nz de facto gmo ban

1
810 NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY VOL 18 AUGUST 2000 http://biotech.nature.com IN BRIEF Joint genome announcement On June 26, Francis Collins, director of the international Human Genome Project (HGP) consortium finally announced that the HGP had completed a “rough assembly” of the human genome sequence. Joining Collins at the White House was Craig Venter, president of Celera Genomics (Rockville, MD), long seen as the rival of the HGP. Celera announced it too had “completed” its own assembly of the human genome, which it “finished” sequencing in April (Nat. Biotechnol., 18, 475, 2000). Both parties’ work is expected to be published simultaneously later this year. Although the announcements were hyped by some scientists as being on par with the 1969 moon landing, most acknowledge that it will be years before sci- entists find all the genes that make up the sequence or before many of those genes yield useful therapeutics. Indeed, Celera’s stock, and that of many other genomics companies, was down following the announcement, after much inflation the previous week when word of the joint briefing leaked out. By the close of the market on June 27, Celera stock had dropped almost 22% over two days, to $99.50. Meanwhile, the news spurred new talk of concerns over genetic privacy and discrimination. But just days after the joint announcement, the US Senate reject- ed a bill that would have afforded broad protections against genetic discrimina- tion in the workplace and from insurance companies, saying it would have led to too many lawsuits. JG Cloning opera In September, audiences in Cambridge (UK) will be treated to a rare mix of music, theol- ogy, and genetics at the world premiere of “Parthenogenesis,” a new musical theater work by British composer James MacMillan. The work was inspired by a story of a virgin birth (no, not that one) in Hanover, Germany, in 1944. A young woman caught by the blast of an Allied bomb gave birth nine months later to a daughter whose fin- gerprints, blood type, and other indicators were identical to those of her mother. Physicians suggested that the bomb blast could have jarred a somatic cell within the woman’s womb, triggering parthenogenesis. Biopharmaceutical sector performance, 2nd quarter 2000 Indexed value Burrill Small-Cap Burrill Mid-Cap Burrill Large-Cap Russell 2000 100 80 60 40 180 200 160 140 120 20 0 220 240 260 45.0 45.2 115.9 30.0 May April June Value raised in US$ million. Source: BioCentury Tanox (Houston, TX) 4/6 (244.2) Lexicon (The Woodlands, TX) 4/6 (220.0) Sangamo (Richmond, CA) 4/6 (52.5) Genomic Solutions (Ann Harbor, MI) 5/5 (61.3) Orchid (Princeton, NJ) 5/5 ( 55.2) GPC (Munich, Germany) 5/31 (96.1) M&E Biotech (Horsholm, Denmark) 5/31 ( 46.8) Cepheid (Sunnyvale, CA) 6/21 (30.0) Neurochem (Ville St. Laurent, Quebec) 6/22 (21.8) Pyrosequencing (Uppsala, Sweden) 6/23 (115.9) Modex (Lausanne, Switzerland) 6/23 (45.2) Charles River (Wilmington, MA) 6/26 (224.0) MediGene (Martinsried, Germany) 6/29 (117.4) Paradigm (Research Triangle Park, NC) 5/5 (47.3) 140.5 244.2 224.0 136.1 36.8 35.0 92.0 Actelion (Allschwil, Switzerland) 4/5 Exelixis (S. San Francisco, CA) 4/10 (136.1) November (Erlangen, Germany) 4/10 (36.8) Praecis (Cambridge, MA) 4/27 ViroLogic (S. San Francisco, CA) 5/1 Dendreon (Seattle, WA) 6/16 81.4 96.1 Westin Medical (Peterborough, UK) 5/3 4/3/00 4/17/00 4/10/00 5/30/00 5/22/00 5/8/00 4/24/00 6/15/00 6/5/00 6/19/00 6/26/00 5/15/00 100 300 400 500 600 200 The second quarter saw 21 IPOs, raising a total of $1.9 billion. Initial public offerings, 2nd quarter 2000 220 52.5 61.3 55.2 47.3 46.8 21.8 117.4 Source: Burrill and Company NZ de facto GMO ban The environmental agency in New Zealand, the Environmental Risk Management Authority (ERMA), is imposing draconian strictures on researchers undertaking the most basic of manipulations of genetic material. ERMA makes no distinctions between experi- ments performed for release and those conducted in contained laboratories. Furthermore, ERMA requires centralized and costly relicensing of what, by interna- tional standards, would be judged the most routine experiments with the slight- est of changes to protocols. The use of bio- logical materials from international col- laborators is, in effect, banned by the imposed necessity for New Zealand researchers to pay $1400 per application to import GM organisms. JH A good story, yet Macmillan’s grip on genet- ics is, perhaps understandably, a little tenu- ous. Sections of the score feature an actress speaking the part of the unborn partheno- genetic child. Her accompaniment, says MacMillan, is “material based on the genetic sequencing of Adenine-Cytosine-Thymine- Guanine, currently being mapped in the Human Genome Project, which is providing scientists with a supposed calculation of humanity.” JH © Marty Katz Chimp genome project Japan’s Institute of Physical and Chemical Research (RIKEN; Saitama Prefecture) has announced the launch of an ambitious project to elucidate what makes us human. Based on the theory that intellectual ability—most notably language and logical thinking—distinguishes humans from nonhu- man primates such as chimpanzees, the project will compare chimp and human genomes, focusing on genes expressed in the language center of the brain. RIKEN’s Genomic Sciences Center (GSC) and its Brain Science Institute will carry out the project, which will start officially in April 2001. Yoshiyuki Sakaki, who leads Japan’s human genome sequencing effort, will be director of the project, which will also compare cognitive genetic data from GSC’s mouse genome database. It is expected that data from Kyoto University’s Primate Research Institute (Inuyama City), which has long researched primate behav- ior, will also be used by RIKEN to study the genetic basis of behavioral patterns. AS © 2000 Nature America Inc. • http://biotech.nature.com © 2000 Nature America Inc. • http://biotech.nature.com

Upload: john

Post on 29-Jul-2016

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: NZ de facto GMO ban

810 NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY VOL 18 AUGUST 2000 http://biotech.nature.com

IN BRIEF

Joint genome announcement

On June 26, Francis Collins, director of theinternational Human Genome Project (HGP)consortium finally announced that the HGPhad completed a “rough assembly” of thehuman genome sequence. Joining Collins atthe White House was Craig Venter, presidentof Celera Genomics (Rockville, MD), longseen as the rival of the HGP. Celeraannounced it too had “completed” its own assembly of the human genome,which it “finished” sequencing in April (Nat. Biotechnol., 18, 475, 2000). Bothparties’ work is expected to be published simultaneously later this year.Although the announcements were hyped by some scientists as being on parwith the 1969 moon landing, most acknowledge that it will be years before sci-entists find all the genes that make up the sequence or before many of thosegenes yield useful therapeutics. Indeed, Celera’s stock, and that of many othergenomics companies, was down following the announcement, after muchinflation the previous week when word of the joint briefing leaked out. By theclose of the market on June 27, Celera stock had dropped almost 22% over twodays, to $99.50.

Meanwhile, the news spurred new talk of concerns over genetic privacy anddiscrimination. But just days after the joint announcement, the US Senate reject-ed a bill that would have afforded broad protections against genetic discrimina-tion in the workplace and from insurance companies, saying it would have led totoo many lawsuits. JG

Cloning opera

In September, audiences in Cambridge (UK)will be treated to a rare mix of music, theol-ogy, and genetics at the world premiere of“Parthenogenesis,” a new musical theaterwork by British composer James MacMillan.The work was inspired by a story of a virginbirth (no, not that one) in Hanover,Germany, in 1944. A young woman caughtby the blast of an Allied bomb gave birthnine months later to a daughter whose fin-gerprints, blood type, and other indicatorswere identical to those of her mother.Physicians suggested that the bomb blastcould have jarred a somatic cell within thewoman’s womb, triggering parthenogenesis.

Biopharmaceutical sector performance, 2nd quarter 2000

Ind

exed

val

ue

Burrill Small-CapBurrill Mid-CapBurrill Large-CapRussell 2000

100

80

60

40

180

200

160

140

120

20

0

220

240

260

45.0 45.2

115.9

30.0

MayApril June

Value raised in US$ million.Source: BioCentury

Tano

x (H

oust

on, T

X) 4/6

(244

.2)

Lexi

con

(The

Woo

dlan

ds, T

X) 4/6

(220

.0)

Sang

amo

(Rich

mon

d, C

A) 4/6

(52.

5)

Genom

ic So

lutio

ns (A

nn H

arbo

r, M

I) 5/

5 (6

1.3)

Orc

hid

(Prin

ceto

n, N

J) 5/

5 ( 5

5.2)

GPC (M

unich

, Ger

man

y) 5

/31

(96.

1)

M&E

Biot

ech

(Hor

shol

m, D

enm

ark)

5/3

1 ( 4

6.8)

Ceph

eid

(Sun

nyva

le, C

A) 6/2

1 (3

0.0)

Neuro

chem

(Vill

e St

. Lau

rent

, Que

bec)

6/2

2 (2

1.8)

Pyro

sequ

encin

g (U

ppsa

la, S

wed

en) 6

/23

(115

.9)

Mod

ex (L

ausa

nne,

Sw

itzer

land

) 6/2

3 (4

5.2)

Char

les R

iver

(Wilm

ingt

on, M

A) 6/2

6 (2

24.0

)

Med

iGen

e (M

artin

srie

d, G

erm

any)

6/2

9 (1

17.4

)

Para

digm

(Res

earc

h Tr

iang

le P

ark,

NC)

5/5

(47.

3)

140.5

244.2

224.0

136.1

36.8 35.0

92.0

Actel

ion

(Alls

chw

il, S

witz

erla

nd) 4

/5

Exel

ixis

(S. S

an F

ranc

isco,

CA) 4

/10

(136

.1)

Novem

ber (

Erla

ngen

, Ger

man

y) 4

/10

(36.

8)

Prae

cis

(Cam

brid

ge, M

A) 4/2

7Vi

roLo

gic

(S. S

an F

ranc

isco,

CA) 5

/1

Dendr

eon

(Sea

ttle

, WA) 6

/16

81.496.1

Wes

tin M

edica

l

(Pet

erbo

roug

h, U

K) 5/3

4/3/

00

4/17

/00

4/10

/00

5/30

/00

5/22

/00

5/8/

00

4/24

/00

6/15

/00

6/5/

00

6/19

/00

6/26

/00

5/15

/00

100

300

400

500

600

200

The second quarter saw 21 IPOs, raising a total of $1.9 billion. Initial public offerings, 2nd quarter 2000

220

52.5

61.355.247.3 46.8

21.8

117.4

Source: Burrill and Company

NZ de facto GMO ban

The environmental agency in NewZealand, the Environmental Risk

Management Authority (ERMA), isimposing draconian strictures onresearchers undertaking the most basic ofmanipulations of genetic material. ERMAmakes no distinctions between experi-ments performed for release and thoseconducted in contained laboratories.Furthermore, ERMA requires centralizedand costly relicensing of what, by interna-tional standards, would be judged themost routine experiments with the slight-est of changes to protocols. The use of bio-logical materials from international col-laborators is, in effect, banned by theimposed necessity for New Zealandresearchers to pay $1400 per applicationto import GM organisms. JH

A good story, yet Macmillan’s grip on genet-ics is, perhaps understandably, a little tenu-ous. Sections of the score feature an actressspeaking the part of the unborn partheno-genetic child. Her accompaniment, saysMacMillan, is “material based on the geneticsequencing of Adenine-Cytosine-Thymine-Guanine, currently being mapped in theHuman Genome Project, which is providingscientists with a supposed calculation ofhumanity.” JH

© M

arty

Kat

z

Chimp genome project

Japan’s Institute of Physical and Chemical Research (RIKEN; SaitamaPrefecture) has announced the launch of an ambitious project to elucidatewhat makes us human. Based on the theory that intellectual ability—mostnotably language and logical thinking—distinguishes humans from nonhu-man primates such as chimpanzees, the project will compare chimp andhuman genomes, focusing on genes expressed in the language center of thebrain. RIKEN’s Genomic Sciences Center (GSC) and its Brain Science Institutewill carry out the project, which will start officially in April 2001. YoshiyukiSakaki, who leads Japan’s human genome sequencing effort, will be director ofthe project, which will also compare cognitive genetic data from GSC’s mousegenome database. It is expected that data from Kyoto University’s PrimateResearch Institute (Inuyama City), which has long researched primate behav-ior, will also be used by RIKEN to study the genetic basis of behavioral patterns. AS

© 2000 Nature America Inc. • http://biotech.nature.com©

200

0 N

atu

re A

mer

ica

Inc.

• h

ttp

://b

iote

ch.n

atu

re.c

om