes.
3. The lead margins in key seats affected by the Patidar Agitation and in rural belt in all
probability will be less than 5000 votes which increases the importance of the last
72 hours significantly.
4. The dominant issue for Patidars doesnt seem to Anamat but the atrocities against
them during the agitation and perceived attitude where BJP did not even listen to
their demands.
5. Rajkot (West) and Mehsana that belong to incumbent Chief Minister, Vijay Rupani
and Dept CM, Nitin Patel respectively may face a tough electoral battle. The victory
margin, especially in Mehsana, will be very less
6. The BJP seems to gain in seats dominated by the tribal belt and those dominated by
the Koli community.
7. The lack of a strong Gujarati face is one of the biggest weakness for INC
0
50
100
Seats in Saurashtra and
Kutch RegionBJP
Congress
Others
Total
0102030405060
North Gujarat
BJP
Congress
Others
Total
0
10
20
30
40
Seats in South Gujarat
BJP
Congress
Others
Total
0
10
20
30
40
Seats in South Gujarat
BJP
Congress
Others
Total
-
8. Key issue: Cotton price for Framers is not being realised, Price rise, Lack of Jobs,
Effect of GST is no longer an issue to target BJP
9. Support among urban youth and women is more for BJP
10. BJP is likely to win Una, as opposed to popular belief.
SECTION 1.4 DISTRICT-WISE SEAT RESULTS
Region District name Total No of
seats
BJP Congress Others
Saurashtra
and Kutch
(54)
Kutch 6 5 1
Surendranagar 5 4 1
Rajkot 8 5 3
Jamnagar 5 3 2
Porbandar 2 0 1 1
Junagarh 5 3 2
Bhavnagar 7 6 1
Morbi 3 2 1
Devbhumi-
Dwarka
2 2 0
Somnath 4 3 1
Botad 2 1 1
Amreli 5 3 2
Total 37 16 1
NORTH
GUJARAT
(53)
Ahmedabad 21 16 5
Gandhinagar 5 1 4
-
Mehsana 7 2 5
Patan 4 1 3
Sabarkantha 4 1 3
Banaskantha 9 4 4 1
Arvalli 3 0 3
Total 24 28 1
CENTRAL
GUJARAT
(40)
Panchmahal 5 3 2
Dahod 6 4 2
Kheda 5 3 2
Anand 7 4 3
Vadodara 10 6 3 1
Mahisagar 3 0 3
Chota Udaypur 3 2 1
Total 23 16 1
SOUTH
GUJARAT
(35)
Bharuch 5 3 1 1
Navsari 5 4 1
Surat 16 11 5
Dang 1 1
Valsad 5 4 1
Tapi 2 1 1
Narmada 2 2
Total 26 8 1
-
SECTION 2 SEAT-WISE ISSUE-LOCATION MATRIX
Seat BJP Congress Key Factors
Limbdi
(Surendranagar)
60 40 Somabhai Patel of Congress outsider
image; resigned and fought from Lok Sabha;
son fought and lost; so Congress has no local
leader/Mahendra Singh Rana of BJP is local
there; Vikas has not happened;
Botad 55 45 Saurabh Patel of BJP is popular but
Farmers not happy/Vikas Not happened
Amreli 40 60 Paresh Dhanani of Congress is popular
youth leader who defeated big leader Dilip
Sanghani of BJP; PD considered as CM
candidate in 2012; done good vikas; Bavaku
Undhad, big leader from BJP standing from
BJP against him.
Dhari (Amreli) 50 50 Former Minister leader Dilip Sanghani from
BJP is standing; but is outsider; JV Kakadiya
of INC is a local popular leader; local samaj
of Koli community supports congress more;
Modi rally factor
Visvadar (Junagarh) 40 60 Kirit patel of BJP is a good leader but
historically Keshubhais seat; patidar factor
will play a big role
Junagarh (5) 90 10 Mahendra Mashru of BJP is very polular
hasnt taken salary since the time he was
elected has been a 5 time MLA
Kutiana (Porbandar) 30 70 Kandhal Jadehja of NCP is very popular and
powerful; won in 2012; and then worked
very hard
Porbandar
(Porbandar)
40 60 Arjun Modhvadiya of Congress is winning
because of his jan sampark, supportive and
more accesible stature; Kharwa samaj
-
(fishermen community) is dominant; esp
after Rahul Gandhi Sabha
BJP not solved the fishermens issues sea
shore not developed; ones who were
supporting BJP are also now supporting
congress; maritime security an important
issue;
Indias largest flyover is under construction
there since years and people are agitated
because of non-completion;
Babu Bokhariya is candidate and sitting MLA
and doesnt have a clean track record
Una 70 30 Dalit mudda has fizzled out; vikas has
happened;
Bhavnagar 80 20 Jeetu Waghani Pradesh Adhyaksh of BJP is
very popular; Rajputs were allegedly little
unhappy with him earlier; he won with a
lead of 60,000 last time; Congress
umeedwaar is not known and not popular
Morbi (3) 70 30 Recent rally of PM Indra Gandhi jibe; BJP
candidate Amrut Kantilal winning since past
25 years since 1995 of Jan Sangh
Tharad
(Banadkantha)
60 40 Parbat Patel of BJP; MoS against DD Rajput,
first time candidate from Congress is rich
and powerful; Maoji Patel is fighting
independently cutting congress votes and
benefitting Parbat Patel
Vav (Banaskantha) 60 40 Big leader Shankar Chaudhary of BJP;
Geniben Thakor from Congress is not that
strong (recommended by Alpesh Thakor);
during floods, SC did good work
Mandvi, Kutch 60 40 Shakti Singh Goyal of Congress big leader
might lose; outsider image; against Virendra
C Jadeja of BJP is a local popular/powerful
leaders; sitting MLA gave up seat for jadeja;
-
vikas is so so given
its a tourist place (Tara Chand Kheda gave
up his seat)
Bhuj 70 30 Nimaben from BJP is a doctor and well
educated; has won; Vikas has happened;
More Ahir population Chaki Adambhai
from Congress has been losing
Vadgam 60 40 Has been citadel of Congress; Jignesh
Mewani is standing independetly; is an
outsider; posters that he shouldnt come to
ask for votes; former Congress candidates
Gir Somnath 60 40 Jasubhai Barad of BJp earlier from Congress
Vikas has happened; tourist development
has happened well; no problem with GST;
drinking water not clean and not on time
Kalol (Gandhinagar) 70 30 Congress has been winning; patidar factor;
2012 won only by 300 votes
Sanand INC farmers; land grabbing; nano plant has
been made on lands of people but have not
benefitted the janta
Gandhinagar(Mansa) 20 80 Patidar dominated area. 2. Hardik patel rally
3. Historically congress
Ahmedabad (Ellis
Bridge)
80 20 Modi working for India, hardik dividing
Gujarat on cast lines, law and order, women
safety , positive about GST
Smbli (Vadodra) 60 40 Ketan Bhai Imandar independent now BJP,
conducts a lot of marrriages ,2012 43.10%,
Congress 29.17%, personal lagaav, solves
personal problem instantly, phone number
was given by a driver of the gaadi
Dabohi( Vadodra) 55 45 Shaliesh bhai mathur new BJP candidate,
obc maximum voter, 17 sept modi went on
birthday, siddarth patel(45.64 5),,work done
-
by bjp
Vadodra city 60 40 Bjp since 1990, manisha ben patel sitting ,
reserved now , sc/st voters now, kam bolta
hai, women safety , drainage system
Sayajiganj(vadodra) 55 45 Baroda smart city visthapit place people not
happy., BJP vote last time 50k , same strong
contestant (jitendra sukhalia), anganwadi
workers samaan vetan, kam kiya hai
Raopura (vodadra) 60 40 Vikas has happened; BJP has worked; urban
centres are well-developed cimema halls,
wide roads, - but displacement of the poor
smart city is not inclusive; drainage, roads,
electricity and water are proper; Rajendra
Prasad of BJP is winning since 3 times with
large margins
Manjalpur
(Vadodara City)
60 40 Gas cylinders price rise; elecrticity, water
and roads work is done (vikas has
happened); patidar factor not at play; BJP
candidate Yogesh Patel vs INCs Chirag Hans
Kumar Javeri
Chota Udaypur (3) 55 45 Local issues safety, governance, water,
infrastructure are good (majority said);
Muslims to vote for Congress and AAP also
standing this time. Candidates INC
candidate is popular; BJP candidate is sitting
MLA work done
Jayatpur (Chota
Udeypur)
60 40 Local issues cleanliness and infrastructure
work has happened and BJP will come;
womens safety is good; GST and demon not
a negative factor; Congress not that big a
factor
Limbayat (Surat) 60 40 Roads are being constructed ; 80% are fine;
womens safety not an issue; GST Demon is
bit difficult; SangeetaBen has done good
work; Ravindra Patil of Congress has left BJP
-
and BJP supporters angry on this; Shiv
Sena floating candidate Samrat Patil who
might cut Patil votes; maximum population
is of Marathas followed by Muslims (72,000
out of over 2,50,000); Muslim women taking
out pro-Modi rallies
Choriyasi (Surat) 55 25/20 BJP is leading followed by independent
candidate who is also strong UP, Bihar
population is more (Hindi Wasi voters
around 1 Lakh); now everyone knows about
him, he is accessible to all; local issues:
drainage system and cleanliness not proper;
safety and infrastructure is fine
Surat West 55 45 Local issues: Navsara Bazaar roads are not
proper, have potholes; Muslims are pro-
congress large Muslim markets of
furniture; labourers are unhappy since they
are sent far off in the periphery; have
increased travel costs and vikas not
happened for them; safety and work has
happened for others
Majra (Surat) 60 40 Vikas is done-on all fronts has happened;
demon and GST has hurt small businessmen;
patidar not a big factor; Congress rally
people claimed they got paid crowd; BJP
MLA has done work
Radhanpur 55 45 70000 Thakors; 22000-30000 Chaudharies;
rest 13000 Rabari, Prajapati; Alpesh
Thakor is outsider Vs Ghar Ka Thakor
Lavingji Thakor was congress and then
shifted to BJP (is an insider, born there);
Alpesh being a turncoat intitally promised
not to fight; Thakor sena is backing Alpesh;
local guy is more approachable; If 70%
thakors go with Alpesh, Chaudharies and
others will go with BJP; so he loses with
narrow margin
Patan 20 80 Ambaji Nagar: 2007 Anandiben won; 2012
BJP won; here lathi charge took place against
Patidaar 2015; BJP Not Allowed boards were
-
displayed here; households hoist Congress
flags; people are very agitaged; no one heard
their grievances from BJP (sunvaayi nahi
hui); Hardik patel strong following phone
DPs and covers; anti-BJP vote
Vari Chaka Thakors are second most
dominant caste; realization of cotton price
not happening; anti-GST sentiment;
cleanliness a huge problem; roads not
constructed; women against price rise;
railway line not constructed shares border
with Rajasthan; GIDC not set up as
demanded; BJP MLA not worked
Nadiad (Kheda) 60 40 Pankaj Bhai of BJP has a good track record
has done work, got girls married, is winning
since last 4 tenures; caste consolidation of
Desais and Patels favours the BJP;
cleanliness and traffic jam are big issues;
Bharoch (Bharuch) 60 40 Uttar Bhartiya factor is most dominating;
BJP MLA Dushyant Patel is so good that
even Muslims appreciate him; significant
muslim population (40%) will vote for
Congress;- roads, cleanliness is a big issue;
visited Makhtampur, Mohammadpura,
Jyaneshwar, 5 Batti, Tulsidham Chowkdi;
Modi factor still at play; rally by Modi; 20%
patidars also likely to go with Congress
Vagra (Bharuch)
Jhagadia (Bharuch) 30 70 Chotu Varsava factor, Varsava community
factor, Chotu Varsava personally has done a
lot of work many people in his constituency,
considered Dabang
-
Rajkot West 50 50 Patidar supporting Indraneil Rajguru,
Indranil Rajguru personally benefitted more
than 1 lakh people, BJPs baston and strong
support of local karyakartas, last 72 hours
crucial, Patidars rallying behind Indranil
Rajguru, Modi factor giving a tough fight to
Rajguru .
Mehsana 45 55 Patidar decide the vote, Deputy CM Nitin
Patel wil find it difficult to retain the seat,
contest will be decided in less than 5000
votes, Radhanpur Chowkdi, Modera
Chowkdi heart belt of Patidar agitation
movement against BJP, Nitin Patel
considered less approachable, when 14 Patel
died in firing Nitin Bhai did not come.
Navsari 70 30 Prime Minister Modis rally in Navsari, a
survey done across population among 1000
people in Navsari
Padra (Vadodara) 50 50 Pond renovation and devt work has
happened; muslim population is more (over
35%); congress floated Muslim candidate;
rural population present;
Cotton farming takes place When Congress
1200 MSp; BJP promised 1200 but in fact
reduced 800
Vaghodia
(Vadodara)
40 60 (BTP) Praful Bhai Vasava of BTP is popular; is PhD
scholar, with a good image educated; high
tribal population (60,000 out of ); Congress
and JDU has not floated any candidate to
support Praful; 1 independent candidate left
BJP has good support will cut BJP votes
Madhubhai Srivastava of BJP won with very
narrow margin; development not done
road construction not proper
Karjan (Vadodara) 40 60 Satish Motibhai Patel sitting MLA of BJP
not worked that much, won last time by
4000 seats; govt hospitals in poor condition
with no ICUs, no good govt. colleges; seats
-
keep changing
Udhna (Surat) 60 40 Vikas has happened for all including Jhuggi
Jhopris; Muslims also said BJP aayega;
more Marathi population, so Shiv Sena also
floated their candidate Patidar factor
slightly at play; GST and Demon good in the
longer run
Section 3 : KEY OBSERVATION ON GUJARAT ASSEMBLY ELECTIONS
TALKING POINTS
SECTION 3.1
-
SECTION 3.2 PATIDARS WHO SEEM TO FAVOUR BJP
KADWA-PATIDAR (80%)
LEUVA-PATIDAR (20%)
-
SECTION 3.3 THE MAIN ISSUE FOR PATIDAR
LAATHI CHARGE INCIDENT OF 2015 (50%)
ANAMAT (30%)
TEACH BJP A LESSON (20%)
-
SECTION 3.4 SUPPORT FOR GST (ON THE SCALE OF 1 TO
10)
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Announcement of GST UPROAR OVER THERATES
REVISION OF GSTRATES OF SOME
ITEMS
NOVEMBER END
0 2 4 6 8 10
MANDI IN BUSINESSESS
UNEMPLOYMENT OF YOUTH
PRICE REALISATION OF COTTON
PRICE RISE EFFECT ON WOMEN
SECTION 3.5 ISSUES IN RURAL AREAS
-
SECTION 3.6 VIKAS GANDO THAYO CHHE vs. VIKAS THAYO
CHHE
VIKAS THAYO CHHE(75%)
VIKAS GANDO THAYOCHHE (25%)
-
SECTION 4 : FACTORS INFLUENCING BOTH MAJOR PARTIES IN GUJARAT
-
SECTION 5 : PMOO MODEL ANALYSIS FOR THE SEAT OF MEHSANA
SIGNTATURE
Pradip Bhandari (Founder & CEO)
Akriti Bhatia (Founding Partner)
Team Contributors
1- Jai Mistry
2- Anirudh Sharma
3- Sparsh Upadhyay
4- Rushi Bhimani
5- Shadab Khan
6- Vaibhav Bajpai
7- Amit Pandey
8- Arya Swami
Special Thanks To Raghav Awasthi and Shri Bharat Wariavwalla